Upgrade to Pro — share decks privately, control downloads, hide ads and more …

The Future of Patient Generated Data and Care Management

Altruista Health
October 02, 2017
54

The Future of Patient Generated Data and Care Management

Presented by Mike Van Den Eynde, Managing Director, Deloitte Consulting

Altruista Health

October 02, 2017
Tweet

Transcript

  1. Copyright © 2017 Deloitte Development LLC. All rights reserved. 2

    Patient Generated Data (PGD) – Why do you care? There will be a significant opportunity to leverage PGD within care management efforts in the future The Technology Change All medical devices will have SIM cards and be able to transmit data by2025 • Many already capable of transmitting • There is a large push by cellular phone manufacturers to get their SIM card in every device Present Status Beginning pilots focused on the utilization of medicaldevices • Some medical devices use it to track and bill for use of the device (e.g. sleep apnea units) • Some pace makers already can be monitored now The Opportunity Revolutionize the continuous monitoring of patients with a range ofconditions • Chronic conditions biometric (implantables?) • Population based research • Home based monitoring
  2. Internet of Everything Over the last two decades, the data-driven

    suite of technologies dubbed the Internet of Things (IoT) has transformed some industries and disrupted others with sophisticated analytical capabilities • The suite of technologies that enables the Internet of Things promises to turn any object into a source of information about that object • This creates both a new way to differentiate products and services and a new source of value that can be managed in its own right. Copyright © 2017 Deloitte Development LLC. All rights reserved. 3
  3. Copyright © 2017 Deloitte Development LLC. All rights reserved. 4

    Internet of Everything: Patient Generated Data (PGD) Healthcare stakeholders have lagged behind other industries in adopting IoT innovations and using available customer data to inform decision making, but the shift is taking place Patient-generated data (PGD) is defined as “health-related data created, recorded, gathered, or inferred by or from patients or their designees to help address a health concern”. It includes patient reported outcomes, medical-device data, wearables data, in addition to consumer-generated data in a health caresetting • Patients make the bulk of their health care decisions outside a clinical setting, and most of those decisions are lifestyle choices rather than doctor-advised medical actions • It has been estimated that in the United States, everyday behaviors lead to conditions that cause 40 percent of premature deaths • Given that digitally collected patient-generated data are more reliable than the self-reported alternative, IoT applications can be critical to improving and personalizing health care, even encouraging behavior changes before they result in illness • The personalization of care and improved patient engagement through IoT technology will make health organizations more competitive and attract more customers in an ever more consumer-driven market
  4. Standards Magnitude Scope | Scale | Frequency Risk Security |

    Reliability | Accuracy Time Latency | Timeliness Act Analyze Create Communicate Aggregate Network Augmented Intelligence Sensors AugmentedBehavior Things Applications PGD & Information Value Loop Realizing the IoT’s full potential requires a framework that captures the series and sequence of activities by which organizations create value from information: the Information Value Loop Copyright © 2017 Deloitte Development LLC. All rights reserved. 5
  5. Stage Examples Create • Medication adherence data created by a

    sensor-enabled pill bottle • Blood glucose levels created by a home monitor • Step count quantified by wearable pedometer Communicate • Blood glucose levels shared via Bluetooth and the Internet Aggregate • Blood glucose levels tracked over time for an individual or a high-risk population Analyze • Patient, caregiver, and/or doctor alerted when patient has not taken his or hermedication • Patient, caregiver, and doctor shown trends in blood glucose levels and key factors affecting these levels, informing future care planning • Patient, caregiver, and doctor shown trends in step counts Act • Adhering to medication regimen • Keeping blood glucose levels within a healthy range • Staying active • Quitting smoking Information Value Loop: Examples Below are a few examples across each stage of the Information Value Loop Copyright © 2017 Deloitte Development LLC. All rights reserved. 6
  6. Internet of Everything: Key Healthcare Opportunities Chronic CareManagement HomeHealth PGD

    carries tremendous potential to lower costs and improve outcomes for healthcare organizations • PGD—whether generated via mobile technologies, medical devices, or patients’ personal computers— can help patients track key health information while assisting providers in more effectively tailoring treatments for the individual or public overall • These technologies save health systems money by lowering readmission rates, reducing appointment no- shows, and promoting adherence to care plans • In the coming decades, demographic changes will increase opportunities to apply IoT technology to support wellness and health care for particular segments of the population • An aging Baby Boomer generation will drive market growth for technologies, such as glucose monitors and motion sensors that allow them to manage their chronic conditions and age within their own homes • As PGD’s use increases, three areas in particular offer a growing evidence base for value in improving health outcomes, reducing cost, and expanding access to care: 1• Short-Term CarePlanning 2• 3• Copyright © 2017 Deloitte Development LLC. All rights reserved. 7
  7. Copyright © 2017 Deloitte Development LLC. All rights reserved. 8

    FACT: • Preventable readmissions costs the health care system approximately $17.5Bannually* • Researchers have shown that increased support substantially promotes care-plan adherence and improves quality outcomes while lowering costs through reduced hospital readmissions and officevisits. *Robert Wood Johnson Foundation, The revolving door: A report on U.S. hospital readmissions, February 2013, Short Term Care Planning PGD presents a significant opportunity to customize care and support patients throughout their treatment and post-operative care plans through education, reminders, and monitoring/detection 1
  8. FACT: • As of 2012, 133 million Americans (approximately one

    in two adults) have a chronicdisease • Chronic diseases account for approximately 70 percent of deaths in the UnitedStates • Chronic disease accounts for 86 percent of America’s direct healthexpenditure • Remote patient monitoring is expected to save up to $36 billion globally over the next fiveyears Chronic Care Management Chronic-disease management presents an high-impact area in which increased use of PGD can provide immediate results 2 Copyright © 2017 Deloitte Development LLC. All rights reserved. 9
  9. FACT: • According to the CDC, falls are the leading

    cause of both fatal and nonfatal injuries in adults 65 and older • One out of three older adults falls each year, though less than half of them mention this to theirproviders. • In 2013, direct medical costs due to falls reached $34 billion. Home Health Home monitoring of an aging population via apps, sensors, and other devices helps people to live at home safely by proactively identifying those who can no longer live safely at home, and by providing a range of support services for those that do 3 Copyright © 2017 Deloitte Development LLC. All rights reserved. 10
  10. Enrollment 1. Liz, a diabetes patient, enrolls in the Patient

    360 Diabetes management program at the recommendation of her doctor. 2. Liz sets up the recommended mobile apps for monitoring activities, nutrition and pill adherence and links her bio- sensors. 3. Liz downloads and installs the Patient 360 app and links her device data to the app(HealthKit). 4. Liz’s RN or doctor sets upher vital thresholds in the Patient 360system. 8. Liz’s doctor views Liz’s vitals (glucose levels, blood pressure and heart rate) against her activity, nutrition and pill intake. He communicates a treatment recommendation to Liz. 7. Patient 360 triggers notifications to Liz and Liz’s RN and doctor when Liz’s vitals trend outside the thresholds. 9. Liz follows her doctor’s instructions and the biosensors continue sending her improving vitals to the Patient 360 healthcloud. Remote Monitoring Copyright © 2017 Deloitte Development LLC. All rights reserved. 11 Remote Treatment 5. Liz’s RN or doctor sets Liz’s prescriptions in Patient 360. 6. The bio-sensors monitor Liz’s vitals – glucose levels, blood pressure and heart rate – and the smart pill box monitors pill intake and all information is sent to the Patient 360 health cloud. PGD Example: Patient Journey Below is one example of how PGD can empower patients and providers to improve health
  11. Non-Medical Data Application(s) Medical DataApplication(s) End-User Application LegacySystems Cloud &Hosting

    Security& Privacy Data Validation Encryption Device Registration &Enrollment Gateway Sim & Terminal Event Management Device Management BI & Augmented Intelligence DataIngestion IoT Platform Analysis Connectivity Medical devices Enabling IoT solutions: Technology Components There are several technology components that will need to be built to enable IoT solutions Copyright © 2017 Deloitte Development LLC. All rights reserved. 12
  12. 1 Copyright © 2017 Deloitte Development LLC. All rights reserved.

    13 2 3 4 5 Consumers have an appetite for using technology-enabled care Seven in ten consumers are likely to use at least one of the technologies we presented Telemedicine, in which half of the respondents show interest, is the most popular technology Respondents are most interested in using it for post-surgical care and chronic disease monitoring Particular subgroups are especially keen on these technologies We saw this especially in those who have chronic diseases, Millennials using telemedicine, and Seniors using remote monitoring Caregivers are a key population Consumers who are caregivers say they are most likely to use sensor technology (the IoT) when caring for others rather than for themselves. Experienced caregivers are more likely users than non-caregivers. Consumers demand high-quality, personalized care They also want assurance that their personal information will be safe 2016 Deloitte Survey: Healthcare Consumer Perspectives The survey explores consumer expectations, preferences, and concerns around technologies that can deliver health care services outside of traditional settings
  13. Earn consumers’trust. Quality of care and protection of personal information

    can be essential for adoption. Prioritize keeping patient information safe. Consider developing risk mitigation strategies that take into account possible uses and misuses of personalinformation. Provide a consistent, trusted connection. Consumers express preference in seeing their regular doctor for telemedicine visits, but are open to seeing other doctors/nurses consistently over time. Engage patients and caregivers. Providers should consider getting to know who is in their patients’ support networks and understand patients’ and caregivers’ learning styles, communication preferences, and willingness to makedecisions. Create a seamless user experience. Tools likely need to provide an end-to-end experience. For example, if a tool helps patients obtain and track prescriptions but doesn’t allow them to refill medication, many would rather not use that tool atall. Give consumers what theywant. Consumers have clear preferences for which health care services they are interested in using technologyfor. Retailers, providers, and plans should consider aligning their offerings where the interest is highest. Graphic: Deloitte University Press Make care delivery more patient-centric. Creating more patient-centric care delivery models will likely require increased collaboration and shared decision making. Include the caregivers. Many caregivers are interested in using technology—but adoption thus far is low. Most caregivers also want toolsto ensure that medications are managed accurately and with ease. Source: Deloitte 2016 Survey of US Health Care Consumers. Copyright © 2017 Deloitte Development LLC. All rights reserved. 14 2016 Deloitte Survey: Implications for health care stakeholders For those developing and implementing technologies for care, opportunities abound for new products and offerings over the coming years and decades
  14. Copyright © 2017 Deloitte Development LLC. All rights reserved. 16

    Key Challenges for PGD (1/2) Despite strong prospects for IoT applications’ use in health care, there are challenges that will shape how PGD is integrated into care delivery Challenge: Data integration and analyticalcomplexities • As with many emerging health technologies, there are few standards governing the configuration of PGD to promote data accuracy and integrity across platforms • Additionally, PGD consists of many different types of data collected on diverse and rapidly evolving devices, with data increasingly being collected on smartphones with or without IoT-enabled external sensors Recommendations: Actively engage the standards-development process. By taking an active role in the development of new standards for the communication of PGD, organizations may be able to both hasten standards’ adoption and potentially adjust them to accommodate high-value use cases. Incorporate flexibility into the platform that will collect and exchange PGD. While this flexibility may add to the cost of early adoption, it may prevent the platform’s obsolescence if standards evolve that are incompatible with the implemented PGD platform.
  15. Copyright © 2017 Deloitte Development LLC. All rights reserved. 17

    Key Challenges for PGD (2/2) Despite strong prospects for IoT applications’ use in health care, there are challenges that will shape how PGD is integrated into care delivery Challenge: Lack of clarity regarding where to use PGD, given its nascence in supporting clinicalcare PGD can inform a wide range of health scenarios, and the evidence base is still evolving, favoring some solutions over others. Reflecting a bottleneck at the value loop’s act phase, organizations face uncertainty about how to prioritize potential uses of this new technology Recommendations: Prioritize validity, repeatability, and scalability of recognized uses when delivering analytics solutions over those that discover new uses for PGD. The tendency in a rapidly evolving environment is to follow a myriad of interesting ideas, which can lead to pilots that never grow into robust, enterprise-wide programs For implementation, instead of investing in fresh, untested IoT areas, leading health organizations are refining and perfecting currently acknowledged use applications. This strategy is helping build an evidence base to develop the most impactfulprograms Build a portfolio by identifying high-value use cases in patient populations. While providers have shown some success in conceiving, developing, and managing PGD-intensive programs in an ad hoc manner, the most successful programs are run by organizations that are proactive in building a portfolio of programs around specific needs in their respective patient populations. This ensures that the technology’s highest-value uses aren’t being overlooked and that patients have a seamless and consistent experience across programs
  16. For information to complete the loop and create value, it

    passes through the stages of the loop, each stage enabled by specific technologies. An act is monitored by a sensor, which creates information. That information passed through a network so that it can be communicated, and standards—be they technical, legal, regulatory, or social—allow that information to be aggregated across time and space. Augmented intelligence is a generic term meant to capture all manner of analytical support, which collectively are used to analyze information. The loop is completed via augmented behavior technologies that either enable automated autonomous action or shape human decisions in a manner that leads to improved action. The amount of value created by information passing through the loop is a function of the value drivers identified in the middle. Falling into three generic categories—magnitude, risk, and time—the specific drivers listed are not exhaustive but only illustrative. Different applications will benefit from an emphasis on different drivers . Information Value Loop Realizing the IoT’s full potential motivates a framework that captures the series and sequence of activities by which organizations create value from information: the Information Value Loop Standards Magnitude Scope | Scale | Frequency Copyright © 2017 Deloitte Development LLC. All rights reserved. 18 Risk Security | Reliability | Accuracy Time Latency | Timeliness Act Analyze Create Communicate Aggregate Network Augmented Intelligence Sensors Augmented Behavior Stages Value Drivers Technologies