Upgrade to Pro
— share decks privately, control downloads, hide ads and more …
Speaker Deck
Features
Speaker Deck
PRO
Sign in
Sign up for free
Search
Search
A perfect Storm for legacy migration
Search
ryan lemmer
October 21, 2013
Programming
0
1.6k
A perfect Storm for legacy migration
EuroClojure 2013 - Berlin
ryan lemmer
October 21, 2013
Tweet
Share
More Decks by ryan lemmer
See All by ryan lemmer
Modern Haskell: making sense of the type system
ryanlemmer
1
590
Distributed Computation: dealing with Time and Failure in the wild
ryanlemmer
0
840
Other Decks in Programming
See All in Programming
Processing Gem ベースの、2D レトロゲームエンジンの開発
tokujiros
2
130
プロパティベーステストによるUIテスト: LLMによるプロパティ定義生成でエッジケースを捉える
tetta_pdnt
0
3.3k
Design Foundational Data Engineering Observability
sucitw
3
200
AI時代のUIはどこへ行く?
yusukebe
18
9k
AIでLINEスタンプを作ってみた
eycjur
1
230
2025 年のコーディングエージェントの現在地とエンジニアの仕事の変化について
azukiazusa1
24
12k
Putting The Genie in the Bottle - A Crash Course on running LLMs on Android
iurysza
0
140
スケールする組織の実現に向けた インナーソース育成術 - ISGT2025
teamlab
PRO
1
160
CJK and Unicode From a PHP Committer
youkidearitai
PRO
0
110
さようなら Date。 ようこそTemporal! 3年間先行利用して得られた知見の共有
8beeeaaat
3
1.5k
ぬるぬる動かせ! Riveでアニメーション実装🐾
kno3a87
1
230
Kiroで始めるAI-DLC
kaonash
2
620
Featured
See All Featured
Designing Experiences People Love
moore
142
24k
Thoughts on Productivity
jonyablonski
70
4.8k
Designing for humans not robots
tammielis
253
25k
Building a Modern Day E-commerce SEO Strategy
aleyda
43
7.6k
CSS Pre-Processors: Stylus, Less & Sass
bermonpainter
358
30k
Testing 201, or: Great Expectations
jmmastey
45
7.7k
Making the Leap to Tech Lead
cromwellryan
135
9.5k
Art, The Web, and Tiny UX
lynnandtonic
303
21k
Producing Creativity
orderedlist
PRO
347
40k
GraphQLの誤解/rethinking-graphql
sonatard
72
11k
Facilitating Awesome Meetings
lara
55
6.5k
The Myth of the Modular Monolith - Day 2 Keynote - Rails World 2024
eileencodes
26
3k
Transcript
@ryanlemmer a perfect storm for legacy migration CAPE TOWN @clj_ug_ct
legacy monolith Customer Accounting Billing Product Catalog CRM ... MySQL
Ruby on Rails
legacy Billing Run Customer Accounting Billing Product Catalog CRM ...
Bank Recon MySQL Ruby Ruby
legacy backlog bugs
legacy replacement replace this
legacy replacement replace substitute something that is broken, old or
inoperative
the “legacy problem” can’t fix bugs can’t add features not
performant
a “legacy solution” immutable It’s just too risky to do
in-situ changes
a “legacy solution” vintage the grapes or wine produced in
a particular season
The situation It’s not broken, just Immutable It’s valuable vintage
- still generating revenue We don’t need to “replace” We need to “make the Legacy Problem go away”
vintage migration vintage ?
vintage migration vintage We chose to migrate “financial” parts first
because it posed the highest risk to the business ?
vintage migration vintage statements MySQL Mongo & Redis
feeding off vintage vintage clients invoices ... ...
feeding off vintage statements clients invoices ? ... ...
feeding off vintage clients invoices transform old client write new
client write new invoice transform old invoice ... ...
... ... migration bridge statemen tage Big Run every night
+ incremental run every 10 mins Bridge is one-directional, Statements is read-only Imperative, sequential code
... ... new migration ? full text search stateme vintage
bridge
migration bridge: search clients invoices index- entity index-field index-field index-field
index-field index-field contacts ... ... ...
migration bridge clients invoices index-field index-field index-field index-field index-field write
client write invoice contacts index- entity search statements transform client transform invoice ... ... ... clients invoices ... ... }
... ... ... statements age search statements (batched) bridge search
About 10 million rows several hours to migrate sequentially
first pass solution Batched data migration BUT WHAT NEXT? it
was the easiest thing to do it is not performant not fault tolerant fragile because of data dependencies go parallel and distributed have fault tolerance go real-time served as scaffolding for the next solution
storm Apache Thrift + Nimbus Ingredients: Zookeeper Clojure (> 50%)
* suitable for polyglots
... storm - spouts clients index-field index-field index-field index-field index-field
write client index- entity transform client ... clients
... storm - spout SPOUT TUPLE
storm - data model TUPLE named list of values [“seekoei”
7] [“panda” 10] [147 {:name ‘John’ ...}] [253 {:name ‘Mary’ ...}] word frequency ID client
... storm - spout a SPOUT emits TUPLES UNBOUNDED STREAM
of TUPLES continuously over time a SPOUT is an
... storm - client spout [“client” {:id 147, ...}] CLIENT
SPOUT CLIENT TUPLE periodically emits a entity values
clojure spout (defspout client-‐spout ["entity" “values”] [conf context collector]
(let [next-‐client (next-‐legacy-‐client) tuple [“client” next-‐client]] (spout (nextTuple [] (Thread/sleep 100) (emit-‐spout! collector tuple)) (ack [id])))) creates a pulse
clojure spout (defspout client-‐spout ["entity" “values”] [conf context collector]
(let [next-‐client (next-‐legacy-‐client) tuple [“client” next-‐client]] (spout (nextTuple [] (Thread/sleep 100) (emit-‐spout! collector tuple)) (ack [id]))))
clojure spout [“client” {:id 147, ...}] CLIENT TUPLE (defspout client-‐spout
["entity" “values”] [conf context collector] (let [next-‐client (next-‐legacy-‐client) tuple [“client” next-‐client]] (spout (nextTuple [] (Thread/sleep 100) (emit-‐spout! collector tuple)) (ack [id])))) TUPLE SCHEMA
... storm - spout [“client” {:id 147, ...}] [“client” {:id
201, ...}] [“client” {:id 407, ...}] [“client” {:id 101, ...}] The client SPOUT packages input and emits TUPLES continuously over time
... storm - bolts transform client CLIENT SPOUT BOLT
storm - bolts (defbolt transform-‐client-‐bolt ["client"]
{:prepare true} [conf context collector] (bolt (execute [tuple] (let [h (.getValue tuple 1)] (emit-‐bolt! collector [(transform-‐tuple h)]) (ack! collector tuple)))))
storm - bolts [{:id 147, ...}] OUTGOING TUPLE [“client” {:id
147, ...}] INCOMING TUPLE (defbolt transform-‐client-‐bolt ["client"] {:prepare true} [conf context collector] (bolt (execute [tuple] (let [h (.getValue tuple 1)] (emit-‐bolt! collector [(transform-‐tuple h)]) (ack! collector tuple)))))
storm - topology (topology {"1" (spout-‐spec (client-‐spout)
:p 1)} {"2" (bolt-‐spec {"1" :shuffle} transform-‐client-‐bolt :p 1)})) 1 2 ...
storm - topology (topology {"1" (spout-‐spec (client-‐spout)
:p 1)} {"2" (bolt-‐spec {"1" :shuffle} transform-‐client-‐bolt :p 1)})) 1 2 ...
bolt tasks (topology {"1" (spout-‐spec (client-‐spout)
:p 1)} {"2" (bolt-‐spec {"1" :shuffle} transform-‐client-‐bolt :p 1)})) 1 2 ...
bolt tasks (topology {"1" (spout-‐spec (client-‐spout)
:p 1)} {"2" (bolt-‐spec {"1" :shuffle} transform-‐client-‐bolt :p 3)})) 1 2 ...
which task? (topology {"1" (spout-‐spec (client-‐spout)
:p 1)} {"2" (bolt-‐spec {"1" :shuffle} transform-‐client-‐bolt :p 3)})) 1 2 ? ...
grouping - “shuffle” (topology {"1" (spout-‐spec (client-‐spout)
:p 1)} {"2" (bolt-‐spec {"1" :shuffle} transform-‐client-‐bolt :p 3)})) 1 2 ...
grouping - “ field” 1 2 ... [“active” {:id 147,
...}] [12 {:inv-id 147, ...}] TUPLE SCHEMA ["client-‐id" “invoice-‐vals”] count invoices per client (in memory)
grouping - “ field” 1 2 ... [“active” {:id 147,
...}] [12 {:inv-id 147, ...}] [“active” {:id 147, ...}] [“active” {:id 147, ...}] [401 {:inv-id 32, ...}] [“active” {:id 147, ...}] [“active” {:id 147, ...}] [232 {:inv-id 45, ...}] TUPLE SCHEMA ["client-‐id" “invoice-‐vals”] group by field “client-id”
grouping - “ field” (topology {"1" (spout-‐spec (client-‐spout)
:p 1)} {"2" (bolt-‐spec {"1" [“client-‐id”]} transform-‐client-‐bolt :p 3)})) 1 2 ...
grouping - “ field” 1 2 ... [“active” {:id 147,
...}] [12 {:inv-id 147, ...}] [“active” {:id 147, ...}] [“active” {:id 147, ...}] [401 {:inv-id 32, ...}] [“active” {:id 147, ...}] [“active” {:id 147, ...}] [232 {:inv-id 45, ...}] 2 2 similar “client-id” vals go to the same Bolt Task
grouping - “ field” ... field compute aggregation
bridge - topology index-field write client write invoice index- fields
transform client transform invoice ... ... ... clients invoices contacts
storm - failure success! oops! a failure! ...
storm reliability Build a tree of tuples so that Storm
knows which tuples are related ack/fail Spouts + Bolts
storm guarantees Storm will re-process the entire tuple tree on
failure First attempt fails Storm retries the tuple tree until it succeeds
failure + idempotency write client transform client x2 x2 side-effects!
...
transactional topologies write client transform client x1 x1 run-once semantics
... strong ordering on data processing Storm Trident
search statements storm topologies real-time bridge age
topology design ... ... ...
topology design ... ... ... design the (directed) graph
grouping + parallelism index-field write client write invoice index- fields
transform client transform invoice :shuffle :shuffle :shuffle :shuffle :shuffle :shuffle :p 1 :p 1 :p 1 :p 10 :p 3 :p 3 ... ... ... tune the runtime by annotating the graph edges
topology - tuple schema [“client”] [“entity” “values”] [“invoice”] [“entity” “values”]
[“entity” “values”] [“client”] [“invoice”] [“key_val_pairs”] [“key_val”] We are actually processing streams of tuples continuously
ntage topology design clients context sales context billing context (queue)
(queue) .. .. .. .. .. ..
storm “real-time, distributed, fault-tolerant, computation system” stream processing realtime analytics
continuous computation distributed RPC ...
reflections
search statements age storm topologies vintage is first- class
search statements age storm topologies transform data
search statements age storm topologies not code refactor if you
can! (but only if it’s worth the effort)
search statements age storm topologies not a picnic because we’re
still replacing code and now we’ve added replication
but worth it Big Replace Smaller replacements In-situ changes Augment:
new alongside old Replace Evolve new Kill Starve (until irrelevant)
EUROCLOJURE Berlin 2013 thanks