Share
Embed
Learning with Fenchel-Young Losses
I read the paper "Learning with Fenchel-Young Losses" (JMLR2020): https://arxiv.org/abs/1901.02324
Han Bao
June 10, 2020
Transcript
46 slides
-
8IBUJTMPTTGVODUJPOT ˙ .FBTVSJOHEJ⒎FSFODFCFUXFFOUBSHFUBOEQSFEJDUJPO ⾣ &YBNQMFSFHSFTTJPO ⾣ &YBNQMFCJOBSZDMBTTJpDBUJPO
yf(x) ℓ(yf(x)) DPSSFDU XSPOH y − f(x) ℓ(y − f(x)) NBLJOH DMPTFSUP TRVBSFEMPTT )VCFSMPTT f(x) y NBLJOH FRVBMUP MPTT MPHJTUJDMPTT IJOHFMPTT sign( f(x)) sign(y) -
'FODIFM:PVOH-PTT %FpOJUJPO-FU CFBlQSFEJDUJPOzSFHVMBSJ[FS Ω : ℝd → ℝ
LΩ (θ; y) := Ω⋆(θ) + Ω(y) − ⟨θ, y⟩ QSFEJDUJPO TDPSF ∈ ℝd UBSHFUMBCFM ∈ dom(Ω) 'FODIFMDPOKVHBUF Ω⋆(θ) := sup μ∈dom(Ω) ⟨θ, μ⟩ − Ω(μ) 8IBUPOUIFFBSUIEPFTJUNFBO 1PUFOUJBMRVFTUJPOT UPCFBOTXFSFE 28IBUJTlQSFEJDUJPOzSFHVMBSJ[FS 28IZEPXFOFFESFHVMBSJ[BUJPOPGQSFEJDUJPO 28IZJTUIFMPTTEFpOFEBTBCPWF -
1JQFMJOFPG4VQFSWJTFE-FBSOJOH *OQVUTQBDF 4DPSFTQBDF 0VUQVUTQBDF ℝd x θ ̂ y
QBSBNFUSJ[FENPEFM fW QSFEJDUJPOGVODUJPO ̂ yΩ 0.821 1.215 ⋮ 5.382 ⋮ −1.012 0 0 ⋮ 1 ⋮ 0 ∈ %// fW BSHNBY ̂ yΩ *OQVU 4DPSF 0VUQVU &YBNQMF DMBTTJpDBUJPO IPUWFDT -
1SFEJDUJPO'VODUJPOT BSHNBY argmax y∈Δd ⟨θ, y⟩ Δ3
BSHNBY ˙ DIPPTJOHBWFSUFY USBDUBCMF -
1SFEJDUJPO'VODUJPOT BSHNBY argmax y∈Δd ⟨θ, y⟩ Δ3
BSHNBY ˙ DIPPTJOHBWFSUFY USBDUBCMF OPOVOJRTPMVUJPO Δ3 BSHNBY -
1SFEJDUJPO'VODUJPOT BSHNBY argmax y∈Δd ⟨θ, y⟩ Δ3
BSHNBY ˙ DIPPTJOHBWFSUFY USBDUBCMF OPOVOJRTPMVUJPO Δ3 BSHNBY OPOEJ⒎FSFOUJBCMF OPVODFSUBJOUZ -
1SFEJDUJPO'VODUJPOT BSHNBY argmax y∈Δd ⟨θ, y⟩ TPGUNBY argmax y∈Δd
⟨θ, y⟩ + HS (y) 4IBOOPO FOUSPQZ -
TPGUNBY ˙ SFHVMBSJ[FUPXBSETDFOUFS argmax y∈Δd ⟨θ, y⟩
+ HS (y) = exp θi ∑d j=1 exp θj i PSEJOBSZFYQSFTTJPO 1SFEJDUJPO'VODUJPOT BSHNBY argmax y∈Δd ⟨θ, y⟩ TPGUNBY argmax y∈Δd ⟨θ, y⟩ + HS (y) 4IBOOPO FOUSPQZ -
TPGUNBY ˙ SFHVMBSJ[FUPXBSETDFOUFS argmax y∈Δd ⟨θ, y⟩
+ HS (y) = exp θi ∑d j=1 exp θj i PSEJOBSZFYQSFTTJPO 1SFEJDUJPO'VODUJPOT BSHNBY argmax y∈Δd ⟨θ, y⟩ EJ⒎FSFOUJBCMF VODFSUBJOUZ TPGUNBY argmax y∈Δd ⟨θ, y⟩ + HS (y) 4IBOOPO FOUSPQZ -
TPGUNBY ˙ SFHVMBSJ[FUPXBSETDFOUFS argmax y∈Δd ⟨θ, y⟩
+ HS (y) = exp θi ∑d j=1 exp θj i PSEJOBSZFYQSFTTJPO 1SFEJDUJPO'VODUJPOT BSHNBY argmax y∈Δd ⟨θ, y⟩ EFOTFTVQQPSU GPSMBSHF JTJOUSBDUBCMF ∑d j=1 d EJ⒎FSFOUJBCMF VODFSUBJOUZ TPGUNBY argmax y∈Δd ⟨θ, y⟩ + HS (y) 4IBOOPO FOUSPQZ -
1SFEJDUJPO'VODUJPOT BSHNBY argmax y∈Δd ⟨θ, y⟩ TPGUNBY argmax y∈Δd
⟨θ, y⟩ + HS (y) 4IBOOPO FOUSPQZ TQBSTFNBY argmax y∈Δd ⟨θ, y⟩− 1 2 ∥y∥2 2 5TBMMJT FOUSPQZ -
1SFEJDUJPO'VODUJPOT BSHNBY argmax y∈Δd ⟨θ, y⟩ TPGUNBY argmax y∈Δd
⟨θ, y⟩ + HS (y) 4IBOOPO FOUSPQZ TQBSTFNBY argmax y∈Δd ⟨θ, y⟩− 1 2 ∥y∥2 2 5TBMMJT FOUSPQZ ˙ &VDMJEFBOQSPKFDUJPOUPXBSETTJNQMFY argmax y∈Δd ⟨θ, y⟩− 1 2 ∥y∥2 = argmax y∈Δd ∥y − θ∥2 UFOEUPCFTQBSTF -
1SFEJDUJPO'VODUJPOT BSHNBY argmax y∈Δd ⟨θ, y⟩ TPGUNBY argmax y∈Δd
⟨θ, y⟩ + HS (y) 4IBOOPO FOUSPQZ TQBSTFNBY argmax y∈Δd ⟨θ, y⟩− 1 2 ∥y∥2 2 5TBMMJT FOUSPQZ ˙ &VDMJEFBOQSPKFDUJPOUPXBSETTJNQMFY argmax y∈Δd ⟨θ, y⟩− 1 2 ∥y∥2 = argmax y∈Δd ∥y − θ∥2 UFOEUPCFTQBSTF EDBTF EFOTF TQBSTF Δ2 -
1SFEJDUJPO'VODUJPOT BSHNBY argmax y∈Δd ⟨θ, y⟩ TPGUNBY argmax y∈Δd
⟨θ, y⟩ + HS (y) 4IBOOPO FOUSPQZ TQBSTFNBY argmax y∈Δd ⟨θ, y⟩− 1 2 ∥y∥2 2 5TBMMJT FOUSPQZ ˙ &VDMJEFBOQSPKFDUJPOUPXBSETTJNQMFY argmax y∈Δd ⟨θ, y⟩− 1 2 ∥y∥2 = argmax y∈Δd ∥y − θ∥2 UFOEUPCFTQBSTF EDBTF EFOTF TQBSTF Δ2 EDBTF Δ3 EFOTF TQBSTF -
1SFEJDUJPO'VODUJPOT BSHNBY argmax y∈Δd ⟨θ, y⟩ TPGUNBY argmax y∈Δd
⟨θ, y⟩ + HS (y) 4IBOOPO FOUSPQZ TQBSTFNBY argmax y∈Δd ⟨θ, y⟩− 1 2 ∥y∥2 2 5TBMMJT FOUSPQZ ˙ &VDMJEFBOQSPKFDUJPOUPXBSETTJNQMFY argmax y∈Δd ⟨θ, y⟩− 1 2 ∥y∥2 = argmax y∈Δd ∥y − θ∥2 UFOEUPCFTQBSTF EDBTF EFOTF TQBSTF Δ2 EDBTF Δ3 EFOTF TQBSTF ⾣ QPJOUTJO ˠEFOTFQSPK ⾣ PUIFSXJTFˠTQBSTFQSPK ⾣ JTGBSTNBMMFSUIBOℝd -
1SFEJDUJPO'VODUJPOT BSHNBY argmax y∈Δd ⟨θ, y⟩ TPGUNBY argmax y∈Δd
⟨θ, y⟩ + HS (y) 4IBOOPO FOUSPQZ TQBSTFNBY argmax y∈Δd ⟨θ, y⟩− 1 2 ∥y∥2 2 5TBMMJT FOUSPQZ TQBSTFNBY USBDUBCMF TUJMMJUEFQFOET EJ⒎FSFOUJBCMF VOJRVFTPMVUJPO TQBSTFTVQQPSU ˠJOUFSQSFUBCMF ˙ &VDMJEFBOQSPKFDUJPOUPXBSETTJNQMFY argmax y∈Δd ⟨θ, y⟩− 1 2 ∥y∥2 = argmax y∈Δd ∥y − θ∥2 -
l3FHVMBSJ[FEz1SFEJDUJPO BSHNBY argmax y∈Δd ⟨θ, y⟩ TPGUNBY argmax y∈Δd
⟨θ, y⟩ + HS (y) 4IBOOPO FOUSPQZ TQBSTFNBY argmax y∈Δd ⟨θ, y⟩− 1 2 ∥y∥2 2 5TBMMJT FOUSPQZ %FpOJUJPO-FU CFBSFHVMBSJ[FS 5IFQSFEJDUJPOGVODUJPOSFHVMBSJ[FECZ JT Ω : ℝd → ℝ Ω ̂ yΩ (θ) = argmax y∈dom(Ω) ⟨θ, y⟩ − Ω(y) QSFEJDUJPO TDPSF ∈ ℝd NBLFTQSFEJDUJPO BQBSUGSPNWFSUJDFT CFBXBSFEJ⒎FSFOU GSPNVTVBMSFHVMBSJ[BUJPO Loss( fW ) + λ∥W∥2 F -
'VSUIFS4USVDUVSFE1SFEJDUJPO UIJTQBSUKVTUNPUJWBUFTSFHVMBSJ[BUJPOGVSUIFSZPVNBZTLJQJU &YBNQMF4FRVFODFMBCFMJOH 0VUQVUTQBDFDPOTJTUTPGTUSVDUVSFEPCKFDUTTVDIBTHSBQIT * MPWF MPTT GVODUJPOT /
/ / / 7 / / / 7 / / / ʜ ʜ JOQVUx PVUQVU DBOETy ʜ ʜ TDPSFTθ MFOHUIn 7 / + ʜ TJ[Fm TFUPGMBCFMT QSPCBCJMJUZ TJNQMFY -
'VSUIFS4USVDUVSFE1SFEJDUJPO UIJTQBSUKVTUNPUJWBUFTSFHVMBSJ[BUJPOGVSUIFSZPVNBZTLJQJU &YBNQMF4FRVFODFMBCFMJOH 0VUQVUTQBDFDPOTJTUTPGTUSVDUVSFEPCKFDUTTVDIBTHSBQIT * MPWF MPTT GVODUJPOT /
/ / / 7 / / / 7 / / / ʜ ʜ JOQVUx PVUQVU DBOETy ʜ ʜ TDPSFTθ MFOHUIn 7 / + ʜ TJ[Fm TFUPGMBCFMT FYQPOFOUJBM || = mn QSPCBCJMJUZ TJNQMFY -
'VSUIFS4USVDUVSFE1SFEJDUJPO UIJTQBSUKVTUNPUJWBUFTSFHVMBSJ[BUJPOGVSUIFSZPVNBZTLJQJU &YBNQMF-JOFBSBTTJHONFOU FHMJTUXJTFSBOLJOH 0VUQVUTQBDFDPOTJTUTPGTUSVDUVSFEPCKFDUTTVDIBTHSBQIT JOQVUx PVUQVU DBOETy
ʜ ʜ TDPSFTθ #JSLIP⒎ QPMZUPQF EPD EPD EPD EPD PGEPDTn ʜ ʜ -
'VSUIFS4USVDUVSFE1SFEJDUJPO UIJTQBSUKVTUNPUJWBUFTSFHVMBSJ[BUJPOGVSUIFSZPVNBZTLJQJU &YBNQMF-JOFBSBTTJHONFOU FHMJTUXJTFSBOLJOH 0VUQVUTQBDFDPOTJTUTPGTUSVDUVSFEPCKFDUTTVDIBTHSBQIT JOQVUx PVUQVU DBOETy
ʜ ʜ TDPSFTθ #JSLIP⒎ QPMZUPQF EPD EPD EPD EPD PGEPDTn FYQPOFOUJBM || = n! ʜ ʜ -
'VSUIFS4USVDUVSFE1SFEJDUJPO ˙ -PXEJNFOTJPOBMJOIFSFOUTUSVDUVSFFYJTUT UIP JTFYQPOFOUJBMMZMBSHF
˙ &YBNQMF4FRVFODFMBCFMJOH ⾣ "TTVNQJOQVUXPSENBUUFST ⾣ "TTVNQQSFWMBCFMNBUUFST || UIJTQBSUKVTUNPUJWBUFTSFHVMBSJ[BUJPOGVSUIFSZPVNBZTLJQJU x1 x2 x3 x4 y1 y2 y3 y4 *OQVUTQBDF 4DPSFTQBDF x θ NPEFM fW -PXEJN TDPSFTQBDF η MJOFBSUSBOT M QSPCMFNEFQFOEFOU 㱺MPXEJNTUSVDUVSFO(nm2) XJEFMZVTFEJOMJOFBSDIBJO$3'T -
'VSUIFS4USVDUVSFE1SFEJDUJPO ."1JOGFSFODF argmax y∈conv() ⟨θ, y⟩ NBSHJOBMJOGFSFODF argmax y∈conv()
⟨θ, y⟩ + HS (y) 4IBOOPO FOUSPQZ 4QBSTF."1 argmax y∈conv() ⟨θ, y⟩ + H2 (y) 5TBMMJT FOUSPQZ UIJTQBSUKVTUNPUJWBUFTSFHVMBSJ[BUJPOGVSUIFSZPVNBZTLJQJU USBDUBCMF OPVODFSUBJOUZ OPEJ⒎FSFOUJBUJPO EJ⒎FSFOUJBCMF VODFSUBJOUZ PGUFO JOUSBDUBCMF EFOTFTVQQPSU EJ⒎FSFOUJBCMF VODFSUBJOUZ USBDUBCMF 'SBOL8PMGF TQBSTFTVQQPSU 3FNBSL TQBSTFNBYEPFTOPUVUJMJ[F MPXEJNTUSVDUVSF 3FNBSL5SBDUBCJMJUZ TFRVFODFMBCFMJOH."1 7JUFSCJ NBSHJOBMBSF MJOBTTJHO."1 )VOHBSJBO JT NBSHJOBMJT1DPNQ O(nm2) O(n3) -
)PXUPEFTJHOMPTT *OQVUTQBDF 4DPSFTQBDF 0VUQVUTQBDF x θ fW ̂ yΩ
QSFEJDUJPO ̂ y TPGUNBY argmax y∈Δd ⟨θ, y⟩ + HS (y) TQBSTFNBY argmax y∈Δd ⟨θ, y⟩− 1 2 ∥y∥2 2 -
)PXUPEFTJHOMPTT *OQVUTQBDF 4DPSFTQBDF 0VUQVUTQBDF x θ fW ̂ yΩ
QSFEJDUJPO ̂ y TPGUNBY argmax y∈Δd ⟨θ, y⟩ + HS (y) TQBSTFNBY argmax y∈Δd ⟨θ, y⟩− 1 2 ∥y∥2 2 UBSHFUMBCFM y -
)PXUPEFTJHOMPTT *OQVUTQBDF 4DPSFTQBDF 0VUQVUTQBDF x θ fW ̂ yΩ
QSFEJDUJPO ̂ y TPGUNBY argmax y∈Δd ⟨θ, y⟩ + HS (y) TQBSTFNBY argmax y∈Δd ⟨θ, y⟩− 1 2 ∥y∥2 2 UBSHFUMBCFM y 2)PXUPNFBTVSF -
)PXUPEFTJHOMPTT TPGUNBY argmax y∈Δd ⟨θ, y⟩ + HS (y)
TQBSTFNBY argmax y∈Δd ⟨θ, y⟩− 1 2 ∥y∥2 2 1SFEJDUJPOGVODUJPO -PTTGVODUJPO -
)PXUPEFTJHOMPTT TPGUNBY argmax y∈Δd ⟨θ, y⟩ + HS (y)
TQBSTFNBY argmax y∈Δd ⟨θ, y⟩− 1 2 ∥y∥2 2 1SFEJDUJPOGVODUJPO -PTTGVODUJPO DSPTTFOUSPQZ log∑ i exp θi − θk UBSHFUDMBTT -
)PXUPEFTJHOMPTT TPGUNBY argmax y∈Δd ⟨θ, y⟩ + HS (y)
TQBSTFNBY argmax y∈Δd ⟨θ, y⟩− 1 2 ∥y∥2 2 1SFEJDUJPOGVODUJPO -PTTGVODUJPO DSPTTFOUSPQZ log∑ i exp θi − θk UBSHFUDMBTT 28IZJUJTHPPE -
)PXUPEFTJHOMPTT TPGUNBY argmax y∈Δd ⟨θ, y⟩ + HS (y)
TQBSTFNBY argmax y∈Δd ⟨θ, y⟩− 1 2 ∥y∥2 2 1SFEJDUJPOGVODUJPO -PTTGVODUJPO DSPTTFOUSPQZ log∑ i exp θi − θk UBSHFUDMBTT ʁʁʁ 28IZJUJTHPPE -
)PXUPEFTJHOMPTT TPGUNBY argmax y∈Δd ⟨θ, y⟩ + HS (y)
TQBSTFNBY argmax y∈Δd ⟨θ, y⟩− 1 2 ∥y∥2 2 1SFEJDUJPOGVODUJPO -PTTGVODUJPO DSPTTFOUSPQZ log∑ i exp θi − θk UBSHFUDMBTT ʁʁʁ 28IZJUJTHPPE 2)PXUPEFTJHO -
'FODIFM:PVOH-PTT %FpOJUJPO-FU CFBlQSFEJDUJPOzSFHVMBSJ[FS Ω : ℝd → ℝ
LΩ (θ; y) := Ω⋆(θ) + Ω(y) − ⟨θ, y⟩ QSFEJDUJPO TDPSF UBSHFUMBCFM 'FODIFMDPOKVHBUF Ω⋆(θ) := sup μ∈dom(Ω) ⟨θ, μ⟩ − Ω(μ) 5XPLFZQSPQFSUJFT ˙ ':MPTTJTOPOOFHBUJWF ˙ DPSSFDUQSFE J⒎[FSPMPTT y = ̂ yΩ (θ) -
'FODIFM:PVOH-PTT %FpOJUJPO-FU CFBlQSFEJDUJPOzSFHVMBSJ[FS Ω : ℝd → ℝ
LΩ (θ; y) := Ω⋆(θ) + Ω(y) − ⟨θ, y⟩ QSFEJDUJPO TDPSF UBSHFUMBCFM 'FODIFMDPOKVHBUF Ω⋆(θ) := sup μ∈dom(Ω) ⟨θ, μ⟩ − Ω(μ) 5XPLFZQSPQFSUJFT ˙ ':MPTTJTOPOOFHBUJWF ˙ DPSSFDUQSFE J⒎[FSPMPTT y = ̂ yΩ (θ) .JOJNJ[JOH':MPTTNBLFTQSFEJDUJPODMPTFUPUBSHFUMBCFM -
'FODIFM:PVOH-PTT %FpOJUJPO-FU CFBlQSFEJDUJPOzSFHVMBSJ[FS Ω : ℝd → ℝ
LΩ (θ; y) := Ω⋆(θ) + Ω(y) − ⟨θ, y⟩ QSFEJDUJPO TDPSF UBSHFUMBCFM 'FODIFMDPOKVHBUF Ω⋆(θ) := sup μ∈dom(Ω) ⟨θ, μ⟩ − Ω(μ) 5XPLFZQSPQFSUJFT ˙ ':MPTTJTOPOOFHBUJWF ˙ DPSSFDUQSFE J⒎[FSPMPTT y = ̂ yΩ (θ) .JOJNJ[JOH':MPTTNBLFTQSFEJDUJPODMPTFUPUBSHFUMBCFM 1SPPG6TF'FODIFM:PVOHJOFRVBMJUZ Ω⋆(θ) + Ω(y) ≥ {⟨θ, y⟩ − Ω(y)} + Ω(y) = ⟨θ, y⟩ -
(FPNFUSJDBM*OUFSQSFUBUJPO Ω(y) y μ 'PSSFHVMBSJ[FS ̂ yΩ (θ) ESBXUBOHFOU
BU CZEFGPG'FODIFMDPOKVHBUF ̂ yΩ (θ) ⟨θ, μ⟩ − Ω⋆(θ) -
(FPNFUSJDBM*OUFSQSFUBUJPO Ω(y) y μ 'PSSFHVMBSJ[FS ̂ yΩ (θ) ESBXUBOHFOU
BU CZEFGPG'FODIFMDPOKVHBUF ̂ yΩ (θ) ⟨θ, μ⟩ − Ω⋆(θ) ⟨θ, y⟩ − Ω⋆(θ) −Ω⋆(θ) -
(FPNFUSJDBM*OUFSQSFUBUJPO Ω(y) y μ 'PSSFHVMBSJ[FS ̂ yΩ (θ) ESBXUBOHFOU
BU CZEFGPG'FODIFMDPOKVHBUF ̂ yΩ (θ) ⟨θ, μ⟩ − Ω⋆(θ) ⟨θ, y⟩ − Ω⋆(θ) −Ω⋆(θ) LΩ (y; θ) -PTTJTEJTUBODFCFUXFFO BOE BU #SFHNBOEJWFSHFODF y -
&YBNQMF4IBOOPO&OUSPQZ HS (y) = − d ∑ j=1 yj
log yj ̂ yHS (θ) = argmax y∈Δd ⟨θ, y⟩ − HS (y) = exp θ ∑d j=1 exp θj TPGUNBY θ ̂ y(θ) CJOBSZTPGUNBYTJHNPJE LHS (θ; y) = H⋆ S (θ) + HS (y) − ⟨θ, y⟩ = log d ∑ j=1 exp θj − θk BTTVNJOHy = ek DSPTTFOUSPQZ JTMPHJTUJDMPTTJOCJOBSZDBTF LHS ( ̂ yHS (θ); y) -
&YBNQMF5TBMMJT&OUSPQZ H2 (y) = 1 2 d ∑ j=1
yj (1 − yj ) Hα (y) = 1 α(α − 1) d ∑ j=1 (yj − yα j ) HS (y) = − d ∑ j=1 yj log yj 5TBMMJTFOUSPQZ α α → 2 α → 1 BLB(JOJJOEFY 4IBOOPOFOUSPQZ TQBSTFNBY θ ̂ y(θ) m ℓ(m) TQBSTFNBYMPTT H⋆ 2 (θ) + H2 (y) − ⟨θ, y⟩ NPEJpFE)VCFSMPTT TQFDJBMJ[FEJOCJOBSZDMBTTJpDBUJPO -
0UIFS/JDF1SPQFSUZ 0WFSWJFX ˙ 4FQBSBUJPONBSHJO j j BpOJUFTDPSFBUUBJOT[FSPMPTT JG JTlTQBSTFz
˙ $BMJCSBUFETVSSPHBUF j NJOJNJ[JOH':MPTTMFBETUPNJOJNJ[JOHDMBTTJpDBUJPOFSSPS NPSFEJTDVTTJPOJTOFFEFEGPSTUSVDUVSFEQSFEJDUJPO ˙ &⒏DJFOUPQUJNJ[BUJPO j BMXBZTDPOWFYCZOBUVSFPQUJNJ[BCMFXJUI'SBOL8PMGFBMHPSJUIN JUFSBUJWFMZNJOJNJ[JOHMJOFBSBQQSPY Ω m ℓ(m) MPHJTUJD 4IBOOPO WBOJTIFTBU 㱣OPTFQNHO TQBSTFNBY 5TBMMJT TFQNHO m ℓ(m) 㱺OPQFOBMJ[BUJPOPOMBSHFFOPVHIQSFEJDUJPONBSHJOT -
4VNNBSZ *OQVUTQBDF 4DPSFTQBDF 0VUQVUTQBDF x θ fW ̂ yΩ
QSFEJDUJPO ̂ y UBSHFUMBCFM y -
4VNNBSZ *OQVUTQBDF 4DPSFTQBDF 0VUQVUTQBDF x θ fW ̂ yΩ
QSFEJDUJPO ̂ y UBSHFUMBCFM y ̂ yΩ (θ) = argmax y∈dom(Ω) ⟨θ, y⟩ − Ω(y) 3FHVMBSJ[FEQSFEJDUJPO NBLFTQBSTF USBDUBCMF ʜ -
4VNNBSZ *OQVUTQBDF 4DPSFTQBDF 0VUQVUTQBDF x θ fW ̂ yΩ
QSFEJDUJPO ̂ y UBSHFUMBCFM y ̂ yΩ (θ) = argmax y∈dom(Ω) ⟨θ, y⟩ − Ω(y) 3FHVMBSJ[FEQSFEJDUJPO NBLFTQBSTF USBDUBCMF ʜ LΩ (θ; y) := Ω⋆(θ) + Ω(y) − ⟨θ, y⟩ 'FODIFM:PVOHMPTT TZTUFNBUJDXBZDPOTUSVDUJOHMPTTGSPNΩ