Share
Refactoring Ruby with Monads
Monads are in danger of becoming a bit of a joke: for every person who raves about them, there’s another person asking what in the world they are, and a third person writing a confusing tutorial about them. With their technical-sounding name and forbidding reputation, monads can seem like a complex, abstract idea that’s only relevant to mathematicians and Haskell programmers.
Forget all that! In this pragmatic talk we roll up our sleeves and get stuck into refactoring some awkward Ruby code, using the good parts of monads to tackle the problems we encounter along the way. We see how the straightforward design pattern underlying monads can help us to make our code simpler, clearer and more reusable by uncovering its hidden structure, and we all leave with a shared understanding of what monads actually are and why people won’t shut up about them.
Given at eurucamp 2014 (http://2014.eurucamp.org/), BaRuCo 2014 (http://lanyrd.com/2014/baruco/) and GoGaRuCo 2014 (http://lanyrd.com/2014/gogaruco/). The accompanying code is at https://github.com/tomstuart/monads, and an article version is available at https://tomstu.art/refactoring-ruby-with-monads.
Tom Stuart
Transcript
154 slides
-
ArrayStack = Struct.new(:values) do def push(value) ArrayStack.new([value] + values) end
! def top values.first end ! def pop ArrayStack.new(values.drop(1)) end ! def empty? values.empty? end ! def self.empty new([]) end end -
LinkedListStack = Struct.new(:top, :pop) do def push(value) LinkedListStack.new(value, self) end
! # def top # # we get this for free! # end ! # def pop # # and this! # end ! def empty? pop.nil? end ! def self.empty new(nil, nil) end end -
>> stack = ArrayStack.empty => #<struct ArrayStack values=[]> >> stack.push('hello').push('world').pop.top
=> "hello" >> stack = LinkedListStack.empty => #<struct LinkedListStack top=nil, rest=nil> >> stack.push('hello').push('world').pop.top => "hello" -
module Stack def size if empty? 0 else pop.size +
1 end end end ! ArrayStack.include(Stack) LinkedListStack.include(Stack) -
>> ArrayStack.empty.size => 0 >> ArrayStack.empty.push('hello').push('world').size => 2 >> LinkedListStack.empty.size
=> 0 >> LinkedListStack.empty.push('hello').push('world').size => 2 -
#each calls a block with a value zero or more
times in immediate sequence -
class GeneratedCollection def each(&block) number = 1 while number <=
5 block.call(number) number = number + 1 end end end -
>> collection = HardcodedCollection.new => #<HardcodedCollection> >> collection.each { |n|
puts n } 1 2 3 4 5 => nil >> collection = GeneratedCollection.new => #<GeneratedCollection> >> collection.each { |n| puts n } 1 2 3 4 5 => nil -
module Collection def select(&block) results = [] each do |value|
results << value if block.call(value) end results end end ! HardcodedCollection.include(Collection) GeneratedCollection.include(Collection) -
>> HardcodedCollection.new.select { |n| n.odd? } => [1, 3, 5]
! >> GeneratedCollection.new.select { |n| n.odd? } => [1, 3, 5] -
Project = Struct.new(:creator) Person = Struct.new(:address) Address = Struct.new(:country) Country
= Struct.new(:capital) City = Struct.new(:weather) -
>> city = City.new('sunny') => #<struct City …> ! >>
country = Country.new(city) => #<struct Country …> ! >> address = Address.new(country) => #<struct Address …> ! >> person = Person.new(address) => #<struct Person …> ! >> project = Project.new(person) => #<struct Project …> -
>> bad_project = Project.new(Person.new(Address.new(nil))) => #<struct Project …> ! >>
weather_for(bad_project) NoMethodError: undefined method `capital' for nil:NilClass -
def weather_for(project) creator = project.creator address = creator.address country =
address.country capital = country.capital weather = capital.weather end -
def weather_for(project) unless project.nil? creator = project.creator unless creator.nil? address
= creator.address unless address.nil? country = address.country unless country.nil? capital = country.capital unless capital.nil? weather = capital.weather end end end end end end -
def weather_for(project) unless project.nil? creator = project.creator end ! unless
creator.nil? address = creator.address end ! unless address.nil? country = address.country end ! unless country.nil? capital = country.capital end ! unless capital.nil? weather = capital.weather end end -
# activesupport/lib/active_support/core_ext/object/try.rb ! class Object def try(*a, &b) if a.empty?
&& block_given? yield self else public_send(*a, &b) if respond_to?(a.first) end end end ! class NilClass def try(*args) nil end end -
def weather_for(project) unless project.nil? creator = project.creator end ! unless
creator.nil? address = creator.address end ! unless address.nil? country = address.country end ! unless country.nil? capital = country.capital end ! unless capital.nil? weather = capital.weather end end -
def weather_for(project) creator = project.try(:creator) address = creator.try(:address) country =
address.try(:country) capital = country.try(:capital) weather = capital.try(:weather) end -
# activesupport/lib/active_support/core_ext/object/try.rb ! class Object def try(*a, &b) if a.empty?
&& block_given? yield self else public_send(*a, &b) if respond_to?(a.first) end end end ! class NilClass def try(*args) nil end end -
>> optional_string = Optional.new('hello') => #<struct Optional value="hello"> >> optional_string.value
=> "hello" >> optional_string = Optional.new(nil) => #<struct Optional value=nil> >> optional_string.value => nil -
>> optional_string = Optional.new('hello') => #<struct Optional value="hello"> >> length
= optional_string.try(:length) => 5 >> optional_string = Optional.new(nil) => #<struct Optional value=nil> >> length = optional_string.try(:length) => nil -
def weather_for(project) creator = project.try(:creator) address = creator.try(:address) country =
address.try(:country) capital = country.try(:capital) weather = capital.try(:weather) end -
def weather_for(project) optional_project = Optional.new(project) optional_creator = Optional.new(optional_project.try(:creator)) optional_address =
Optional.new(optional_creator.try(:address)) optional_country = Optional.new(optional_address.try(:country)) optional_capital = Optional.new(optional_country.try(:capital)) optional_weather = Optional.new(optional_capital.try(:weather)) weather = optional_weather.value end -
def weather_for(project) optional_project = Optional.new(project) optional_creator = Optional.new(optional_project.try(:creator)) optional_address =
Optional.new(optional_creator.try(:address)) optional_country = Optional.new(optional_address.try(:country)) optional_capital = Optional.new(optional_country.try(:capital)) optional_weather = Optional.new(optional_capital.try(:weather)) weather = optional_weather.value end -
def weather_for(project) optional_project = Optional.new(project) optional_creator = optional_project.try { |project|
Optional.new(project.creator) } optional_address = optional_creator.try { |creator| Optional.new(creator.address) } optional_country = optional_address.try { |address| Optional.new(address.country) } optional_capital = optional_country.try { |country| Optional.new(country.capital) } optional_weather = optional_capital.try { |capital| Optional.new(capital.weather) } weather = optional_weather.value end -
>> weather_for(project) => "sunny" ! >> weather_for(bad_project) NoMethodError: undefined method
`capital' for nil:NilClass -
def weather_for(project) optional_project = Optional.new(project) optional_creator = optional_project.try { |project|
Optional.new(project.creator) } optional_address = optional_creator.try { |creator| Optional.new(creator.address) } optional_country = optional_address.try { |address| Optional.new(address.country) } optional_capital = optional_country.try { |country| Optional.new(country.capital) } optional_weather = optional_capital.try { |capital| Optional.new(capital.weather) } weather = optional_weather.value end -
def weather_for(project) optional_project = Optional.new(project) optional_creator = optional_project.and_then { |project|
Optional.new(project.creator) } optional_address = optional_creator.and_then { |creator| Optional.new(creator.address) } optional_country = optional_address.and_then { |address| Optional.new(address.country) } optional_capital = optional_country.and_then { |country| Optional.new(country.capital) } optional_weather = optional_capital.and_then { |capital| Optional.new(capital.weather) } weather = optional_weather.value end -
def weather_for(project) Optional.new(project). and_then { |project| Optional.new(project.creator) }. and_then {
|creator| Optional.new(creator.address) }. and_then { |address| Optional.new(address.country) }. and_then { |country| Optional.new(country.capital) }. and_then { |capital| Optional.new(capital.weather) }. value end -
def weather_for(project) Optional.new(project). and_then { |project| Optional.new(project.creator) }. and_then {
|creator| Optional.new(creator.address) }. and_then { |address| Optional.new(address.country) }. and_then { |country| Optional.new(country.capital) }. and_then { |capital| Optional.new(capital.weather) }. value end -
Optional = Struct.new(:value) do def and_then(&block) if value.nil? Optional.new(nil) else
block.call(value) end end ! def method_missing(*args, &block) and_then do |value| Optional.new(value.public_send(*args, &block)) end end end -
def words_in(blogs) blogs.flat_map { |blog| blog.categories.flat_map { |category| category.posts.flat_map {
|post| post.comments.flat_map { |comment| comment.split(/\s+/) } } } } end -
blogs = [ Blog.new([ Category.new([ Post.new(['I love cats', 'I love
dogs']), Post.new(['I love mice', 'I love pigs']) ]), Category.new([ Post.new(['I hate cats', 'I hate dogs']), Post.new(['I hate mice', 'I hate pigs']) ]) ]), Blog.new([ Category.new([ Post.new(['Red is better than blue']) ]), Category.new([ Post.new(['Blue is better than red']) ]) ]) ] -
>> words_in(blogs) => ["I", "love", "cats", "I", "love", "dogs", "I",
"love", "mice", "I", "love", "pigs", "I", "hate", "cats", "I", "hate", "dogs", "I", "hate", "mice", "I", "hate", "pigs", "Red", "is", "better", "than", "blue", "Blue", "is", "better", "than", "red"] -
def words_in(blogs) blogs.flat_map { |blog| blog.categories.flat_map { |category| category.posts.flat_map {
|post| post.comments.flat_map { |comment| comment.split(/\s+/) } } } } end -
def words_in(blogs) blogs.flat_map { |blog| blog.categories.flat_map { |category| category.posts.flat_map {
|post| post.comments.flat_map { |comment| comment.split(/\s+/) } } } } end -
def words_in(blogs) Many.new(blogs).and_then do |blog| Many.new(blog.categories).and_then do |category| Many.new(category.posts).and_then do
|post| Many.new(post.comments).and_then do |comment| Many.new(comment.split(/\s+/)) end end end end.values end -
def words_in(blogs) Many.new(blogs).and_then do |blog| Many.new(blog.categories) end.and_then do |category| Many.new(category.posts)
end.and_then do |post| Many.new(post.comments) end.and_then do |comment| Many.new(comment.split(/\s+/)) end.values end -
def words_in(blogs) Many.new(blogs). and_then { |blog | Many.new(blog.categories) }. and_then
{ |category| Many.new(category.posts) }. and_then { |post | Many.new(post.comments) }. and_then { |comment | Many.new(comment.split(/\s+/)) }. values end -
def words_in(blogs) Many.new(blogs). and_then { |blog | Many.new(blog.categories) }. and_then
{ |category| Many.new(category.posts) }. and_then { |post | Many.new(post.comments) }. and_then { |comment | Many.new(comment.split(/\s+/)) }. values end -
Many = Struct.new(:values) do def and_then(&block) Many.new(values.map(&block).flat_map(&:values)) end ! def
method_missing(*args, &block) and_then do |value| Many.new(value.public_send(*args, &block)) end end end -
{ "current_user_url": "https://api.github.com/user", "authorizations_url": "https://api.github.com/authorizations", "emails_url": "https://api.github.com/user/emails", "emojis_url": "https://api.github.com/emojis", "events_url":
"https://api.github.com/events", "feeds_url": "https://api.github.com/feeds", "following_url": "https://api.github.com/user/following{/target}", "gists_url": "https://api.github.com/gists{/gist_id}", "hub_url": "https://api.github.com/hub", "issues_url": "https://api.github.com/issues", "keys_url": "https://api.github.com/user/keys", "notifications_url": "https://api.github.com/notifications", "organization_url": "https://api.github.com/orgs/{org}", "public_gists_url": "https://api.github.com/gists/public", "rate_limit_url": "https://api.github.com/rate_limit", "repository_url": "https://api.github.com/repos/{owner}/{repo}", "starred_url": "https://api.github.com/user/starred{/owner}{/repo}", "starred_gists_url": "https://api.github.com/gists/starred", "team_url": "https://api.github.com/teams", "user_url": "https://api.github.com/users/{user}" } -
def get_json(url, &success) Thread.new do uri = URI.parse(url) json =
Net::HTTP.get(uri) value = JSON.parse(json) success.call(value) end end -
get_json('https://api.github.com/') do |urls| org_url_template = URITemplate.new(urls['organization_url']) org_url = org_url_template.expand(org: 'ruby')
! get_json(org_url) do |org| repos_url = org['repos_url'] ! get_json(repos_url) do |repos| most_popular_repo = repos.max_by { |repo| repo['watchers_count'] } repo_url = most_popular_repo['url'] ! get_json(repo_url) do |repo| contributors_url = repo['contributors_url'] ! get_json(contributors_url) do |users| most_prolific_user = users.max_by { |user| user['contributions'] } user_url = most_prolific_user['url'] ! get_json(user_url) do |user| puts "The most influential Rubyist is #{user['name']} (#{user['login']})" end end end end end end -
Eventually = Struct.new(:block) do def initialize(&block) super(block) end ! def
run(&success) block.call(success) end end -
class Eventually def and_then(&block) Eventually.new do |success| run do |value|
block.call(value).run(&success) end end end end -
get_json('https://api.github.com/') do |urls| org_url_template = URITemplate.new(urls['organization_url']) org_url = org_url_template.expand(org: 'ruby')
! get_json(org_url) do |org| repos_url = org['repos_url'] ! get_json(repos_url) do |repos| most_popular_repo = repos.max_by { |repo| repo['watchers_count'] } repo_url = most_popular_repo['url'] ! get_json(repo_url) do |repo| contributors_url = repo['contributors_url'] ! get_json(contributors_url) do |users| most_prolific_user = users.max_by { |user| user['contributions'] } user_url = most_prolific_user['url'] ! get_json(user_url) do |user| puts "The most influential Rubyist is #{user['name']} (#{user['login']})" end end end end end end -
Eventually.new { |s| get_json('https://api.github.com/', &s) }.and_then do |urls| org_url_template =
URITemplate.new(urls['organization_url']) org_url = org_url_template.expand(org: 'ruby') ! Eventually.new { |s| get_json(org_url, &s) }.and_then do |org| repos_url = org['repos_url'] ! Eventually.new { |s| get_json(repos_url, &s) }.and_then do |repos| most_popular_repo = repos.max_by { |repo| repo['watchers_count'] } repo_url = most_popular_repo['url'] ! Eventually.new { |s| get_json(repo_url, &s) }.and_then do |repo| contributors_url = repo['contributors_url'] ! Eventually.new { |s| get_json(contributors_url, &s) }.and_then do |users| most_prolific_user = users.max_by { |user| user['contributions'] } user_url = most_prolific_user['url'] ! Eventually.new { |s| get_json(user_url, &s) } end end end end end.run do |user| puts "The most influential Rubyist is #{user['name']} (#{user['login']})" end -
Eventually.new { |s| get_json('https://api.github.com/', &s) }.and_then do |urls| org_url_template =
URITemplate.new(urls['organization_url']) org_url = org_url_template.expand(org: 'ruby') ! Eventually.new { |s| get_json(org_url, &s) }.and_then do |org| repos_url = org['repos_url'] ! Eventually.new { |s| get_json(repos_url, &s) }.and_then do |repos| most_popular_repo = repos.max_by { |repo| repo['watchers_count'] } repo_url = most_popular_repo['url'] ! Eventually.new { |s| get_json(repo_url, &s) }.and_then do |repo| contributors_url = repo['contributors_url'] ! Eventually.new { |s| get_json(contributors_url, &s) }.and_then do |users| most_prolific_user = users.max_by { |user| user['contributions'] } user_url = most_prolific_user['url'] ! Eventually.new { |s| get_json(user_url, &s) } end end end end end.run do |user| puts "The most influential Rubyist is #{user['name']} (#{user['login']})" end -
get_github_api_urls.and_then do |urls| org_url_template = URITemplate.new(urls['organization_url']) org_url = org_url_template.expand(org: 'ruby')
! Eventually.new { |s| get_json(org_url, &s) }.and_then do |org| repos_url = org['repos_url'] ! Eventually.new { |s| get_json(repos_url, &s) }.and_then do |repos| most_popular_repo = repos.max_by { |repo| repo['watchers_count'] } repo_url = most_popular_repo['url'] ! Eventually.new { |s| get_json(repo_url, &s) }.and_then do |repo| contributors_url = repo['contributors_url'] ! Eventually.new { |s| get_json(contributors_url, &s) }.and_then do |users| most_prolific_user = users.max_by { |user| user['contributions'] } user_url = most_prolific_user['url'] ! Eventually.new { |s| get_json(user_url, &s) } end end end end end.run do |user| puts "The most influential Rubyist is #{user['name']} (#{user['login']})" end -
def get_org(urls, name) org_url_template = URITemplate.new(urls['organization_url']) org_url = org_url_template.expand(org: name)
! Eventually.new { |success| get_json(org_url, &success) } end -
get_github_api_urls.and_then do |urls| org_url_template = URITemplate.new(urls['organization_url']) org_url = org_url_template.expand(org: 'ruby')
! Eventually.new { |s| get_json(org_url, &s) }.and_then do |org| repos_url = org['repos_url'] ! Eventually.new { |s| get_json(repos_url, &s) }.and_then do |repos| most_popular_repo = repos.max_by { |repo| repo['watchers_count'] } repo_url = most_popular_repo['url'] ! Eventually.new { |s| get_json(repo_url, &s) }.and_then do |repo| contributors_url = repo['contributors_url'] ! Eventually.new { |s| get_json(contributors_url, &s) }.and_then do |users| most_prolific_user = users.max_by { |user| user['contributions'] } user_url = most_prolific_user['url'] ! Eventually.new { |s| get_json(user_url, &s) } end end end end end.run do |user| puts "The most influential Rubyist is #{user['name']} (#{user['login']})" end -
get_github_api_urls.and_then do |urls| ! ! ! get_org(urls, 'ruby').and_then do |org|
repos_url = org['repos_url'] ! Eventually.new { |s| get_json(repos_url, &s) }.and_then do |repos| most_popular_repo = repos.max_by { |repo| repo['watchers_count'] } repo_url = most_popular_repo['url'] ! Eventually.new { |s| get_json(repo_url, &s) }.and_then do |repo| contributors_url = repo['contributors_url'] ! Eventually.new { |s| get_json(contributors_url, &s) }.and_then do |users| most_prolific_user = users.max_by { |user| user['contributions'] } user_url = most_prolific_user['url'] ! Eventually.new { |s| get_json(user_url, &s) } end end end end end.run do |user| puts "The most influential Rubyist is #{user['name']} (#{user['login']})" end -
get_github_api_urls.and_then do |urls| ! ! ! get_org(urls, 'ruby').and_then do |org|
repos_url = org['repos_url'] ! Eventually.new { |s| get_json(repos_url, &s) }.and_then do |repos| most_popular_repo = repos.max_by { |repo| repo['watchers_count'] } repo_url = most_popular_repo['url'] ! Eventually.new { |s| get_json(repo_url, &s) }.and_then do |repo| contributors_url = repo['contributors_url'] ! Eventually.new { |s| get_json(contributors_url, &s) }.and_then do |users| most_prolific_user = users.max_by { |user| user['contributions'] } user_url = most_prolific_user['url'] ! Eventually.new { |s| get_json(user_url, &s) } end end end end end.run do |user| puts "The most influential Rubyist is #{user['name']} (#{user['login']})" end -
get_github_api_urls.and_then do |urls| ! ! ! get_org(urls, 'ruby').and_then do |org|
! ! get_repos(org).and_then do |repos| most_popular_repo = repos.max_by { |repo| repo['watchers_count'] } repo_url = most_popular_repo['url'] ! Eventually.new { |s| get_json(repo_url, &s) }.and_then do |repo| contributors_url = repo['contributors_url'] ! Eventually.new { |s| get_json(contributors_url, &s) }.and_then do |users| most_prolific_user = users.max_by { |user| user['contributions'] } user_url = most_prolific_user['url'] ! Eventually.new { |s| get_json(user_url, &s) } end end end end end.run do |user| puts "The most influential Rubyist is #{user['name']} (#{user['login']})" end -
get_github_api_urls.and_then do |urls| ! ! ! get_org(urls, 'ruby').and_then do |org|
! ! get_repos(org).and_then do |repos| ! ! ! get_most_popular_repo(repos).and_then do |repo| ! ! get_contributors(repo).and_then do |users| ! ! ! get_most_prolific_user(users) end end end end end.run do |user| puts "The most influential Rubyist is #{user['name']} (#{user['login']})" end -
get_github_api_urls.and_then do |urls| get_org(urls, 'ruby').and_then do |org| get_repos(org).and_then do |repos|
get_most_popular_repo(repos).and_then do |repo| get_contributors(repo).and_then do |users| get_most_prolific_user(users) end end end end end.run do |user| puts 'The most influential Rubyist is' + " #{user['name']} (#{user['login']})" end -
get_github_api_urls.and_then do |urls| get_org(urls, 'ruby') end.and_then do |org| get_repos(org) end.and_then
do |repos| get_most_popular_repo(repos) end.and_then do |repo| get_contributors(repo) end.and_then do |users| get_most_prolific_user(users) end.run do |user| puts 'The most influential Rubyist is' + " #{user['name']} (#{user['login']})" end -
get_github_api_urls. and_then { |urls | get_org(urls, 'ruby') }. and_then {
|org | get_repos(org) }. and_then { |repos| get_most_popular_repo(repos) }. and_then { |repo | get_contributors(repo) }. and_then { |users| get_most_prolific_user(users) }. run do |user| puts 'The most influential Rubyist is' + " #{user['name']} (#{user['login']})" end -
Eventually = Struct.new(:block) do def initialize(&block) super(block) end ! def
run(&success) block.call(success) end ! def and_then(&block) Eventually.new do |success| run do |value| block.call(value).run(&success) end end end end -
Optional = Struct.new(:value) do def and_then(&block) if value.nil? Optional.new(nil) else
block.call(value) end end end Eventually = Struct.new(:block) do def and_then(&block) Eventually.new do |success| run do |value| block.call(value).run(&success) end end end end Many = Struct.new(:values) do def and_then(&block) Many.new( values.map(&block).flat_map(&:values) ) end end -
def Optional.from_value(value) Optional.new(value) end ! def Many.from_value(value) Many.new([value]) end !
def Eventually.from_value(value) Eventually.new { |success| success.call(value) } end -
#and_then calls a block with a value zero or more
times at some point -
Optional = Struct.new(:value) do def and_then(&block) if value.nil? Optional.new(nil) else
block.call(value) end end end Eventually = Struct.new(:block) do def and_then(&block) Eventually.new do |success| run do |value| block.call(value).run(&success) end end end end Many = Struct.new(:values) do def and_then(&block) Many.new( values.map(&block).flat_map(&:values) ) end end -
module Monad def within(&block) and_then do |value| self.class.from_value(block.call(value)) end end
end ! Optional.include(Monad) Many.include(Monad) Eventually.include(Monad) -
>> optional_json = Optional.new('{ "login": "nobu", "name": "Nobuyoshi Nakada" }')
=> #<struct Optional value="{ \"login\": \"nobu\", \"name\": \"Nobuyoshi Nakada\" }"> >> optional_description = description_from(optional_json) => #<struct Optional value="Nobuyoshi Nakada (nobu)"> >> optional_description.value => "Nobuyoshi Nakada (nobu)" -
>> optional_json = Optional.new(nil) => #<struct Optional value=nil> >> optional_description
= description_from(optional_json) => #<struct Optional value=nil> >> optional_description.value => nil -
>> many_jsons = Many.new([ '{ "login": "nobu", "name": "Nobuyoshi Nakada"
}', '{ "login": "matz", "name": "Yukihiro Matsumoto" }' ]) => #<struct Many values=[ "{ \"login\": \"nobu\", \"name\": \"Nobuyoshi Nakada\" }", "{ \"login\": \"matz\", \"name\": \"Yukihiro Matsumoto\" }" ]> >> many_descriptions = description_from(many_jsons) => #<struct Many values=[ "Nobuyoshi Nakada (nobu)", "Yukihiro Matsumoto (matz)" ]> >> many_descriptions.values => ["Nobuyoshi Nakada (nobu)", "Yukihiro Matsumoto (matz)"] -
>> eventually_json = Eventually.new do |success| Thread.new do uri =
URI.parse('https://api.github.com/users/nobu') json = Net::HTTP.get(uri) success.call(json) end end => #<struct Eventually block=#<Proc>> >> eventually_description = description_from(eventually_json) => #<struct Eventually block=#<Proc>> >> eventually_description.run { |description| puts description } => #<Thread run> Nobuyoshi Nakada (nobu) -
Stuart Understanding Computation From Simple Machines to Impossible Programs Tom
Stuart Understanding Computation .com @oreillymedia k.com/oreilly uart, a computer t and programmer, ounder of Codon, a product consultancy don. He works as a ant, mentor, and helping companies ove the quality and of their approach to g software products. http://computationbook.com/