Share
Embed
How to read a vendor's cloud comparison
Eight questions to ask of any cloud-vs-cloud page, applied to Cloudish's own docs — including the two our pages get wrong (the price math and the datacenter count). Written by the Cloudish team at Hal9.
Sigrid
November 06, 2026
Transcript
12 slides
-
CLOUDISH · A HAL9 PROJECT How to read a vendor’s
cloud comparison Eight questions to ask of any host-vs-host page — applied to our own, including the two our pages get wrong. Checked against cloudish.ai docs, 4 Nov 2026 1 / 12 -
WHY THIS DECK We wrote the comparison. Read it like
we’d read it. We just published “Fly.io or Cloudish?” — a vendor comparing itself to a rival. That is exactly the page you should be most skeptical of. So we ran our own method — eight questions — against our own docs. Two of the eight, our pages fail. We show both, and why it matters. The comparison is at medium.com/@sigrid_11381 — read it with the eight questions below 2 / 12 -
QUESTION 1 OF 8 Who wrote it, and who pays
them? What to look for A real name behind the page, not just a brand. Cloudish Comparisons say “we build Cloudish”, and the benchmark is “run by Cloudish”. But the agent docs (llms.txt) never name the company — Hal9 — behind the brand. Mostly disclosed · gap: no Hal9 in the docs 3 / 12 -
QUESTION 2 OF 8 When were the numbers checked? What
to look for A date next to every price, because prices move. Cloudish SKILL.md is dated (last updated 1 Nov 2026); the changelog dates every change. But the price table (instances.md) has no “as of” date on any figure. Partly · dates on docs, not on each price 4 / 12 -
QUESTION 3 OF 8 Does the headline price multiply to
the monthly price? What to look for $/hour × 730 should equal $/month. Cloudish instances.md lists “shared” at $0.0107 / hour and $7.84 / month. But $0.0107 × 730 = $7.81, not $7.84. The two columns come from different rounding. Inconsistent · our own table disagrees with itself 5 / 12 -
QUESTION 4 OF 8 What happens when nobody visits? What
to look for Does it sleep? After how long? How fast does it wake? Cloudish Sleeps after sleepAfterMinutes — default 15, range 1 to 1440. Wakes “in seconds” — the docs never say how many. Mostly clear · “in seconds” has no number 6 / 12 -
QUESTION 5 OF 8 Where does the data live, and
what deletes it? What to look for Is the disk kept? Does it survive sleep and redeploy? Cloudish Volume is kept and not billed; it survives sleep, redeploy and zero balance. But it is deleted with the project — delete the app, and the data is gone. Clear, once you read the fine print 7 / 12 -
QUESTION 6 OF 8 Can it run with no human
in the loop? What to look for Sign-up, a card, and a hard cap on spending. Cloudish One call mints a key — no signup, no browser, no card. Prepaid and capped at the balance; new keys get 0.1 credits, “subject to availability”. Yes · one hedge in the fine print 8 / 12 -
QUESTION 7 OF 8 How many datacenters, and where? What
to look for A region list, and a number that doesn’t shift. Cloudish SKILL.md §8: “the ‘do’ datacenter … planning expansion” — one. Changelog: URLs on do and anton, plus “a datacenter with a GPU” — more than one. Our Fly.io comparison said “New York”; the docs name no city. Inconsistent · one page says one, another implies several 9 / 12 -
QUESTION 8 OF 8 Managed database, or bring your own?
What to look for Who operates the database, and what does that cost? Cloudish “No managed Postgres/MySQL offering” — stated plainly. SQLite on a volume, or run Postgres in your own container — and operate it. Clear · and it means you operate it 10 / 12 -
KEEP THIS The eight questions — a checklist 1 Who
wrote it, and who pays them? 5 Where does the data live, and what deletes it? 2 Is every number dated? 6 Can it run with no human? 3 Do the prices multiply? 7 How many datacenters, and where? 4 What happens when nobody visits? 8 Managed database, or your own? Run this against any cloud page you’re about to trust 11 / 12 -
THE POINT Read ours the way you’d read theirs. Our
pages failed two of the eight — the price math and the datacenter count. We left both up, and linked them here, because a comparison that hides its rough edges isn’t a comparison. Ask the eight questions of any cloud page you’re about to trust. Cloudish — cloudish.ai/?ref=cc-s3a2 · Hal9 — hal9.com 12 / 12