Upgrade to Pro
— share decks privately, control downloads, hide ads and more …
Speaker Deck
Features
Speaker Deck
PRO
Sign in
Sign up for free
Search
Search
Test Your Legacy Code
Search
Noel Rappin
November 07, 2011
Technology
3
210
Test Your Legacy Code
Presented at RubyMidwest, November 2011
Noel Rappin
November 07, 2011
Tweet
Share
More Decks by Noel Rappin
See All by Noel Rappin
Rails on Ruby: How Ruby Makes Rails Great
noelrap
0
350
In Defense of Metaprogramming
noelrap
0
480
Rails 7 Front End Tooling
noelrap
1
580
More Engineers, More Problems: Solutions for Big Teams
noelrap
0
210
The Rails 6 Front End: Building with Webpacker and Stimulus
noelrap
3
1.2k
The Developer's Toolkit
noelrap
0
190
High Cost Tests and High Value Tests: GOTO Chicago 2018
noelrap
2
150
High Cost Tests and High Value Tests
noelrap
1
190
The Road To Legacy is Paved With Good Intentions
noelrap
1
180
Other Decks in Technology
See All in Technology
Microsoft Defender XDRで疲弊しないためのインシデント対応
sophiakunii
3
400
AIを使っていい感じにE2Eテストを書けるようになるまで / Trying to Write Good E2E Tests with AI
katawara
2
1.6k
All About Sansan – for New Global Engineers
sansan33
PRO
1
1.2k
OpenTelemetry の Log を使いこなそう
biwashi
4
970
Shadow DOMとセキュリティ - 光と影の境界を探る / Shibuya.XSS techtalk #13
masatokinugawa
0
270
Data Engineering Study#30 LT資料
tetsuroito
1
550
PHPからはじめるコンピュータアーキテクチャ / From Scripts to Silicon: A Journey Through the Layers of Computing
tomzoh
2
380
激動の時代、新卒エンジニアはAIツールにどう向き合うか。 [LayerX Bet AI Day Countdown LT Day1 ツールの選択]
tak848
0
530
Turn Your Community into a Fundraising Catalyst for Black Philanthropy Month
auctria
PRO
0
120
20250719_JAWS_kobe
takuyay0ne
1
160
株式会社島津製作所_研究開発(集団協業と知的生産)の現場を支える、OSS知識基盤システムの導入
akahane92
1
1.1k
MCPに潜むセキュリティリスクを考えてみる
milix_m
1
680
Featured
See All Featured
Refactoring Trust on Your Teams (GOTO; Chicago 2020)
rmw
34
3.1k
A Tale of Four Properties
chriscoyier
160
23k
Speed Design
sergeychernyshev
32
1k
Connecting the Dots Between Site Speed, User Experience & Your Business [WebExpo 2025]
tammyeverts
8
370
Building a Scalable Design System with Sketch
lauravandoore
462
33k
jQuery: Nuts, Bolts and Bling
dougneiner
63
7.8k
Scaling GitHub
holman
461
140k
Learning to Love Humans: Emotional Interface Design
aarron
273
40k
Producing Creativity
orderedlist
PRO
346
40k
How STYLIGHT went responsive
nonsquared
100
5.6k
Why You Should Never Use an ORM
jnunemaker
PRO
58
9.5k
XXLCSS - How to scale CSS and keep your sanity
sugarenia
248
1.3M
Transcript
Test Your Legacy Code Noel Rappin @noelrap Monday, November 7,
11
You are handed a “rescue” project Monday, November 7, 11
Oh. My. God. The last person to work on this
was an idiot Monday, November 7, 11
Now what? Monday, November 7, 11
Shake your fists at the heavens for one minute. Photo
by Sha Sha Chu http://www.flickr.com/photos/shashachu/88654315/ Monday, November 7, 11
Get back to work. Monday, November 7, 11
What is a legacy application? Monday, November 7, 11
Code without tests Monday, November 7, 11
Code based on lost requirements Monday, November 7, 11
You don’t know what “correct” means Monday, November 7, 11
What’s your goal? Monday, November 7, 11
Respect working code. Do no harm. Monday, November 7, 11
Deliver features Monday, November 7, 11
At a sustainable pace Monday, November 7, 11
Improve code quality Monday, November 7, 11
The Boy Scout Rule Monday, November 7, 11
Our rescue project needs to change Monday, November 7, 11
Goofus and Gallant Monday, November 7, 11
“First, let’s write tests and cover the whole app” Monday,
November 7, 11
“That change is easy, I’ll just drop that in” Monday,
November 7, 11
They are both Goofus Monday, November 7, 11
Why not cover the whole app in tests? Monday, November
7, 11
“It’s a small world, but I wouldn’t want to paint
it” Monday, November 7, 11
It’s not a quick win Monday, November 7, 11
You can introduce bugs Monday, November 7, 11
Why not just drop something in? Monday, November 7, 11
It sets a bad precedent Monday, November 7, 11
It doesn’t make anything better Monday, November 7, 11
What’s a Gallant Software Craftsman to do? Monday, November 7,
11
The basic TDD process... Monday, November 7, 11
...applied to new changes only Monday, November 7, 11
Red. Green. Refactor. Monday, November 7, 11
Over time, coverage and quality grow organically Monday, November 7,
11
Okay, it’s not that easy Monday, November 7, 11
Why not? Monday, November 7, 11
You don’t know what to test Monday, November 7, 11
It’s hard to isolate objects under test Monday, November 7,
11
A friendly reminder: git is your friend Monday, November 7,
11
Cucumber Photo by karenandbradmerson http://www.flickr.com/photos/karenandbrademerson/492770419 Monday, November 7, 11
Cucumber is independent of the code Monday, November 7, 11
Cucumber can cover a lot of the app quickly Monday,
November 7, 11
But... Monday, November 7, 11
Cucumber is slow Photo by matley0 http://www.flickr.com/photos/matley0/2973398121/ Monday, November 7,
11
And it’s not great at isolating where a problem is
Monday, November 7, 11
Test-Driven Exploration Monday, November 7, 11
It’s like TDD... with cheating Monday, November 7, 11
Red. Make it green. Refactor. Monday, November 7, 11
The code is source of truth Monday, November 7, 11
Mock Testing Monday, November 7, 11
Mocks are fast and allow unit testing Monday, November 7,
11
But they can be hard to set up Monday, November
7, 11
Isolation Monday, November 7, 11
Only touch existing methods to call your new methods Monday,
November 7, 11
def crazy_insane_method return clean_new_method if new_condition # all the old
ugly stuff end Monday, November 7, 11
Seams Photo by boogah http://www.flickr.com/photos/boogah/4541496/ Monday, November 7, 11
Default method arguments Monday, November 7, 11
def crazy_insane_method(arg, arg, new_arg = nil) # crazy insane stuff
# now with new stuff end Monday, November 7, 11
Changing behavior without touching code Monday, November 7, 11
Monday, November 7, 11
class TestPurchase < Purchase def bang # no-op end end
user.purchase << TestPurchase.new Monday, November 7, 11
class Purchase def bang # no-op end end Monday, November
7, 11
Singleton classes Monday, November 7, 11
x = Purchase.new x.def bang # no-op end Monday, November
7, 11
Duck Typing Photo by Andyofne http://www.flickr.com/photos/andyofne/3757051334/ Monday, November 7, 11
class TestPurchase def bang # no-op end end user.purchase <<
TestPurchase.new Monday, November 7, 11
Use a pebble Photo by Slideshow Bruce http://www.flickr.com/photos/springfieldhomer/39079430/ Monday, November
7, 11
class Pebble def initialize(name) @name = name end def method_missing(method_name,
*args) p "#{method_name}(#{args.join(", ")}) from #{caller_method}" self end end Monday, November 7, 11
def caller_method(depth = 1) parse_caller(caller(depth+1).first).last end def parse_caller(at) if /^(.+?):(\d+)(?::in
`(.*)')?/ =~ at file = Regexp.last_match[1] line = Regexp.last_match[2].to_i method = Regexp.last_match[3] [file, line, method] end Monday, November 7, 11
What about bad tests? Monday, November 7, 11
Make sure the suite runs Monday, November 7, 11
Tests are also code Monday, November 7, 11
The 5-minute rule Monday, November 7, 11
When to refactor Monday, November 7, 11
Simple refactors can be done at any time... Monday, November
7, 11
...as long as the tests are green Monday, November 7,
11
Especially if you can’t test without refactoring Monday, November 7,
11
More complex refactors should be tied to actual new requests
Monday, November 7, 11
And in conclusion... Monday, November 7, 11
Respect working code Monday, November 7, 11
Test at as high a level as you can Monday,
November 7, 11
Leave things better than you found them Monday, November 7,
11
Isolate code under test Monday, November 7, 11
Consider the cost of change against the cost of no
change Monday, November 7, 11
railsrx.com @noelrap Rails Test Prescriptions Rate: http://bit.ly/nrmwtest Monday, November 7,
11