Share
Embed
Galactic archaeology and asteroseismology of white dwarf stars
Colloquium, 45 min. March 2021: SAC Seminar, Aarhus University, Aarhus, Denmark
jjhermes
March 11, 2021
Transcript
48 slides
-
JJ Hermes, Boston University | SAC Seminar | 4 1.
White Dwarfs are Stellar Fossils that We Can Directly Age-Date 2. We Are Using TESS to Better Model These Stellar Fossils -
• a stellar remnant that is no longer fusing in
its core • the endpoints of everything < 8 M¤ • electron degeneracy limits WD mass to < 1.4 M¤ A ‘typical’ 0.6 solar-mass white dwarf electron degenerate C/O core (r = 8500 km) non-degenerate He layer (260 km) non-degenerate H layer (30 km) [thermal reservoir] [insulating blanket] JJ Hermes, Boston University | SAC Seminar | 5 What Do We Mean by ‘White Dwarf’? -
A ‘typical’ 0.6 solar-mass white dwarf electron degenerate C/O core
(r = 8500 km) non-degenerate He layer (260 km) non-degenerate H layer (30 km) [thermal reservoir] [insulating blanket] JJ Hermes, Boston University | SAC Seminar | 6 White Dwarfs are Excellent for Ages: They Simply Radiate Their Stored Heat, Which is Not Replenished 65,000 K (0.001 Gyr) 25,000 K (0.02 Gyr) 13,000 K (0.31 Gyr) 10,500 K (0.56 Gyr) 7100 K (1.5 Gyr) 5100 K (5 Gyr) 3300 K (11 Gyr) -
Gaia has revolutionized our ability to nd white dwarfs Gaia
Collaboration, Babusiaux et al. 2018 • Before Gaia we knew of ~35,000 white dwarfs (mostly from SDSS) • Gentile Fusillo et al. 2019 catalog nearly half a million candidates from Gaia DR2 JJ Hermes, Boston University | SAC Seminar | 7 -
Gaia eDR3: We Are Directly Testing Ages in Wide WD+WD
Tyler Heintz (BU), also Kareem El-Badry (Berkeley) JJ Hermes, Boston University | SAC Seminar | 8 El-Badry, Rix & Heintz 2021: arXiv: 2101.05282 1565 high-confidence, wide (>100 au) binaries with 2 WDs! -
Soon We Will Have a Better-Calibrated Sample of Wide WD
Co-PI: Jennifer Van Saders JJ Hermes, Boston University | SAC Seminar | 9 200 pc sample from El-Badry et al. 2018, 2021 >16,000 high-confidence, wide (>100 au) binaries with 1 WD! -
0.6 M¤ 0.9 M¤ 1.1 M¤ Gaia Reveals Interesting Physics
in White Dwarf Cooling JJ Hermes, Boston University | SAC Seminar | 10 Tremblay et al. 2019 -
0.6 M¤ 0.9 M¤ 1.1 M¤ JJ Hermes, Boston University
| SAC Seminar | 11 Tremblay et al. 2019 White dwarfs within 100 pc in Gaia • Gaia CMD showed an overdensity aside from expected cooling tracks -
JJ Hermes, Boston University | SAC Seminar | 12 Tremblay
et al. 2019 DA (H-atmosphere) white dwarfs within 100 pc in Gaia • The overdensity appears better focusing only on DA white dwarfs -
20% of core is crystallized 80% of core is crystallized
JJ Hermes, Boston University | SAC Seminar | 13 Tremblay et al. 2019 DA (H-atmosphere) white dwarfs within 100 pc in Gaia • The overdensity appears better focusing only on DA white dwarfs -
107.5 yr, 0.4 M¤ 107.5 yr, 1.3 M¤ +100.02 yr
Onset of crystallization 80% of mass is crystallized JJ Hermes, Boston University | SAC Seminar | 14 Tremblay et al. 2019 Crystallization causes a pile-up in white dwarf cooling Predicted theoretically by Van Horn 1968 -
No crystallization Latent heat from crystallization Gaia Observed Latent heat
from crystallization, plus gravitational energy from 16O sedimentation JJ Hermes, Boston University | SAC Seminar | 15 Tremblay et al. 2019 This overdensity is exactly where we expect crystallization! Gaia WD Luminosity Function -
JJ Hermes, Boston University | SAC Seminar | 16 (What
is latent heat? Why does it stall cooling?) • Latent heat: extra energy required to carry out a first-order phase transition • (When smoking a brisket the moisture in the meat undergoes a 1st-order phase transition at 160F [70C] from evaporative cooling) -
“Long after our roiling, boiling life-giving star runs out of
fuel, it will slowly form a cold, dead, super-dense crystal sphere about the size of the Earth that will linger like a translucent tombstone.” – Deborah Netburn, The Los Angeles Times JJ Hermes, Boston University | SAC Seminar | 17 -
Adding tangential velocities to the Gaia CMD… 100 pc sample
from Gentile Fusillo et al. 2019 JJ Hermes, Boston University | SAC Seminar | 18 0.6 M¤ 1.2 M¤ -
1. Fundamental physics from White Dwarfs in Gaia CMD JJ
Hermes, Boston University | SAC Seminar | 19 • Most (>90%) of WDs Should Cool Predictably & Eventually Crystallize, Releasing Latent Heat • We are Testing Expectations with Wide, Coeval WD+WD Binaries 65,000 K (0.001 Gyr) 25,000 K (0.02 Gyr) 13,000 K (0.31 Gyr) 10,500 K (0.56 Gyr) 7100 K (1.5 Gyr) 5100 K (5 Gyr) 3300 K (11 Gyr) -
He P.I. zone (30-20 kK) H P.I. zone (13-10 kK)
N2 Ll 2 DAV Propagation Diagram Core Surface p-modes σ2 > L l 2, N2 convection zone log σ2 (s-2) g-modes σ2 < L l 2, N2 DBV: aka V477 Her DAV: aka ZZ Ceti Fontaine & Brassard 2008 Aerts, JCD, Kurtz 2010 JJ Hermes, Boston University | SAC Seminar | 20 -
White Dwarfs: g-modes, not all modes are observed excited (much
like delta Scuti p-modes) 5 min 4 min 6 min Solar p-modes BiSON; Thompson et al. 2003 2 min 3 min 4 min 5 min 6 min 10 min JJ Hermes, Boston University | SAC Seminar | 21 n -
White Dwarfs: g-modes, not all modes are observed excited (much
like delta Scuti p-modes) Adiabatic Model: 11,245 K, 0.632 M¤ , 10-4.12 MH /MWD (Romero et al. 2012) 2 min 3 min 4 min 5 min 6 min 10 min JJ Hermes, Boston University | SAC Seminar | 22 l=1 l=2 -
KIC 08626021: Østensen et al. 2011, 2013 JJ Hermes, Boston
University | SAC Seminar | 23 The Most Studied Kepler Pulsating WD: A Hot DBV Red: Location of m=0 models of Giammichele et al. 2018 Blue: Location of m=0 models of Bischoff-Kim et al. 2014 -
Core Surface ß 99% of mass X(O) = 78.03% ±
4.2% X(C) = 21.96% ± 4.2% X(He) = 0.0113% ± 0.006% KIC 08626021: Giammichele et al. 2018 JJ Hermes, Boston University | SAC Seminar | 24 Toulouse Models Predict A Large, O-Dominated Core -
JJ Hermes, Boston University | SAC Seminar | 25 Toulouse
Models Neglected to Include Neutrino Cooling Timmes et al. 2018 KIC 08626021: Giammichele et al. 2018 -
JJ Hermes, Boston University | SAC Seminar | 26 Toulouse
Models Now Updated to Include Neutrino Cooling KIC 08626021: Charpinet et al. 2019 8 observed modes & many free parameters There is great potential in getting this right! Gaia CMD position infers: 0.73 ± 0.12 M¤ Black: Models of Giammichele et al. 2018 Red: Models of Charpinet et al. 2019 including neutrino cooling -
JJ Hermes, Boston University | SAC Seminar | 27 7.5
8.5 8.0 Blue: K2 Pulsating WDs log(g) = 9 20,000 K 10,000 K Kepler/K2 Observed 90 Pulsating White Dwarfs Hermes et al. 2021, in prep. 81 DAV (H-atm.) WDs First 27 published in Hermes et al. 2017 Grey: All 2166 WDs 7 DBV (He-atm.) WDs Analysis in Vanderbosch et al. 2021 2 DOV (pre-WDs, C/O-atm.) -
1000 s 200 s 500 s 125 s l=1 l=2
White Dwarf Seismologist’s Dilemma: Often Few Modes JJ Hermes, Boston University | SAC Seminar | 28 -
1000 s 200 s 500 s 125 s l=1 l=2
White Dwarf Seismologist’s Dilemma: Often Few Modes (consecutive g-modes evenly spaced in period, not frequency) JJ Hermes, Boston University | SAC Seminar | 29 -
l = 1 n = 1 l = 1 n
= 2 l = 1 n = 3 SDSSJ0051+0339, g=17.6, K2 Campaign 8 White Dwarf Seismologist’s Dilemma: Often Few Modes Chris Clemens et al. in prep. Kepler and TESS makes some short-period mode identification relatively trivial JJ Hermes, Boston University | SAC Seminar | 30 -
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 50
100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 Mode Period (s) N l = 1 n = 1 l = 1 n = 2 l = 1 n = 3 n = 1 n = 2 n = 3 n = 4 If we only plot identified l=1 (m=0) modes: White Dwarf Seismologist’s Dilemma: Often Few Modes Chris Clemens et al. in prep. JJ Hermes, Boston University | SAC Seminar | 31 -
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 50
100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 Mode Period (s) N n = 1 n = 2 n = 3 n = 4 l = 1 n = 1 l = 1 n = 2 l = 1 n = 3 If we only plot identified l=1 (m=0) modes: White Dwarf Seismologist’s Dilemma: Often Few Modes Chris Clemens et al. in prep. JJ Hermes, Boston University | SAC Seminar | 32 -
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 50
100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 l=1 DAV periods, observed Full evolutionary models computed by Romero et al. 2012 Chris Clemens et al. in prep. White Dwarf Seismologist’s Dilemma: Often Few Modes JJ Hermes, Boston University | SAC Seminar | 33 -
Drawing from a random distribution of all hydrogen layer masses
Full evolutionary models computed by Romero et al. 2012 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 l=1 DAV periods, observed 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 l=1 random MH simulation Chris Clemens et al. in prep. White Dwarf Seismologist’s Dilemma: Often Few Modes JJ Hermes, Boston University | SAC Seminar | 34 -
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 50
100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 l=1 DAV periods, observed 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 l=1 random MH simulation l=1 canonical MH simulation Full evolutionary models computed by Romero et al. 2012 Only drawing from the models with canonically thick (10-4 MH /M★ ) hydrogen layers Chris Clemens et al. in prep. Most (>80%) of DAs Have Thick H Layers JJ Hermes, Boston University | SAC Seminar | 35 -
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 50
100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 l=1 DAV periods, observed 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 l=1 random MH simulation l=1 canonical MH simulation Full evolutionary models computed by Romero et al. 2012 Only drawing from the models with canonically thick (10-4 MH /M★ ) hydrogen layers Chris Clemens et al. in prep. Most (>80%) of DAs Have Thick H Layers 10-15 s offset: Could be that He-layer masses too thick in canonical models à Would lead to systematically younger WD cooling ages (~10%) JJ Hermes, Boston University | SAC Seminar | 36 -
JJ Hermes, Boston University | SAC Seminar | 37 We
Have Strong Motivation to Keep Going with TESS -
JJ Hermes, Boston University | SAC Seminar | 38 We
Have Strong Motivation to Keep Going with TESS Blue: TESS Pulsating WDs Grey: All 3383 WDs with T < 17 mag 7.5 8.5 8.0 log(g) = 9 20,000 K 10,000 K So Far TESS Has Detected Oscillations in 62 Pulsating WDs -
White Dwarfs Are Faint, But TESS Data is Still Valuable
JJ Hermes, Boston University | SAC Seminar | 39 -
White Dwarfs Are Faint, But TESS Data is Still Valuable
JJ Hermes, Boston University | SAC Seminar | 40 -
WD 0158-160 (TIC 257459955): T=14.1 mag JJ Hermes, Boston University
| SAC Seminar | 41 Bell et al. 2019 TESS DAVs: Bognar et al. 2020 9 observed l=1 modes Gaia parallax implies a distance of 68.14 ± 0.28 pc Seismic distance, Model 2: 66.5 ± 2.5 pc Seismic distance, Model 1/3: 87.7 ± 7.9 pc -
The 20-Second Cadence Is Often Necessary for Our Science JJ
Hermes, Boston University | SAC Seminar | 42 Pulsation amplitudes have been, on average, 35% underestimated by the 2-min cadence so far in Cycle 3 -
2. TESS Will Keep Refining Models of White Dwarf Interiors
JJ Hermes, Boston University | SAC Seminar | 43 • Boutique Asteroseismology of WDs Still Hard, But Improving, Especially With Ensemble Approaches at Short Periods • In Many Cases, 20-second TESS Data Is Crucial • We Are Working Onwards Towards Constraining WD Core Compositions and Envelopes! 65,000 K (0.001 Gyr) 25,000 K (0.02 Gyr) 13,000 K (0.31 Gyr) 10,500 K (0.56 Gyr) 7100 K (1.5 Gyr) 5100 K (5 Gyr) 3300 K (11 Gyr) -
Adding tangential velocities to the Gaia CMD… 100 pc sample
from Gentile Fusillo et al. 2019 JJ Hermes, Boston University | SAC Seminar | 44 0.6 M¤ 1.2 M¤ -
Massive WDs descended from 4-8 solar-mass ZAMS stars Cheng et
al. 2019 JJ Hermes, Boston University | SAC Seminar | 45 • Massive WDs should come from stars that spend <0.5 Gyr on the main sequence -
Something is delaying cooling in some massive WDs JJ Hermes,
Boston University | SAC Seminar | 46 • Models include crystallization: something else is slowing them down! • Fast kinematics suggests these have had their ages “reset”! • But why are they piling up? Cheng et al. 2019 -
0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6
0.8 1.0 Sedimentation Cooling Delay [Gyr] °3.5 °3.0 °2.5 °2.0 °1.5 0 2 4 Q Branch 0.9 MØ C/O WD Z = 0.035 Clustering, hNi = 3,000 Clustering, hNi = 1,000 Clustering, hNi = 300 Single-particle Diffusion °3.5 °3.0 °2.5 °2.0 °1.5 0 2 4 Q Branch 1.0 MØ C/O WD Z = 0.035 °3.5 °3.0 °2.5 °2.0 °1.5 0 2 4 Q Branch 1.1 MØ C/O WD Z = 0.035 °3.5 °3.0 °2.5 °2.0 °1.5 log(L/LØ) 0 2 4 Q Branch 1.18 MØ C/O WD Z = 0.035 0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 m [MØ] 0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 Mass Fraction 22Ne 12C 16O initial final Something is delaying cooling in some massive WDs JJ Hermes, Boston University | SAC Seminar | 47 • That something could be 22Ne sedimentation (perhaps in clusters) in C/O-rich cores Bauer et al. 2020 Bildsten & Hall 2001 -
1. Fundamental physics from White Dwarfs in Gaia CMD JJ
Hermes, Boston University | SAC Seminar | 48 • Most (>90%) of WDs Should Cool Predictably & Crystallize, Releasing Latent Heat • We are Testing Expectations with Wide, Coeval WD+WD Binaries • Pile-ups among ~7% of massive WDs reveal crystallization PLUS poorly modeled physics (perhaps related to mergers & sedimentation of 22Ne clusters?) 65,000 K (0.001 Gyr) 25,000 K (0.02 Gyr) 13,000 K (0.31 Gyr) 10,500 K (0.56 Gyr) 7100 K (1.5 Gyr) 5100 K (5 Gyr) 3300 K (11 Gyr)