Share
Embed
Transcript
71 slides
-
Flare Statistics for Young Stars from a Convolutional Neural Network
Analysis of TESS Data Adina Feinstein NSF Graduate Research Fellow Ben Montet (UNSW), Megan Ansdell (NASA HQ), Brian Nord (UChicago/KICP/Fermi), Jacob Bean (UChicago), Max Günther (MIT), Michael Gully-Santiago (UT Austin), Josh Schlieder (NASA GSFC) arXiv:2005.07710 ! 1 -
Flares can lead to increased photoevaporation of inner disks. (Benz
& Güdel, 2010) !3 -
Flares can lead to increased photoevaporation of inner disks. (Benz
& Güdel, 2010) !3 -
Flares can lead to increased photoevaporation of inner disks. (Benz
& Güdel, 2010) !3 -
Flares have been shown to increase atmospheric erosion, especially when
they are still forming & contracting. (Lammer et al. 2007; Owen & Wu 2017) !4 -
Flares have been shown to increase atmospheric erosion, especially when
they are still forming & contracting. (Lammer et al. 2007; Owen & Wu 2017) !4 -
Flares have been shown to increase atmospheric erosion, especially when
they are still forming & contracting. (Lammer et al. 2007; Owen & Wu 2017) !4 -
Flares have been seen to have long term effects on
atmospheric chemical compositions. (Venot et al. 2016) !5 Metals & molecules -
Flares have been seen to have long term effects on
atmospheric chemical compositions. (Venot et al. 2016) !5 Metals & molecules Different metals & molecules -
What is the relationship between stellar flare energy and spectral
type? Age? Spot phase? !6 -
What is the relationship between stellar flare energy and spectral
type? Age? Spot phase? !7 -
Similar studies with Kepler demonstrated a relationship between spectral type,
rotation period, and flare energy. (Davenport, 2016) 1.66 1.13 0.86 0.73 0.62 0.47 0.28 Mass [MSun ] Maximum Log(Flare Energy [ergs]) 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 !8 -
Similar studies with Kepler demonstrated a relationship between spectral type,
rotation period, and flare energy. (Davenport, 2016) 1.66 1.13 0.86 0.73 0.62 0.47 0.28 Mass [MSun ] Maximum Log(Flare Energy [ergs]) 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 !8 -
Similar studies with Kepler demonstrated a relationship between spectral type,
rotation period, and flare energy. (Yang & Liu, 2019) (Davenport, 2016) 1.66 1.13 0.86 0.73 0.62 0.47 0.28 Mass [MSun ] Maximum Log(Flare Energy [ergs]) 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 !8 -
Similar studies with Kepler demonstrated a relationship between spectral type,
rotation period, and flare energy. (Yang & Liu, 2019) (Davenport, 2016) 1.66 1.13 0.86 0.73 0.62 0.47 0.28 Mass [MSun ] Maximum Log(Flare Energy [ergs]) 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 !8 -
What is the relationship between stellar flare energy and spectral
type? Age? Spot phase? !9 -
Analysis of the Pleiades (0.125 Gyr) and Praesepe (0.63 Gyr)
showed a decrease in flare rate with age. (Ilin et al. 2019) 3000-3249 K 3250-3499 K 3500-3749 K 3750-4000 K Pleiades Praesepe !10 -
What is the relationship between stellar flare energy and spectral
type? Age? Spot phase? !11 -
In the same year, two papers presented conflicting results on
where flares occur with relation to spots. !12 -
In the same year, two papers presented conflicting results on
where flares occur with relation to spots. (Doyle et al. 2018) !12 -
In the same year, two papers presented conflicting results on
where flares occur with relation to spots. (Doyle et al. 2018) !12 -
In the same year, two papers presented conflicting results on
where flares occur with relation to spots. (Doyle et al. 2018) (Roettenbacher et al. 2018) 1-5% increase > 5% increase !12 -
In the same year, two papers presented conflicting results on
where flares occur with relation to spots. (Doyle et al. 2018) (Roettenbacher et al. 2018) 1-5% increase > 5% increase !12 -
In the same year, two papers presented conflicting results on
where flares occur with relation to spots. (Doyle et al. 2018) (Roettenbacher et al. 2018) 1-5% increase > 5% increase Sample size: 32 Sample size: 119 !12 -
What is the relationship between stellar flare energy and spectral
type? Age? Spot phase? !13 -
The Transiting Exoplanet Survey Satellite (TESS) is a four+ year,
nearly all-sky survey monitoring millions of stars. 27 days 54 days 81 days 108 days 189 days 351 days !14 -
There is no one best way to determine the age
of a star or group of stars. !15 -
There is no one best way to determine the age
of a star or group of stars. (Curtis et al. 2019) Gyrochronology !15 -
There is no one best way to determine the age
of a star or group of stars. (Curtis et al. 2019) Gyrochronology !15 Isochrone Fitting (Murphy et al. 2020) -
There is no one best way to determine the age
of a star or group of stars. (Curtis et al. 2019) Gyrochronology !15 Isochrone Fitting (Murphy et al. 2020) (Schneider et al. 2019) Kinematics -
We have completed a literature search for young moving group
members with ages 1-750 Myr. !16 -
However, the outlier metrics used will bias studies towards identifying
only the strongest flares. (Chang, Byun, & Hartman, 2015) !18 -
However, the outlier metrics used will bias studies towards identifying
only the strongest flares. (Chang, Byun, & Hartman, 2015) !18 -
However, the outlier metrics used will bias studies towards identifying
only the strongest flares. (Chang, Byun, & Hartman, 2015) :( !18 -
Machine learning can be used when searching for signals with
a characteristic shape. (Pearson et al. 2017) !19 -
Machine learning can be used when searching for signals with
a characteristic shape. (Pearson et al. 2017) !19 -
We used the TESS flare catalog from Günther et al.
(2020) as our training, validation, and test sets. !20 -
Every light curve example receives a label that the neural
network learns over several hundred epochs. !21 -
The results of 10 stella models show good training demonstrated
through the accuracy and loss metrics. (Feinstein et al. 2020) !22 -
We ensure the neural network is classifying our light curves
correctly by looking at the test set. !23 -
The confusion matrix for the stella test set is used
to visualize what the false cases look like. (Feinstein et al. 2020) !24 -
The CNN is used as a sliding-box detector, where the
probability will increase as the flare nears the center of the box. !25 -
The CNN is used as a sliding-box detector, where the
probability will increase as the flare nears the center of the box. !25 -
https://GitHub.com/afeinstein20/stella Looking at some example light curves, the cadences “light
up” when believed to be a flare. (Feinstein et al. 2020) ! 26 -
What relationship did we find between stellar flare energy and
spectral type? Age? Spot phase? !27 -
We find a clear difference in flare rate at Gaia
Bp -Rp = 2 (Teff ~ 4000K). (Feinstein et al. 2020) !28 -
The coolest stars have stronger flares in relation to their
luminosity. (Feinstein et al. 2020) !29 -
What relationship did we find between stellar flare energy and
spectral type? Age? Spot phase? !30 -
Flares amplitudes and rates are higher the coolest stars across
all ages, with noticeable evolution in other temperature bins. (Feinstein et al. 2020) !31 -
Subdividing by age, it’s easier to see the differences in
flare rate between cool (< 4000K) stars and hot stars. (Feinstein et al. 2020) !32 -
What relationship did we find between stellar flare energy and
spectral type? Age? Spot phase? !33 -
Across 1500 stars, there seems to be no preference for
where flares happen. They happen everywhere! (Feinstein et al. 2020) !34 -
Across 1500 stars, there seems to be no preference for
where flares happen. They happen everywhere! (Feinstein et al. 2020) !34 -
What do we think these stellar surfaces look like? What
we think we’re seeing: !35 -
What do we think these stellar surfaces look like? What
we think we’re seeing: !35 -
What do we think these stellar surfaces look like? What
we think we’re seeing: What a flare-phase relationship would’ve looked like: !35 -
What do we think these stellar surfaces look like? What
we think we’re seeing: What a flare-phase relationship would’ve looked like: The Sun: !35 -
Flares have been shown to alter atmospheric chemistry and could
partially affect mass-loss rates during formation. (Feinstein et al. 2020) !36 -
Flares have been shown to alter atmospheric chemistry and could
partially affect mass-loss rates during formation. (Feinstein et al. 2020) !36 -
Flares have been shown to alter atmospheric chemistry and could
partially affect mass-loss rates during formation. (Feinstein et al. 2020) !36 -
Young planets are challenging to detect and occur on similar
timescales to flares, so let’s “flip” stella! (David et al. 2019) !38 -
Young planets are challenging to detect and occur on similar
timescales to flares, so let’s “flip” stella! (David et al. 2019) !38 -
There’s a huge (500 Myr!!) age range of missing planets.
stella may be able to find them. (Exoplanet Archive, as of 6/25/2020) !39 -
There’s a huge (500 Myr!!) age range of missing planets.
stella may be able to find them. (Exoplanet Archive, as of 6/25/2020) !39 -
My project at the tess.ninja workshop already demonstrates the power
of stella when applied to transits. !40 -
We hope to search both the 2-minute and 30-minute TESS
data for new young planet candidates. Photo credit: Ethan Kruse !41 (Feinstein et al. 2019) -
Summary • This is the first application of CNNs to
find stellar flares. It provides a new statistical analysis of these events. • We find no phase preference for flares, indicating the surfaces of young stars have an overall very high spot coverage. • Cool stars (Teff < 4000 K) have high and consistent flare rates at all ages between 1-800 Myr, while hot stars show decline over time. • Flares have negative consequences for photoevaporative mass loss of exoplanet atmospheres. • Next — let’s find more young planets! !42