Share
Embed
Electrifying metal-organic frameworks: absolute electron energies
Invited presentation at the 2016 Fall Meeting of the Materials Research Society (Symposium EC2)
Aron Walsh
November 29, 2016
Transcript
42 slides
-
Electrifying Metal-Organic Frameworks: Absolute Electron Energies Prof. Aron Walsh Chair
in Materials Design Department of Materials Imperial College London https://wmd-group.github.io @lonepair hν e- MOF Detector ΔE = ? -
Metal-Organic Frameworks (MOFs) Crystals of Organic & Inorganic Building Blocks
Metal Ligand 0 1 2 3 0 Molecular complexes O0I0 Hybrid chains O0I1 Hybrid layers O0I2 Hybrid framework O0I3 1 Coordination polymer O1I0 Mixed layers O1I1 Mixed framework O1I2 2 Coordination layer O2I0 Mixed framework O2I1 3 Coordination framework O3I0 Rule: n+m ≤ 3 Dimensionality of Inorganic Connectivity (In) I – O – I Connectivity (Om) Adapted from A. K. Cheetham et al, Chem. Comm. 4780 (2006) -
Electroactive MOFs Materials Platform for Exciting Physical Properties This is
an isotherm-free presentation Hendon, Butler & Walsh, MRS Bulletin 41, 870 (2016) -
Electroactive MOFs Materials Platform for Exciting Physical Properties This is
an isotherm-free presentation Hendon, Butler & Walsh, MRS Bulletin 41, 870 (2016) -
Absolute Band Energies are Important Relative Electron Energies Band gaps
and valence / conduction band widths Absolute Electron Energies Dictate stability and transfer of charge • Redox chemistry: photocatalysis to batteries • Defect physics: controlling n-type / p-type • Device engineering: band alignment & barriers -
Talk Outline: Ionisation Potentials 1. History of Absolute Electron Energies
2. Bridging Theory and Experiment 3. Workfunctions of Porous Materials -
(Semiconductor) Terminology 1. Ionisation Potential – Energy to remove electron
from valence band (VB) to the vacuum level (VL) 2. Workfunction – Energy to remove electron from the Fermi level (EF ) to the vacuum level 3. Electron Affinity – Energy to add an electron to the conduction band (CB) from the vacuum level VB CB VL EF -
19th Century: Photoelectric Effect Ultraviolet Light “Excites” Certain Materials Annalen
der Physik (1887); DOI: 10.1002/andp.18872670827 -
Bulk Electron Binding Energy Binding Energy = E[N-1] – E[N]
Energy of system with N electrons -
Surface Electrostatic Double Layer Workfunction = E[N-1] – E[N] +
ED Energy due to surface dipole -
Surface Electrostatic Double Layer Workfunction = E[N-1] – E[N] +
ED !+ !- Electrons spill at a surface -
Exit Density Functional Theory Arbitrary Reference for Electronic Eigenvalues of
Solids – Potential Zero is Shape Dependent -
Talk Outline: Ionisation Potentials 1. History of Absolute Electron Energies
2. Bridging Theory and Experiment 3. Workfunctions of Porous Materials -
Phenomenological Theory Geometric Mean of the Electronegativity This approximates the
mid-gap energy (for atoms the Mulliken electronegativity is the mean of the IP and EA) Nethercot (1974); Butler & Ginley (1978); Xu & Schoonen (2000) Used in many recent high-throughput screening studies, but is clearly limited: no account of local structure, oxidation state, or chemical bonding -
Phenomenological Theory Actually a Decent Guess… Butler & Ginley, J.
Electrochem. Soc. 125, 229 (1978) Calculated -
Screening New Photoactive Materials Sustainability index From Searching over 4
Trillion Compounds… D. W. Davies et al, Chem 1, 617 (2016); https://github.com/WMD-group/SMACT -
Screening New Photoactive Materials Sustainability index From Searching over 4
Trillion Compounds… D. W. Davies et al, Chem 1, 617 (2016); https://github.com/WMD-group/SMACT -
Quantitative Techniques Experiment Simulation Photoelectron Spectroscopy (secondary electron cutoff) Surface
Termination (vacuum alignment) Electrochemical Response (flat-band potential) Molecular Dynamics (explicit solvent) Photoelectron Spectroscopy (core level binding) Heterojunction (core level alignment) Electrochemical Response (redox energies) Molecular Dynamics (explicit solvent / charge) -
Embedded Crystal Approach Quantum Mechanical (QM) / Molecular Mechanical (MM)
Embedding of Crystalline Solids Region I: QM Region II: MM (active) Region III: MM (frozen) Region IV: Point Charges Aim to reproduce electrostatic, chemical, and mechanical environment of crystal in Region I Daresbury Laboratory (UK): www.chemshell.org -
Embedded Crystal Approach D. O. Scanlon et al, Nat. Mater.
12, 798 (2013); www.chemshell.org Calculate Ionisation Potentials with Long-range Polarisation of Crystal (ΔSCF procedure) -
Effect of Local Coordination J. Buckeridge et al, Chem. Mater.
17, 3844 (2015); www.chemshell.org Range of Oxygen Environments (2,3,4) in TiO2 -
Effect of Local Coordination J. Buckeridge et al, Chem. Mater.
17, 3844 (2015); www.chemshell.org Range of Electron Energies in TiO2 Polymorphs Ti is 7-fold coordinated! -
Effect of Local Coordination J. Buckeridge et al, Chem. Mater.
17, 3844 (2015); www.chemshell.org Range of Electron Energies in TiO2 Polymorphs Ti is 7-fold coordinated! -
Talk Outline: Ionisation Potentials 1. History of Absolute Electron Energies
2. Bridging Theory and Experiment 3. Workfunctions of Porous Materials -
Limitations of Current Atomistic Theory Technique Limitations Surface Termination (vacuum
alignment) Values depend on surface Molecular Dynamics (explicit solvent) Requires large scale simulations – convergence Heterojunction (core level alignment) Requires compatible crystal structures Embedded Clusters (direct IP calculation) Requires complex setup procedure and forcefield -
Frameworks with Large Pores a d b e c f
r = 6 r = 5, 7, 8 r = 9 r = 7.5 r = 7.5 r = 10 Pore Radius () MOF-5 HKUST-1 ZIF-8 COF-1M CPO-27 MIL-125 -
Use the Internal Vacuum Level Eigenvalues Aligned to Pore Potential
https://github.com/WMD- group/MacroDensity • Integrate sphere at center of pore • Check that potential has reached a plateau • Implemented in Python code (for 1D, 2D and 3D averages): -
Band Alignment of MOFs Place MOFs and Inorganic Semiconductors on
a Common Energy Scale Butler, Hendon and Walsh, JACS 136, 2703 (2014) Good agreement with first measurements of MOF workfunctions -
Band Alignment of MOFs Explain Electron Localisation in d0 Frameworks
Nasalevich et al, Sci. Rep. 6, 23676 (2016) -
Electroactive MOFs Materials Platform for Exciting Physical Properties Hendon, Butler
& Walsh, MRS Bulletin 41, 870 (2016) -
Electroactive MOFs Materials Platform for Exciting Physical Properties Hendon, Butler
& Walsh, MRS Bulletin 41, 870 (2016) -
Conclusions 1. Solid absolute electron energies are simple to define
but challenging for theory and experiment 2. Electroactive MOF knowledge is increasing towards rational control of functionality Collaborators: Keith Butler (Bath); Chris Hendon (MIT); Yu Kumagai & Fumiyasu Oba (Tokyo Tech); Su-Huai Wei (Beijing CSRC); Alexey Sokol & John Buckeridge (UCL); Jorge Gascon (Delft) Funders: JSPS; ERC; EPSRC; Royal Society Slides: https://speakerdeck.com/aronwalsh