Share
Embed
Transcript
64 slides
-
The Stellar Ultrasound M.Cantiello (Kavli Institute for Theoretical Physics) J.Fuller,
D. Stello, L. Bildsten, R. A. Garcia, T. Bedding, D. Huber, V. Silva Aguirre -
Exciting times for Stellar Physics ! Transient surveys unraveling unpredicted
variety of explosive stellar deaths (PTF, Pan-STARRS and soon LSST). We do not understand SN progenitors ! Exoplanetary science requires precise characterization of host stars properties ! We are entering the era of high precision stellar physics (Kepler, K2, GAIA, TESS, PLATO). Theory is lagging behind Motivation -
How to probe the deep stellar interiors? “It would seem
that the deep interiors of the Sun and stars is less accessible to investigation than any other region of the Universe” Sir Eddington, 1926 ! Rotation ! Magnetic Fields Motivation -
Asteroseismology now allows to probe the deep interiors of stars
and measure properties like radial differential rotation and internal magnetic fields! ! Rotation ! Magnetic Fields Take Away Message € ω -
Range of rotational velocity Fukuda 1982 “In practice all stars
are rotating around their axis” - Maeder & Meynet -
P ( VEq sin i ) P ( VEq )
334 B Stars Dufton et al. 2013 Early type stars in 30 Doradus VLT-FLAMES Tarantula Survey -
Long GRB Central Engine Collapsar Woosley 1993 Eacc ~ 0.01..1Msunc2~1052..54ergs
Q: What sets the rotation rate of stellar cores? -
(Spitkovski 2006) Erot ~ 3 1052 (P/ms)-2 (R/10km)2 ergs Millisecond
Magnetar Usov 1992 Long GRB Central Engine Q: Strong B-fields: Where do they come from? -
Final j-distribution 1D Stellar evolution calculations SN: no accretion disk
during collapse / no rapidly rotating NS GRB (?): enough angular momentum in the core to make an accretion disk during collapse / create a rapidly rotating NS -
! Hydrodynamics instabilities ! Rotationally induced circulations ! Magnetic torques
! Internal gravity waves Angular Momentum Transport Different classes of mechanisms have been proposed: e.g. Rogers et al. 2013 e.g Maeder & Meynet 2002 e.g. Spruit 2002 e.g. Heger et al. 2000 Convective Regions usually assumed rigidly rotating -
! Dynamical Shear Hydrodynamic Instabilities Dynamical shear instability occurs when
the energy that can be gained from the shear flow becomes comparable to the work that has to be done against the gravitational potential for the adiabatic turnover of a mass element -
The thermal flux through the surface of a (radiative) rotating
star is proportional to the local effective gravity. Since this depends on the co-latitude, one expects a greater radiative flux at the poles than at the equator. Rotationally Induced Circulations Convective Core € ω Von Zeipel (1924) Von Zeipel Theorem -
Interferometry of rotating stars Altair (A7IV-V Star): confirms Von Zeipel
‘gravity darkening’ even if with a slightly different exponent -
! Eddington-Sweet Circulation ! Is a meridional circulation mixing the
stellar interior ! Mixing process on tKH τES ∝τKH ωK ω ⎛ ⎝ ⎜ ⎞ ⎠ ⎟ 2 Rotationally Induced Circulations Maeder & Meynet 2002 -
! Hydrodynamics instabilities ! Rotationally induced circulations ! Magnetic torques
! Internal gravity waves Angular Momentum Transport Different classes of mechanisms have been proposed: e.g. Rogers et al. 2013 e.g Maeder & Meynet 2002 e.g. Spruit 2002 e.g. Heger et al. 2000 -
Tayler-Spruit Dynamo ! Dynamo in a radiative layer ! Magnetic
energy is generated from differential rotation ! Initially a seed magnetic field is stretched by the differential rotation, amplifying the toroidal component of the field ! An instability in the toroidal component of the field (Tayler instability) is used to close the dynamo loop Spruit 2002 Toroidal Poloidal -
! Tayler-Spruit Dynamo (Spruit 2002) ! Core - Envelope coupling
1.Differential rotation winds up toroidal component of B 2.Magnetic torques tend to restore rigid rotation Core If the envelope slows down angular momentum is also removed from the core Tayler-Spruit Dynamo -
! Hydrodynamics instabilities ! Rotationally induced circulations ! Magnetic torques
! Internal gravity waves Angular Momentum Transport Different classes of mechanisms have been proposed: e.g. Rogers et al. 2013 e.g Maeder & Meynet 2002 e.g. Spruit 2002 e.g. Heger et al. 2000 ! Rogers et al. 2013 ! Charbonnel & Talon 2005 ! Alvan et al. 2014 ! Fuller, MC et al. 2015 ! Fuller, Lecoanet, MC et al. 2014 -
Internal Gravity Waves Alvan et al. 2014 IGW: Excited by
turbulent convection Spectrum: Not well understood. But likely Kolmogorov-like with a steep exponent Dissipation: Radiative dissipation usually dominates in stellar interiors They carry angular momentum See e.g.: Charbonnel & Talon 2005, Goldreich & Kumar 1990, Lecoanet & Quatert 2013, Mathis et al. 2014, Rogers et al. 2013 -
200 400 600 800 ModelNumber 0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8
1.0 1.2 1.4 M/M⊙ 1.5M⊙ , Z=0.02, MESA V. 5118 −1 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 Nueclear Energy generation, Log (erg/g/s) Evolution of a 1.5 MSun Core H-burning Convective Envelope H-Shell burning In Mass Coordinate -
2.96 2.98 3.00 3.02 3.04 3.06 3.08 3.10 3.12 t
×109 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 r/R⊙ 1.5M⊙ , Z=0.02, MESA V. 5118 −1 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 Nueclear Energy generation, Log (erg/g/s) Convective Envelope H-Shell burning In Radius Coordinate Evolution of a 1.5 MSun -
Evolution after H-exhaustion ! A dramatic change in the stellar
structure ! Huge density contrast between core and envelope ! Assuming simple conservation of angular momentum, core spins up, envelope spins down ! As a star evolves past H-exhaustion angular momentum transport mechanisms determine the rotation rate of the core -
Credit: BBSO/NJIT Solar-Like Oscillations n m l ! Turbulent convection
causes stochastic excitation of (non-radial) pulsation ! Solar-like oscillations expected and observed in red giants as well (see e.g. Dupret et al. 2009) -
Space-Based Photometry 27 cm diameter Launched December 2006 CoRoT Kepler
95 cm diameter Launched March 2009 -
evanescent zone g-mode cavity p-mode cavity νmax p-mode cavity (envelope)
g-mode cavity (core) evanescent zone Courtesy: Dennis Stello Mixed Modes N2 -
Mixed Modes p-mode cavity (envelope) g-mode cavity (core) If the
frequencies of the stochastically excited p-modes become comparable to the frequencies of the g-modes, a ‘cross-talk’ between core and envelope is possible (mixed modes). This happens in Red Giant stars due to the increased core density. -
Mixed Modes p-mode cavity (envelope) g-mode cavity (core) Since a
mixed mode lives both as a p-mode (in the envelope) and as a g-mode (in the core), if observed at the surface can give informations about conditions (e.g. rotation rate) in different regions of the star! -
A test for the physics of rotation Beck et al.
2012 Stellar rotation lifts the degeneracy (in the azimuthal order ‘m’) of non radial modes, resulting in a multiplet of (2l+1) frequency peaks in the power spectrum for each mode. Observed splittings ~ 0.2 MicroHz l=1 l=0 -
Evolution of Core Rotation Mosser et al. 2012 Early RGB
H-burning Clump Stars He-burning P~R2 P~R0.7 -
Other possible mechanisms? !Angular momentum transport from IGW during the
Red Giant Phase !Magnetic coupling from fossil or convective dynamo generated magnetic fields Alvan et al. 2014 See also e.g. Charbonnel & Talon (2007) See e.g. Mader & Meynet (2014) -
Internal Gravity Waves Alvan et al. 2014 IGW: Excited by
turbulent convection Spectrum: Not well understood. But likely Kolmogorov-like with a steep exponent Dissipation: Radiative dissipation usually dominates in stellar interiors They carry angular momentum See e.g.: Charbonnel & Talon 2005, Goldreich & Kumar 1990, Lecoanet & Quatert 2013, Mathis et al. 2014, Rogers et al. 2013 -
IGW: Damping Length Zahn et al. (1997) Compositional Gradients inhibit
the propagation Higher Frequency IGW propagate further -
IGW: Wave Decoupling Fuller et al. (2014) Core: Decoupled Core:
Coupled 0.9 1.0 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 2.0 2.5 Consistent with Tayar & Pinsonneault (2013) requiring decoupling of the low mass subgiant star “Otto”(Deheuvels et al. 2012) to occur at a stellar radius 1.5-1.9 RSun -
IGW: Dissipation Length Decoupling of the core occurs due to
3 effects: 1. Evolution timescale decreases from 109 to 107 yr 2. Convection zone deepens, resulting in smaller turnover frequencies (hence smaller frequencies of the IGW) 3. As the core contracts the Brunt-Vasaila frequency N increases by more than an order of magnitude The inner core becomes optically thick to the waves, prohibiting efficient core-envelope coupling (due to IGW) Fuller et al. (2014) -
!Thanks to space-based asteroseismology it is now possible to access
the internal rotational profile of stars other than the Sun !Despite great progress in last few years, the nature of internal mixing of angular momentum is still an unsolved problem Conclusions (I) SLOW FAST Cantiello et al. 2014, Fuller et al. 2014 Credits: R. Townsend -
Stars evolve this direction Depressed Depressed Stello, Cantiello, Fuller et
al. (Nature 2016) Depressed Dipolar Modes -
Stello, Cantiello, Fuller et al. (Nature 2016) Puzzle: Depressed Dipolar
Modes Important fact: l=0 normal, l=1 depressed! Stars evolve this direction -
Core Mode Visibility Not to Scale! In normal red giants
with mixed modes, wave energy that tunnels into the core eventually tunnels back out to produce the observed oscillation mode -
Excitation Damping Convective Envelope p-modes B Alfven Waves Magneto Gravity
Waves Evanescent Region Core For depressed mixed modes let’s assume that all the energy leaking into the g-mode cavity never makes it back to the envelope At equilibrium, damping and excitation rate balance each other (Dupret et al. 2009) -
Excitation Damping Convective Envelope p-modes B Alfven Waves Magneto Gravity
Waves Evanescent Region Core Transmission through the evanescent region Envelope crossing time At equilibrium, damping and excitation rate balance each other (Dupret et al. 2009) -
Convective Envelope p-modes B Alfven Waves Magneto Gravity Waves Evanescent
Region Core One can write the ratio of visibility of suppressed/normal modes as: Envelope crossing Inverse of the envelope damping rate (typical value for RGB ~ 10d) norm e.g. Corsaro et al. 2015 r2 r1 -
Fuller + Cantiello et al. 2015 (Science) Conclusion: Depressed dipoles
explained by a mechanism efficiently trapping wave energy in the core Stars evolve this direction Data: Mosser+2012, Garcia+2014 -
In the presence of strong B-fields, magnetic tension forces can
become comparable to buoyancy Critical Field Strength Lorentz Force ~ Buoyancy Force -
Magnetic Greenhouse Effect Fuller + Cantiello et al. (Science 2015)
Dipolar waves “scattered” to high harmonic degrees l Magnetic fields break spherical symmetry in the core High l waves trapped in the core Reese et al. 2004, Rincon & Rieutord 2003, Lee 2007,2010, Mathis & De Brye 2010,2012 Typical Critical B-field ~ 105 G -
Augustson et al. 2016 ! Convective core dynamos on the
MS: Beq~105 G ! Magnetic field topology is complex ! Flux conservation can easily lead to B~106-107 G on the RG ! Stable magnetic configurations of interlocked poloidal+toroidal fields exist in radiative regions Prendergast 1956, Kamchatnov 1982, Mestel 1984, Braithwaite & Nordlund 2006, Duez et al. 2010 Brun et al. 2005 2Msun -
Stars evolve this direction Stello, MC, JF et al. (Nature
2016) Mass Dependence -
Stello, Cantiello, Fuller et al. (Nature 2016) Fraction of stars
with strong internal B-fields From a sample of 3000+ stars -
Conclusions (II) ! Novel asteroseismic technique allows to reveal the
presence of strong internal magnetic fields in thousand red giants ! Fields of roughly 105 G are very common in the core of intermediate mass stars ! These fields are likely dynamo generated in the star’s convective core during the main sequence Courtesy: Kyle Augustson