数理的アプローチで挑むスマホUIのデザイン改善：タップ成功率推定ツール「Tappy」の社内活用事例 / Improving Smartphone UI Design with a Mathematical Approach: In-house Use Case of the Tap Success Rate Estimation Tool "Tappy"

*NQSPWJOH4NBSUQIPOF6*%FTJHO XJUIB.BUIFNBUJDBM"QQSPBDI *OIPVTF6TF$BTFPGUIF5BQ4VDDFTT3BUF &TUJNBUJPO5PPM5BQQZ -:3FTFBSDI 3%%FQBSUNFOU )VNBO$PNQVUFS*OUFSBDUJPO5FBN 4IPUB:BNBOBLB

• #BDLHSPVOE • %FNPOTUSBUJPOPG5BQQZ • 3FMBUFEXPSL • *OIPVTFVTFDBTFT • *NQPSUBODFPGEFTJHOJOHCFUUFSJOUFSGBDFT
"HFOEB

+PJOFE:BIPP+"1"/3FTFBSDI -FBEFS )VNBO$PNQVUFS*OUFSBDUJPO5FBN 3FTFBSDI"SFB )VNBODPNQVUFSJOUFSBDUJPO )$* BOEVTFSJOUFSGBDFT 6* &TQFDJBMMZ IPXUPEFTJHOCFUUFSXFCQBHFTBQQTUIBUVTFSTJOUFSBDUXJUI
4FMGJOUSPEVDUJPO 4IPUB:BNBOBLB 1I%JO&OHJOFFSJOH .FJKJ6OJWFSTJUZ *IBWFPOFDBUBOEUXPEPHT

5SBEJUJPOBMMZ JUIBTCFFOEJGGJDVMUUPRVBOUJUBUJWFMZFWBMVBUFUIFVTBCJMJUZPGNPCJMF6*T *GBVTFSTVDDFFETUJNFTPVUPGUBQBUUFNQUT UIFUBQTVDDFTTSBUFJT 5BQQZ 5PPMGPSFTUJNBUJOHUBQTVDDFTTSBUFTPG6*FMFNFOUT FH CVUUPOT MJOLT PONPCJMFXFCQBHFTBQQT
😄&BTZUPUBQ 😢'SFRVFOUFSSPST -BSHF TNBMM 4VDDFTT &SSPS TVDDFTTSBUF

8IFONBOZ6*TNVTUCFQMBDFEPOBTDSFFO EFTJHOFSTDBOOPUBMXBZTGPMMPXHVJEFMJOFT &H "OESPJEEFTJHOHVJEFMJOFSFDPNNFOET6*FMFNFOUTUPCFBUMFBTUNNJOTJ[F IUUQTTVQQPSUHPPHMFDPNBDDFTTJCJMJUZBOESPJEBOTXFS IMKB ✘ *UJTPGUFOOPUGFBTJCMFUPFOTVSFUIBUFWFSZ6*FMFNFOUJTNNPSMBSHFS 8IFOB6*FMFNFOUJT)NNʷ8NN JUJTVODMFBSIPXBDDVSBUFMZVTFSTUBQJU
4VDDFTTSBUFTBMMPXGPSEFDJTJPOTCBTFEPORVBOUJUBUJWFJOEJDBUPST &H l-FU`TFOTVSFBUMFBTUBTVDDFTTSBUFGPSBMM6*TPOUIJTXFCQBHFz ✘ .FBTVSJOHUBQTVDDFTTSBUFTCZIBWJOHNBOZQFPQMFUBQIVOESFETPGUJNFTJTDPTUMZ %JGGJDVMUZJO6*EFTJHO

8FJNQMFNFOUFESFMFBTFEUXPUPPMT 5BQQZXFCBQQ 5BQQZGPS'JHNBQMVHJO

6TFSTFOUFSB63-BOE TFMFDUBTNBSUQIPOF 4J[F<JONN>BOE UBQTVDDFTTSBUFPGFBDI6* FMFNFOUBSFEJTQMBZFE %FNPWJEFP5BQQZXFCBQQ IUUQTUBQQZZBIPPDPKQ

• 0QUJNJ[JOHBEQMBDFNFOUUISPVHI%0.BOBMZTJT<8V /FVSPDPNQVUJOH> • %FUFDUJOHQIJTIJOHBUUBDLTUISPVHI%0.BOBMZTJT<.BP 1SPDFEJB$PNQVU4DJ> • &TUJNBUJOHUBQQBCMFFMFNFOUTJOTDSFFOTIPUTVTJOHDPNQVUFSWJTJPO <4DIPPQ $)*>
• %FUFDUJOHUBQQBCMFFMFNFOUTJOTDSFFOTIPUTVTJOHBVUPNBUFECPUT<8V 6*45> ✔5BQQZDBOJEFOUJGZXIFUIFSFWFSZQJYFMPOUIFTDSFFOJTUBQQBCMF XJUIBMNPTUOPMBH 3FTFBSDISFMBUFEUP5BQQZXFCBQQ

%JGGJDVMUZJOEFUFDUJOH6*TUISPVHI$7 &YBNQMFTXIFSFDPNQVUFSWJTJPOUFDIOJRVFTDBOOPUEJTUJOHVJTIUBQQBCMFBSFBT )ZQFSMJOL )ZQFSMJOL )ZQFSMJOL )ZQFSMJOL )ZQFSMJOL )ZQFSMJOL )ZQFSMJOL )ZQFSMJOL
)ZQFSMJOL )ZQFSMJOL )ZQFSMJOL )ZQFSMJOL 'SPNBQQFBSBODFBMPOF JUJTEJGGJDVMUUPEFUFSNJOFFYBDUMZ XIJDIBSFBTBSFUBQQBCMF 0OMZUIFUFYUJUTFMGJTUBQQBCMF 5IFBSFBBSPVOEUIFUFYU JTBMTPUBQQBCMF 5IFUBQQBCMFSFHJPODIBOHFTEFQFOEJOH POUIFQMBDFNFOUPGTVSSPVOEJOHMJOLT

:PVDBOTUBSUVTJOHJUSJHIUBXBZ CZFOUFSJOH5BQQZJOUIF QMVHJOTFBSDIGPSN %FNPWJEFP5BQQZGPS'JHNBQMVHJO IUUQTXXXGJHNBDPNDPNNVOJUZQMVHJOUBQQZ

3FBTPOCFIJOEEFWFMPQJOH5BQQZ *G6*FMFNFOUTBSFUPPTNBMM VTBCJMJUZEFDSFBTFT *G6*FMFNFOUTBSFUPPMBSHF VTFSTXJMMOFFEUPTDSPMMNPSF &WFOKVTUBDDVSBUFMZVOEFSTUBOEJOHUIFUBQTVDDFTTSBUFDBOIFMQTVQQPSU6*EFTJHO

3FBTPOCFIJOEEFWFMPQJOH5BQQZ l8FTIPVMENBLFJUCJHHFS CFDBVTFVTFSTUFOEUPNJTTJDPOTz l*U`TOPUVTFEWFSZPGUFO TPJU`TGJOFUPLFFQJUTNBMMz #ZVTJOH5BQQZ EFWFMPQNFOUUFBNTDBOEJTDVTT6*EFTJHOCBTFEPORVBOUJUBUJWFNFUSJDT /PUGSFRVFOUMZVTFE

3FMBUFESFTFBSDIPOUBSHFUQPJOUJOH 7BSJBCJMJUZPGUBQQFEQPJOUT "JNFEQPTJUJPO 'JUUT`MBX <'JUUT > 1SFEJDUUBQUJNF𝑇 𝑇 = 𝑎
+ 𝑏 log! 𝐷 𝑊 + 1 4DINJEU`TMBX <4DINJEU > 1SFEJDUUBQQPJOUWBSJBCJMJUZ𝜎 𝜎 = 𝑎 + 𝑏 𝐷 𝑇 &SSPSSBUFNPEFM <8PCCSPDL > 𝐸𝑅 = 1 − erf 2.066 𝑊 𝐷 2 "!#$ % − 1 2

$MJDLDPPSEJOBUFTGPMMPXBOPSNBMEJTUSJCVUJPO 7BSJBODF𝜎!DBOCFFTUJNBUFECBTFEPOUIFTJ[F𝑊 𝜎! = 𝑎 + 𝑏𝑊! 1SPCBCJMJUZUIBUBDMJDLGBMMTXJUIJOUIFUBSHFUJT𝑆𝑅 = 𝑃
− " ! ≤ 𝑋 ≤ " ! = erf " ! !# 5IFPSFUJDBMCBDLHSPVOEPG5BQQZ 3FMBUJPOTIJQCFUXFFOUBSHFUTJ[F8BOEDMJDLDPPSEJOBUFWBSJBODFМ<#J 6*45> %JTUBODF𝐷 4J[F𝑊 4VDDFTT &SSPS &SSPS 𝑥! 𝑥" 'SFRVFODZ 𝜎! [mm!] 𝑊! [mm!] Z Y 3

VTFSTUBQQFEWBSJPVTCVUUPOTUJNFT UBQT <:BNBOBLB *44> 'PSFMMJQUJDBMUBSHFUT UIFIJUBSFBJTDBMDVMBUFEVTJOHUIFCPVOEJOHSFDUBOHMF 5BQDPPSEJOBUFTBSFOPSNBMMZEJTUSJCVUFEFWFOGPSSFDUBOHVMBSUBSHFUT<6TVCB *44> .PWFNFOUEJTUBODFIBTMJUUMFFGGFDUPOUIFWBSJBODFPGUBQQPJOUT<:BNBOBLB
*44> .PEFMBOEEBUBVTFEGPS5BQQZ 𝑋~𝑁(𝜇! , 𝜎! ") 𝑌~𝑁(𝜇# , 𝜎# ") 𝑃 𝑆 = / $ 1 2𝜋𝜎% exp − 𝑥" 2𝜎% " 1 2𝜋𝜎& exp − 𝑦" 2𝜎& " 𝑑𝑥𝑑𝑦 8 ) 𝑅 = 𝑥, 𝑦 | − 𝑊 2 ≤ 𝑥 ≤ 𝑊 2 , − 𝐻 2 ≤ 𝑦 ≤ 𝐻 2 𝜎% " = 𝑎 + 𝑏𝑊" 𝜎& " = 𝑐 + 𝑑𝐻"

"UBTLXIFSFQBSUJDJQBOUTUVSOCBDLBUBOBJNFEQPTJUJPO "GUFSNBOZSFQFUJUJPOT UIFUVSOBSPVOEQPJOUTGPSNBOPSNBMEJTUSJCVUJPO #FDBVTFUIJTJTTJNJMBSUPUBSHFUDMJDLJOHPOB1$ JUJTGSFRVFOUMZDJUFEFWFOJOSFDFOUSFTFBSDIQBQFST &OEQPJOUWBSJBCJMJUZJOBJNJOHUBTL "SFTFBSDIUPQJDTUVEJFETJODFUIFUIDFOUVSZ 8PPEXPSUI 345IFBDDVSBDZPGWPMVOUBSZNPWFNFOU1TZDIPMPHJDBM3FWJFX .POPHSBQI
4VQQMFNFOUT 7PM /P QQr 5VSOBSPVOEQPJOUTGPMMPX BOPSNBMEJTUSJCVUJPO

3FDFOUXPSLPOTVDDFTTSBUFNPEFMT 5BQQJOHPONPWJOHDJSDVMBSUBSHFUT <)VBOH 6*45> $MJDLJOHPONPWJOHUBSHFUTPG BSCJUSBSZTIBQFT <;IBOH $)*>

*UJTPGUFOTUBUFEUIBUNPEFMTGPSFTUJNBUJOHTVDDFTTSBUFTDBOTVQQPSUEFTJHOFST • lPVSXPSLBMTPQSPWJEFTUIFGPMMPXJOHJOTJHIUTGPSJOUFSGBDF EFTJHOJOWPMWJOHQPJOUJOHBUNPWJOH UBSHFUTz<;IBOH $)*> • lPVSNPEFMDBOIFMQJNQSPWFJOUFSGBDFEFTJHOJOSFBMXPSMEBQQMJDBUJPOTTVDIBT73 BQQMJDBUJPOTBOEHBNFTz<)VBOH $)*>
• lJUDBOCFVTFECZ6*EFTJHOFSTJOEFTJHOJOHBOEFWBMVBUJOHUPVDITDSFFOVTFSJOUFSGBDFTz <.B 6*45> )PXFWFS UIFSFXFSFOPTUVEJFTFYBNJOJOHXIFUIFSTVDINPEFMTBSFBDUVBMMZVTFGVMJOUIF6*EFTJHO XPSLPGQSPGFTTJPOBMEFTJHOFSTBOEFOHJOFFST *OPVSSFTFBSDI XFDPOEVDUFEJOUFSOBMJOUFSWJFXTXJUIVTFSTPGUIFXFCBQQWFSTJPOPG5BQQZ $MBJNTGPSNPEFMTJOQSFWJPVTTUVEJFT

5IFUBQTVDDFTTSBUFGPSUIFIBNCVSHFSNFOVXBTMPXFSUIBOFYQFDUFE #ZFYQBOEJOHUIFUBQQBCMFBSFBUPJODMVEFUIFTVSSPVOEJOHXIJUFTQBDF UIFTVDDFTTSBUFXJMMJODSFBTFUPPWFS 6TFDBTF :BIPP+"1"/5SBWFM

'PSBETPG:BIPP+"1"/4IPQQJOH JO:BIPP+"1"/4FBSDI UBQQJOHUIFMJOLUIBUJOEJDBUFTB TIPQPGGFSTTVQFSJPSTIJQQJOHTIPXTBOFYQMBOBUJPO CVUUIFTVDDFTTSBUFXBTMPXFSUIBOFYQFDUFE 4JODFUIJTMJOLJTOPUVTFEWFSZGSFRVFOUMZBOEFYQBOEJOHJUTUBQQBCMFBSFBJTBMPXQSJPSJUZ UIFEFDJTJPOXBTNBEFUPQPTUQPOFBOZNPEJGJDBUJPOT 6TFDBTF :BIPP+"1"/4FBSDI

6TFSTDBOSBUFBQSPEVDUCZUBQQJOHl˒zCVUUIFTVDDFTTSBUFXBTMPXFSUIBOFYQFDUFE #FDBVTFUIFTFBSFOPUGSFRVFOUMZVTFECVUUPOTBOEUIFGFBUVSFJTOPUFTTFOUJBMGPS QVSDIBTJOHQSPEVDUT UIFEFDJTJPOXBTNBEFUPQPTUQPOFBOZNPEJGJDBUJPOT 6TFDBTF :BIPP+"1"/4IPQQJOH

"NPOHUIFGFFECBDLCVUUPOTGPSBSUJDMFJNQSFTTJPOT POMZUIFl/FX1FSTQFDUJWFz CVUUPOIBEBIJHIUBQTVDDFTTSBUF "$44DPOGJHVSBUJPOFSSPSXBTGPVOEBOEGJYFE 6TFDBTF :BIPP+"1"/5FDI#MPH Before correction After correction

63-TBOBMZ[FE 6OJRVFVTFST 6OJRVF63-T
5PUBMOVNCFSPGBOBMZTFTTIPXO JOUIJTGJHVSFJT 0WFSPGUIFSFNBJOJOH63-T XFSFBOBMZ[FEUJNFT 6TBHFTUBUVTPG5BQQZXFCBQQ 'JSTUUISFFNPOUITBGUFSUIFQVCMJDSFMFBTF +BOVBSZ r"QSJM 63-TBOBMZ[FEPSNPSFUJNFT

"NPOHUIFTNBSUQIPOFNPEFMTVTFEGPSBOBMZTJT UIPTFTFMFDUFEUJNFTPSNPSF 5IFEFGBVMUTFUUJOH J1IPOF XBTUIFNPTU GSFRVFOUMZDIPTFO 5IFSFXFSFBMTPNBOZBOBMZTFTDPOEVDUFEVTJOH NVDIPMEFSNPEFMT FH
J1IPOF XIJDIJTPWFSZFBSTPME 6TBHFTUBUVTPGUIF5BQQZXFCBQQ 'JSTUUISFFNPOUITBGUFSUIFQVCMJDSFMFBTF +BOVBSZ r"QSJM

VTFSTBSFDVSSFOUMZVTJOHUIFQMVHJO 6TBHFTUBUVTPG5BQQZGPS'JHNBQMVHJO 4JODFJUTQVCMJDSFMFBTF GSPN0DUPCFS

*EFBMPQFSBUJPOTJUVBUJPO 5BQQJOHXJUIUIFJOEFYGJOHFSPGUIFEPNJOBOUIBOE 5BQTVDDFTTSBUFTDBOWBSZEFQFOEJOHPOGJOHFSVTFEBOEHSJQQPTUVSF 4DSFFOMBZPVUJTOPUDPOTJEFSFE 5BSHFUTOFBSUIFTDSFFOFEHFUFOEUPIBWFIJHIFSFSSPSSBUFT 5IFQSFTFODFPGPUIFSCVUUPOTOFBSUIFUBSHFUDBOBMTPBGGFDUTVDDFTTSBUFT 4VDDFTTSBUFTBSFDBMDVMBUFEGPSUIFCPVOEJOHSFDUBOHMFGPSTJNQMJDJUZ )5.-BMMPXTGPSCVUUPOTPGBSCJUSBSZTIBQFT 6TJOHNPEFMTGPSTVDIUBSHFUTNBLFTUIJTQPTTJCMFCVUJODSFBTFTDPNQVUBUJPOUJNF -JNJUBUJPOT
*UFNTOPUJOWFTUJHBUFEJOUIJTTUVEZ

8FBSFDPNQFUJOHXJUIPUIFSNFEJBGPSVTFST`UJNF &H EVSJOHNJOPGEBJMZJOUFSOFUVTF VTFSTTQFOEQBSUPGUIBUUJNFPO-:$PSQPSBUJPOTFSWJDFT #ZQSPWJEJOHDPNGPSUBCMFTFSWJDFTBOEBQQT FH GFXPQFSBUJPOFSSPST • 6TFS`TQFSTQFDUJWF
8BTUFEUJNFEVSJOHJOUFSOFUVTFDBOCFSFEVDFE • 1SPWJEFS`TQFSTQFDUJWF 6TFSTBSFNPSFMJLFMZUPDPOUJOVFVTJOHUIFJSTFSWJDFT 8IZDPOEVDU6*SFTFBSDIBU-:$PSQPSBUJPO 6TFSGSJFOEMZ6*TBSFJNQPSUBOUGPSCPUIVTFSTBOETFSWJDFQSPWJEFST $JUFEGSPN IUUQTXXXTPVNVHPKQNBJO@DPO UFOUQEG 57WJFXNJO *OUFSOFUVTBHFNJO BTPG

6TFSTEJTMJLFXFCTFSWJDFTUIBUXBTUFUIFJSUJNF • *GBXFCQBHFMPBETXJUIJOTFD POMZPGVTFSTMFBWF • *GMPBEJOHUBLFTTFD UIFESPQPVUSBUFJODSFBTFTUP 5BQQZEFWFMPQNFOUUFBN`TQFSTQFDUJWF • *OBEEJUJPOUPOFUXPSLSFTFBSDIEFWFMPQNFOU
JNQSPWJOH6*EFTJHODBOBMTPQSPWJEFDPNGPSUBCMFTFSWJDFTBOESFEVDFXBTUFEUJNF %FWFMPQNFOUGPSDPNGPSUBCMFTFSWJDFT $JUFEGSPNl%PFT1BHF-PBE5JNF3FBMMZ"GGFDU#PVODF 3BUF 1JOHEPN3PZBMz 1JOHEPN IUUQTXXXQJOHEPNDPNCMPHQBHFMPBEUJNFSFBMMZ BGGFDUCPVODFSBUF

&SSPSDMJDLJOHJODVSTBEEJUJPOBMBDUJPOT BOEFYUSBUJNF UPSFDPWFSGSPNUIFFSSPS ᶃ "DDJEFOUBMMZTFMFDUJOHUIFXSPOHMJOL POFBCPWFUIFJOUFOEFEPOF ᶄ $MJDLJOHUIFCSPXTFS`Tl#BDLzCVUUPOUPSFMPBEUIFQSFWJPVTQBHF ᶅ 4DSPMMJOHUISPVHIUIFQBHFUPGJOEBOEDMJDLUIFDPSSFDUMJOLBHBJO
8BTUFEUJNFCZFSSPSPQFSBUJPO &YUSBTUFQTSFRVJSFEUPSFDPWFSGSPNVTFSNJTUBLFT

4MJHIUMZPMEFSEBUB ':2GJOBODJBMSFTVMUT NJOQFSVTFSQFSEBZ • /VNCFSPGNPOUIMZMPHHFEJOVTFS*%TNJMMJPO • 5PUBMVTBHFUJNFCZMPHHFEJOVTFST TNBSUQIPOF 1$ CJMMJPOIPVST
*GFSSPSDMJDLTPDDVSEVSJOHNJO dTFDPGFYUSBXPSLJTOFFEFE dPGUPUBMUJNF ✘*ODPOWFOJFOUBOEXBTUFEUJNFGPSVTFST ✘'PSTFSWJDFQSPWJEFST JUSFQSFTFOUTBTJHOJGJDBOUMPTTPGPQQPSUVOJUZ • *GUIBUXBTUFEUJNFIBECFFOTQFOUVTJOHUIFTFSWJDF JUDPVMEIBWFMFEUPJODSFBTFE TBMFTGPSTIPQQJOHTJUFTPSNPSFBEWJFXTGPSOFXTTJUFT #FDBVTFEFTJHOJOH6*TUIBUQSFWFOUVTFSFSSPSTJTTPJNQPSUBOU XFEFWFMPQFE5BQQZ 6TBHFTUBUVTPG-:$PSQPSBUJPOTFSWJDFT $JUFEGSPNIUUQTTZJNHKQJEPDTJSBSDIJWFTQSFTFOUKQQSFTFOUBUJPOQEG

8FBSFDVSSFOUMZXPSLJOHPOSFTFBSDIUPQJDTUIBUNBZCFDPNFBQQTQMVHJOTUPCF SFMFBTFETFWFSBMZFBSTGSPNOPX )JTUPSZPG5BQQZEFWFMPQNFOU 5BQQJOHUBTL +BOVBSZ 1BQFS1VCMJDBUJPO /PWFNCFS 8FCBQQSFMFBTF +BOVBSZ

5IBOLZPV 5BQQZXFCBQQ 5BQQZGPS'JHNBQMVHJO

数理的アプローチで挑むスマホUIのデザイン改善：タップ成功率推定ツール「Tappy」の社内活用...

数理的アプローチで挑むスマホUIのデザイン改善：タップ成功率推定ツール「Tappy」の社内活用事例 / Improving Smartphone UI Design with a Mathematical Approach: In-house Use Case of the Tap Success Rate Estimation Tool "Tappy"

LINEヤフーTech (LY Corporation Tech)
PRO

More Decks by LINEヤフーTech (LY Corporation Tech)

Other Decks in Design

Featured

Transcript

NQSPWJOH4NBSUQIPOF6%FTJHO XJUIB.BUIFNBUJDBM"QQSPBDI OIPVTF6TF$BTFPGUIF5BQ4VDDFTT3BUF &TUJNBUJPO5PPM5BQQZ -:3FTFBSDI 3%%FQBSUNFOU )VNBO$PNQVUFSOUFSBDUJPO5FBN 4IPUB:BNBOBLB

• #BDLHSPVOE • %FNPOTUSBUJPOPG5BQQZ • 3FMBUFEXPSL • OIPVTFVTFDBTFT • NQPSUBODFPGEFTJHOJOHCFUUFSJOUFSGBDFT

+PJOFE:BIPP+"1"/3FTFBSDI -FBEFS )VNBO$PNQVUFSOUFSBDUJPO5FBN 3FTFBSDI"SFB )VNBODPNQVUFSJOUFSBDUJPO )$ BOEVTFSJOUFSGBDFT 6* &TQFDJBMMZ IPXUPEFTJHOCFUUFSXFCQBHFTBQQTUIBUVTFSTJOUFSBDUXJUI

5SBEJUJPOBMMZ JUIBTCFFOEJGGJDVMUUPRVBOUJUBUJWFMZFWBMVBUFUIFVTBCJMJUZPGNPCJMF6T GBVTFSTVDDFFETUJNFTPVUPGUBQBUUFNQUT UIFUBQTVDDFTTSBUFJT 5BQQZ 5PPMGPSFTUJNBUJOHUBQTVDDFTTSBUFTPG6*FMFNFOUT FH CVUUPOT MJOLT PONPCJMFXFCQBHFTBQQT

8FJNQMFNFOUFESFMFBTFEUXPUPPMT 5BQQZXFCBQQ 5BQQZGPS'JHNBQMVHJO

6TFSTFOUFSB63-BOE TFMFDUBTNBSUQIPOF 4J[F<JONN>BOE UBQTVDDFTTSBUFPGFBDI6* FMFNFOUBSFEJTQMBZFE %FNPWJEFP5BQQZXFCBQQ IUUQTUBQQZZBIPPDPKQ

• 0QUJNJ[JOHBEQMBDFNFOUUISPVHI%0.BOBMZTJT<8V /FVSPDPNQVUJOH> • %FUFDUJOHQIJTIJOHBUUBDLTUISPVHI%0.BOBMZTJT<.BP 1SPDFEJB$PNQVU4DJ> • &TUJNBUJOHUBQQBCMFFMFNFOUTJOTDSFFOTIPUTVTJOHDPNQVUFSWJTJPO <4DIPPQ $)*>

%JGGJDVMUZJOEFUFDUJOH6*TUISPVHI$7 &YBNQMFTXIFSFDPNQVUFSWJTJPOUFDIOJRVFTDBOOPUEJTUJOHVJTIUBQQBCMFBSFBT )ZQFSMJOL )ZQFSMJOL )ZQFSMJOL )ZQFSMJOL )ZQFSMJOL )ZQFSMJOL )ZQFSMJOL )ZQFSMJOL

:PVDBOTUBSUVTJOHJUSJHIUBXBZ CZFOUFSJOH5BQQZJOUIF QMVHJOTFBSDIGPSN %FNPWJEFP5BQQZGPS'JHNBQMVHJO IUUQTXXXGJHNBDPNDPNNVOJUZQMVHJOUBQQZ

3FBTPOCFIJOEEFWFMPQJOH5BQQZ G6FMFNFOUTBSFUPPTNBMM VTBCJMJUZEFDSFBTFT G6FMFNFOUTBSFUPPMBSHF VTFSTXJMMOFFEUPTDSPMMNPSF &WFOKVTUBDDVSBUFMZVOEFSTUBOEJOHUIFUBQTVDDFTTSBUFDBOIFMQTVQQPSU6*EFTJHO

3FBTPOCFIJOEEFWFMPQJOH5BQQZ l8FTIPVMENBLFJUCJHHFS CFDBVTFVTFSTUFOEUPNJTTJDPOTz lU`TOPUVTFEWFSZPGUFO TPJU`TGJOFUPLFFQJUTNBMMz #ZVTJOH5BQQZ EFWFMPQNFOUUFBNTDBOEJTDVTT6EFTJHOCBTFEPORVBOUJUBUJWFNFUSJDT /PUGSFRVFOUMZVTFE

3FMBUFESFTFBSDIPOUBSHFUQPJOUJOH 7BSJBCJMJUZPGUBQQFEQPJOUT "JNFEQPTJUJPO 'JUUT`MBX <'JUUT > 1SFEJDUUBQUJNF𝑇 𝑇 = 𝑎

$MJDLDPPSEJOBUFTGPMMPXBOPSNBMEJTUSJCVUJPO 7BSJBODF𝜎!DBOCFFTUJNBUFECBTFEPOUIFTJ[F𝑊 𝜎! = 𝑎 + 𝑏𝑊! 1SPCBCJMJUZUIBUBDMJDLGBMMTXJUIJOUIFUBSHFUJT𝑆𝑅 = 𝑃

VTFSTUBQQFEWBSJPVTCVUUPOTUJNFT UBQT <:BNBOBLB 44> 'PSFMMJQUJDBMUBSHFUT UIFIJUBSFBJTDBMDVMBUFEVTJOHUIFCPVOEJOHSFDUBOHMF 5BQDPPSEJOBUFTBSFOPSNBMMZEJTUSJCVUFEFWFOGPSSFDUBOHVMBSUBSHFUT<6TVCB 44> .PWFNFOUEJTUBODFIBTMJUUMFFGGFDUPOUIFWBSJBODFPGUBQQPJOUT<:BNBOBLB

3FDFOUXPSLPOTVDDFTTSBUFNPEFMT 5BQQJOHPONPWJOHDJSDVMBSUBSHFUT <)VBOH 645> $MJDLJOHPONPWJOHUBSHFUTPG BSCJUSBSZTIBQFT <;IBOH $)>

UJTPGUFOTUBUFEUIBUNPEFMTGPSFTUJNBUJOHTVDDFTTSBUFTDBOTVQQPSUEFTJHOFST • lPVSXPSLBMTPQSPWJEFTUIFGPMMPXJOHJOTJHIUTGPSJOUFSGBDF EFTJHOJOWPMWJOHQPJOUJOHBUNPWJOH UBSHFUTz<;IBOH $)> • lPVSNPEFMDBOIFMQJNQSPWFJOUFSGBDFEFTJHOJOSFBMXPSMEBQQMJDBUJPOTTVDIBT73 BQQMJDBUJPOTBOEHBNFTz<)VBOH $)*>

5IFUBQTVDDFTTSBUFGPSUIFIBNCVSHFSNFOVXBTMPXFSUIBOFYQFDUFE #ZFYQBOEJOHUIFUBQQBCMFBSFBUPJODMVEFUIFTVSSPVOEJOHXIJUFTQBDF UIFTVDDFTTSBUFXJMMJODSFBTFUPPWFS 6TFDBTF :BIPP+"1"/5SBWFM

6TFSTDBOSBUFBQSPEVDUCZUBQQJOHl˒zCVUUIFTVDDFTTSBUFXBTMPXFSUIBOFYQFDUFE #FDBVTFUIFTFBSFOPUGSFRVFOUMZVTFECVUUPOTBOEUIFGFBUVSFJTOPUFTTFOUJBMGPS QVSDIBTJOHQSPEVDUT UIFEFDJTJPOXBTNBEFUPQPTUQPOFBOZNPEJGJDBUJPOT 6TFDBTF :BIPP+"1"/4IPQQJOH

"NPOHUIFGFFECBDLCVUUPOTGPSBSUJDMFJNQSFTTJPOT POMZUIFl/FX1FSTQFDUJWFz CVUUPOIBEBIJHIUBQTVDDFTTSBUF "$44DPOGJHVSBUJPOFSSPSXBTGPVOEBOEGJYFE 6TFDBTF :BIPP+"1"/5FDI#MPH Before correction After correction

63-TBOBMZ[FE 6OJRVFVTFST 6OJRVF63-T

"NPOHUIFTNBSUQIPOFNPEFMTVTFEGPSBOBMZTJT UIPTFTFMFDUFEUJNFTPSNPSF 5IFEFGBVMUTFUUJOH J1IPOF XBTUIFNPTU GSFRVFOUMZDIPTFO 5IFSFXFSFBMTPNBOZBOBMZTFTDPOEVDUFEVTJOH NVDIPMEFSNPEFMT FH

VTFSTBSFDVSSFOUMZVTJOHUIFQMVHJO 6TBHFTUBUVTPG5BQQZGPS'JHNBQMVHJO 4JODFJUTQVCMJDSFMFBTF GSPN0DUPCFS

8FBSFDPNQFUJOHXJUIPUIFSNFEJBGPSVTFST`UJNF &H EVSJOHNJOPGEBJMZJOUFSOFUVTF VTFSTTQFOEQBSUPGUIBUUJNFPO-:$PSQPSBUJPOTFSWJDFT #ZQSPWJEJOHDPNGPSUBCMFTFSWJDFTBOEBQQT FH GFXPQFSBUJPOFSSPST • 6TFS`TQFSTQFDUJWF

6TFSTEJTMJLFXFCTFSWJDFTUIBUXBTUFUIFJSUJNF • GBXFCQBHFMPBETXJUIJOTFD POMZPGVTFSTMFBWF • GMPBEJOHUBLFTTFD UIFESPQPVUSBUFJODSFBTFTUP 5BQQZEFWFMPQNFOUUFBN`TQFSTQFDUJWF • *OBEEJUJPOUPOFUXPSLSFTFBSDIEFWFMPQNFOU

&SSPSDMJDLJOHJODVSTBEEJUJPOBMBDUJPOT BOEFYUSBUJNF UPSFDPWFSGSPNUIFFSSPS ᶃ "DDJEFOUBMMZTFMFDUJOHUIFXSPOHMJOL POFBCPWFUIFJOUFOEFEPOF ᶄ $MJDLJOHUIFCSPXTFS`Tl#BDLzCVUUPOUPSFMPBEUIFQSFWJPVTQBHF ᶅ 4DSPMMJOHUISPVHIUIFQBHFUPGJOEBOEDMJDLUIFDPSSFDUMJOLBHBJO

4MJHIUMZPMEFSEBUB ':2GJOBODJBMSFTVMUT NJOQFSVTFSQFSEBZ • /VNCFSPGNPOUIMZMPHHFEJOVTFS*%TNJMMJPO • 5PUBMVTBHFUJNFCZMPHHFEJOVTFST TNBSUQIPOF 1$ CJMMJPOIPVST

8FBSFDVSSFOUMZXPSLJOHPOSFTFBSDIUPQJDTUIBUNBZCFDPNFBQQTQMVHJOTUPCF SFMFBTFETFWFSBMZFBSTGSPNOPX )JTUPSZPG5BQQZEFWFMPQNFOU 5BQQJOHUBTL +BOVBSZ 1BQFS1VCMJDBUJPO /PWFNCFS 8FCBQQSFMFBTF +BOVBSZ

5IBOLZPV 5BQQZXFCBQQ 5BQQZGPS'JHNBQMVHJO