Share
Embed
Transcript
28 slides
-
YCM Market Analysis: Objec5ves • Evaluate the demand for
flight service to Niagara District Airport (YCM). • Analyze the potenAal for flight use to YCM from airports within an 800km radius. IniAal target markets include OHawa, Montreal and New York City. • Evaluate the tourism industry’s capacity to support flight service including visitor services such as ground transportaAon; compelling experiences; and markeAng. Page 1 -
Background: How do people travel? (Generally – not
Niagara specific) Page 2 97.2% 94.3% 85.9% 61.8% 42.3% 31.5% 14.8% 0.2% 1.5% 10.3% 33.7% 55.2% 65.6% 82.1% 2.7% 4.2% 3.8% 4.4% 2.5% 2.9% 3.2% 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% 50 - 150 miles 150 -250 miles 250 -500 miles 500-749 miles 750-999 miles 1,000-1,499 miles 1,500+ miles One-Way Travel Distance US Residents: Mode of Travel by One-Way Travel Distance, 2001 Personal vehicle Air Bus, train, other Source: 2001 National Travel Survey, US Department of Transportation; RRC Associates. -
Exploratory YCM target airports in 250-‐500 mi radius (Plus
YTZ – Toronto Billy Bishop) Page 3 Source: ESRI; RRC Associates. -
YCM Market Analysis: Outline • Evaluate potenAal for flights
between YCM and US airports (market share approach): 1. IdenAfy overall size of exisAng flight market 2. Evaluate YCM capture rates required for flights to break even financially 3. Evaluate interest by exisAng Niagara visitors/ prospects in YCM flights (survey) 4. Evaluate potenAal incremental demand sAmulated by YCM flights (survey) • Evaluate potenAal for flights between YCM and Canadian airports: – (Similar process as for US airports) Page 4 -
Page 5 Size of Exis5ng Niagara Flight Market To/From
US Airports Existing Enplanements (approx.) Market Annual Apr - Sep 1 US / overseas visitors to Niagara flying to BUF 300,000 230,000 2 US / overseas visitors to Niagara flying to Toronto from US 230,000 170,000 Subtotal: US / overseas visitors flying in US en route to Niagara 530,000 400,000 3 Canadian residents flying out of BUF & IAG 905,000 375,000 Grand total 1,435,000 775,000 Sources: 1. RRC Associates, based on several extrapolation methods 2. Stats Canada - Int'l Traveler Survey (2007-11 annual avg). (All computations, use and interpretation of these data are entirely that of RRC Associates.) 3. Canadian Airports Council, March 20, 2012; Stats Canada Canadian Resident Travel Survey 2007-11; RRC Associates. -
Size of Exis+ng Niagara Flight Market SUPPORTING DETAIL
Strong inbound pax to BUF in summer à Indicator of summer visitors Page 6 Source: US Department of Transportation, including Origin and Destination Survey; Aviation DataMiner; RRC Associates. 23% 25% 17% 26% 26% 27% 27% 25% 32% 24% 24% 24% 0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 30% 35% 2011 Total US domestic and international enplanements 2011 BUF enplanements - originating in BUF 2011 BUF enplanements - originating at other airports Percent of Annual Enplanements 2011 Quarter 1 (Jan -Mar) 2011 Quarter 2 (Apr - Jun) 2011 Quarter 3 (Jul - Sep) 2011 Quarter 4 (Oct - Dec) } U.S. overall: Moderate summer peak (vacation travel) } BUF outbound: Moderate winter/spring peak (snowbirds) } BUF inbound (above Q1 baseline): Niagara tourists (roughly) BUF inbound (below Q1 baseline): Year-round background traffic (business, etc.) -
YCM Market Analysis: Outline • Evaluate potenAal for flights
between YCM and US airports: 1. IdenAfy overall size of exisAng flight market 2. Evaluate YCM capture rates required for flights to break even 3. Evaluate interest by exisAng Niagara visitors/ prospects in YCM flights (survey) 4. Evaluate potenAal incremental demand sAmulated by YCM flights (survey) • Evaluate potenAal for flights between YCM and Canadian airports: – (Similar process as for US airports) Page 7 -
Capture rates required for YCM US-‐bound flights to break even
in Apr-‐Sep (Depending on plane size & frequency, average fare, and opportunity cost for carrier) Page 8 Source: Statistics Canada International Travel Survey 2007-11; RRC Associates. All computations, use and interpretation of these data are entirely that of RRC Associates. YCM pax required to break-even: Days in Apr - Sep service period: 180 Seats / day (2 flights @ 75 seats each): 150 Target load factor: 70% Demand required to break even on Apr - Sep flights: 18,900 YCM capture rates required to break even: Existing Enplanements Market Apr - Sep US / overseas visitors to Niagara flying to BUF 230,000 8.2% US / overseas visitors to Niagara flying to Toronto from US 170,000 11.1% Subtotal: US / overseas visitors to Niagara 400,000 4.7% Canadian residents flying out of BUF & IAG 375,000 5.0% Grand total 775,000 2.4% Capture rate req'd for YCM to achieve 18,900 pax -
Capture rates required for YCM US-‐bound flights to break-‐even in
Apr-‐Sep: by Des5na5on Airport (Depending on average fare, and opportunity cost for carrier) Page 9 Source: Aviation DataMiner; RRC Associates. Note: Required BUF capture rates will be lower to the extent YCM also captures some share from US-Toronto flights. - Toronto likely has at least as many passengers to the respective US airports as BUF, although concrete data is unavailable. Required YCM capture rates relative to BUF enplanements (Req'd capture rates lower when include YYZ & YTZ) Destination city/airports: Apr - Sep 2012 outbound enplanements from BUF New York - EWR, JFK, LGA 297,064 6.4% Chicago - MDW, ORD 208,951 9.0% Washington DC / Baltimore - DCA, IAD, BWI 180,118 10.5% Boston - BOS 81,944 23.1% Philadelphia - PHL 49,693 38.0% Capture rate req'd for YCM to achieve 18,900 pax -
YCM Market Analysis: Outline • Evaluate potenAal for flights
between YCM and US airports: 1. IdenAfy overall size of exisAng flight market 2. Evaluate capture rates required for flights to break even 3. Evaluate interest by exisAng Niagara visitors/ prospects in YCM flights (survey) 4. Evaluate potenAal incremental demand sAmulated by YCM flights (survey) • Evaluate potenAal for flights between YCM and Canadian airports: – (Similar process as for US airports) Page 10 -
To what degree might the following factors increase or decrease
your interest in flying to Niagara District Airport on a future trip to the Niagara area? Base: US residents living more than 5 hours’ drive from Niagara (n=98) Page 11 Source: RRC Associates survey of TPN database, April 2013. - Sample frame: TPN email database, excluding southern Ontario (except including Toronto FSA). - Total response: n=904. (US – 398, Canada – 501, other countries – 5.) 3% 4% 6% 6% 8% 12% 17% 2% 7% 9% 19% 19% 18% 51% 72% 58% 71% 59% 48% 51% 17% 12% 20% 9% 9% 11% 9% 29% 9% 8% 4% 5% 9% 5% -40% -20% 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% Airport is approximately 15 minutes drive from primary attractions in the Niagara, Canada region Airport is located on the Canadian side of the Canada/US border Small size of airport (less busy, but limited services) Passengers may need to walk across the tarmac between the terminal building and the plane (no passenger boarding bridges) Limited selection of flights (e g 1 or 2 flights per day) Round-trip airfare to YCM may be $50-$75 higher than airfare to other airports in the region (e g Buffalo, Toronto, etc ) Flights might be on 20-70 seat turboprop (propeller) planes Greatly decreases my interest in using YCM Slightly decreases my interest in using YCM No impact on my interest in using YCM Slightly increases my interest in using YCM Greatly increases my interest in using YCM -
Likelihood of Flying to YCM from/through Selected Ci5es on
a Future Trip to Niagara Page 12 Source: RRC Associates survey of TPN database, April 2013. Base: US residents living more than 5 hour drive from Niagara (n=98) Likelihood of using flight from YCM to City Newark Chicago Washington DC Boston 0 - Not at all likely 66% 69% 70% 72% Unlikely (1 - 4) 9% 7% 8% 10% Possibly (5, 6) 12% 11% 15% 10% Somewhat likely (7, 8) 7% 6% 5% 2% Very likely (9, 10 - extremely likely) 5% 6% 2% 5% Total 100% 100% 100% 100% % Very/somewhat likely (7 to 10) 12% 13% 7% 7% -
Likelihood of Flying to YCM from/through Selected Ci5es on
a Future Trip to Niagara: Page 13 Source: RRC Associates survey of TPN database, April 2013. Base: US residents very likely to fly* on future trip to Niagara (n=18) *9 or 10 on 0-10 likelihood scale Note: Caution required due to small sample size Likelihood of using flight from YCM to City Newark Chicago Washington DC Boston 0 - Not at all likely 50% 76% 59% 53% Unlikely (1 - 4) 6% 6% 6% 18% Possibly (5, 6) 11% 12% 18% 18% Somewhat likely (7, 8) 22% 6% 12% 6% Very likely (9, 10 - extremely likely) 11% 0% 6% 6% Total 100% 100% 100% 100% % Very/somewhat likely (7 to 10) 33% 6% 18% 12% -
YCM Market Analysis: Outline • Evaluate potenAal for flights
between YCM and US airports: 1. IdenAfy overall size of exisAng flight market 2. Evaluate YCM capture rates required for flights to break even 3. Evaluate interest by exisAng Niagara visitors/ prospects in YCM flights (survey) 4. Evaluate potenAal incremental demand sAmulated by YCM flights (survey) • Evaluate potenAal for flights between YCM and Canadian airports: – (Similar process as for US airports) Page 14 -
Likelihood of Visi5ng Niagara Region More Frequently or
Taking Longer Trips to the Niagara Region if Flights to YCM from Newark/Chicago/DC/Boston Were Available Page 15 Source: RRC Associates survey of TPN database, April 2013. Base: US residents living more than 5 hour drive from Niagara (n=98) Likelihood of visiting the Niagara region more frequently Likelihood of taking longer trips to the Niagara region 0 - Not at all likely 49% 49% Unlikely (1 - 4) 12% 10% Possibly (5, 6) 22% 22% Somewhat likely (7, 8) 7% 9% Very likely (9, 10 - extremely likely) 9% 11% Total 100% 100% % Very/somewhat likely (7 to 10) 16% 19% -
Likelihood of Visi5ng Niagara Region More Frequently or
Taking Longer Trips to the Niagara Region if Flights to YCM from Newark/Chicago/DC/Boston Were Available Page 16 Source: RRC Associates survey of TPN database, April 2013. Base: US residents very likely to fly* on future trip to Niagara (n=18) *9 or 10 on 0-10 likelihood scale Note: Caution required due to small sample size Likelihood of visiting the Niagara region more frequently Likelihood of taking longer trips to the Niagara region 0 - Not at all likely 22% 24% Unlikely (1 - 4) 6% 6% Possibly (5, 6) 22% 24% Somewhat likely (7, 8) 28% 24% Very likely (9, 10 - extremely likely) 22% 24% Total 100% 100% % Very/somewhat likely (7 to 10) 50% 47% -
YCM Market Demand Analysis: for US Airports Summary
Page 17 • ExisAng visitor flight market between Niagara and US is large (430K spring/summer) • YCM would likely need to capture ~5% of exisAng visitor flight market to break even – (Depending on plane size, frequency, fares, and carrier opportunity costs) – A lower break-‐even of 2.5% would be viable if YCM captures a proporAonate share of Canadian resident market at BUF/IGA • TPN database survey suggests that 5%+ capture rate of US resident visitor flight market is reasonable at target US airports • New York City is the best target airport – Preeminent market for exisAng US flights from BUF and Toronto – Preeminent desAnaAon for overseas visitors to US (33% share) – Largest visitor market beyond a 5 hour drive of Niagara (27% of TPN database; Philadelphia next at 9%) • Chicago a possible secondary YCM target; Washington DC third • A significant share of flight volume to YCM could be incremental -
YCM Market Analysis: Outline • Evaluate potenAal for flights
between YCM and US airports: 1. IdenAfy overall size of exisAng flight market 2. Evaluate YCM capture rates required for flights to break even 3. Evaluate interest by exisAng Niagara visitors/ prospects in YCM flights (survey) 4. Evaluate potenAal incremental demand sAmulated by YCM flights (survey) • Evaluate potenAal for flights between YCM and Canadian airports: – (Similar process as for US airports) Page 18 -
Number of Person-‐Trips by Canadian Residents to Niagara Region:
2007-‐11 Average for Apr-‐Sep Period Small size of exis+ng domes+c Canadian flight market to Niagara suggests low current poten+al for YCM flights to Montreal, OQawa & Toronto Billy Bishop. Thus, YCM Canadian airport analysis has not been pursued further. Page 19 Total visitor-trips Flew as part of trip Person-Trips to Niagara Region - by Province: (Apr - Sep) (Apr - Sep) Newfoundland and Labrador 500 500 >100% Prince Edward Island 500 500 >100% Nova Scotia 2,300 1,300 >100% New Brunswick 3,800 1,200 >100% Quebec 73,100 0 >100% Subtotal: Quebec & east 80,200 3,500 >100% Ontario 3,468,400 5,000 >100% Manitoba 3,200 2,600 >100% Saskatchewan 1,600 1,400 >100% Alberta 9,600 7,100 >100% British Columbia 9,100 6,800 >100% Subtotal: Manitoba and West 23,500 17,900 >100% Canadian residents total 3,572,000 26,500 71% Person-Trips to Niagara Region - Selected CMAs: Montreal 38,100 0 >100% Ottawa-Gatineau 45,200 500 >100% Toronto 1,839,200 1,300 >100% Capture of existing air pax req'd for YCM to achieve 18,900 pax Source: Statistics Canada Travel Survey of Residents of Canada 2007-11. All computations, use and interpretation of these data are entirely that of RRC Associates. -
Niagara Tourism Industry’s Capacity to Support YCM Flight Service
• Industry representaAves expressed high confidence in area’s capacity to support YCM flight service: – Strong belief in diversity and quality of tourism product (Falls and other draws), ability to provide ground transportaAon services, and ability of industry players to work together – Strong interest and support for air service, parAcularly to New York City & in peak season (concern about off-‐season) – Some concern expressed about ensuring that YCM faciliAes are up to visitor expectaAons prior to flight iniAaAon – Some expressed need for support for airport/air service at upper governmental levels – Some expressed need for an individual person or commiHee to champion air service to ensure it occurs Page 20 -
THANK YOU Niagara District Airport (YCM): Analysis of Potential Market
Demand for Commercial Flight Service Tourism Partnership of Niagara – Annual MeeAng Americana Resort May 1, 2013 -
Primary YCM target air market: Beyond 5 hour drive
5me Page 22 Source: ESRI; RRC Associates. -
Size of Exis+ng Niagara Flight Market To/From US Airports
SUPPORTING DETAIL Page 23 • US/Overseas flight market from US to BUF/ Toronto inferred from: 1. Niagara Falls US: US Visitor Survey 2. StaAsAcs Canada US Traveler Survey 3. StaAsAcs Canada Overseas Traveler Survey 4. Buffalo/Niagara Airport enplanement paHerns (incorporaAng both US & overseas visitors) • Canadian resident leakage to Buffalo-‐area airports: data from Canadian Airports Council • SupporAng data from each source is provided in the slides to follow -
Size of Exis+ng Niagara Flight Market To/From US Airports
SUPPORTING DETAIL Visitors extrapola5on method #2 (Stats Canada US Traveler Survey): Likely 268,000+ US Resident Person-‐Trips to Niagara Canada via Air Page 24 Source: Statistics Canada Travel Survey of Residents of Canada 2007-11. All computations, use and interpretation of these data are entirely that of RRC Associates. 2007-11 Avg Annual US Person-Trips 3,177,000 Total Average Annual Person-Trips to Niagara by US Residents, 2007-11 DEFINITELY FLEW EN ROUTE TO NIAGARA: 132,600 Entered Canada via Toronto airports (Pearson and City Center) 2,800 Entered Canada via other Canadian airports 135,400 Total flew to Canadian airport LIKELY FLEW EN ROUTE TO NIAGARA: 111,600 Entered Canada via rental car via Niagara crossings (Port Erie, Rainbow, Whirlpool, Queenston) 19,200 Entered Canada via rental car via Windsor and Sarnia 2,600 Entered Canada via rental car via other crossing 133,400 Total entered Canada via rental car 268,800 Total definitely or likely flew en route to Niagara SOME PORTION POSSIBLY FLEW EN ROUTE TO NIAGARA: 1,726,900 Same day automobile 1,075,300 Private automobile 79,800 Bus 19,000 Other 4,200 Train 2,905,200 Total -
Size of Exis+ng Niagara Flight Market To/From US Airports
SUPPORTING DETAIL Visitors extrapola5on method #3 (Stats Canada Overseas Traveler Survey): Likely 145,700 Overseas Resident Person-‐Trips to Niagara Canada that are candidates for YCM service Page 25 Source: Statistics Canada International Travel Survey 2007-11. All computations, use and interpretation of these data are entirely that of RRC Associates. Overseas Visitors to Niagara: 2007-11 Average Annual Person-Trips Route used to Route used to ENTER Canada EXIT Canada Direct from overseas: 564,700 646,700 - Flew to Toronto 458,100 521,200 - Flew to Montreal* 35,400 65,900 - Flew to Ottawa* 3,500 1,700 - Flew to Vancouver 46,400 39,500 - Other port 21,300 18,500 Via the US: 204,800 122,800 - Flew to Toronto** 98,000 43,000 - Flew to Montreal* 3,900 5,200 - Flew to Ottawa* 100 1,100 - On land: Niagara ports (Erie, Rainbow, etc.)** 47,700 58,100 - Other 55,000 15,300 Total overseas person-visits to Niagara region 769,500 769,500 *Possible candidates for YCM flights from Canadian airports **Possible candidates for YCM flights from US airports -
Size of Exis+ng Niagara Flight Market To/From US Airports
SUPPORTING DETAIL Extrapola5on method #4 (cont’d): Analysis of BUF enplanements Est. approx. 300,000 – 400,000 inbound tourist fliers to BUF annually (Inclusive of US and overseas travelers) Page 26 Source: US Department of Transportation, including Origin and Destination Survey; Aviation DataMiner; RRC Associates. 2011 passengers inbound to BUF (originating at other airports) 2011 Q1 baseline Quarter vs. Q1 baseline Quarter 1 (Jan - Mar) 181,000 181,000 0 Quarter 2 (Apr - Jun) 282,000 181,000 101,000 Quarter 3 (Jul - Sep) 341,000 181,000 160,000 Quarter 4 (Oct - Dec) 257,000 181,000 76,000 Total 1,061,000 724,000 337,000 <-- BUF incremental seasonal inbound enplanements (Rough indicator of tourist flight traffic) -
Size of Exis+ng Niagara Flight Market To/From US Airports
SUPPORTING DETAIL Canadian Resident Leakage to BUF & IAG Page 27 • Causes of Canadian resident leakage to US: – Price-‐driven: base fare & taxes/fees/charges; strength of Canadian dollar vs. US – Low-‐cost carriers at US border airports – Aggressive markeAng and airport improvements by US border airports & airlines – (Anecdotal, in Niagara region: Toronto InternaAonal Airport issues: high parking costs, long lines & immigraAon processing Ame, traffic congesAon on roads) Annual enplanements attributable to Canadians Share of total airport enplanements attributable to Canadians BUF 837,500 33% IAG (Niagara Falls Int'l) 67,500 85% Total 905,000 35% Source: "Why are Canadians Driving to US Airports? The Issue for Canada," March 20, 2012, Canadian Airports Council, Leakage Working Group Air Policy Committee. Note: BUF was cited as deriving a similar 36% of its passengers from Canada in 2009, per "An ominous flight pattern: Canadians opting for US airports," The Globe and Mail, Nov. 26, 2010. -
Size of Exis+ng Niagara Flight Market SUPPORTING DETAIL
Niagara US: 23% of US Overnight Visitors Fly (2008) Page 28 US resident overnight person-trips to Niagara, Canada: (If assume same air usage as Niagara Falls USA) 1,241,000 US resident overnight visitor person-trips to Niagara, Canada (2010 - Statistics Canada) 23% Travel by commercial air (if same as Niagara Falls, USA; per 2008 - Longwoods) 285,000 Approx. US resident overnight person-trips to Niagara CA by commercial air - if same share as Niagara US Note: Estimates exclude overseas visitors. Note: In 2010, there were an additional 1,850,400 same-day person trips to Niagara, Canada by US residents. Some portion (likely smaller) of these same-day US visitors likely flew to region as well. Note: 2002 DK Shifflet Top Line Travel Profile for Niagara Falls, US, found 20% of US visitors flew - similar to 23% Longwoods 2008 finding.