Share
Embed
Cypress or Playwright?
Rainer Hahnekamp
April 26, 2024
Transcript
42 slides
-
RainerHahnekamp About Me... Professional NgRx https://www.youtube.com/ @RainerHahnekamp https://www.ng-news.com https://github.com/softarc-consulting/sheriff •
Rainer Hahnekamp ANGULARarchitects.io • Developer / Trainer / Speaker Modern Spring for Angular @RainerHahnekamp -
RainerHahnekamp Goal • Discuss both Frameworks from different Perspectives •
Provide enough information for a founded decision • Present my own opinion -
RainerHahnekamp Agenda 1. Technological Approach 2. Developer Experience 3. CI
4. Coding 5. Architecture & Extensibility 6. Misc. Features 7. Summary -
RainerHahnekamp 2010 2005 2015 2020 Selenium RC Selenium 2 CDP
Cypress Playwright -
RainerHahnekamp Browser Support • Browsers ◦ Chromium Family ◦ Firefox
◦ Webkit • Languages ◦ JavaScript/TypeScript ◦ .NET ◦ Java ◦ Python Playwright • Browsers ◦ Chromium Family ◦ Firefox ◦ Webkit • Languages ◦ JavaScript/TypeScript -
RainerHahnekamp Dependencies • Almost Zero dependencies • Build everything on
their own Mocha & Chai jQuery Playwright -
RainerHahnekamp Cypress Test Runner Embedded Browser Test Code History with
"Time Travel" Detailed Logging Info -
RainerHahnekamp CI • Traceview • Parallelization • Sharding Playwright •
Video Recording per Test • Screenshot for failed Test • Commercial Cypress Cloud -
RainerHahnekamp Coding: Selectors, Actions & Assertions • Testing framework built-in
◦ Different Selector Engines ◦ Special Web Assertions • Locators as Abstraction to DOM • Async/Await Playwright • Relies on External Libraries ◦ Selection via jQuery ◦ Assertion via Mocha & Chai ◦ Explicit Assertions • Retryability • "Declarative Asynchrony" -
RainerHahnekamp cy.visit() cy.get() cy.click() synchronous • visit • get •
click asynchronous -
RainerHahnekamp Architecture & Extensibility • Recommends Page Objects • Fixtures
as DI Playwright • Page Objects possible • Recommendation to extend cy ◦ Mind the Query! -
RainerHahnekamp Playwright Page Object import { Page } from '@playwright/test';
export class SidemenuPage { constructor(private page: Page) {} async select(menu: 'customers' | 'holidays') { await this.page.getByTestId(`btn-${menu}`).click(); } } -
RainerHahnekamp Playwright Fixture import { SidemenuPage } from '../page-objects/sidemenu-page'; export
interface SidemenuFixtures { sidemenuPage: SidemenuPage; } export const sidemenuFixtures = { sidemenuPage: async ({ page }, use) => { const sidemenuPage = new SidemenuPage(page); await use(sidemenuPage); }, }; -
RainerHahnekamp Playwright Usage in Test const test = base.extend<SidemenuFixtures>(sidemenuFixtures); test('rename
Latitia to Laetitia', async ({ page, sidemenuPage }) => { await page.goto(''); await sidemenuPage.select('customers'); // ... }); -
RainerHahnekamp Cypress Commands declare namespace Cypress { interface Chainable<Subject> {
openMenu(item: 'Customers' | 'Holidays'): void; } } Cypress.Commands.add('openMenu', (item: 'Customers' | 'Holidays') => { cy.findByRole('link', { name: item }).click(); }); -
RainerHahnekamp Cypress Commands declare namespace Cypress { interface Chainable<Subject> {
openMenu(item: 'Customers' | 'Holidays'): void; } } Cypress.Commands.add('openMenu', (item: 'Customers' | 'Holidays') => { cy.findByRole('link', { name: item }).click(); }); -
RainerHahnekamp Cypress Queries declare namespace Cypress { interface Chainable<Subject> {
openMenu(item: 'Customers' | 'Holidays'): void; testid(selector: string): Chainable<JQuery<HTMLElement>>; } } Cypress.Commands.add('openMenu', (item: 'Customers' | 'Holidays') => { cy.findByRole('link', { name: item }).click(); }); Cypress.Commands.addQuery('testid', (selector: string) => { const getFn = cy.now('get', `[data-testid=${selector}]`) as () => Promise<Chainable<JQuery>>; return () => getFn(); }); -
RainerHahnekamp Miscellaneous Features • Network: Stubbing, Verifying, Requesting • Visual
Regression • A11y: User-Facing Selectors, Axe Plugin • Recorder: Chrome Extensions • Session Storage -
RainerHahnekamp Browser Support ✅ Performance ✅ More Control over the
Browser ✅ Tracing ✅ Backed by Microsoft Playwright ✅ Developer Experience ✅ Mature ✅ Component Testing