Upgrade to Pro — share decks privately, control downloads, hide ads and more …

Site Migrations for News Publishers

Site Migrations for News Publishers

Slides from my talk at the 2024 News and Editorial SEO Summit where I dove into site migrations for news publishers, looking at different types of migrations and their risks and best practices.

Barry Adams

March 04, 2025
Tweet

More Decks by Barry Adams

Other Decks in Marketing & SEO

Transcript

  1. Starter Reading Material • Official Google Doc: https://developers.google.com/search/docs/crawling-indexing/site-move-with-url-changes • Great

    Migration Guides: https://seranking.com/blog/site-migration/ https://seosly.com/blog/seo-migration-checklist/ https://www.wix.com/seo/learn/resource/site-migrations-fundamentals
  2. I Identify Four Types of Migrations 1. Redesign; ➢ Changes

    in the front-end design and code 2. Restructure; ➢ Changes in site navigation and internal linking 3. Replatforming; ➢ New CMS – often accompanied by types 1 & 2 4. Relaunch; ➢ Domain/Hostname change
  3. Change = Risk • Every change on a site represents

    a potential risk; ➢ Minimise changes to minimise risk • But what about improvements? ➢ This is where good understanding of SEO comes in ➢ Not every ‘improvement’ is an actual improvement -Example: Changing a URL to make it ‘optimised’ for SEO ▪ Changing URLs is almost always unnecessary ▪ Changing a URL is, in fact, an SEO risk
  4. Preparation Do this for EVERY migration: • Spec out existing

    SEO functionality; ➢ Be as detailed and granular as possible ➢ NEVER assume a function will exist in the new design ➢ Make sure these SEO specs are part of the requirements • Crawl the current site; ➢ Gather all relevant SEO attributes (titles, descriptions, headlines, links, etc.) • Export top 1000 best performing URLs from GSC; ➢ If you have API access, export it all • Download all existing XML sitemaps • Use a secure staging environment to test the new site before launch
  5. 1. Redesign • Purpose: ➢ Update the front-end design of

    the website -And ONLY the design ➢ No change in URLs, CMS, navigation, hostname, etc. • Usually the easiest type of migration; ➢ But there are still risks…
  6. 1. Redesign - Risks • Website effect: ➢ Front-end code

    changes • Which carries the following risks: ➢ SEO tags aren’t migrated across; - Missing NewsArticle SD, incorrect Open Graph tags, wrong canonicals, etc… ➢ Functional aspects are changed in a non-optimal way; - Pagination becomes JS-powered, structured data is loaded with CSR, recommended article / trending article blocks are changed, etc… • Compare Live crawl to Staging crawl; ➢ Focus on on-page SEO signals ➢ Export crawls to Excel for 1-to-1 comparisons
  7. 2. Restructure • Purpose: ➢ Change of site architecture, internal

    linking, and/or topic focus ➢ Often combined with a Redesign • Usually doesn’t involve a change in CMS or hostname; ➢ Can sometimes involve URL changes
  8. 2. Restructure - Risks • Same risks as Redesign, plus:

    ➢ Altered flow of link value through the website - Different crawl paths for Googlebot; - Different link values for your pages ➢ Changed URLs; - Loss of ranking value (even through a redirect) ➢ Change in topic authority; - Due to perceived changes in your most important sections & topics • Compare Live crawl to Staging crawl; ➢ Focus on URLs, crawl depth, and link scores
  9. 3. Replatforming • Purpose: ➢ Change / update the CMS

    ➢ Usually enables functionality, performance, security • Can involve multiple changes: ➢ Front-end design and code ➢ Site structure and internal linking ➢ Article and topic page URLs
  10. 3. Replatforming - Risks • Same as Redesign & Restructure,

    plus: ➢ URLs could change; - 1-to-1 redirects for all old to new URLs ➢ Technical SEO can be heavily impacted; - Check every SEO aspect of the new platform ➢ Performance and Core Web Vitals; - New CMS isn’t always better - Feature bloat can make a platform slow - Test every page type thoroughly
  11. Old Example: Propertynews.com • Detailed migration plan; ➢ Every aspect

    mapped out and planned ➢ However… none of it was executed.
  12. 4. Relaunch • Purpose: ➢ Change the site’s (sub)domain ➢

    Rebrand, audience growth, different market fit • Ideally done in isolation; ➢ Combining this with other migration types is high risk
  13. 4. Relaunch - Risks • Google News & Top Stories

    inclusion; ➢ This is based on the hostname ➢ Changing (sub)domain means losing inclusion • Topic Authority is (probably) hostname-specific; ➢ Changing hostname = rebuilding topic authority • Redirects do not pass full link value; ➢ Some value is lost, reflected in rankings • Communicate the dangers to key stakeholders; ➢ For a web-focused business, risks may outweigh rewards
  14. TheTimes.co.uk >> TheTimes.com • Hostname change; ➢ Google News inclusion

    at risk ➢ Mitigated with Publisher Center settings • Minimal other changes; ➢ Design, structure, CMS – all unchanged ➢ Decreases risk significantly ➢ Allows for very rapid rollback
  15. Combined Migrations • Redesign + Restructure + Replatforming + Relaunch;

    ➢ Every change adds complexity ➢ Every change adds risk • Try to isolate each element; ➢ Give it time to bed in - 10-12 weeks ➢ Then roll out the next (set of) change(s) • What about ‘ripping off the band aid’? ➢ Speeds up the process ➢ Potential for more short-term pain ➢ But potential for quicker recovery and long-term growth
  16. Site Mergers Two or more websites combine into one •

    Example: Multiple ccTLDs merge into one gTLD • Example: Two similar news publishers merge into a new website with a unified brand • Example: A separate brand is acquired and joins a pre- existing news brand
  17. Site Mergers: Risks and Rewards • Risks: ➢ Mismatch in

    topic authority ➢ Global audience gain, local audience loss ➢ Authority signals lost in redirects ➢ Incomplete content migration (due to overlap) • Rewards: ➢ Combined authority signals ➢ Broader content appeal & visibility ➢ Economies of scale
  18. Site Separations Site section splits off to a separate website

    • Example: UK-news section on a gTLD news site becomes its own .co.uk website • Example: The ‘AI’ section of a financial publisher becomes its own brand and website
  19. Site Separations: Risks and Rewards • Risks: ➢ New site

    lacks authority signals ➢ No brand awareness, low CTR ➢ Google News inclusion can take a long time • Rewards: ➢ Stronger topic authority ➢ Better search intent match ➢ Diversified online presence
  20. Site Migration Pro Tips 1/2 • Use a good SEO

    crawling tool; ➢ Compare old & new crawls ➢ Tech SEO checks on templates; - Homepage, Sections, Tags, Articles, etc ➢ Compare internal link graphs; - Visual crawl maps & key pages’ link values • Save pre-migration page templates; ➢ Raw HTML + rendered DOM ➢ Allows for effective comparisons to new templates • Replatforming & Relaunch: Decrease domain name’s DNS TTL value; ➢ Enables faster propagation of hosting changes • Use Server Logs to identify key pages; ➢ Googlebot crawl activity = SEO value
  21. Site Migration Pro Tips 2/2 • Use XML Sitemaps; ➢

    Submit XML sitemaps in GSC with old URLs that redirect ➢ Monitor redirect uptake & indexing levels in GSC • AI-powered Redirect Mapping: https://searchengineland.com/site-migrations-ai-powered-redirect-mapping-437793 • Redirects can be deleted after 6 months; ➢ Ranking signals will be consolidated on the new URLs ➢ Exception: URLs with a lot of incoming links; - Keep redirects in place indefinitely ➢ Avoid chained redirects; - Update old redirects from previous migrations • Optimise for fast crawling; ➢ Google will temporarily increase crawl rate
  22. The Keys to a Successful Migration • Prepare; ➢ Spec

    out every detail ➢ Don’t make any assumption • Minimise the amount of changes in one go; ➢ Plan for rollbacks • URLs are sacred; ➢ 301 redirects are not the default solution, they are the last resort
  23. Barry Adams ➢ Dutchman in Northern Ireland ➢ Active in

    SEO since 1998 ➢ Specialised in SEO for News Publishers since 2010 ➢ Newsletter: SEOforGoogleNews.com ➢ Co-founder of the News & Editorial SEO Summit
  24. Need help with your site migration? Get in touch: barry@polemicdigital.com

    https://www.linkedin.com/in/barryadams/ https://www.SEOforGoogleNews.com/