Upgrade to Pro
— share decks privately, control downloads, hide ads and more …
Speaker Deck
Features
Speaker Deck
PRO
Sign in
Sign up for free
Search
Search
Whoops! Where did my architecture go?
Search
Sponsored
·
SiteGround - Reliable hosting with speed, security, and support you can count on.
→
Oliver Drotbohm
October 13, 2016
Programming
2
790
Whoops! Where did my architecture go?
Slides of the talk I gave at GOTO London, 2016.
Oliver Drotbohm
October 13, 2016
Tweet
Share
More Decks by Oliver Drotbohm
See All by Oliver Drotbohm
What's new in Spring Modulith?
olivergierke
1
230
Domain-centric? Why Hexagonal and Onion Architecture Are Answers to the Wrong Question
olivergierke
4
1.8k
It Takes Two to Tango – Designing Module Interactions in Modulithic Spring Applications
olivergierke
5
780
Bottom-Up Architecture – Bridging the Achitecture Code Gap
olivergierke
4
1k
Spring Modulith – A Deep Dive
olivergierke
9
5k
Spring for the Architecturally Curious Developer
olivergierke
5
1.9k
Spring Boot 3 & Spring Framework 6
olivergierke
4
2.1k
Architecturally-evident Java Applications with jMolecules
olivergierke
9
3k
A Deep Dive into Spring Application Events
olivergierke
12
3.4k
Other Decks in Programming
See All in Programming
Smart Handoff/Pickup ガイド - Claude Code セッション管理
yukiigarashi
0
150
AI巻き込み型コードレビューのススメ
nealle
2
1.3k
インターン生でもAuth0で認証基盤刷新が出来るのか
taku271
0
190
「ブロックテーマでは再現できない」は本当か?
inc2734
0
1k
React 19でつくる「気持ちいいUI」- 楽観的UIのすすめ
himorishige
11
7.5k
AIによるイベントストーミング図からのコード生成 / AI-powered code generation from Event Storming diagrams
nrslib
2
1.9k
15年続くIoTサービスのSREエンジニアが挑む分散トレーシング導入
melonps
2
230
それ、本当に安全? ファイルアップロードで見落としがちなセキュリティリスクと対策
penpeen
7
4k
20260127_試行錯誤の結晶を1冊に。著者が解説 先輩データサイエンティストからの指南書 / author's_commentary_ds_instructions_guide
nash_efp
1
990
プロダクトオーナーから見たSOC2 _SOC2ゆるミートアップ#2
kekekenta
0
220
Best-Practices-for-Cortex-Analyst-and-AI-Agent
ryotaroikeda
1
110
ぼくの開発環境2026
yuzneri
0
240
Featured
See All Featured
Designing Experiences People Love
moore
144
24k
Helping Users Find Their Own Way: Creating Modern Search Experiences
danielanewman
31
3.1k
Technical Leadership for Architectural Decision Making
baasie
2
250
ピンチをチャンスに:未来をつくるプロダクトロードマップ #pmconf2020
aki_iinuma
128
55k
SEOcharity - Dark patterns in SEO and UX: How to avoid them and build a more ethical web
sarafernandez
0
120
Un-Boring Meetings
codingconduct
0
200
WCS-LA-2024
lcolladotor
0
450
Joys of Absence: A Defence of Solitary Play
codingconduct
1
290
Beyond borders and beyond the search box: How to win the global "messy middle" with AI-driven SEO
davidcarrasco
1
57
ReactJS: Keep Simple. Everything can be a component!
pedronauck
666
130k
Jamie Indigo - Trashchat’s Guide to Black Boxes: Technical SEO Tactics for LLMs
techseoconnect
PRO
0
65
Build The Right Thing And Hit Your Dates
maggiecrowley
39
3k
Transcript
Whoops! Where did my architecture go? In between a monolith
and a system of systems mess… / @olivergierke
None
None
Background Consulting & engineering @ Pivotal Lots of code reviews
Eoin Woods‘ talk on InfoQ
Roadmap Divide and conquer Of layers and slices The modular
monolith
Divide and conquer
Component Single unit to understand
Component Single unit to change
Component Scope of risk of change
B Smaller unit to understand A
B Reduced risk of change A
B Cost of separation A
B Definition and maintenance of dependencies A
Of layers and slices…
Presentation Service Data Access Billing Inventory Order
Layers Well understood Known to developers Less important to business
Slices Hardly understood New to developers Key for business requirements
Presentation Service Data Access Billing Inventory Order
Monolith VS. System of Systems
Monolith VS. System of Systems Order Inventory Billing Order Inventory
Billing
In-process calls VS. Inter-process calls Order Inventory Billing Order Inventory
Billing
Performance? Overhead? Error scenarios? Order Inventory Billing Order Inventory Billing
" If you can’t build a modular monolith, why do
you think microservices are the answer? — Simon Brown
How to manage modularity in different architectural contexts?
Means to enforce context boundaries? Order Inventory Billing Order Inventory
Billing
The modular monolith
How to implement a modular monolith?
How to maintain a modular monolith?
Bounded Context all the things! Domain-Driven Design is a great
idea! Surprise! In a monolith, too!
Architecturally- evident code
Code analysis jDepend Sonarcube Structure 101 / Sonargraph jQAssistant
A plain Java based approach
How to write code that’s less likely to deteoriate?
Presentation Service Data Access Billing Inventory Orders
Packages
….layer.slice ….slice.layer ….slice
….web.core ….service.core ….repository.core
….core.web ….core.service ….core.repository
….core ….customer ….account
Does it make a difference?
Dependency management
Orders Inventory Billing Orders Inventory Billing
A rule violation is just an @Inject away! Orders Inventory
Billing
You only need to manage what you can refer to…
Layers first Leaks slice internals Lower layers visible to everyone
Needs to be public :( Allows other code to circumvent
business logic
Slices only Keeps technical division private Encapsulates business module Internals
understood anyway
All package protected Compiler induced dependency control
Presentation Service Data Access Billing Inventory Order
Presentation Service Data Access Billing Inventory Order
Resources Blogpost Sonargraph jQAssistant Spring Data JPA @ GitHub
Sample Code http://github.com/olivergierke/ whoops-architecture
Thanks & Credits Eoin Woods — Talk @ InfoQ Stefan
Tilkov — Talk @ InfoQ