Share
Embed
Recent Work on the Lowest-Mass White Dwarfs
Colloquium, 45 min. November 2014: Keele University, Keele, UK.
jjhermes
November 19, 2014
Transcript
47 slides
-
Motivation and Outline • Extremely Low-Mass (ELM, <0.3 M¤ )
White Dwarfs (WDs) – Set Galactic gravitational wave foreground – eLISA verification binaries – Progenitors of Galactic exotica: merged WDs and subdwarfs, AM CVn systems, -
• WDs: Burnt-out cores of all low-mass stars initially <8-10
M¤ • WDs are the endpoints of stellar evolution – Their progenitors lost considerable mass White Dwarfs, the Quantum Dots -
Kleinman et al. 2013, ApJS, 204, 5 • All WDs
discussed today have pure hydrogen atmospheres (DA) – 4/5 of WDs are DA; strong gravitational settling • Estimate WD masses from observed Balmer line profiles: Teff /log(g) He-Core WDs CO-Core WDs ONe-Core WDs Mass Distribution of Known White Dwarfs -
• The Galaxy is not old enough for a single
star to evolve into a -
Latest ELM Survey release: Brown et al. 2013, ApJ, 769,
66 • ELM Survey: u-g, g-r color selection from Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS) • Discovery spectroscopy from -
• ELM Survey: SDSS u-g, g-r color selection • Discovery
spectroscopy from -
Discovery spectroscopy determines the binary and atmospheric parameters blue-shifted red-shifted
Brown et al. 2012, ApJ, 744, 142 T eff = 10,540 ± 170 K log(g) = 6.01 ± 0.06 P orb = 87.996 ± 0.006 min K 1 = 508 ± 4 km s-‐‑1 M 2 > 1.10 M¤ if M 1 = 0.17 M¤ t merge < 170 Myr J1741+6526: An 88-min WD+WD binary -
Asin(φ) = 0.50 ± 0.08 % Doppler beaming Acos(2φ) =
1.30 ± 0.08 % Ellipsoidal variations J1741+6526: An 88-min WD+WD binary • Follow-up photometry yields further physical constraints -
• Doppler beaming: Radiation is beamed toward our line of
sight, proportional to how fast the source is moving (V): • (Also a small factor for the -
• Ellipsoidal variations: Changing projected area of a tidally distorted
star • Tidal bulge rotates once per orbit – We see its oblique (fat) side -
J0751-0141: A New Eclipsing WD+WD Binary Kilic et al. 2014,
MNRAS, 438, L26 P orb = 115.22 min 3.2% rel. amplitude -
Yellow: Our eight new tidally distorted ELM WDs Black: Eclipsing
WD+WD binaries Pink: Eclipsing -
Some Open Questions Regarding ELM WDs – CNO flashing episodes and
HR-diagram loops – Hydrogen-layer masses in He-core WDs – The ubiquity of metals in the lowest-gravity WDs – Tidal torques on binary inspiral -
ELM WDs and Predicted CNO Flashes Althaus et al. 2013,
A&A, 557, A19 • Two low-mass WDs of different masses often cross the same points in a T eff —log(g) diagram • There is a non-uniqueness to using T eff ,log(g) for ELM WD mass -
ELM WDs and Predicted CNO Flashes Althaus et al. 2013,
A&A, 557, A19 • For example, take a 10,000 K, log(g) = 6.60 WD: -
Some Open Questions Regarding ELM WDs – CNO flashing episodes and
HR-diagram loops – Hydrogen-layer masses in He-core WDs – The ubiquity of metals in the lowest-gravity WDs – Tidal torques on binary inspiral -
Discovery of Pulsations in Low-Mass WDs Hermes et al. 2012,
ApJ, 750, L28 Hermes et al. 2013, ApJ, 765, 102 Hermes et al. 2013, MNRAS, 436, 3573 Kilic et al. 2015, MNRAS, 446, 26 • CNO flashes erode the hydrogen layer mass of ELM WDs • An observational test would come from pulsating WDs: asteroseismology • Since October 2011 we discovered the first five pulsating low-mass, -
Pulsating Hydrogen-Atmosphere (DA) WDs • Global g-mode pulsations driven by
a hydrogen partial ionization zone -
G117-B15A: A 0.59 M¤ Pulsating CO-Core WD • Stable pulsating
WD • dP/dt ~ 4 x 10-15 s s-1 • Main pulsation modes: – P1 = 215.2 s – P2 = 304.1 s – P3 = 270.5 s • Can multiply the star’s frequencies by 300,000 to convert to audible range: Kepler et al. 2005, ApJ, 634, 1311 target comparison -
J1614+1912: A 0.20 M¤ Pulsating ELM WD • The pulsating
ELM WD with the shortest-period variability • Main pulsation modes: – P1 = 1262.7 s – P2 = 1184.1 s • Scaling frequencies by 300,000 to an audible range: Hermes et al. 2013, MNRAS, 436, 3573 target comparison -
J2228+3623: A 0.16 M¤ Pulsating ELM WD • The pulsating
ELM WD with the longest-period variability • Main pulsation modes: – P1 = 4181 s – P2 = 3252 s – P3 = 6229 s • Scaling frequencies by 300,000 to an audible range: target comparison Hermes et al. 2013, MNRAS, 436, 3573 -
J1112+1117: A 0.17 M¤ Pulsating ELM WD Hermes et al.
2013, ApJ, 765, 102 • Main pulsation modes: – P1 = 2258.5 s – P2 = 2539.7 s – P3 = 1884.6 s – P4 = 2855.7 s – P5 = 1792.9 s • Scaling frequencies by 300,000 to an audible range: target comparison -
Full Seismology Will Reveal ELM WD Structure • We are
currently only able to qualitatively match the periods to WD models • Near to having a large grid of He-core WD models with different hydrogen layer masses to perform asteroseismology Van Grootel et al. 2013, ApJ, 762, 57 MH /M* = 10-4 MH /M* = 10-2 J1840 J1518 J1518 J1112 Theoretical periods for ell=1 g-modes modes vs. Observed Periods -
Some Open Questions Regarding ELM WDs – CNO flashing episodes and
HR-diagram loops – Hydrogen-layer masses in He-core WDs – The ubiquity of metals in the lowest-gravity WDs – Tidal torques on binary inspiral -
• Roughly 1 in every 2-3 WDs we find has
some metal pollution • Metals should settle out of the high-surface-gravity atmosphere very quickly (of order days) • Consensus: Metals are from accreted, tidally disrupted debris • Abundances match bulk -
• Ca II lines phase with the ~288 km/s RV
of the Balmer lines – Metals are photospheric, not interstellar • We obtained an HST/COS -
• This ELM WD is carbon deficient, just like planetary
debris • BUT: Oxygen abundance inconsistent with rocky accretion: -
GALEX J1717: A 5.9-hr, Metal-Rich He-WD+WD R 1 = 0.093
± 0.013 R¤ i = 86.9 ± 0.4 deg P orb = 5.90724895(41) hr -‐‑20 v rot = 50+30 km s-‐‑1 P rot = 2.3+2.0 hr Hermes et al. 2014, MNRAS, 444, 1674 • Prot < Porb but not yet formally significant • Direct test of tidal synchronization! -‐‑1.0 -
Some Open Questions Regarding ELM WDs – CNO flashing episodes and
HR-diagram loops – Hydrogen-layer masses in He-core WDs – The ubiquity of metals in the lowest-gravity WDs – Tidal torques on binary inspiral -
phase = 0 • We detected eclipses in April 2011
• This is the most compact detached binary system currently known! J0651+2844: A 12.75-min WD+WD Binary Brown et al. 2011, ApJ, 737, L23 -
J0651+2844: A 12.75-min WD+WD Binary Average distance between the Earth
and the Moon: 384,400 km -
(from Phase 0 to Phase 1 is 12.75 minutes) Hermes
et al. 2012, ApJ, 757, L21 P orb = 765.20644(95) s K 1 = 616.9 ± 5.0 km s-‐‑1 i = 86.3 ± 1.0 deg T eff,1 = 16,340 ± 260 K M 1 = 0.252 ± 0.04 M¤ T eff,2 = 10,370 ± 360 K M 2 = 0.50 ± 0.04 M¤ J0651+2844: A 12.75-min WD+WD Binary -
Orbital Decay in J0651+2844 After just 13 months we confirmed
orbital decay from gravitational radiation. Hermes et al. 2012, ApJ, 757, L21 -
We expect dPorb /dt = (-0.26 ± 0.05) ms/yr and
observe (-0.2834 ± 0.0039) ms/yr! – a 1.4% measurement! Orbital Decay in J0651+2844 -
• This 12.75-min WD+WD binary is decaying > 3.5 times
faster than the 7.75-hr Hulse-Taylor binary pulsar, which was the first indirect detection of gravitational radiation (1993 Nobel prize in physics) Weisberg et al. 2010, ApJ, 722, 1030 J0651+2844 PSR B1913+16 dP/dt = -0.283 ms/yr dP/dt = -0.076 ms/yr Orbital Decay in J0651+2844 -
• Gravity bends space; it effectively determines geometry of space
• General Relativity: Any mass in nonuniform, nonspherical motion emits gravitational radiation • Ripples in space-time caused by gravitational radiation carry away energy • This is an energy leak and acts -
• Tidal torques should increase the rate of orbital decay
in J0651+2844 – Additional angular momentum is lost from the orbit to spin-up the WDs to remain synchronized, leading to >5% faster rate of orbital decay (e.g., Piro 2011, ApJ, 740, L53; Fuller & Lai 2012, MNRAS, 421, 426) The Fate of the WDs in J0651+2844 -
Conclusions • Extremely Low-Mass (ELM, <0.3 M¤ ) White Dwarfs
(WDs) constrain the endpoints of stellar and binary evolution • “Low-Mass White Dwarfs Need Friends” – Close companions provide many ways to observationally constrain systems • Pulsations allow us a new way to explore He-Core, ELM WD Interiors • ELM WDs provide a unique test for tidal effects on binary inspiral • The first directly detected gravitational waves and confirmed EM counterpart systems will likely be ELM WDs D. Berry, GSFC!