CMMMASS - Metrics 1.pdf

Transcript

1. CRITICAL MMMASS Sustainable Architecture for Monday Morning Manoochehri | KTH-A | 110216 METRICS 1
2. RECAP
3. What is architecture? Optimisation of desirables vs constraints What is sustainability? New constraints What is sustainable architecture? Architecture for a world with new constraints
4. What is (sustainable) architecture? Disconnecting from fossil ‘opportunities’ Making desirables out of constraints (Re)-connecting to solar opportunities and constraints
5. SUSTAINABLE - SYSTEMS vs OBJECTS
6. SUSTAINABLE - SYSTEMS vs OBJECTS
7. Systems SUSTAINABLE - SYSTEMS vs OBJECTS
8. Systems Within constraints, over repeating time unit (90% by 2050) SUSTAINABLE - SYSTEMS vs OBJECTS
9. Systems Within constraints, over repeating time unit (90% by 2050) SUSTAINABLE - SYSTEMS vs OBJECTS
10. Systems Within constraints, over repeating time unit (90% by 2050) Objects SUSTAINABLE - SYSTEMS vs OBJECTS
11. Systems Within constraints, over repeating time unit (90% by 2050) Objects Equal resource allocation? SUSTAINABLE - SYSTEMS vs OBJECTS
12. Systems Within constraints, over repeating time unit (90% by 2050) Objects Equal resource allocation? > Power > Benefit distribution SUSTAINABLE - SYSTEMS vs OBJECTS
13. Systems Within constraints, over repeating time unit (90% by 2050) Objects Equal resource allocation? > Power > Benefit distribution Conditioned behaviour by objects? SUSTAINABLE - SYSTEMS vs OBJECTS
14. Systems Within constraints, over repeating time unit (90% by 2050) Objects Equal resource allocation? > Power > Benefit distribution Conditioned behaviour by objects? > Positive and negative conditioning! (cars > bicycles) SUSTAINABLE - SYSTEMS vs OBJECTS
15. Systems Within constraints, over repeating time unit (90% by 2050) Objects Equal resource allocation? > Power > Benefit distribution Conditioned behaviour by objects? > Positive and negative conditioning! (cars > bicycles) Future Use? SUSTAINABLE - SYSTEMS vs OBJECTS
16. Systems Within constraints, over repeating time unit (90% by 2050) Objects Equal resource allocation? > Power > Benefit distribution Conditioned behaviour by objects? > Positive and negative conditioning! (cars > bicycles) Future Use? > Positive & negative future use (waste >design for recycling/durability) SUSTAINABLE - SYSTEMS vs OBJECTS
17. Systems Within constraints, over repeating time unit (90% by 2050) Objects Equal resource allocation? > Power > Benefit distribution Conditioned behaviour by objects? > Positive and negative conditioning! (cars > bicycles) Future Use? > Positive & negative future use (waste >design for recycling/durability) SUSTAINABLE - SYSTEMS vs OBJECTS
18. Systems Within constraints, over repeating time unit (90% by 2050) Objects Equal resource allocation? > Power > Benefit distribution Conditioned behaviour by objects? > Positive and negative conditioning! (cars > bicycles) Future Use? > Positive & negative future use (waste >design for recycling/durability) SCALE & PROBABILITY ! (system view > objects) SUSTAINABLE - SYSTEMS vs OBJECTS
19. Systems Within constraints, over repeating time unit (90% by 2050) Objects Equal resource allocation? > Power > Benefit distribution Conditioned behaviour by objects? > Positive and negative conditioning! (cars > bicycles) Future Use? > Positive & negative future use (waste >design for recycling/durability) SCALE & PROBABILITY ! (system view > objects) 90% by 2050 SUSTAINABLE - SYSTEMS vs OBJECTS
20. CLASS INPUT
21. U value = W/m2/K METRIC APPLICATION OBSERVATION Measurement of insulation capacity W = J/s K = thermal gradient R = /actual/ insulating capacity
22. CONTENT
23. METRICS
24. METRICS
25. Raw Data (Cardinal): Carbon, Energy, Resources, Nature METRICS
26. Raw Data (Cardinal): Carbon, Energy, Resources, Nature Aggregate Data (Ordinal): Footprint, Assessment Tools METRICS
27. Raw Data (Cardinal): Carbon, Energy, Resources, Nature Aggregate Data (Ordinal): Footprint, Assessment Tools Supply-chain (Longitudinal): LCA METRICS
28. Raw Data (Cardinal): Carbon, Energy, Resources, Nature Aggregate Data (Ordinal): Footprint, Assessment Tools Supply-chain (Longitudinal): LCA METRICS
29. Raw Data (Cardinal): Carbon, Energy, Resources, Nature Aggregate Data (Ordinal): Footprint, Assessment Tools Supply-chain (Longitudinal): LCA Industry Tools: LEED, BREEAM, BIM/LCA/PLD METRICS
30. Raw Data (Cardinal): Carbon, Energy, Resources, Nature Aggregate Data (Ordinal): Footprint, Assessment Tools Supply-chain (Longitudinal): LCA Industry Tools: LEED, BREEAM, BIM/LCA/PLD METRICS
31. METRICS Raw Data (Cardinal)
32. METRICS Raw Data (Cardinal) Carbon, Energy, Resources, Nature
33. METRICS Raw Data (Cardinal) Carbon, Energy, Resources, Nature Others? Measurement?
34. METRICS Raw Data (Cardinal) Carbon, Energy, Resources, Nature Others? Measurement? Sustainability? Decisions?
35. METRICS Raw Data (Cardinal) Carbon, Energy, Resources, Nature Others? Measurement? Sustainability? Decisions? ISSUES
36. METRICS Raw Data (Cardinal) Carbon, Energy, Resources, Nature Others? Measurement? Sustainability? Decisions? ISSUES Information Lack? > Gaps in available/convenient/reliable information?
37. METRICS Raw Data (Cardinal) Carbon, Energy, Resources, Nature Others? Measurement? Sustainability? Decisions? ISSUES Information Lack? > Gaps in available/convenient/reliable information? Lack of knowledge of limits? > Focus on main parameters & trends?
38. METRICS Raw Data (Cardinal) Carbon, Energy, Resources, Nature Others? Measurement? Sustainability? Decisions? ISSUES Information Lack? > Gaps in available/convenient/reliable information? Lack of knowledge of limits? > Focus on main parameters & trends? Indicator Ease & Applicability > Indexes/Aggregates
39. METRICS Aggregates (Ordinal; & Cardinal?)
40. METRICS Aggregates (Ordinal; & Cardinal?) Carbon, Energy
41. METRICS Aggregates (Ordinal; & Cardinal?) Carbon, Energy Others? Measurement?
42. METRICS Aggregates (Ordinal; & Cardinal?) Carbon, Energy Others? Measurement? Eco-footprint
43. METRICS Aggregates (Ordinal; & Cardinal?) Carbon, Energy Others? Measurement? Eco-footprint Indexes?
44. METRICS Aggregates (Ordinal; & Cardinal?) Carbon, Energy Others? Measurement? Eco-footprint Indexes? ISSUES
45. METRICS Aggregates (Ordinal; & Cardinal?) Carbon, Energy Others? Measurement? Eco-footprint Indexes? ISSUES Quantification: Cardinal vs Ordinal? > Groups of cardinal metrics? Credibility: Who believes this stuff? > What is their real use (marketing)?
46. METRICS Aggregates (Ordinal; & Cardinal?) Carbon, Energy Others? Measurement? Eco-footprint Indexes? ISSUES Quantification: Cardinal vs Ordinal? > Groups of cardinal metrics? Credibility: Who believes this stuff? > What is their real use (marketing)? Governance: Who decides this stuff? > Can architects invent their own?
47. METRICS Aggregates (Ordinal; & Cardinal?) Carbon, Energy Others? Measurement? Eco-footprint Indexes? ISSUES Quantification: Cardinal vs Ordinal? > Groups of cardinal metrics? Credibility: Who believes this stuff? > What is their real use (marketing)? Governance: Who decides this stuff? > Can architects invent their own? Sustainability: Is an A-grade really about sustainability? > Or what?
48. METRICS Supply Chain Data (Longitudinal)
49. METRICS Supply Chain Data (Longitudinal) LCA using e.g. Carbon, Energy, Resources, Nature
50. METRICS Supply Chain Data (Longitudinal) LCA using e.g. Carbon, Energy, Resources, Nature Other inputs to LCA? Measurement?
51. METRICS Supply Chain Data (Longitudinal) LCA using e.g. Carbon, Energy, Resources, Nature Other inputs to LCA? Measurement? Sustainability? Decisions?
52. METRICS Supply Chain Data (Longitudinal) LCA using e.g. Carbon, Energy, Resources, Nature Other inputs to LCA? Measurement? Sustainability? Decisions? ISSUES
53. METRICS Supply Chain Data (Longitudinal) LCA using e.g. Carbon, Energy, Resources, Nature Other inputs to LCA? Measurement? Sustainability? Decisions? ISSUES Partitioning? > Where is the boundary of responsibility for any object?
54. METRICS Supply Chain Data (Longitudinal) LCA using e.g. Carbon, Energy, Resources, Nature Other inputs to LCA? Measurement? Sustainability? Decisions? ISSUES Partitioning? > Where is the boundary of responsibility for any object? Functional Unit? > Measuring what really matters?
55. METRICS Supply Chain Data (Longitudinal) LCA using e.g. Carbon, Energy, Resources, Nature Other inputs to LCA? Measurement? Sustainability? Decisions? ISSUES Partitioning? > Where is the boundary of responsibility for any object? Functional Unit? > Measuring what really matters? Information/Subjectivity? > Standard cardinal/ordinal problems
56. PREVIEW
57. METRICS Industry Tools
58. METRICS Industry Tools LEED
59. METRICS Industry Tools LEED BREEAM
60. METRICS Industry Tools LEED BREEAM BIM + LCA
61. METRICS Industry Tools LEED BREEAM BIM + LCA = PLD
62. METRICS Raw Data (Cardinal): Carbon, Energy, Resources, Nature Aggregate Data (Ordinal): Footprint Supply-chain (Longitudinal): LCA Industry Tools: LEED, BREEAM, BIM/LCA/PLD
63. METHODS What is architectural method? Beyond random squishing together of variables, consider metrics, then functional recomposition of programme, then signature moves
64. 17 Urban Villa Row House Courtyard Highrise House High Rise Office Educational Industrial Rural Dwelling Mixed Use Urban
65. CRITICAL MMMASS Sustainable Architecture for Monday Morning jm@resourcevision.se | KTH-A | 110216 METRICS 1