Share
Embed
Reclaim The Records - May 2018 National Genealogical Society (NGS) presentation
Using Freedom of Information Laws for Genealogical and Archival Research
Reclaim The Records
May 03, 2018
Transcript
150 slides
-
National Genealogical Society 2018 Family History Conference NAME: BROOKE
SCHREIER GANZ TITLE: RECLAIM THE RECORDS: USING FREEDOM OF INFORMATION LAWS FOR GENEALOGICAL AND ARCHIVAL RESEARCH SESSION: T262 SYLLABUS: PAGES 281-282 -
Out of respect for others, please silence electronic devices
during lecture. -
• Please no photographs, audio or video recording during the
lecture. • Presentations, including slides and syllabus material, are protected by copyright. • Slides will be freely available online at www.ReclaimTheRecords.org • Please hold questions until the end. -
USING FREEDOM OF INFORMATION LAWS FOR GENEALOGICAL AND ARCHIVAL RESEARCH
RECLAIM THE RECORDS Brooke Schreier Ganz Founder, Reclaim The Records [email protected] Twitter: @ReclaimTheRecs https://www.ReclaimTheRecords.org/ -
BIRTH INDEX MARRIAGE INDEX DEATH INDEX VOTER REGISTRATION FORMS SCHOOL
RECORDS CIVIL SERVICE RECORDS PASSPORT RECORDS TAX LISTS AND MUCH MORE -
HI, WE'RE "RECLAIM THE RECORDS" ★We want to spread the
word that you can successfully use Freedom of Information laws for genealogical and archival records! ★Crowdsource ideas from the public for new record sets to reclaim, using our Records Survey ★List our future targets publicly on our To-Do List ★Publish all requests and public correspondence with agencies in real-time through MuckRock ★Educational resource and advice portal for other people who want to make their own records requests ★Voice for change in records access, voice for the individual researchers instead of the for-profit companies -
HI, WE'RE "RECLAIM THE RECORDS" ★E-mail newsletter ★ ~5200 subscribers
★ Sent out about once every six weeks ★ Sign Up at https://www.ReclaimTheRecords.org/ ★Facebook page ★ ~7000 people follow our page ★ Updated about once a month ★ Like Us at https://www.facebook.com/ReclaimTheRecords ★Twitter feed ★ ~2100 people follow us ★ Updated every few days ★ Snarky running commentary on our cases, also retweet FOIA/FOIA news ★ Follow Us at @ReclaimTheRecs - https://twitter.com/ReclaimTheRecs -
TAMMY HEPPS OUR AWESOME BOARD JONATHAN WEBB DEISS MEGAN SMOLENYAK
BARBARA MATHEWS DALLAN QUASS JASON GERSH BROOKE SCHREIER GANZ -
HI, I'M BROOKE SCHREIER GANZ ★Born, raised, and married in
New York ★Family from New York, by birth or immigration ★All eight great-grandparents lived and married in New York City ★...but I live in California ★...and the records I want are in New York ★...and practically nothing is was online ★...and the government agencies, archives, and repositories that hold New York records are (mostly) really difficult to deal with, not proactive and not very responsive -
DUDE, WHERE ARE MY RECORDS? THE FRUSTRATIONS OF THE LONG
DISTANCE GENEALOGIST ★Every state has different laws about what CAN go online ★Every agency and archive has different policies about what WILL go online ★NY and NYC = not online, and no plans to go online ★Compare to other states, countries ★What can we do? -
PHASE I: BROOKE'S PERSONAL PROJECT FOCUSED ON NEW YORK
CITY The New York City marriage license index, 1930-1995 The list of registered voters in New York City, 1924 The New York City marriage license index, 1908-1929 MID 2016 2015 LATE 2016 ALL WE DO IS WIN, WIN, WIN ~3,000,000 records ~5,000,000 records ~800,000 records -
PHASE II: STILL BROOKE'S PERSONAL PROJECT EXPANDS IN THE
NORTHEAST LATE 2016 ALL WE DO IS WIN, WIN, WIN ~450,000 records The New Jersey birth index, 1901-1903 The New Jersey death index, 1901-1903 The New Jersey grooms index, 1901-1903 New Jersey brides index 1901-1914 -
PHASE II: STILL BROOKE'S PERSONAL PROJECT EXPANDS IN THE
NORTHEAST The New York State death index, 1880-1956 - does not include NYC (usually) - does not include the cities of Albany, Buffalo, or Yonkers prior to about 1915 JAN 2016 - MAY 2017 ALL WE DO IS WIN, WIN, WIN ~8,000,000 records -
PHASE III: RECLAIM THE RECORDS LEVELS UP NOW
A 501(C)(3) NON-PROFIT ORG The Buffalo, New York death index, 1852-1944 The New Jersey marriage index, 1901-2016 - Brides Index 1901-2000 - Grooms Index WITH SOME GAPS - Combined Index 2001-2016 AUGUST 2017 NOVEMBER 2017 ALL WE DO IS WIN, WIN, WIN ~5,000,000 records ~640,000 records -
PHASE IV: PICKING UP SPEED COMING SOON TO A
WEBSITE NEAR YOU The Wyoming death index, ~1909-1952 (Registration kind of spotty until 1920's) The Wyoming marriage index, 1941-1966 (Separate Brides Index and Grooms Index) The Wyoming divorce index, 1941-1952 (Separate Husbands Index and Wives Index) EARLY 2018 ALL WE DO IS WIN, WIN, WIN ??? records -
PHASE IV: COMING SOON TO A WEBSITE NEAR YOU! The
New York City marriage license index, 1996-2017 SUMMER 2018 ALL WE DO IS WIN, WIN, WIN ??? records IS THERE A NOTARY IN THE HOUSE? -
PHASE IV: COMING SOON TO A WEBSITE NEAR YOU The
New York State marriage index, 1881-1968 [& 1969-2016] FALL 2018 ALL WE DO IS WIN, WIN, WIN ??? records [AND POSSIBLY A LAWSUIT...] -
COMMON RECORDS ACCESS ISSUES ★ FORMAT RESTRICTIONS: There's an index
or a record, but it's only on microfilm, microfiche, or crumbling paper and it has never been digitized ★ LOCATION RESTRICTIONS: There's an index or a record, but it's only available in limited locations (i.e. one repository) during limited operating hours and days ★ LIBRARY RESTRICTIONS: There's an index or a record, but the librarian or archivist doesn't allow the public direct access to it ★ GOVERNMENT AGENCY RESTRICTIONS: There's an index or a record, but the government doesn't allow the public direct access to it ★ FINANCIAL RESTRICTIONS: There's an index or a record, but it's only available at a paywalled website for a substantial fee or annual subscription ★ KNOWLEDGE RESTRICTIONS: The library or archive doesn't publish a list of its holdings so you don't know what they even have, so you can't easily make requests -
FROM FRUSTRATION TO... ★IDENTIFICATION of records ★LEGAL JUSTIFICATION for getting
public copies ★ACQUISITION using FOIL or FOIA requests, as appropriate (and maybe using Open Data initiatives someday) ★DUPLICATION into better formats (microfilm --> digital image) ★PUBLICATION onto the Internet, raw data and tools for data ★DONATION of the original records to a library or archive ★EDUCATION of how other people can do this too -
GOVERNMENT-CREATED RECORDS ONLY ...BUT THEY MIGHT BE HELD AT A
NON-GOVERNMENT LOCATION -
ALL ABOUT FOIA AND FOIL ★FOIA = Freedom of Information
Act. (Note the A!) ★This is for records held by FEDERAL agencies ★FBI, CIA, State Department, Justice Department, etc. ★The famous one, first signed into law July 4, 1966, amended several times. ★Minor improvements were signed into law by President Obama. -
ALL ABOUT FOIA AND FOIL ★EXAMPLE: The SS-5 from the
Social Security Administration -
ALL ABOUT FOIA AND FOIL ★EXAMPLE: The SS-5 from the
Social Security Administration -
ALL ABOUT FOIA AND FOIL ★EXAMPLE: Passport Records from the
State Department -
ALL ABOUT FOIA AND FOIL ★EXAMPLE: Passport Records from the
State Department -
ALL ABOUT FOIA AND FOIL ★EXAMPLE: Passport Records from the
State Department -
STATE FOI LAWS THE FREEDOM OF INFORMATION LAW (FOIL) THE
OPEN PUBLIC RECORDS ACT (OPRA) THE SUNSHINE LAW THE RIGHT-TO-KNOW LAW (RTK) THE PUBLIC INFORMATION ACT (PIA) (ETC.) -
50 NIFTY UNITED STATES (& DC) ★ There are 51
different STATE FOI laws / Open Records laws / Sunshine laws: ★ https://ballotpedia.org/State_sunshine_laws -
FREE FREE FREE FREE FREE FREE ★ Making a request
is FREE. Appealing a denial, that is also FREE ★ A few states have ombudsmen or FOI panels, in lieu of going to court ★ If you need to go to court, and you win the release of your records, you MIGHT get your attorneys' fees paid (possible in 47 states, soon 48) ★ Usually only if the agency wrongly withheld records ★ And/or the agency failed to meet time limits ★ Five states REQUIRE your attorneys fees to be paid by state in that scenario: California, Colorado, Florida, Illinois, and New Jersey. NEW: New York is now included sometimes! ★ In some states, sometimes there can also be punitive FINES against state officials who wrongly withhold records ★ Per incident, or per record, or per day -
CURSES, FOILED AGAIN! ★You can send a records request under
FOIL to an AGENCY ★An AGENCY is defined (in New York) as: "...any state or municipal department, board, bureau, division, commission, committee, public authority, public corporation, council, office or other governmental entity performing a governmental or proprietary function for the state or any one or more municipalities thereof..." ★ Most states have pretty similar definitions of an agency. ★ Every agency should have a FOIL OFFICER to whom you address the request. WHO CAN YOU FOIL? -
CURSES, FOILED AGAIN! ★You can NOT FOIL (in New York
and several other states): ★"...except the judiciary or the state legislature." ★They're not an AGENCY. ★That means no using FOIL for adoption files, court cases, divorce cases, name changes, naturalization files, etc. ★Workaround #1: Use different laws, not FOIL, to get stuff from the judiciary ★Workaround #2: If some relevant court files wound up in the possession of an AGENCY, you can often FOIL them directly from the agency. WHO CAN YOU NOT FOIL? -
CURSES, FOILED AGAIN! ★Find out the PARENT AGENCY in charge
of the records you want ★Births and Deaths might be under the control of your state's Department of Health ★Might be extra/second copies of births and deaths (usually pre- dating statewide registration) kept in city or county archives, with the city or county clerk's office ★Marriages and Divorces might be under the control of your state's judiciary, court-by-court or county-by-county (or both), or a city or county clerk's office HOW DO YOU FOIL? -
CURSES, FOILED AGAIN! ★Can you just FOIL a copy of
a birth/marriage/death certificate? NO. GIMME MAH RECORDS -
CURSES, FOILED AGAIN! ★States set privacy restrictions on WHO can
access specific certificates ★Define family members or next-of-kin, sometimes in ridiculous or overly-limited ways ★States say WHEN a certificate is available to the public ★Model records: 125 / 100 / 75 / 50 years ★States set a fee structure stating HOW MUCH each certificate costs. ★Could be $20/certificate rather than $0.10/page under FOIL GIMME MAH RECORDS -
CURSES, FOILED AGAIN! ★Can you just FOIL a copy of
a birth/marriage/death index? YES. (usually) GIMME MAH RECORDS -
CURSES, FOILED AGAIN! ★States generally don't say WHO can access
an index ★One exception in law we've found so far: Pennsylvania ★States generally don't say WHEN an index is public ★But they'll fight you over it ★States sometimes set a fee structure stating HOW MUCH it costs for a search of an index ★But this may be illegal GIMME MAH RECORDS -
CURSES, FOILED AGAIN! ★Can you just FOIL a copy of
another type of records index? YES. (sometimes) GIMME MAH RECORDS -
CURSES, FOILED AGAIN! ★Can you use FOIL for the right
to merely VIEW or get a "genealogical" or "informational" copy of a vital record that is old and does not usually have any privacy restrictions? MAYBE. (will probably involve some legal work) GIMME MAH RECORDS -
CURSES, FOILED AGAIN! ★Once you know the PARENT AGENCY, find
the name and contact information for their FOIL OFFICER. ★Search their website, or call them up and ask. ★Remember to use your state's specific term for its Freedom of Information law ★You can submit everything: ★through e-mail; ★or through postal mail; ★or through MuckRock.com (super-helpful!) HOW DO YOU FOIL? -
THE SECRET SAUCE ★ Hi, my name is [YOUR NAME
HERE] and I am making a records request under [FOIA OR NAME OF YOUR STATE'S FOI LAW HERE]. ★ I am seeking records about [YOUR RECORDS REQUEST HERE]. ★ Try to be specific! Try to be helpful! Limit the dates! Cite laws or reasoning! ★ [IN SOME STATES: I am a private individual, not a for-profit company. These records will be made freely available to the general public.] ★ [IN VERY SMALL NUMBER OF STATES: I am a legal resident of this state.] ★ I would prefer to receive these records in [YOUR PREFERRED FORMAT HERE - COPIES, SCANS, MICROFILMS, DIGITAL PHOTOS, CSV DATABASE DUMP, ETC.]. ★ I am willing to pay for the copies of these records, up to [$XXX]. If this request might cost more, please contact me first to discuss the request. [IN SOME STATES, AND FOR FOIA: I am requesting a fee waiver, because...] HOW TO CRAFT A FOIA OR FOIL REQUEST -
THE SECRET SAUCE ★ Hi, my name is BROOKE SCHREIER
GANZ and I am making a records request under THE NEW YORK STATE FREEDOM OF INFORMATION LAW (1977 N.Y. Laws ch. 933). ★ I am seeking A COPY OF THE NEW YORK STATE DEATH INDEX, FROM JANUARY 1 1880 TO DECEMBER 31 1956. THIS INDEX IS ALREADY OPEN TO THE PUBLIC AT MANY NEW YORK STATE LIBRARIES, BUT ONLY TO PEOPLE ONSITE. THE 1957-1965 RECORDS ARE ALREADY ONLINE, SO WHY NOT RELEASE THE OLDER ONES TOO? ★ I am a private individual, not a for-profit company. These records will be made freely available to the general public. ★ [IN VERY SMALL NUMBER OF STATES: I am a legal resident of this state.] ★ I would prefer to receive these records IN CSV FILE OR OTHER DATABASE FORMAT, ALTHOUGH I WILL ACCEPT COPIES OF MICROFILMS/MICROFICHE IF THAT'S ALL YOU HAVE. ★ I am willing to pay for the copies of these records, up to $500. If this request might cost more, please contact me first to discuss the request. [IN SOME STATES, AND FOR FOIA: I am requesting a fee waiver, because...] EXAMPLE OF A NEW YORK STATE FOIL REQUEST -
FIND GROUPS TO HELP YOU ★ State and local organizations
can help you with FOI questions - free! ★ Might be aimed more towards journalists than the public ★ New York has the utterly awesome Committee on Open Government (COOG) ★ Will write free Advisory Opinions about your records request! ★ https://www.dos.ny.gov/coog/ -
50 NIFTY UNITED STATES (& DC) ★ There are 51
different FOI laws / Open Records Laws / Sunshine Laws: ★ https://ballotpedia.org/State_sunshine_laws -
57 VARIETIES, JUST LIKE KETCHUP ★ 57 separate VITAL RECORDS
JURISIDICTIONS: ★ All 50 states ★ ...plus Washington DC ★ ...plus 5 territories: Puerto Rico, Guam, US Virgin Islands, Northern Mariana Islands, and American Samoa ★ ...plus NEW YORK CITY ★ From a vital records standpoint, New York State and New York City are entirely separate entities, but both are still subject to New York State's Freedom of Information Law (FOIL) -
TWO KINDS OF MARRIAGE RECORDS ★ Kept from the 1880's
through 1937 ★ These are TWO-PAGE documents with basic info on the couple, and the second page is basically just everyone's signatures ★ A "Brides Index" and a "Grooms Index" of these certificates were created in the 1930's, handwritten on index cards ★ Those cards were scanned by FamilySearch and are available on FamilySearch microfilms, as are the actual certificates ★ Volunteers at the non-profit genealogy group ItalianGen transcribed the Brides Index and Grooms Index cards into TWO searchable databases ★ These ItalianGen databases best searched using Steve Morse's website, but now also available through Ancestry.com RECORD TYPE #1: THE HEALTH DEPARTMENT CERTIFICATES -
TWO KINDS OF MARRIAGE RECORDS RECORD TYPE #1: THE HEALTH
DEPARTMENT CERTIFICATES PAGE 1 OF 2 -
TWO KINDS OF MARRIAGE RECORDS RECORD TYPE #1: THE HEALTH
DEPARTMENT CERTIFICATES PAGE 2 OF 2 -
TWO KINDS OF MARRIAGE RECORDS ★ Kept from 1908 to
the present day! ★ These are THREE-PAGE documents, usually containing MORE information than the Health Department certificates. ★ These records are: 1. the AFFIDAVIT that the couple signed, swearing that they have the right and the ability to get married (of legal age! no bigamy! no STD's!); 2. the LICENSE APPLICATION and the LICENSE that the couple has now been officially granted, so that they can go get married a few weeks later; 3. the CERTIFICATE filled out by the clergyman on the day of the wedding, with witnesses, and sometimes witnesses' addresses; ★ THREE DIFFERENT SETS OF HANDWRITING! RECORD TYPE #2: THE CITY CLERK'S OFFICE RECORDS -
TWO KINDS OF MARRIAGE RECORDS ★ EXTRA AWESOME things that
the City Clerk's Office records have that the Health Department Certificates DO NOT have: ★ The bride’s occupation ★ The couple’s cities of birth (not just country of birth) ★ Their parents’ countries of birth ★ If either of the pair were ever widowed and if so, when their spouse died ★ If either of the pair ever were divorced and if so, when the divorce was finalized (and starting in late 1930's, lists the grounds for the divorce) ★ The home addresses of the witnesses RECORD TYPE #2: THE CITY CLERK'S OFFICE RECORDS -
TWO KINDS OF MARRIAGE RECORDS ★ EXTRA AWESOME things that
the City Clerk's Office records have that the Health Department Certificates DO NOT have: ★ Yes, women worked outside of the home. RECORD TYPE #2: THE CITY CLERK'S OFFICE RECORDS -
TWO KINDS OF MARRIAGE RECORDS ★ EXTRA AWESOME things that
the City Clerk's Office records have that the Health Department Certificates DO NOT have: ★ Addresses for the witnesses (started appearing on form circa 1924) RECORD TYPE #2: THE CITY CLERK'S OFFICE RECORDS -
TWO KINDS OF MARRIAGE RECORDS ★ EXTRA AWESOME things that
the City Clerk's Office records have that the Health Department Certificates DO NOT have: ★ (bottom of a 1932 license and application) RECORD TYPE #2: THE CITY CLERK'S OFFICE RECORDS -
TWO KINDS OF MARRIAGE RECORDS ★ EXTRA AWESOME things that
the City Clerk's Office records have that the Health Department Certificates DO NOT have: ★ (bottom of a 1937 license and application, new lines added) RECORD TYPE #2: THE CITY CLERK'S OFFICE RECORDS -
TWO KINDS OF MARRIAGE RECORDS ★ EXTRA AWESOME things that
the City Clerk's Office records have that the Health Department Certificates DO NOT have: ★10% more records! RECORD TYPE #2: THE CITY CLERK'S OFFICE RECORDS -
TWO KINDS OF MARRIAGE RECORDS ★ Only available onsite?! ★
These City Clerk's records are not even listed on the "Genealogy Collections" one-sheet that is handed out onsite at the Municipal Archives at 31 Chambers Street. ★ It's like these amazing, awesome, useful records...don't even exist. RECORD TYPE #2: THE CITY CLERK'S OFFICE RECORDS ★ photo credit: Bette Stoop Mas -
FOIL CASE AGAINST DORIS, 2015 ★They never ever cited any
legal reasons why these records should not be available under FOIL. ★FOIL Appeal procedures were not followed. ★Stonewalled. ★What now? -
FROM FRUSTRATION TO... ★IDENTIFICATION of records ★LEGAL JUSTIFICATION for getting
public copies ★ACQUISITION using FOIL or FOIA requests, as appropriate (and maybe using Open Data initiatives someday) ★DUPLICATION into better formats (microfilm --> digital image) ★PUBLICATION onto the Internet, raw data and tools for data ★DONATION of the original records to a library or archive ★EDUCATION of how other people can do this too -
THE RIPPLE EFFECTS ★ Phyllis Kramer, VP at JewishGen, genealogist
in NY and FL ★ When people register to vote, those records are public ★ Had to re-register every year, not just when you moved ★ "List of Registered Voters" published annually, like an index ★ Actual registration sheets, filled out by would-be voters ★ Includes naturalization court name and exact date! ★ Why 1924? ★ Let's FOIL them and get them online, so we can transcribe! VOTER LISTS AND REGISTRATION FORMS FOR MANHATTAN 1924 -
THE RIPPLE EFFECTS ★Didn't need to use OPRA at all!
★Birth Index: 1901-1903 ★Marriages: Grooms Index 1901-1903, Brides Index 1901-1914 ★Death Index, 1901-1903 ★These were microfilm only and onsite access only, at the New Jersey State Archives in Trenton ★First 20th Century vital records from New Jersey! NEW JERSEY BIRTH, MARRIAGE, & DEATH INDEX, 1901-03/1914 -
THE CITY CLERK'S OFFICE THE NEW YORK CITY MARRIAGE INDEX,
1930-1995 NYC MARRIAGE INDEX MICROFILMS FOR 1930 THRU APRIL 1972 (OR QUEENS 1971) -
(ABOUT 3,100,000 RECORDS, OR 6,200,000 NAMES) NYC MARRIAGE INDEX MICROSOFT
EXCEL SPREADSHEETS, 1950-1995 (WITH GAPS) -
OPEN DATA: NEW YORK STATE ★ https://health.data.ny.gov/Health/Genealogical-Research-Death-Index-Beginning-1957/vafa-pf2s 1957-1968 DEATH INDEX
FOR NEW YORK STATE (MINUS NEW YORK CITY), UPDATED QUARTERLY -
AFTER 17 MONTHS, WE WON THE NEW YORK STATE DEATH
INDEX, 1880-1956 NOW ONLINE FOR FREE FOREVER -
BIRTH INDEX 1910-2015 DEATH INDEX 1965-2015 SURNAME, GIVEN NAME,
AND DATE. THAT'S IT. -
THE NEW JERSEY MARRIAGE INDEX ★Won it with OPRA, the
New Jersey Open Public Records Act ★1901-2016! ★1901-2000 has a Brides Index for every year, but temporarily missing a few years from the 1930's (coming soon) ★1901-2000 has a Grooms Index for SOME years, not all ★2001-2016 has a consolidated index, roughly chronological, includes same-sex couples starting in September 2013 ★Yes, this will all be indexed by all your favorite genealogy websites....eventually -
TELL US ABOUT YOUR PROBLEMS ★Take our RECORDS SURVEY so
we can add items to our TO-DO LIST ★TELL US about records you think are being wrongfully withheld -
THERE'S A MILLION THINGS WE HAVEN'T DONE ...BUT JUST YOU
WAIT, JUST YOU WAIT -
THE RECORDS FAIRY ★Index to Deaths in Albany and Yonkers,
1880-1916 ★Index to New York State Births (Outside of New York City), 1880-1942 ★Index to New York State Statements of Dissolutions of Marriage (Divorce Index) (Outside of New York City), 1963-2017 ★Index to New York State Domestic Partnership Registry, 2006-2017 WHAT'S NEXT? NEW YORK STATE -
THE RECORDS FAIRY ★List of EVERYTHING held at the Municipal
Archives ★Index to New York City Domestic Partnership Registry, 1993-2016 ★New York City Jury Censuses, 1816, 1819, and 1821 ★New York City Birth Certificates, 1910-1917 ★New York City Delayed and Special Birth Certificates, for births up to 1909, issued up to 1984 (approx. 100,000 certificates) WHAT'S NEXT? NEW YORK CITY -
THE RECORDS FAIRY ★Maryland ★Connecticut ★Florida ★California ★Library of Congress
★National Archives (NARA) ★USCIS ★Veteran's Administration ★Social Security Administration WHAT'S NEXT? NATIONWIDE -
THE MOST IMPORTANT REASON ★We should use Freedom of Information
laws BECAUSE WE CAN -
THE MOST IMPORTANT REASON ★We should use Freedom of Information
laws BECAUSE WE CAN