Share
Embed
Around the World in 80 Pull Requests: Open Source Through the Eyes of a Maintainer
Marco Belladelli
June 03, 2026
Transcript
51 slides
-
About Me Marco Belladelli • Software Developer @ IBM •
Hibernate maintainer, ORM team • Quarkus and LangChain4j contributor • OSS Advocate • Commonhaus Foundation member This activity is not sponsored or approved by IBM. All those involved are voluntarily engaging in their individual capacities and not in their IBM roles. -
What does “open source” mean? Source code that anyone can
see, modify, and distribute -
• Freedom 0: Freedom to run the program • Freedom
1: Freedom to study and modify the program • Freedom 2: Freedom to redistribute copies of the program • Freedom 3: Freedom to distribute modi f ied copies of the program -
L’esplosione • 1991: Linus Torvalds publishes the Linux Kernel with
GPLv2 • 1993: Debian • 1995: Apache HTTP Server • 1996: MySQL Linux e gli anni ‘90 -
Mainstream • 1998: The term "open source" is coined •
2008: GitHub is born, o ff ering collaboration on a global scale • 2010s: Kubernetes, Docker, React, TensorFlow Open Source per tutti -
Short story • 2001: Gavin King creates Hibernate (alternative to
EJB2 entity beans) • 2006: JPA spec 1.0, Hibernate becomes the reference implementation • Oggi: Hibernate ORM 7, Search Reactive, Validator How the Hibernate family was born -
Open Source Foundations Commonhaus Foundation Apache Software Foundation Linux Foundation
Cloud Native Computing Foundation -
For the project • Bug reports from millions of users
(large-scale free QA) • Contributions from background and di ff erent use cases • Trust and transparency: "read the code" OSS Bene f its -
For the ecosystem • Shared infrastructure, less duplication of e
ff orts • Interoperability and standards • Linus' law: "with enough eyes, all bugs are super f icial" OSS Bene f its -
For the developers • Low entry threshold: there is always
a need for contributions • Building a portfolio, reputation • Career opportunities • Continuous learning OSS Bene f its -
Contributing != Writing Code There are a thousand ways to
get started • Bug reports • Forum, Stack Over f low, Chat • Guides, blog posts, tutorials • Mentoring and education • Documentation • Presentations • Testing pre-release -
Models with corporate backing • Open Core: Free base +
paid enterprise functionality (GitLab, Elastic) • SaaS / hosted: Sell the service, not the code (MongoDB Atlas, Redis Cloud) • Supporto e consulenza: RedHat / IBM (Hibernate, JBoss EAP, Quarkus, Liberty) • Dual licensing: MySQL / MariaDB (Oracle), Qt -
The role of the maintainer It's not just code •
Triaging issues • Documentation • Community management • Release engineering • CVE response • Backward compatibility • Often unpaid • Done in free time • -> Burnout -
Jackson • “Marshalling”: JSON, XML, YAML, CBOR, Smile, Avro, CSV,
Properties, ecc. • 25M+ monthly downloads • Websites, services, Android apps JSON for Java -
Day in the life Of a Hibernate Maintainer • PR
from every time zone, every continent • Di ff erent languages, di ff erent cultures, di ff erent levels • The art of saying "no" with kindness and "yes" with attention • The human element -
The hardships • PRs that do not follow the guidelines
• Discussions with community members • "Fixes" that cause even more problems • Con f licts of code and opinion • Pretentious users (and customers) • The eternal list of things to do • The few resources available -
The human side • True relationships that transcend national borders
• Mentoring and learning • Responsibility for individual decisions • Work-life balance Behind a big project -
XZ Utils • Compression library included in most Linux distributions
• Maintained by a single person: Lasse Collin • Low tra ff ic repository, small community (~10 people on IRC) • OpenSSH dependency xz / liblzma https://tukaani.org/xz/ -
Social Engineering • Ott 2021: "Jia Tan" sends the f
irst contribution (an .editorcon f ig f ile) • 2022: "community" begins to put pressure on Lasse Collin • Jia Tan positions himself as the reliable and available co- maintainer • Years of patient, constant, genuine contributions Building a relationship of trust -
The backdoor • Feb 2024: 8 malicious commits • CVE-2024-3094,
CVSS scre: 10.0 (max) • Hidden in binary f iles (tarball used in tests) • Objective: OpenSSH • The stakes: a universal key to enter all machines with SSH xz 5.6.0 e 5.6.1 -
The lesson Open Source needs us • Maintainers without adequate
resources are not only impacted personally — they put everyone's safety at risk • The OpenSSF and the OpenJS Foundation warned: this may not be an isolated case • Similar social engineering attempts detected on JavaScript projects • This is the risk you run when the critical infrastructure depends on unpaid and unsupported work -
The new reality • GitHub Copilot, ChatGPT, Claude, … •
Lower threshold for "writing code" • Poor average quality • Total number of PRs is growing Of the OSS world -
Maintainer Pressure • More reviews, often on low- quality code
• Large amount of code, more di ff icult to understand • Missing feedback loop with human on the other side • Signal/noise ratio worsens The responsibility -
AI is a tool that greatly ampli f ies our
potential, for better or for worse -
Positive side • AI can also help maintainers: triage, testing,
documentation, review • Lower access barrier for new contributors • Powerful collaboration and learning tool Great power Great responsibility Open questions • Who is the real “author” of these contributions? • More e ff icient maintainers, or higher workload? • Will the quality of the code of large projects be guaranteed? -
The general picture • Open Source is global collaboration •
Based on trust, on the reliability of people • On which the whole world of software depends -
What can we do • As users and companies: Financing
the projects we depend on • As developers: starting to contribute • As maintainers: sustaining a rich and hospitable environment