Share
Embed
勉強会資料 / “Asymptotic Statistics” Section 2.1
A.W. van der Vaart著 “Asymptotic Statistics”の勉強会資料を公開します。
担当範囲:
第2章 Stochastic Convergence
2.1節 Basic Theory
2.5 Lemma (Helly's lemma)
Minato
August 06, 2023
Transcript
44 slides
-
〤」〶〠 ょ゙が〣ิ (p.9) ろ゚ぢや〣ෆࣜ (Example 2.6, p.10) ୈ 3 ճ
ษڧձ A.W. van der Vaart ”Asymptotic Statistics” Section 2.1 ょ゙が〣ิ〝ろ゚ぢや〣ෆࣜ Minato 2022 10 ݄ 1 1 / 43 -
〤」〶〠 ょ゙が〣ิ (p.9) ろ゚ぢや〣ෆࣜ (Example 2.6, p.10) ࠓճ〣ษڧձ〣༰ ه๏〣४උ ࣍
1 〤」〶〠 ࠓճ〣ษڧձ〣༰ ه๏〣४උ 2 ょ゙が〣ิ (p.9) ؔ〝 defective 〟ؔ ょ゙が〣ิ 3 ろ゚ぢや〣ෆࣜ (Example 2.6, p.10) 1 / 43 -
〤」〶〠 ょ゙が〣ิ (p.9) ろ゚ぢや〣ෆࣜ (Example 2.6, p.10) ࠓճ〣ษڧձ〣༰ ه๏〣४උ 〤」〶〠
2 / 43 ࠓճ〣༰ Chapter 2ɿStochastic Convergence [1] Section 2.1ɿBasic Theory (p.8, 9) ิ 2.5ɿょ゙が〣ิ ゆ゜り゜や〣ఆཧ (ఆཧ 2.4) 〣ূ໌〣ཁ〝〟ิ〣ূ໌ ྫ 2.6ɿろ゚ぢや〣ෆࣜぇ༻⿶〔֬มྻ〣Ұ༷ۓີੑ〣ٞ A.W. van der Vaart ”Asymptotic Statistics” -
〤」〶〠 ょ゙が〣ิ (p.9) ろ゚ぢや〣ෆࣜ (Example 2.6, p.10) ࠓճ〣ษڧձ〣༰ ه๏〣४උ ه๏〣४උ
Table: ओ〟ه๏ N ࣗવશମ〣ू߹ R ࣮શମ〣ू߹ Q ༗ཧશମ〣ू߹ Rk ू߹ {x = (x1 , . . . , xk )⊤ : xi ∈ R (i = 1, . . . , k)} Qk ू߹ {x = (x1 , . . . , xk )⊤ : xi ∈ Q (i = 1, . . . , k)} R≥0 ू߹ {x ∈ R : x ≥ 0} E[·] ظ V[·] ࢄ F(a+) F 〣 x = a 〠々ӈଆۃݶ F(a−) F 〣 x = a 〠々ࠨଆۃݶ Xn ⇝ X Xn X 〠ऩଋ『 3 / 43 -
〤」〶〠 ょ゙が〣ิ (p.9) ろ゚ぢや〣ෆࣜ (Example 2.6, p.10) ࠓճ〣ษڧձ〣༰ ه๏〣४උ よぜぷ゚ಉ࢜〣߸ɾෆ߸〣ఆٛ
kɿ2 Ҏ্〣ࣗવ Rk 〣ݩ x = (x1 , . . . , xk )⊤, y = (y1 , . . . , yk )⊤ 〠ର「ɺ x ≤ y def ⇐⇒ xi ≤ yi (∀i = 1, . . . , k) x = y def ⇐⇒ xi = yi (∀i = 1, . . . , k) x ̸= y def ⇐⇒ ∃j s.t. xj ̸= yj x < y def ⇐⇒ x ≤ y 〙 x ̸= y x < y ⇔ xi ≤ yi (∀i = 1, . . . , k) 〙 ∃j s.t. xj < yj ಉ༷〠ɺx ≥ y, x > y 〷ఆٛ『ɻ 4 / 43 -
〤」〶〠 ょ゙が〣ิ (p.9) ろ゚ぢや〣ෆࣜ (Example 2.6, p.10) ؔ〝 defective 〟ؔ
ょ゙が〣ิ ࣍ 1 〤」〶〠 ࠓճ〣ษڧձ〣༰ ه๏〣४උ 2 ょ゙が〣ิ (p.9) ؔ〝 defective 〟ؔ ょ゙が〣ิ 3 ろ゚ぢや〣ෆࣜ (Example 2.6, p.10) 5 / 43 -
〤」〶〠 ょ゙が〣ิ (p.9) ろ゚ぢや〣ෆࣜ (Example 2.6, p.10) ؔ〝 defective 〟ؔ
ょ゙が〣ิ ょ゙が〣ิ〠〙⿶〛 (p.9 લ) ゆ゜り゜や〣ఆཧ (ఆཧ 2.4, p.8) 〣ূ໌〣ཁ〝〟〣〤ょ゙が〣 ิ (Helly’s lemma) 〜⿴ɻ ょ゙が〣ิ〤ɺ〞え〟ؔྻ〠ର「〛〷ؔɺ⿴⿶〤 defective 〟ؔ〠ऑऩଋ『෦ྻଘࡏ『〈〝ぇओு『 ิ〜⿴ɻ ょ゙が〣ิ〣આ໌〠ೖલ〠ɺ ؔ〣ੑ࣭ defective 〟ؔ〣ఆٛ ෦ྻ〣ఆٛ〹ੑ࣭ 〠〙⿶〛《〾⿶『ɻ 6 / 43 -
〤」〶〠 ょ゙が〣ิ (p.9) ろ゚ぢや〣ෆࣜ (Example 2.6, p.10) ؔ〝 defective 〟ؔ
ょ゙が〣ิ ؔ〣ੑ࣭ ؔ〣ੑ࣭ Rk ্〣ؔ F 〠ؔ「〛ɺ࣍〣ੑ࣭〿ཱ〙ɿ 1 ඇݮগؔ〜⿴ɻ 2 ֤〜ӈ࿈ଓ〜⿴ɻ 3 (ଟ࣍ݩ〣߹) ۣܗ〣࣭ྔ (masses of cells) ඇෛ〜⿴ a ྫ⿺〥ɺk = 2 〣〝 ɺa ≤ b ぇຬ〔『ҙ〣 a, b ∈ R2 〠ର「ɺ F(b) + F(a) − F(a1 , b2 ) − F(a2 , b1 ) ≥ 0 〿ཱ〙ɻ 4 x → ∞ 〣〝 F(x) → 1.b 5 x → −∞ 〣〝 F(x) → 0.c aょ゙が〣ิ〣࠷ऴஈམ〣ূ໌”In the higher-dimensional case, ...”ぇࢀরɻ1 ࣍ݩ 〜⿴ぁ〥 a ≤ b ⇒ F(b) − F(a) ≥ 0 ぇҙຯ『ɺ〈ぁ〤ඇݮগੑ〽〿〿ཱ〙ɻ b lim x1,...,xk→∞ F(x1, . . . , xk) = 1 ぇҙຯ『ɻ c lim xi→−∞ F(x1, . . . , xk) = 0 શ〛〣 i = 1, . . . , k ぇҙຯ『ɻ 7 / 43 -
〤」〶〠 ょ゙が〣ิ (p.9) ろ゚ぢや〣ෆࣜ (Example 2.6, p.10) ؔ〝 defective 〟ؔ
ょ゙が〣ิ defective 〟ؔ Def: defective 〟ؔ ؔ F 〣ੑ࣭ (1)ʙ(5) 〣⿸〖ɺ(1)ʙ(3) 〿ཱ〙ɺ(4) 〝 (5) 〿ཱ〔』ɺ x → ∞ 〠⿶〛 1 ະຬ〣ۃݶぇ〷〙 x → −∞ 〜 0 〽〿େ ⿶〣ۃݶぇ〷〙 〜⿴〽⿸〟ؔ〣〈〝ぇɺdefective 〟ؔ (defective distribution function) 〝⿶⿸ɻ (1) ඇݮগੑɾ(2) ӈ࿈ଓੑɾ(3) ۣܗ〣࣭ྔඇෛ〝⿶⿸ؔ 〣ੑ࣭ぇຬ〔『Ұํ〜ɺx → ∞, x → −∞ 〣ۃݶ〠ؔ『ؔ 〣ੑ࣭ぇຬ〔《〟⿶〽⿸〟ؔぇɺ”defective”〝දݱ「〛⿶ defective 〟ؔ〠ର「ɺ(4)ɾ(5) (ۃݶ〣ੑ࣭) 〷ຬ〔『〽⿸ 〟ؔ〣〈〝ぇ proper 〟ؔ〝⿶⿸ɻ 8 / 43 -
〤」〶〠 ょ゙が〣ิ (p.9) ろ゚ぢや〣ෆࣜ (Example 2.6, p.10) ؔ〝 defective 〟ؔ
ょ゙が〣ิ ྻ〣෦ྻ Def: ྻ〣෦ྻ {an }∞ n=1 ぇྻ〝「ɺφ : N → N ぇॱংぇอ〙୯ࣹɺ『〟い〖 n < m ⇒ φ(n) < φ(m) 〜⿴〝『ɻ〈〣〝 ɺ{aφ(n) }∞ n=1 ぇ {an }∞ n=1 〣෦ྻ (subsequence) 〝⿶⿸ɻ ෦ྻ〤ݩ〣ྻ〾ແݶݸ〣߲ぇऔ〿ग़『〈〝〠〽〿〜 〔 ྻ〜⿴ɺ〒〣߲〣ॱং〤ݩ〣ॱং〝มい〾〟⿶ɻ『〟い〖ɺ φ(1) < φ(2) < · · · < φ(n) < . . . . ্ه〣෦ྻ〣ఆٛ〤ɺࣸ૾ぇ༻⿶〔෦ྻ〣ఆٛ〜⿴ɻຊจ 〜〤ɺࣸ૾ぇཅ〠ॻ』ɺ෦ྻぇ {anj }∞ j=1 〝දه「〛⿶〔〶ɺ ຊとぐへ〜〷جຊత〠〈〣දه〠ଇ〘〛ূ໌ぇਐ〶ɻ 9 / 43 -
〤」〶〠 ょ゙が〣ิ (p.9) ろ゚ぢや〣ෆࣜ (Example 2.6, p.10) ؔ〝 defective 〟ؔ
ょ゙が〣ิ ྻ〣෦ྻ〣ੑ࣭ Th: ऩଋ『ྻ〣෦ྻ〷ಉ」ۃݶぇ〷〙 [2] ྻ {an } 〠⿶〛ɺ lim n→∞ an = a 〜⿴〝『ɻ ྻ {an } 〣ҙ〣෦ྻ {aφ(n) } 〠ର「ɺ lim n→∞ aφ(n) = a. ෦ྻ〣֓೦ぇ༻⿶〛ɺ࣮〣࿈ଓੑ〠ؔ『ެཧ〾る゚びきぽ-ゞ ぐご゚てゔぷと〣ఆཧಋぁɻ Th: る゚びきぽ-ゞぐご゚てゔぷと〣ఆཧ [2] ྻ {an } ⊂ R ༗ք〣〝 ɺऩଋ෦ྻぇ〷〙ɻ 10 / 43 -
〤」〶〠 ょ゙が〣ิ (p.9) ろ゚ぢや〣ෆࣜ (Example 2.6, p.10) ؔ〝 defective 〟ؔ
ょ゙が〣ิ ょ゙が〣ิ ょ゙が〣ิ (Lemma2.5, p.9) {Fn }∞ n=1 ぇ Rk ্〣ྦྷੵؔ〣ྻ〝『ɻ⿴෦ྻ {Fnj }∞ j=1 ଘࡏ「〛ɺ⿴ (defective 〠〟〿⿸) ؔ F 〠ର「ɺF 〣ҙ〣 ࿈ଓ x ∈ Rk 〠〙⿶〛ɺ lim j→∞ Fnj (x) = F(x). 11 / 43 -
〤」〶〠 ょ゙が〣ิ (p.9) ろ゚ぢや〣ෆࣜ (Example 2.6, p.10) ؔ〝 defective 〟ؔ
ょ゙が〣ิ ゆ゜や゜や〣ఆཧ〝ゞぐご゚てゔぷと〣ఆཧ〣ؔ࿈ ゆ゜り゜や〣ఆཧ (Theorem2.5, p.8) Xn ぇ Rk ্〣֬ม〝『ɻ 1 Xn ⿴֬ม X 〠ऩଋ『〝 ɺ{Xn : n ∈ N} 〤Ұ༷ ۓີ〜⿴ɻ 2 Xn Ұ༷ۓີ〟〾〥ɺ⿴֬ม X ଘࡏ「〛ɺ Xnj ⇝ X(j → ∞). Th: る゚びきぽ-ゞぐご゚てゔぷと〣ఆཧ [2] ྻ {an } ⊂ R ༗ք〣〝 ɺऩଋ෦ྻぇ〷〙ɻ ゆ゜り゜や〣ఆཧ (2) 〤ɺる゚びきぽ-ゞぐご゚てゔぷと〣ఆཧ 〣֬ม൛〝ղऍ〜 ɻ ゆ゜り゜や〣ఆཧ (2) ぇূ໌『〔〶〣ݤ〝〟ิɺょ゙が〣 ิ〜⿴ɻ 12 / 43 -
〤」〶〠 ょ゙が〣ิ (p.9) ろ゚ぢや〣ෆࣜ (Example 2.6, p.10) ؔ〝 defective 〟ؔ
ょ゙が〣ิ ょ゙が〣ิ〣ূ໌ํ ෦ྻ {Fnj }∞ n=1 ぇఆٛ「ɺؔ F ぇߏ『ɻ ؔ F ぇ⿶ 〟〿ߟ⿺〣〤「⿶〣〜ɺ࣍〣खॱ〜ূ໌『ɻ 1 る゚びきぽ-ゞぐご゚てゔぷと〣ఆཧぇ܁〿ฦ「ద༻『〈〝〜ɺ ҙ〣 q ∈ Qk 〠ର「ɺFn j (q) ऩଋ『〽⿸〟෦ྻ {Fnj }∞ n=1 ぇߏ『ɻFn j (q) 〣ऩଋઌぇ G(q) 〝『ɻ 2 G 〤 Qk ্〠⿶〛〣〴ఆٛ《ぁ〔ؔ〜⿴ɻ〈ぁぇ〷〝〠ɺ Rk ্〣ؔ F ぇఆٛ『ɿ F(x) = inf G(q) : q ∈ Qk, q > x 3 F ඇݮগ〟ӈ࿈ଓؔ〜⿴〈〝ぇࣔ『ɻ 4 F 〣ҙ〣࿈ଓ x ∈ Rk 〠〙⿶〛ɺ lim j→∞ Fnj (x) = F(x) 〿ཱ 〙〈〝ぇࣔ『ɻ 5 ଟ࣍ݩ〣〝 〠ɺF defective 〟ؔ〜⿴〔〶〠ຬ〔『〮 ੑ࣭ぇࣔ『ɻ 13 / 43 -
〤」〶〠 ょ゙が〣ิ (p.9) ろ゚ぢや〣ෆࣜ (Example 2.6, p.10) ؔ〝 defective 〟ؔ
ょ゙が〣ิ ょ゙が〣ิ〣ূ໌ ू߹ Qk 〣ݩぇ q1 , q2 , · · · ∈ Qk 〝൪߸ぇৼɻ1 ɹ ྻ {Fn (q1 )}∞ n=1 〤༗ք〕〾ɺる゚びきぽ-ゞぐご゚てゔぷと〣ఆ ཧ〽〿ऩଋ෦ྻぇ〷〙ɻ〒〣〽⿸〟ఴࣈू߹ぇ n1 j ∞ j=1 〝「ɺऩଋ ઌぇ G(q1 ) 〝『ɻ『〟い〖ɺ G(q1 ) = lim j→∞ Fn1 j (q1 ). ࣍〠ɺ n1 j ∞ j=1 〣த〾 {Fn (q2 )}∞ n=1 〣ऩଋ෦ྻ n2 j ∞ j=1 ぇऔ〿ग़ 「ɺऩଋઌぇ G(q2 ) 〝。ɻ ऩଋ෦ྻ〣औ〿ํ〾 n1 j ∞ j=1 ⊃ n2 j ∞ j=1 〜⿴〿ɺ G(q2 ) = lim j→∞ Fn2 j (q2 ). 1Qk 〤Մࢉແݶू߹〜⿴〾ࣗવશମ〣ू߹ N 〭〣શ୯ࣹଘࡏ『〔〶ɺ〈〣 〽⿸〟ૢ࡞Մೳ〜⿴ 14 / 43 -
〤」〶〠 ょ゙が〣ิ (p.9) ろ゚ぢや〣ෆࣜ (Example 2.6, p.10) ؔ〝 defective 〟ؔ
ょ゙が〣ิ ょ゙が〣ิ〣ূ໌ ҎԼɺಉ༷〣खଓ ぇଓ々〈〝〜ɺ n1 j ∞ j=1 ⊃ n2 j ∞ j=1 ⊃ · · · ⊃ ni j ∞ j=1 ⊃ . . . (1) ぇಘɻ 〈〈〜ɺ৽〔〟ఴࣈू߹ nj ∞ j=1 ぇɺ֤ j ∈ N 〠ର「 nj = nj j ∈ nj j ∞ j=1 〝〟〽⿸ɺର֯ઢ্〠ྻぇऔ〿ग़『ɻ Table: {nj } 〣औ〿ํ〣ぐゐがで {n} 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 . . . {n1 j } n1 1 (= n1 ) n1 2 n1 3 n1 4 n1 5 . . . {n2 j } n2 1 n2 2 (= n2 ) n2 3 . . . {n3 j } n3 1 n3 2 n3 3 (= n3 ) . . . ද〾ɺ{nj } 〣औ〿ํ〤ݩ〣ྻ〣ॱংぇอ࣋「〛⿶〔〶ɺ {Fnj (q)}∞ j=1 〤 {Fn (q)}∞ n=1 〣෦ྻ〜⿴〈〝いɻ 15 / 43 -
〤」〶〠 ょ゙が〣ิ (p.9) ろ゚ぢや〣ෆࣜ (Example 2.6, p.10) ؔ〝 defective 〟ؔ
ょ゙が〣ิ ょ゙が〣ิ〣ূ໌ 〈〣〽⿸〠 nj ∞ j=1 ぇબ〫〈〝〠〽〿ɺ ҙ〣 i ∈ N 〠ର「ɺlim j→∞ Fn j (qi ) = G(qi ). (2) 〿ཱ〙ɻ (2) 〣ূ໌ ҙ〣 i ∈ N 〠ର「ɺFni j (qi ) 〤 G(qi ) 〠ऩଋ『ɻ〈〈〜ɺࣜ (1) 〽 〨 nj ∞ j=1 〣औ〿ํ〾ɺ {nj }∞ j=i ⊂ ni j ∞ j=1 〜⿴ɻऩଋ『ྻ〣෦ྻ〤ಉ」ۃݶ〠ऩଋ『〣〜ɺFn j (qi ) 〤 G(qi ) 〠ऩଋ『 (ɿj < i 〜 nj ∈ ni j ∞ j=1 〜〟。〛〷ऩଋઌ〣ٞ 〠〤Өڹ「〟⿶)ɻ 16 / 43 -
〤」〶〠 ょ゙が〣ิ (p.9) ろ゚ぢや〣ෆࣜ (Example 2.6, p.10) ؔ〝 defective 〟ؔ
ょ゙が〣ิ ょ゙が〣ิ〣ূ໌ ֤ n 〠ର「ɺྦྷੵؔ Fn 〤ඇݮগ〕〾ɺ q ≤ q′ ⇒ G(q) ≤ G(q′). (3) (3) 〣ূ໌ q ≤ q′ 〣〝 ɺྦྷੵؔ Fn j 〣ඇݮগੑ〾ɺҙ〣 j 〜 Fn j (q) ≤ Fn j (q′) 〜⿴ɻ〳〔ɺࣜ (2) 〽〿ɺ lim j→∞ Fn j (q) = G(q), lim j→∞ Fn j (q′) = G(q′). ۃݶ〣େখؔ〷อ〔ぁ〾ɺG(q) ≤ G(q′). 17 / 43 -
〤」〶〠 ょ゙が〣ิ (p.9) ろ゚ぢや〣ෆࣜ (Example 2.6, p.10) ؔ〝 defective 〟ؔ
ょ゙が〣ิ ょ゙が〣ิ〣ূ໌ G(q) 〤 Qk ্〠⿶〛〣〴ఆٛ《ぁ〛⿶ɻ 〒〈〜ɺRk ্〣ؔ F ぇ F(x) = inf q>x G(q) = inf G(q) : q ∈ Qk, q > x 〝ఆ〶ɻ〈〣〝 ɺF 〤ඇݮগؔ〜⿴ɻ F ඇݮগؔ〜⿴〈〝〣ূ໌ x ≤ y 〣〝 ɺ {G(q) : q ∈ Qk, q > x} ⊃ {G(q) : q ∈ Qk, q > y} 〿ཱ〙ɻ〽〘〛ɺԼݶ〣ੑ࣭ 2 〽〿 F(x) ≤ F(y) 〜⿴〾ɺF 〤ඇݮগؔɻ 2Ұൠ〠ɺू߹ A, B 〠ର「〛 A ⊃ B 〟〾〥 inf A ≤ inf B 〜⿴ɻ 18 / 43 -
〤」〶〠 ょ゙が〣ิ (p.9) ろ゚ぢや〣ෆࣜ (Example 2.6, p.10) ؔ〝 defective 〟ؔ
ょ゙が〣ิ ょ゙が〣ิ〣ূ໌ 《〾〠ɺF 〤֤ x ∈ Rk 〠ର「ӈ࿈ଓ〜⿴ɻ〟】〟〾ɺε > 0 ぇ ҙ〠〝〘〔〝 ɺ⿴ q > x ଘࡏ「〛ɺG(q) − F(x) < ε 〿ཱ〖ɺ 〈〣〈〝〾 x ≤ y ≤ q ぇຬ〔『ҙ〣 y 〜 F(y) − F(x) < ε 〿ཱ 〙〾〜⿴ɻ F ֤ x ∈ Rk 〠ର「ӈ࿈ଓ〜⿴〈〝〣ূ໌ (1/3) ҙ〣 x ∈ Rk 〠ର「ɺF x ্〜ӈ࿈ଓؔ〜⿴〈〝ぇࣔ『ɻ〒 〣〔〶〠〤ɺҎԼぇࣔ【〥ྑ⿶ɿ ∀ε > 0, ∃q ∈ Qk s.t. q > x 〙 [x < ∀y < q ⇒ F(y) − F(x) < ε]. (4) දهぇ؆ܿ〠『〔〶〠ɺAx = {G(q) : q ∈ Qk, q > x} 〝 ɺ F(x) = inf Ax 〝ද『〈〝〝『ɻ 19 / 43 -
〤」〶〠 ょ゙が〣ิ (p.9) ろ゚ぢや〣ෆࣜ (Example 2.6, p.10) ؔ〝 defective 〟ؔ
ょ゙が〣ิ ょ゙が〣ิ〣ূ໌ F ֤ x ∈ Rk 〠ର「ӈ࿈ଓ〜⿴〈〝〣ূ໌ (2/3) ҙ〣 ε > 0 ぇݻఆ『ɻF(x) = inf Ax 〽〿ɺԼݶ〣ఆٛ〾ɺ ∃s ∈ Ax s.t. F(x) + ε > s. (5) s ∈ Ax 〽〿ɺ ∃q ∈ Qk s.t. q > x 〙 s = G(q). (6) ࣜ (5) 〝ࣜ (6) 〽〿ɺ G(q) − F(x) < ε. 〈〈〜ɺx < y < q ぇຬ〔『ҙ〣 y 〠ର「ɺ F(y) = inf{G(q′) : q′ ∈ Qk, q′ > y} ≤ G(q). 20 / 43 -
〤」〶〠 ょ゙が〣ิ (p.9) ろ゚ぢや〣ෆࣜ (Example 2.6, p.10) ؔ〝 defective 〟ؔ
ょ゙が〣ิ ょ゙が〣ิ〣ূ໌ F ֤ x ∈ Rk 〠ର「ӈ࿈ଓ〜⿴〈〝〣ূ໌ (3/3) 〈ぁ〽〿ɺ F(y) − F(x) ≤ G(q) − F(x) < ε. ্ࣜ〾ࣜ (4) 〿ཱ〙〾ɺF ҙ〣 x ∈ Rk 〜ӈ࿈ଓ〜⿴ 〈〝ࣔ《ぁ〔ɻ 〟ɺຊจ〜〤”x ≤ y ≤ q”ぇຬ〔『ҙ〣 y 〜 F(y) − F(x) < ε 〝ɺ ߸ぇೖぁ〔ܗ〜ॻぁ〛⿶ɻy = x 〜〿ཱ〙〣〤໌〾〜⿴ɻ y = q 〜ཱ《【〔々ぁ〥ɺq ぇ x < q′ < q ぇຬ〔『〽⿸〟 q′ ∈ Rk 〠 ஔ ⿺〛ಉ」ٞぇ『〈〝〠〽〿߸ぇೖぁ〛ཱ『〈〝֬ 〶〾ぁɻ3 3߸ぇؚ〶〞⿸〤ӈ࿈ଓੑ〣ٞ〠⿶〛ຊ࣭త〜〤〟⿶〔〶ɺ߸ぇؚ〶』 ٞ「〔ɻ 21 / 43 -
〤」〶〠 ょ゙が〣ิ (p.9) ろ゚ぢや〣ෆࣜ (Example 2.6, p.10) ؔ〝 defective 〟ؔ
ょ゙が〣ิ ょ゙が〣ิ〣ূ໌ 《〾〠ɺF 〣࿈ଓ x 〠⿶〛ɺҙ〣 ε > 0 〠ର「ɺ⿴ q, q′ ∈ Qk ଘࡏ「〛ɺG(q′) − G(q) < ε ぇຬ〔『ɻ ্ه〣ূ໌ (1/4) x ぇ F 〣ҙ〣࿈ଓɺε > 0 ぇҙ〠〝〿ݻఆ『ɻඇݮগؔ F 〤 x ্〜࿈ଓ〕〾ɺ ∃δ > 0 (∈ Rk) s.t. x − δ < ∀y < x + δ ⇒ |F(x) − F(y)| < ε 2 . (7) 22 / 43 -
〤」〶〠 ょ゙が〣ิ (p.9) ろ゚ぢや〣ෆࣜ (Example 2.6, p.10) ؔ〝 defective 〟ؔ
ょ゙が〣ิ ょ゙が〣ิ〣ূ໌ 《〾〠ɺF 〣࿈ଓ x 〠⿶〛ɺҙ〣 ε > 0 〠ର「ɺ⿴ q, q′ ∈ Qk ଘࡏ「〛ɺG(q′) − G(q) < ε ぇຬ〔『ɻ ্ه〣ূ໌ (2/4) 〈〈〜ɺq0 , q, q′ ∈ Qk ぇɺ x − δ < q0 < q < x < q′ < x + δ ぇຬ〔『〽⿸〠〝〝ɺq0 < q < x < q′ 〝 F 〣ඇݮগੑɺ〽〨ࣜ (7)4 〾ɺ F(x) − ε 2 < F(q0 ) ≤ F(q) ≤ F(x) ≤ F(q′) < F(x) + ε 2 . 4ࣜ (7) 〽〿ɺx − δ < ∀y < x + δ ⇒ F(x) − ε/2 < F(y) < F(x) + ε/2 〜⿴ 〾ɺy = p0, q, x, q′ 〝「〔ࣜぇ༻⿶ɻ 23 / 43 -
〤」〶〠 ょ゙が〣ิ (p.9) ろ゚ぢや〣ෆࣜ (Example 2.6, p.10) ؔ〝 defective 〟ؔ
ょ゙が〣ิ ょ゙が〣ิ〣ূ໌ 《〾〠ɺF 〣࿈ଓ x 〠⿶〛ɺҙ〣 ε > 0 〠ର「ɺ⿴ q, q′ ∈ Qk ଘࡏ「〛ɺG(q′) − G(q) < ε ぇຬ〔『ɻ ্ه〣ূ໌ (3/4) 《〾〠ɺF 〣ఆٛ〾ɺ F(q0 ) = inf{G(˜ q) : ˜ q ∈ Qk, ˜ q > q0 } ≤ G(q) (∵ q ∈ Qk, q > q0 ) ≤ F(q). 〈〈〜ɺ࠷ޙ〣ෆࣜ〠ؔ「〛〤ɺF 〣ఆٛࣜ F(q) = inf{G(˜ q) : ˜ q ∈ Qk, ˜ q > q} (= inf Aq 〝。) ぇৼ〿ฦ〝ɺG 〣ඇݮগੑ〾ɺҙ〣 s ∈ Aq 〠ର「〛 G(q) ≤ s 〜 ⿴〾 G(q) 〤 Ax 〣Լք〜⿴〿ɺinf 〣࠷େԼքੑ〽〿 G(q) ≤ inf Aq = F(q) 〿ཱ〙〈〝〾ै⿸ɻ 24 / 43 -
〤」〶〠 ょ゙が〣ิ (p.9) ろ゚ぢや〣ෆࣜ (Example 2.6, p.10) ؔ〝 defective 〟ؔ
ょ゙が〣ิ ょ゙が〣ิ〣ূ໌ 《〾〠ɺF 〣࿈ଓ x 〠⿶〛ɺҙ〣 ε > 0 〠ର「ɺ⿴ q, q′ ∈ Qk ଘࡏ「〛ɺG(q′) − G(q) < ε ぇຬ〔『ɻ ্ه〣ূ໌ (4/4) ಉ༷〠ɺ F(x) = inf{G(˜ q) : ˜ q ∈ Qk, ˜ q > x} ≤ G(q′) (∵ q′ ∈ Qk, q′ > x) ≤ F(q′). ∴ F(x) − ε 2 < G(q) ≤ G(q′) < F(x) + ε 2 . 〽〘〛ɺ G(q′) − G(q) < F(x) + ε 2 − F(x) − ε 2 = ε. 25 / 43 -
〤」〶〠 ょ゙が〣ิ (p.9) ろ゚ぢや〣ෆࣜ (Example 2.6, p.10) ؔ〝 defective 〟ؔ
ょ゙が〣ิ ょ゙が〣ิ〣ূ໌ લらがで〣ٞ〾࣍〣ෆࣜ〿ཱ〙ɿ G(q) ≤ F(x) ≤ G(q′) (8) 〈〈〜ɺྦྷੵؔ Fn j 〣ඇݮগੑ〽〿 Fn j (q) ≤ Fn j (x) ≤ Fn j (q′) 〿ཱ〙〈〝〾ɺ֤ล〜্ۃݶɾԼۃݶぇ〝〈〝〜 lim inf j→∞ Fn j (q) ≤ lim inf j→∞ Fn j (x) ≤ lim inf j→∞ Fn j (q′), lim sup j→∞ Fn j (q) ≤ lim sup j→∞ Fn j (x) ≤ lim sup j→∞ Fn j (q′). 26 / 43 -
〤」〶〠 ょ゙が〣ิ (p.9) ろ゚ぢや〣ෆࣜ (Example 2.6, p.10) ؔ〝 defective 〟ؔ
ょ゙が〣ิ ょ゙が〣ิ〣ূ໌ 〳〔ɺࣜ (2) 〽〿 G(q) = lim j→∞ Fn j (q), G(q′) = lim j→∞ Fn j (q′) 〜⿴〾 G(q) = lim inf j→∞ Fn j (q) = lim sup j→∞ Fn j (q), G(q′) = lim inf j→∞ Fn j (q′) = lim sup j→∞ Fn j (q′) 〜⿴〈〝ぇ༻⿶〝ɺ ∴ G(q) ≤ lim inf j→∞ Fn j (x) ≤ G(q′), (9) G(q) ≤ lim sup j→∞ Fn j (x) ≤ G(q′). (10) 27 / 43 -
〤」〶〠 ょ゙が〣ิ (p.9) ろ゚ぢや〣ෆࣜ (Example 2.6, p.10) ؔ〝 defective 〟ؔ
ょ゙が〣ิ ょ゙が〣ิ〣ূ໌ Ҏ্〽〿ɺF 〣࿈ଓ x 〠ର「ɺ lim inf j→∞ Fn j (x) − F(x) ≤ G(q′) − G(q) < ε, lim sup j→∞ Fn j (x) − F(x) ≤ G(q′) − G(q) < ε. 〿ཱ〙〈〝〾ɺ lim inf j→∞ Fn j (x) = lim sup j→∞ Fn j (x) = F(x). 〽〘〛ɺۃݶ lim j→∞ Fn j (x) ଘࡏ「ɺ lim j→∞ Fn j (x) = F(x). 28 / 43 -
〤」〶〠 ょ゙が〣ิ (p.9) ろ゚ぢや〣ෆࣜ (Example 2.6, p.10) ؔ〝 defective 〟ؔ
ょ゙が〣ิ ょ゙が〣ิ〣ূ໌ 〈〈〜ɺk ≥ 2 〣߹ɺF defective 〟ؔ〜⿴〔〶〠〤ɺۣܗ 〣࣭ྔඇෛ〜⿴〈〝ぇࣔ『ඞཁ⿴ɻྫ⿺〥ɺk = 2 〣〝 ɺ a ≤ b ぇຬ〔『ҙ〣 a = (a1 , a2 ), b = (b1 , b2 ) 〠ର「〛ɺ F(b) + F(a) − F(a1 , b2 ) − F(a2 , b1 ) ≥ 0 (11) 〿ཱ〙〝 〠 F defective 〟ؔ〠〟ɻҎԼɺࣜ (11) ぇ ࣔ『ɻ Fn j 〤ؔ〜⿴〾ɺ Fnj (b) + Fnj (a) − Fnj (a1 , b2 ) − Fnj (a2 , b1 ) ≥ 0 (12) 〿ཱ〙ɻ 29 / 43 -
〤」〶〠 ょ゙が〣ิ (p.9) ろ゚ぢや〣ෆࣜ (Example 2.6, p.10) ؔ〝 defective 〟ؔ
ょ゙が〣ิ ょ゙が〣ิ〣ূ໌ 〳』ɺ a, b, (a1 , b2 ), (a2 , b1 ) F 〣࿈ଓ〜⿴〝 ɺ lim j→∞ Fnj (a) = F(a), lim j→∞ Fnj (b) = F(b), lim j→∞ Fnj (a1 , b2 ) = F(a1 , b2 ), lim j→∞ Fnj (a2 , b1 ) = F(a2 , b1 ) 〿ཱ〙〈〝〾ɺࣜ (12) 〣ۃݶ j → ∞ ぇߟ⿺〈〝〜ɺࣜ (11) 〿ཱ〙〈〝いɻ Ұൠ〣߹ɺ『〟い〖ɺ4 F 〣࿈ଓ〝〤ݶ〾〟⿶〽⿸〟߹〤ɺ ӈ࿈ଓੑ〾ࣜ (11) 〣ཱࣔ《ぁɻ 30 / 43 -
〤」〶〠 ょ゙が〣ิ (p.9) ろ゚ぢや〣ෆࣜ (Example 2.6, p.10) ؔ〝 defective 〟ؔ
ょ゙が〣ิ ょ゙が〣ิ〣ূ໌ Ұൠ〣߹〣ূ໌ํ 1 a ্〜 F 〤ӈ࿈ଓ〜⿴〣〜ɺa 〣〰え〣গ「ӈଆ〣 y 〜〤 F(y) − F(a) ε ະຬ〠〟ɿ ∀ε > 0, ∃δa > 0 s.t. a < ∀y < δa ⇒ F(y) − F(a) < ε. ଞ〣 b, c, d 〜〷〿ཱ〙ɻ 2 F 〣࿈ଓ〤 Rk ্ີ〜⿴〈〝ぇ༻⿶〛ɺ֤ a, b, c, d 〣〰え 〣গ「ӈଆ〣〜ɺa′, b′, (a′ 1 , b′ 2 )(= c′〝。), (a′ 2 , b′ 1 )(= d′〝。) F 〣࿈ଓ〜⿴〽⿸〠 a′, b′ ぇ〝ɻ 3 F(a) = F(a′), F(b) = F(b′), F(c) = F(c′), F(d) = F(d′) 〜⿴ 〈〝ぇࣔ『ɻ 4 a′, b′, c′, d′ 〤શ〛࿈ଓ〕〾ɺલ〣ٞ〽〿 F(a′) + F(b′) − F(c′) − F(d′) ≥ 0 〜⿴ɻ〈ぁ〝্ࣜ〾Ұൠ〣 ߹ࣔ【ɻ 31 / 43 -
〤」〶〠 ょ゙が〣ิ (p.9) ろ゚ぢや〣ෆࣜ (Example 2.6, p.10) ؔ〝 defective 〟ؔ
ょ゙が〣ิ ょ゙が〣ิ〣ূ໌ 4 〣⿸〖ɺ⿶』ぁ〣ෆ࿈ଓぇؚ〵߹ぇߟ⿺ɻ දهぇ؆ܿ〠『〔〶〠 c = (a1 , b2 ), d = (a2 , b1 ) 〝。ɻ5 F 〤֤ a, b, c, d ্〜ӈ࿈ଓ〕〾ɺε > 0 ぇҙ〠〝〝ɺ ∃δa > 0 s.t. a < ∀y < a + δa ⇒ F(y) − F(a) < ε, ∃δb > 0 s.t. b < ∀y < b + δb ⇒ F(y) − F(b) < ε, ∃δc > 0 s.t. c < ∀y < c + δc ⇒ F(y) − F(c) < ε, ∃δd > 0 s.t. d < ∀y < d + δd ⇒ F(y) − F(d) < ε 〿ཱ〙ɻ 5c 〝 d 〤 a 〹 b 〝ແؔ〟〷〣〜〤〟。ɺa 〝 b ఆ〳ぁ〥ࣗಈత〠ఆ〳〷〣〜⿴ 〈〝〠ҙɻ 32 / 43 -
〤」〶〠 ょ゙が〣ิ (p.9) ろ゚ぢや〣ෆࣜ (Example 2.6, p.10) ؔ〝 defective 〟ؔ
ょ゙が〣ิ ょ゙が〣ิ〣ূ໌ F 〣࿈ଓ〤 Rk ্ີ〜⿴〈〝〾ɺ6 a < a′ < a + δa , b < b′ < b + δb , c < c′ < c + δc , d < d′ < d + δd ぇຬ〔『〽⿸〠࿈ଓ a′, b′, c′, d′ ぇ〝〈〝〜 ɻ〔〕「ɺ a′ = (a′ 1 , a′ 2 ), b = (b′ 1 , b′ 2 ) 〝「〔〝 ɺc′ = (a′ 1 , b′ 2 ), d′ = (a′ 2 , b′ 1 ) 〝 『ɻ 〈〣〽⿸〟࿈ଓ a′, b′, c′, d′ 〠ର「〛ɺ্ه〣࿈ଓ〣ٞ〾ɺ F(a′) + F(b′) − F(c′) − F(d′) ≥ 0. (13) ଓ⿶〛ɺF(a) = F(a′) ぇࣔ『 (ଞ〣〷ಉ༷)ɻ 6https://qiita.com/mochimochidog/items/a5091dda350fb00f6086 ぇࢀর「〳 「〔ɻ 33 / 43 -
〤」〶〠 ょ゙が〣ิ (p.9) ろ゚ぢや〣ෆࣜ (Example 2.6, p.10) ؔ〝 defective 〟ؔ
ょ゙が〣ิ ょ゙が〣ิ〣ূ໌ લ〣らがで〜〝〘〔 ε > 0 〠ର「ɺF 〣 x = a 〠々ӈ࿈ଓੑ〽〿ɺ F(a′) − F(a) < ε. (14) a′ 〤 F 〣࿈ଓ〜⿴〾લ〣ٞ〠〽〿 lim j→∞ Fn j (a′) = F(a′). ∴ ∃J ∈ N s.t. j ≥ J ⇒ Fn j (a′) − F(a′) < ε. (15) 〈ぁ〽〿ɺj ≥ J 〣〝 ɺ Fn j (a′) − F(a) = Fn j (a′) − F(a′) + F(a′) − F(a) ≤ Fn j (a′) − F(a′) + |F(a′) − F(a)| < ε + ε = 2ε. ্ࣜ〤 lim j→∞ Fn j (a′) = F(a) ぇҙຯ『ɻऩଋઌ〤Ұҙ〕〾 F(a) = F(a′) ⿶⿺〔ɻ 34 / 43 -
〤」〶〠 ょ゙が〣ิ (p.9) ろ゚ぢや〣ෆࣜ (Example 2.6, p.10) ؔ〝 defective 〟ؔ
ょ゙が〣ิ ょ゙が〣ิ〣ূ໌ ଞ〣〷ಉ༷〠ߟ⿺ɺF(b) = F(b′), F(c) = F(c′), F(d) = F(d′) 〜⿴ 〈〝ぇࣔ【ɻ〈〣〈〝〝 F(a′) + F(b′) − F(c′) − F(d′) ≥ 0. 〿ཱ〙〈〝〾ɺ F(a) + F(b) − F(c) − F(d) ≥ 0. 〿ཱ〙ɻҎ্〽〿ɺҰൠ〣߹〠⿶〛〷ۣܗ〣࣭ྔ〤ඇෛ〜⿴ 〈〝ݴ⿺〔〾ɺଟ࣍ݩ〣߹〜〷 F 〤 defective 〟ؔ〠〟ɻ (ょ゙が〣ఆཧ〣ূ໌ऴ) 35 / 43 -
〤」〶〠 ょ゙が〣ิ (p.9) ろ゚ぢや〣ෆࣜ (Example 2.6, p.10) ࣍ 1 〤」〶〠
ࠓճ〣ษڧձ〣༰ ه๏〣४උ 2 ょ゙が〣ิ (p.9) ؔ〝 defective 〟ؔ ょ゙が〣ิ 3 ろ゚ぢや〣ෆࣜ (Example 2.6, p.10) 36 / 43 -
〤」〶〠 ょ゙が〣ิ (p.9) ろ゚ぢや〣ෆࣜ (Example 2.6, p.10) ろ゚ぢや〣ෆࣜ 〳』ɺろ゚ぢや〣ෆࣜぇհ『ɻ Th:
ろ゚ぢや〣ෆࣜ [3] X ぇۭ֬ؒ (Ω, F, P) ্〣 Rk-֬ม〝『ɻඇෛؔ h : Rk → R≥0 〠ର「〛 h(X) Մੵ〟〾〥ɺҙ〣 ε > 0 〠ର「〛ɺ P(h(X) ≥ ε) ≤ E[h(X)] ε . 37 / 43 -
〤」〶〠 ょ゙が〣ิ (p.9) ろ゚ぢや〣ෆࣜ (Example 2.6, p.10) ྫ 2.6 〣લ
(1/3) ྫ 2.6 〣ओு (લ) (p.10) ֬มྻ Xn ぇɺ⿴ p > 0 ଘࡏ「〛 E[|Xn |p] = O(1) ぇຬ〔『〷 〣〝『ɻ〈〣〝 ɺ{Xn : n ∈ N} 〤Ұ༷ۓີ〜⿴ɻ O(1) 〣ղऍ〠ؔ『ิ アはげ〣ざがはがه๏〣ఆٛ〠「〔⿺〥ɺ E[|Xn |p] = O(1) ⇔ [∃N ∈ N, ∃C > 0 s.t. n > N ⇒ E[|Xn |p] ≤ C] ぇҙຯ『〔〶ɺn > N ぇຬ〔『શ〛〣 n 〜〤 |Xn |p 〤Մੵ〜⿴ɻ 〝〈あɺn ≤ N ぇຬ〔『 n 〜 |Xn |p Մੵ〜⿴อূぇ『〈〝 〤〜 〟⿶ɻ〷「⿴ n(≤ N) 〜 |Xn |p Մੵ〜〟⿶〽⿸〟߹ɺ〈 〣ޙ〣ٞ〠ࠩ「ো〔〶ɺ〈〈〜〤ɺE[|Xn |p] = O(1) 〣ҙຯぇ ∃C > 0 s.t. ∀n ∈ N ⇒ E[|Xn |p] ≤ C 〝ղऍ「〛ٞぇਐ〶〈〝〠『ɻ 38 / 43 -
〤」〶〠 ょ゙が〣ิ (p.9) ろ゚ぢや〣ෆࣜ (Example 2.6, p.10) ྫ 2.6 〣લ
(2/3) 〟】〟〾ɺろ゚ぢや〣ෆࣜ〽〿ɺҙ〣 M > 0 〠ର「〛 P(|Xn | > M) ≤ 1 Mp E[|Xn |p] (16) 〿ཱ〙ɻ ࣜ (16) 〣ূ໌ M > 0 ぇҙ〠〝ɻE[|Xn |p] = O(1) 〽〿ɺҙ〣 n ∈ N 〠ର「 |Xn |p 〤Մੵ〜⿴〾ɺろ゚ぢや〣ෆࣜ〽〿ɺ P(|Xn |p ≥ Mp) ≤ E[|Xn |p] Mp . ∴ P(|Xn | ≥ M) ≤ E[|Xn |p] Mp . ∴ P(|Xn | > M) ≤ E[|Xn |p] Mp . 39 / 43 -
〤」〶〠 ょ゙が〣ิ (p.9) ろ゚ぢや〣ෆࣜ (Example 2.6, p.10) ྫ 2.6 〣લ
(3/3) M ぇेେ 。〝〈〝〠〽〿ɺࣜ (16) 〣ӈล〤⿶。〾〜〷খ《。〟 〔〶ɺ{Xn : n ∈ N} Ұ༷ۓີ〜⿴〈〝いɻ ্〣ओு〣ิ ࣜ (16) 〣྆ล〠ؔ「〛্ݶぇ〝ぁ〥ɺ sup n∈N P(|Xn | > M) ≤ sup n∈N 1 Mp E[|Xn |p] = 1 Mp sup n∈N E[|Xn |p]. 〈〈〜ɺE[|Xn |p] = O(1) 〽〿ɺ⿴ఆ C > 0 ଘࡏ「〛, sup n∈N P(|Xn | > M) ≤ C Mp . 〈ぁ〽〿ɺ lim M→∞ sup n∈N P(|Xn | > M) = 0. 〽〘〛ɺ{Xn : n ∈ N} 〤Ұ༷ۓີ〜⿴ɻ 40 / 43 -
〤」〶〠 ょ゙が〣ิ (p.9) ろ゚ぢや〣ෆࣜ (Example 2.6, p.10) ྫ 2.6 〣ޙ
(1/2) ྫ 2.6 〣ޙ (p.10) E[X2 n ] = V[Xn ] + (E[Xn ])2 〿ཱ〙〈〝〾ɺ E[Xn ] = O(1) 〙 V[Xn ] = O(1) 〜⿴〈〝〤Ұ༷ۓີੑ〣े݅ ぇ༩⿺ɻ ্〣ओு〣ิ E[Xn ] = O(1) 〙 V[Xn ] = O(1) 〿ཱ〙〝 ɺ E[X2 n ] = V[Xn ] + (E[Xn ])2 〽〿 E[X2 n ] = O(1) 〜⿴ɻ 〽〘〛ɺp = 2 〜 |Xn |p Մੵ〜⿴〈〝〾্هै⿸ɻ〔〕「ɺ ٯ〤〿ཱ〔〟⿶ɻ 41 / 43 -
〤」〶〠 ょ゙が〣ิ (p.9) ろ゚ぢや〣ෆࣜ (Example 2.6, p.10) ྫ 2.6 〣ޙ
(2/2) ྫ ֬มྻ Xn ぇɺશ〛〣 n 〜 Xn ぇぢがてが 7 〠ै⿸֬ม〜 ⿴〽⿸〟֬มྻ〝『ɻ֤ n 〠ର「 Xn 〤ۓີ〕〾ɺε > 0 ぇ ҙ〠〝〘〔〝 ɺ⿴ M > 0 ଘࡏ「〛ɺ P(|Xn | > M) < ε 〜⿴ɻ《〾〠ɺશ〛〣 n 〜 Xn ಉ〠「〔⿸〾ɺ sup n∈N P(|Xn | > M) < ε 〿ཱ〙ɻ〽〘〛ɺ{Xn : n ∈ N} 〤Ұ༷ۓີ〜⿴ɻ ҰํɺXn 〤ぢがてが〠「〔⿸〾ɺظ〹ࢄ〤ଘࡏ「〟⿶ 〔〶ɺE[Xn ] ̸= O(1), V[Xn ] ̸= O(1). 7ぢがてが〣ಛ〝「〛ɺฏۉ〷ࢄ〷ଘࡏ【』ɺ྆〣֬ີ〤 0 〠ۙ『 ࿈ଓత〟֬〜⿴〝⿶⿸ڍ〆〾ぁɻશ〛〣 n 〠ର「〛 Xn ぇぢがてが 〝「〛「〳⿺〥ɺฏۉ〷ࢄ〷ଘࡏ「〟⿶〾 O(1) 〜〟。ɺ֤ Xn 〣ۓີੑ֬ม ྻ {Xn} 〣Ұ༷ۓີੑぇ〿ཱ〔【〛⿶ɻ 42 / 43 -
〤」〶〠 ょ゙が〣ิ (p.9) ろ゚ぢや〣ෆࣜ (Example 2.6, p.10) Reference I [1]
Aad W Van der Vaart. Asymptotic statistics, Vol. 3. Cambridge university press, 2000. [2] ਿӜޫ. جૅֶ 2 ղੳೖ 1, ୈ 2 ר. ౦ژେֶग़൛ձ. [3] ౷ܭֶ〭〣֬, 〒〣ઌ〭: に゜〾〣ଌతཧղ〝ۙཧ〭〣Ս々ڮ. ాะ, 2021. [4] सٱ. ֬. ߨ࠲ֶ〣ߟ⿺ํ / ൧ߴໜ [〰] ฤ. ேॻళ, 2004. 43 / 43