Share
Embed
Slaying 2FA
Reviewing security postures and attacks on various 2FA (2-factor authentication) means, including security keys and passkeys. (OWASP Saitama MTG #27, talk #1)
Takahiro Yoshimura
August 26, 2025
Transcript
44 slides
-
SLAYING 2FA OWASP SAITAMA MTG #27, TALK #1 “LEVIATHAN” by
Tman, CC BY-NC-SA 2.0 -
TEXT SESSION FLAGS ▸ ըɾԻɾެ։: OK "Gay Traffic Lights" by
Nico Kaiser, CC BY 2.0 -
TEXT BACKGROUND ▸ ͜ͷ͝Ζʹͳͬͯূ݊ձࣾͷޱ࠲͕ୣऔ͞ΕΔ ࣄҊ͕ଓग़ →2FA͕ޮ͍͍ͯΔʹ͔͔ΘΒͣ… →ۚ༥ி͔Β2FAΛݪଇېࢭ͢͠ͱͷ௨ୡ ▸ ͳʹ͕͋ͬͨͷͩΖ͏͔ʁ 2FAΛېࢭͯ͠ͳʹΛೖΕΔͱ͍͏ͷͩΖ͏͔ʁ
“Leviathans glide, Graceful giants of the sea, Whale songs fill the depths.” by Nick Kenrick, CC BY-NC-SA 2.0 -
TEXT WHO I AM ▸ Takahiro Yoshimura (@alterakey) https://keybase.io/alterakey ▸
Monolith Works Inc. Co-founder, CTO Security researcher ▸ ໌࣏େֶαΠόʔηΩϡϦςΟݚڀॴ ٬һݚڀһ (ʙ3݄) -
TEXT WHAT I DO ▸ Security research and development ▸
iOS/Android Apps →Financial, Games, IoT related, etc. (>200) →trueseeing: Non-decompiling Android Application Vulnerability Scanner [2017] ▸ Windows/Mac/Web/HTML5 Apps →POS, RAD tools etc. ▸ Network/Web penetration testing →PCI-DSS etc. ▸ Search engine reconnaissance (aka. Google Hacking) ▸ Whitebox testing ▸ Forensic analysis -
TEXT WHAT I DO ▸ CTF ▸ Enemy10, Sutegoma2 ▸
METI CTFCJ 2012 Qual.: Won ▸ METI CTFCJ 2012: 3rd ▸ DEF CON 21 CTF: 6th ▸ DEF CON 22 OpenCTF: 4th ▸ ൃදɾߨԋͳͲ DEF CON 25 Demo Labs (2017) DEF CON 27 AI Village (2019) CODE BLUE (2017, 2019) CYDEF (2020) etc. “DEFCON 2016” by Wiyre Media, CC BY 2.0 -
TEXT WHAT'S 2FA? ▸ 2 Factor Authentication →2ཁૉೝূ ▸ ҎԼ͔Β#1Ҏ֎ʹ1ͭΛཁٻ͢Δೝূͷ͜ͱ
▸ #1: what you know →password / passphrase ▸ #2: what you have →ܭࢉೳྗػࡐͳͲʢ←TOTP, SMS etc.ʣ ▸ #3: what you are →ੜମͷಛʢ←ࢦ, ࠼, إ, etc.ʣ “M&S Bank 2FA output” by Orde Saunders, CC BY 2.0 -
TEXT 2 STEPS? NO, YOU DON'T HAVE TO BE ▸
ͪͳΈʹ2 StepͰ͋Δඞཁͳ͍ ▸ ྑࠞ͘ಉ͞ΕΔ͕֓೦తʹผ ▸ ಉ࣌ʹཁٻͯ͠ྑ͍ ▸ ٯʹಉ͡factorΛෳஈʹ͚ͯཁٻͨ͠ͱ͜ΖͰɺ໘ʹ ͳΔ͚ͩͰڧ্ঢ͠ͳ͍ ▸ શମͷڧweakest link →e.g. Googleͷphone/emailิ… →࣮࣭తʹύεϫʔυ͕ӳ4ʙ6ܻఔʹʢOSINTՄʣ →རศੑ༏ઌͷͨΊͩΖ͏͕ࡶͳҹ “2FA-2017” by EFF Photos, CC BY 2.0 -
TEXT RECAP ON THE FLOW OF 2FA ▸ ϩάΠϯϑΥʔϜ ▸
ϢʔβID / ύεϫʔυΛೖྗ ʢ˞֬ೝࣦഊ࣌ʹऴྃ͢Δ͜ͱ͕ଟ͍ʣ ▸ τʔΫϯͷΛೖྗ ▸ ϩάΠϯཱ “Spiffy Little Login Form PSD” by Zack Smith, CC BY 2.0 -
TEXT RECAP ON THE FLOW OF 2FA ▸ Ϣʔβ໊ͱύεϫʔυ [factor
#1] ▸ τʔΫϯͷॴ༗ [factor #2] ▸ OTP (One Time Password) →҉߸ֶతʹڧྗͳํ๏Ͱܭࢉ͞Ε͍ࣺͨͯ ͷύεϫʔυΛੜͰ͖Δ͜ͱͰॴ༗Λ֬ೝ (※TOTP: Time-based OTP͕ओྲྀ) ▸ SMSೝূ: ੜͨ͠OTP͋Δ͍ཚΛ֬ೝ͢ Δ͜ͱͰॴ༗Λ֬ೝ “Wells Fargo 2FA RSA Token - Two Factor Authentication - Six Digit Code” by Tony Webster, CC BY 2.0 -
TEXT RECAP ON THE FLOW OF 2FA ▸ τʔΫϯҰछͷchallenge-responseೝূ ▸
TOTP: ࣌ࠁ: challenge, OTP: response ▸ SMS: ཚ: challenge/response ▸ ͕ͩ: Ϣʔβ=ਓ͕ؒհ →߈ܸऀ͕डྖͰ͖Εೝূཱ →ʮೝূ൪߸Λڭ͑ͳ͍ͰʂʯͱݴΘΕΔཧ༝ “Writing Up Challenge Responses” by Alan Levine, CC BY 2.0 -
TEXT ATTACK PLAN ▸ جຊతͳ߈ܸํ๏ ▸ ϢʔβID/ύεϫʔυΛͬͯchallengeૹ ▸ responseΛਪఆʢΉ͠Ζୣऔʣ ▸
ϩάΠϯཱ “Building Planning” by Susan Smith, CC BY-NC-ND 2.0 -
TEXT ATTACK #1: PHISH'EM ▸ ϑΟογϯάʹΑΔํ๏ ▸ Ϣʔβ͕ϢʔβID/ύεϫʔυΛೖΕΔ →߈ܸऀཪͰαʔϏεʹதܧ →αʔϏε͕challengeΛૹ
▸ Ϣʔβ͕responseΛೖྗ →߈ܸऀ͕ୣऔ͠αʔϏεʹதܧ ▸ ϩάΠϯཱ →ϢʔβΤϥʔΛฦ͢ ▸ ʮϑΟογϯάʹҙʂʯͷཧ༝ “phishing!” by Monja, CC BY-NC-ND 2.0 -
TEXT ATTACK #1: PHISH'EM ▸ ͦͦϑΟογϯάΛݟഁΔͷͳ͔ͳ͔ ͍͠ →࣮ͷ༰Λྲྀ༻͢Δέʔε͕΄ͱΜͲ ▸ ϢʔβΊΒΕͳ͍
→ϒϥβͷURLόʔͰ…ͱ͔ೖྗ͢Δͳͱ͔ →্͔Βઢͷܒʹͳʹ͔ҙຯ͕͋Δͷ͔ “Phishing Website Screenshot” by Gary Cope, CC BY-NC-ND 2.0 -
TEXT ATTACK #2: ENTICE'EM ▸ ιʔγϟϧΤϯδχΞϦϯάʹΑΔํ๏ ▸ ߈ܸऀ͕ϢʔβID/ύεϫʔυΛೖΕΔ →αʔϏε͕challengeΛૹ ▸
ϢʔβʹresponseΛ࿈ܞͤ͞Δ →߈ܸऀ͕ୣऔ ▸ ϩάΠϯཱ ▸ ʮೝূ൪߸Λڭ͑ͳ͍Ͱʂʯͷཧ༝ “Smooth Talker” by Mark Vaske, CC BY-NC-SA 2.0 -
TEXT ATTACK #2: ENTICE'EM ▸ ڭ͑ͳ͍ͰɺͱݴΘΕͯڭ͑ͳ͍Α͏Ͱιʔ γϟϧΤϯδχΞϦϯά͕Γͳ͍… ▸ ڭ͑ͤ͞Δͷ͕ٕྔ →ҙשىҙຯΛͳ͍ͯ͠ͳ͍
→্͔Βઢͷܒʹͳʹ͔ҙຯ͕͋Δͷ͔ “Smooth Talker” by Mark Vaske, CC BY-NC-SA 2.0 -
TEXT ATTACK #3: FEED'EM UP ▸ ർ࿑ͤ͞Δํ๏ ▸ ߈ܸऀ͕αʔϏε܁Γฦ͠ΞΫηε →challengeΛૹ
▸ Ϣʔβ͕responseΛ͍ͣΕฦ͢ ▸ ϩάΠϯཱ “Fatigue” by Patrick Bouchard, CC BY-NC-ND 2.0 -
TEXT ATTACK #3: FEED'EM UP ▸ 2FA fatigue߈ܸ ▸ ೣḏࢠ2FA…ͷ݁Ռ
→Ϣʔβͷҙࢥ֬ೝʹͯ͠͠·͏έʔε ʢ…Google Promptʁ Githubʁʣ ▸ ϢʔβΛർΕͤ͞Ε௨Δ… →ଟ͗͢Δܹແࢹ͞ΕΔ →ҙͷϑΟϧλ -
TEXT ATTACK #4: PEEK'EM ▸ ౪ௌ (SIM swapping etc.) ▸
߈ܸऀ͕ਖ਼نαΠτʹΞΫηε →challengeΛૹɾडྖ ▸ ߈ܸऀ͕responseΛૹ ▸ ϩάΠϯཱ “Coral pendant” by Sheila Sund, CC BY 2.0 -
TEXT ATTACK #4: PEEK'EM ▸ ͱ͍ͬͯSIM swappingͳΜͯ… ▸ ࢸۃଥͳݒ೦ ▸
࣮ࡍຊͰগͳ͍ →ܞଳిෆਖ਼ར༻ࢭ๏ͷ͓͔͛ͩΖ͏͔ ▸ ͔ͳΓevident: ΒΕΔͱ͔Δ →͍͖ͳΓ௨͡ͳ͘ͳΔ “SIM card macro” by Pedro Vera, CC BY-NC-ND 2.0 -
TEXT ATTACK #4: PEEK'EM ▸ ͕ͩ͜ΕͳΒͲ͏ͩΖ͏ ▸ SMSͷୣऔ (Android) →
READ_PHONE_STATE/READ_SMS ▸ Auto fi llͷ༠Ҿ (※1): →android:auto fi llHints:"smsOTPCode" →TextField.textContentType(.oneTimeCode) →autocomplete="one-time-code" ▸ ※1: iOS 26: ใݯΛݱঢ়iMessage/Apple Mailͷ Έ͔Β3rd party apps (GmailͳͲ) ʹ֦ு༧ఆ -
TEXT ATTACK #4: PEEK'EM ▸ SMS͕དྷͨॠؒʹɺ͋Δ͍λοϓ͞ΕͨॠؒʹϦ ϨʔՄೳ ▸ ಛʹin-app browserʹѱҙ͕͋ͬͨ߹ʹphishingͷ
ඞཁ͢Βͳ͍͜ͱʹҙ →in-app browserଆͰDOMͷஔ͖͑ϑοΫ͕Ͱ͖ ΔͨΊ ▸ ྫ͑: ෆਖ਼ΞϓϦʹΑΔ௨ˠࣗͰਖ਼ͳURLΛ։͔ͤͯ DOMΛॻ͖͑ˠλοϓΛ༠ಋͯ͠code͚ͩୣऔͳͲ “gotcha !” by Timothy Valentine, CC BY-NC-SA 2.0 -
TEXT ERRARE HUMANUM EST. ▸ ਓ͕ؒհ͍ͯ͠Δ͜ͱ͕ ▸ ೝೳྗͷݶք: ݟؒҧ͏ɺ۠ผͰ͖ͳ͍ ▸
ҙྗͷݶք: ർΕΔɺ͏͔ͬΓૢ࡞͢Δ ▸ அྗͷݶք: ڴ͞ΕΔɺὃ͞ΕΔ ▸ ୭͕࣋ͭಛੑ; ΊΒΕΔ͖ͷͰͳ͍ “Humans Are Stupid” by Cat Branchman, CC BY 2.0 -
TEXT ALL OF YOU NEED TO BE PRESENT HERE ▸
ڑΛऔΕΔ͜ͱ͕ →͍ͬͯΔਓؒͱ͍࣋ͬͯΔਓؒΕ͍ͯͯ ྑ͍ͷ͔…ʁ ▸ ྑ͘ͳ͍ →ೝূର͕ࣗવਓͰ͋ΔҎ্ ▸ 2FAՃ֬ೝͰͳ͘ೝূཁૉ (factor) ͩ… →2ஈ֊ೝূͱҧ͏ຊ࣭తͳཧ༝ →શͯͷೝূཁૉଋറ͞Ε͍ͯΔ͖ (←ॏཁ) “Call me” by Jim Nix, CC BY-NC-SA 2.0 -
TEXT SECURITY KEYS: 2FA DONE RIGHT ▸ Security keys (U2F/WebAuthn)
▸ USB/NFCͰଓͯ͠ػೳ (※Bluetoothଓͷͷ͔ͭͯ͋ͬͨ) ▸ ެ։伴҉߸ܥͰೝূओମͱσόΠεͷਖ਼ੑ Λ૬ޓೝূ →࣮࣭తͳfactor #2ͱͯ͠ػೳ (U2F=Universal 2nd Factor [FIDO Alliance]) “Yubikey USB 2FA U2F Security Token” by Tony Webster, CC BY 2.0 -
TEXT PASSKEYS: LOOK MA, NO PASSWORDS! ▸ ύεΩʔ (Passkeys) ▸
ύεϫʔυʹΘΔͷͱͯ͠৮Ε͜·ΕΔ… ▸ ެ։伴҉߸ܥʹΑΔೝূͳͷͰ҆શ ▸ ੜମೝূͰϩάΠϯͰ͖ΔͷͰ҆શ ▸ ύεϫʔυΛΘͳ͍ͷͰ҆શ etc. “Vintage Keys...” by Heartlover1717, CC BY-NC-ND 4.0 -
TEXT PASSKEYS: HENCE, UNBREAKABLE? ▸ ύεΩʔ (Passkeys) ▸ ύεϫʔυʹΘΔͷͱͯ͠৮Ε͜·ΕΔ… ▸
ެ։伴҉߸ܥʹΑΔೝূͳͷͰ҆શ →͏ʔΜ…ͳʹ͕Ͳ͏҆શͳΜͩ… ▸ ੜମೝূͰϩάΠϯͰ͖ΔͷͰ҆શ →͏ʔΜ…ͦΕ࣮ͷͩ… ▸ ύεϫʔυΛΘͳ͍ͷͰ҆શ etc. →͏ʔΜ…ࣗಈతʹ҆શʹͳΔΘ͚Ͱ… “Contraseña / Password” by Microsiervos, CC BY 2.0 -
TEXT PASSKEYS: GHOST OF PASSWORDS? ▸ ύεϫʔυʹΘΔͷͱͯ͠৮Ε͜·ΕΔ… →·͔ͣ͜͜Βҧ͏ ▸ 2FAchallenge-responseೝূ
▸ ͜ΕΛਖ਼͘͠Ζ͏ͱ͍͏ͷ͕త →Կ͕͔ͩͬͨʁ →ਓؒͷհࡏͱඇଋറੑ “Password-less logins via IndieAuth with a #pebble watch! Blog post coming soon” by Aaron Parecki, CC BY 2.0 -
TEXT PASSKEYS STITCH TIMESPACE ▸ passkeyσόΠεೝূ [factor #2] ▸ ެ։伴ೝূͳͷ͕ͩɺೝূओମ͝ͱॺ໊͢Δ
ͱͱʹೖྗओମͱͷڑଋറ͍ͯ͠Δ ▸ Local keystore (※2) ͋Δ͍BLE (iOS/Android※3) (cf. Security Keys: USB/NFC) “signature” by Chris Clark, CC BY-NC 2.0 -
TEXT PASSKEYS ARE SECURITY KEYS ▸ Security Keysͱ΄΅ಉͷΞϓϩʔν ▸ WebAuthn:
U2Fͷ্Ґޓ [FIDO2] webauthn.guide -
TEXT ... WITH THEIR SHARE OF WEAKNESSES ▸ ※2: ͷηΩϡϦςΟ͕ΘΕΔ
▸ ※3: ѱҙ͋Δτϯωϧ͕ηογϣϯΛऔͰ͖Δ ͜ͱʹҙ (CVE-2024-9956) [1] ▸ KEXͰͳ͘୯ͳΔॺ໊֬ೝͰ͋ΔͨΊ ▸ ͕ͩ…ͳͥτϯωϧͳͲΛೖΕͨͷ͔ ʢauthenticatorʹΛར༻Ͱ͖ΔΑ͏ʹ͢ ͘ɺQRίʔυΛར༻͢ΔͨΊ͕ͩ… ͕ͩ…ʣ “Gettysburg Address: fountain pen handwriting practice” by Stephen Little, CC BY-NC 2.0 -
TEXT .. AND ARE FAIRLY SECURE ▸ Security KeysʹൺΔͱ1ϥϯΫԼ…͕૬ (cf.
AppleͳͲͷऔΓѻ͍) ▸ Bluetooth FIDOσόΠεͲ͏ͳ͔ͬͨʁ →iOS/AndroidʹΑΔauthenticatorͱՁ →ͪ͜Βʹٵऩ͞Εͯ͠·ͬͨՄೳੑ “Gettysburg Address: fountain pen handwriting practice” by Stephen Little, CC BY-NC 2.0 -
TEXT TAKEAWAYS ▸ 2FA: 2ཁૉೝূ (2ஈ֊Ͱͳ͍) →શͯͷೝূཁૉଋറ͞Ε͍ͯΔ͖ →challenge-responseೝূ ▸ OTP/SMSͳͲਓؒͷதܧ͕લఏ
(ʹඇଋറత) →ͷຊ࣭; SMSSIM swappingͳ͠Ͱ… ▸ Security Keys/Passkeys2FAΛਖ਼͘͠Δͷ →ର·ͱΊͯॺ໊; ೝূཁૉଋറ →SK: USB/NFC+HSM, PK: BLE+Local KS →΄΅ಉ͡ͷ͕ͩSKʹ·ͩҰͷ͕͋Δ “Writing Up Challenge Responses” by Alan Levine, CC BY 2.0 -
TEXT TAKEAWAYS ▸ Passkeysvirtual security key… ▸ ssh for web:
→࡞༻ػংࣅ͍ͯΔ͕ҧ͏ ▸ password manager with biometric auth →શ͘ҧ͏ “Pointing at button” by Steve wilson, CC BY 2.0 -
TEXT WHERE TO STORE? ▸ OTP, Passkeyͱʹൿີ͕͋Δ ▸ ύεϫʔυϚωʔδϟ͕ѻͬͯྑ͍ͷ͔… “Linux
password file” by Christiaan Colen, CC BY-SA 2.0 -
TEXT OTP SEEDS ARE PASSWORDS ▸ OTPੜ: ͞΄Ͳେ͖ͳͳ͍ͱߟ͑Δ ▸ ੜ伴ग़ͯ͜ͳ͍
▸ DBେE2EEతʹ҉߸Խ͞Ε͍ͯΔ ʢ˞͞Ε͍ͯͳ͔ͬͨΒͦΕͦΕͰʣ ▸ 2FAઐ༻ΞϓϦͷ༻ͱେࠩͳ͍ͷͰ “M&S Bank 2FA output” by Orde Saunders, CC BY 2.0 -
TEXT PASSKEYS ARE PRIVATE KEYS ▸ Passkey: Ίͨ΄͏͕ྑ͍ ▸ ͦΕͳΓͷdynamism͕͋Δ
(e.g. authenticator୳ࡧ [CTAP]) ▸ Ωʔͷॏཁ͕͔ͳΓҧ͏ ▸ ϓϥοτϑΥʔϜʹ͓͍ͤͯͨ΄͏͕ྑ͍ “Private keys” by Laszlo Gyarmati, CC BY-NC-SA 2.0 -
TEXT MAY YOU HAVE PASSKEYS WITH YOURSELF ▸ Passkey: Ͱ͖ΕLocal
keystoreͷ΄͏͕… ▸ ͳͥʁྫ͑ѱҙ͋Δϖʔδ͕CTAP 2.2 transaction initiating URI ( fi do:/) Λِ͠ɺѱ ҙ͋Δτϯωϧϔredirect͢Δ͜ͱͰηογϣϯ ΛऔՄೳͳ (ઌͷ˞3; CVE-2024-9956) [1] ▸ ରࡦ: fi do:/ Λϒϥβ͔Β։͚ͳͨ͘͠ ͜ΕͰdoneͱ͞Ε͍ͯΔ͕… “keys” by plenty.r., CC BY-SA 2.0 -
TEXT .. INTO VERY YOURSELF ▸ …ͦΕͰेશͳͷ͔ʁ ▸ ߈ܸऀ͕ѱҙͷ͋ΔQRίʔυΛషͬͨΒʁ (※CTAP
2.2: epochͷنఆ͕optional) ▸ τϯωϧͷਖ਼ੑ୲อʹؔ͢Δنఆ͕ͳ͍ →Ephemeral Keysͷ༻ͳͲ͕ඞཁͳͷͰ →͘͠epochΛඞਢʹ͢ΔͳͲ “Yahoo! delivers amazing new experiences via Android and HTML5” by Yahoo, CC BY 2.0 -
TEXT REFERENCES ▸ [1] "CVE-2024-9956 - PassKey Account Takeover in
All Mobile Browsers", Tobia Righi, February 2025. https://mastersplinter.work/research/passkey/ “look at alll the papers!” by Sara Grajeda, CC BY-NC-SA 2.0