Upgrade to Pro
— share decks privately, control downloads, hide ads and more …
Speaker Deck
Sign up for free
Menu
Search
Features
All features
Private URLs
Password Protection
Custom URLS
Scheduled publishing
Remove Branding
Restrict embedding
Deck Collections
Notes
Features
All features
Private URLs
Password Protection
Custom URLS
Scheduled publishing
Remove Branding
Restrict embedding
Deck Collections
Notes
Explore
Featured decks
Featured speakers
Programming
Technology
Storyboards
Explore
Featured decks
Featured speakers
Programming
Technology
Storyboards
Pricing
Search
Sign in
Sign up for free
Penetration Testing is Stupid - BsidesSF 2013
Search
Brett Hardin
February 25, 2013
Technology
2.3k
2
Share
Embed
Copy iframe code
Copy JS code
Copy link
Start on current slide
Penetration Testing is Stupid - BsidesSF 2013
Brett Hardin
February 25, 2013
Transcript
113 slides
Penetration Testing is stupid
Brett Hardin @miscsecurity
None
None
pentesters
Why Who Where When What PENETRATION TESTING Why Who Where
When What
Why Who Where When What PENETRATION TESTING What
Audience Participation Educated Guess?
A live test of the effectiveness of security defenses through
mimicking the actions of real-life attackers. ISACA
test security defenses
mimicking real-life attackers
MIMIC THE REAL
Gunter Ollmann of Damballa on Real Attacks
Submit CV 2000
USB Keys 2005 2000
Buy the machine 2009+ 2005 2000
Penetration tests are unique
Penetration testers are friendly
Penetration tests don’t simulate attacks
Why Who Where When What PENETRATION TESTING Who
The Average Penetration tester
performed by
Jack Nicholson
I’M A PROFESSIONAL TRUST ME.
I’LL TRY ‘PASSWORD’
I’LL TRY ‘PA55WORD’
LET ME IN. PLEASE.
YOU WILL LET ME IN.
WE’RE FRIENDS
WHY CAN’T I GET IN?
LOOK, A WAY IN.
THEY WERE SO DUMB
I’M GONNA REDRUM HIM
pentesters
The average penetration tester
The average are common
The average are necessary
The average are cheap
The average are simple to copy
The average follow methodologies
The best penetration testers
The best are rare
The best invent new attacks
The best are expensive
The best are overkill
The best mimic the real
The average mimic tools
MIMIC THE REAL
MIMIC THE REAL
Why Who Where When What PENETRATION TESTING When
ATTACKS happen when you’re asleep
ATTACKS happen when you’re on vacation
ATTACKS happen when you have no budget
ATTACKS happen when during business hours
ATTACKS happen when you are not ready
ATTACKS happen when you are ready PENTESTS
Date&Time&Resources
None
Attackers aren’t limited by resources
MIMIC THE REAL
MIMIC THE REAL
Why Who Where When What PENETRATION TESTING Where
Rules of Engagement
Internet
Web Application only
On-site
Dialup
The Wi-fi’s
‘puters
News Flash
Attackers don’t care
Limits
Attackers aren’t limited by resources previously learned
Attackers aren’t limited by resources Revision
Attackers aren’t limited
Phone
MIMIC THE REAL
Why Who Where When What PENETRATION TESTING Why
Penetration testing isn’t important
Penetration testing isn’t important to most organizations
Penetration testing doesn’t secure you
Penetration testing tests defenses
required We’ve Convinced Everyone* it’s
TANGENT ALERT
Penetration Testers love to diss vendors
Penetration Testers are vendors
BACK TO YOUR REGULARLY SCHEDULED PROGRAM
Penetration testing proves two things
Penetration testing proves vulnerability One
Penetration testing proves vulnerability adjective One
Penetration testing identifies a few* risky issues Two
Penetration testing identifies a few* risky issues * Actual Results
may vary Two
known and unknown
new exploits aren’t needed
known exploits work
low-hanging fruit
expensive & rare New Exploits
MIMIC THE REAL
When pen testing isn’t stupid
No more defensive ideas
No more low-hanging fruit
Management wants to assess security controls
check&balance
Why Who Where When What < Attackers are unique
Why Who Where When What < Different attack methods
Why Who Where When What < Unlimited by time
Why Who Where When What No Rules of Engagement <
Why Who Where When What < Doesn’t protect you
Penetration Tests don’t mimic real attacks summary
Penetration Tests don’t secure you summary
Penetration Tests test your defenses summary
Thanks.
Brett Hardin http://bretthard.in
More Decks by Brett Hardin
See All by Brett Hardin
Building Your House on Sand
bretthardin
2
1.5k
Bad Version of Builders vs. Breakers
bretthardin
1
100
Builders vs. Breakers - AppSec 2012
bretthardin
2
1.5k
Security the Wrong Way
bretthardin
2
270
BSidesSanFrancisco2011 - Misdirection: The Rise and Fall and Rise of Regulatory Compliance
bretthardin
1
280
Security? Who Cares! - Privacy is Dead
bretthardin
1
220
OWASP - Top 10
bretthardin
0
1.2k
Other Decks in Technology
See All in Technology
農家は秘伝のタレを知らない - NOBODY KNOWS THE HIDDEN SOURCE - Kaggriculture 3rd Place Solution
masspeaks
2
530
人の努力に頼らないセキュリティをエンジニアリングする在り方 / An approach to engineering security that does not rely on human effort
carta_engineering
0
220
マネジメントされる側の仕事は「文句」を言うこと
riyaamemiya
7
5.8k
自動計装なしでECSサービスをApplication Signalsに載せるまで
ota1022
2
390
Agent Routerで作るマルチテナント 推論基盤 #CNDW2026 / Building Multi-Tenant Inference Platform with Agent Router #CNDW2026
everpeace
3
250
高品質と高スピードを支える品質のシフトレフトのアプローチ
goyoki
4
1.6k
契約書SaaSにAIエージェントを組み込む
sansantech
PRO
0
190
CloudTrail を推したい
kazzpapa3
1
140
設計手法を「道具」として使いこなすために
a_suenami
4
740
Frontier Teams — Amazon は AI で「開発のやり方」をどう変えたのか
kmotohas
0
300
re:Inventを楽しむために、 1日1つ「これが楽しみ」を決めよう
beli68
0
120
Agent Harnessはどう作る?事例から学ぶAI Agentの設計思想
sergicalsix
0
350
Featured
See All Featured
The World Runs on Bad Software
bkeepers
PRO
72
12k
How to Ace a Technical Interview
jacobian
280
24k
世界の人気アプリ100個を分析して見えたペイウォール設計の心得
akihiro_kokubo
PRO
74
43k
Agile Actions for Facilitating Distributed Teams - ADO2019
mkilby
0
340
From Legacy to Launchpad: Building Startup-Ready Communities
dugsong
0
380
Navigating Weather and Climate Data
rabernat
0
590
GraphQLとの向き合い方2022年版
quramy
50
15k
It's Worth the Effort
3n
188
29k
A brief & incomplete history of UX Design for the World Wide Web: 1989–2019
jct
2
570
Easily Structure & Communicate Ideas using Wireframe
afnizarnur
194
17k
The State of eCommerce SEO: How to Win in Today's Products SERPs - #SEOweek
aleyda
2
12k
For a Future-Friendly Web
brad_frost
184
11k