Auralization of road vehicles using spectral modeling synthesis

Masters Thesis presentation on auralization of road vehicles using spectral modeling synthesis

Transcript

1. Auralization of road vehicles using spectral modeling synthesis Chinmay Pendharkar, Applied Acoustics, Chalmers, 2011 Monday, April 8, 13
2. • LISTEN Project • Auralization • Sound Synthesis • Spectral Modeling Synthesis (SMS) • SMS Implementation for Vehicle Sounds • Listening Test • Results and Analysis • Q & A Organization Monday, April 8, 13
3. LISTEN Project Monday, April 8, 13
4. LISTEN Project • Collaboration - KTH, Konstfack, SU, II. Monday, April 8, 13
5. LISTEN Project • Collaboration - KTH, Konstfack, SU, II. • Software Demonstrator/Simulator Monday, April 8, 13
6. LISTEN Project • Collaboration - KTH, Konstfack, SU, II. • Software Demonstrator/Simulator • Qualitative listening of urban soundscapes Monday, April 8, 13
7. LISTEN Demonstrator Monday, April 8, 13
8. LISTEN Demonstrator • Auralization of Urban Soundscapes Monday, April 8, 13
9. LISTEN Demonstrator • Auralization of Urban Soundscapes • Qualitative vs Quantitative Analysis Monday, April 8, 13
10. LISTEN Demonstrator • Auralization of Urban Soundscapes • Qualitative vs Quantitative Analysis Monday, April 8, 13
11. Auralization • Source + Propagation Monday, April 8, 13
12. Auralization Monday, April 8, 13
13. Auralization • Source Modeling Monday, April 8, 13
14. Auralization • Source Modeling • Vehicles as sound sources. • Amplitude / Level • Frequency • Directivity • Non-Stationary sound. Monday, April 8, 13
15. Auralization • Recordings - Large and Inflexible • 6 seconds - 853KB • For each velocity, vehicle type, ... Monday, April 8, 13
16. Auralization Monday, April 8, 13
17. Auralization • What if..? Monday, April 8, 13
18. Auralization • What if..? • Extract the important ‘features’ Monday, April 8, 13
19. Auralization • What if..? • Extract the important ‘features’ • Calculate waveforms ‘on the fly’ Monday, April 8, 13
20. Auralization • What if..? • Extract the important ‘features’ • Calculate waveforms ‘on the fly’ • Parameters to change the sound Vehicle Model Speed Monday, April 8, 13
21. Sound Synthesis Monday, April 8, 13
22. Sound Synthesis • Electronic Generation of Audio Waveforms Monday, April 8, 13
23. Sound Synthesis • Electronic Generation of Audio Waveforms • Model to Waveform Monday, April 8, 13
24. Sound Synthesis • Electronic Generation of Audio Waveforms • Model to Waveform • Computer Music Origin Monday, April 8, 13
25. Sound Synthesis • Electronic Generation of Audio Waveforms • Model to Waveform • Computer Music Origin • Current Uses • Electronic Music Production, • Games • Interactive Media Monday, April 8, 13
26. Sound Synthesis Monday, April 8, 13
27. Sound Synthesis • Flexible Model Monday, April 8, 13
28. Sound Synthesis • Flexible • Real Time Model Monday, April 8, 13
29. Sound Synthesis • Flexible • Real Time • Low Memory Requirement Model ~10KB vs 1MB Monday, April 8, 13
30. Sound Synthesis Monday, April 8, 13
31. Sound Synthesis • Types Monday, April 8, 13
32. Sound Synthesis • Types • Additive Synthesis Monday, April 8, 13
33. Sound Synthesis • Types • Additive Synthesis • Frequency Modulation Synthesis Monday, April 8, 13
34. Sound Synthesis • Types • Additive Synthesis • Frequency Modulation Synthesis • Physical Synthesis Monday, April 8, 13
35. Sound Synthesis • Types • Additive Synthesis • Frequency Modulation Synthesis • Physical Synthesis • Spectral Modeling Synthesis Monday, April 8, 13
36. Sound Synthesis Monday, April 8, 13
37. Sound Synthesis • Vehicle Sounds • Tonal Component - Engine Noise • Noise Component - Tyre Noise Monday, April 8, 13
38. Sound Synthesis • Vehicle Sounds • Tonal Component - Engine Noise • Noise Component - Tyre Noise • Non - Stationary Monday, April 8, 13
39. Spectral Modeling Synthesis (SMS) Monday, April 8, 13
40. Spectral Modeling Synthesis (SMS) • Xavier Serra and Julius Smith, 1990 Monday, April 8, 13
41. Spectral Modeling Synthesis (SMS) • Xavier Serra and Julius Smith, 1990 • Modeling musical instruments Monday, April 8, 13
42. Spectral Modeling Synthesis (SMS) • Xavier Serra and Julius Smith, 1990 • Modeling musical instruments • Deterministic + Stochastic Decomposition Monday, April 8, 13
43. Spectral Modeling Synthesis (SMS) • Xavier Serra and Julius Smith, 1990 • Modeling musical instruments • Deterministic + Stochastic Decomposition • Tonal Sounds + Noise Monday, April 8, 13
44. SMS Demo Monday, April 8, 13
45. SMS Demo • Original • Tonal (Deterministic) • Noise (Stochastic) • ReSynthesis Monday, April 8, 13
46. SMS Demo • Original • Tonal (Deterministic) • Noise (Stochastic) • ReSynthesis Monday, April 8, 13
47. SMS Demo • Original • Tonal (Deterministic) • Noise (Stochastic) • ReSynthesis Monday, April 8, 13
48. SMS Demo • Original • Tonal (Deterministic) • Noise (Stochastic) • ReSynthesis Monday, April 8, 13
49. SMS Demo • Original • Tonal (Deterministic) • Noise (Stochastic) • ReSynthesis Monday, April 8, 13
50. • LISTEN Project • Auralization • Sound Synthesis • Spectral Modeling Synthesis (SMS) • SMS Implementation for Vehicle Sounds • Listening Test • Results and Analysis • Q & A Organization Monday, April 8, 13
51. SMS Algorithm STFT Analysis Original Audio Peak Detection Peak Tracking Peak Trajectories Tonal ReSynth Residual Audio Residual Parameterization Residual Parameters Noise ReSynth ReSynth Audio Monday, April 8, 13
52. SMS Algorithm STFT Analysis Original Audio Peak Detection Peak Tracking Peak Trajectories Tonal ReSynth Residual Audio Residual Parameterization Residual Parameters Noise ReSynth ReSynth Audio Tonal Analysis Monday, April 8, 13
53. SMS Algorithm STFT Analysis Original Audio Peak Detection Peak Tracking Peak Trajectories Tonal ReSynth Residual Audio Residual Parameterization Residual Parameters Noise ReSynth ReSynth Audio Tonal Analysis Noise Analysis Monday, April 8, 13
54. SMS Algorithm STFT Analysis Original Audio Peak Detection Peak Tracking Peak Trajectories Tonal ReSynth Residual Audio Residual Parameterization Residual Parameters Noise ReSynth ReSynth Audio Tonal Analysis Noise Analysis Synthesis Monday, April 8, 13
55. SMS Algorithm Tonal Analysis • Original Audio - Peak Trajectories STFT Analysis Original Audio Peak Detection Peak Tracking Peak Trajectories Monday, April 8, 13
56. SMS Algorithm STFT Monday, April 8, 13
57. SMS Algorithm STFT • Short Term Fourier Transform (STFT) Monday, April 8, 13
58. SMS Algorithm STFT • Short Term Fourier Transform (STFT) • Fourier Analysis of Short Time Instances Monday, April 8, 13
59. SMS Algorithm STFT • Short Term Fourier Transform (STFT) • Fourier Analysis of Short Time Instances • Sliding Window Analysis Monday, April 8, 13
60. SMS Algorithm Peak Detection Monday, April 8, 13
61. SMS Algorithm Peak Detection • Gradient Based Detection Monday, April 8, 13
62. SMS Algorithm Peak Detection • Gradient Based Detection Monday, April 8, 13
63. SMS Algorithm Peak Detection • Gradient Based Detection Monday, April 8, 13
64. SMS Algorithm Peak Detection • Gradient Based Detection • Interpolation due to DFT Sampling. Monday, April 8, 13
65. SMS Algorithm Peak Detection • Gradient Based Detection • Interpolation due to DFT Sampling. Monday, April 8, 13
66. SMS Algorithm Peak Tracking Monday, April 8, 13
67. SMS Algorithm Peak Tracking • Frequency Guides - Peak Trajectories Monday, April 8, 13
68. SMS Algorithm Peak Tracking • Frequency Guides - Peak Trajectories • Gradually Varying Sinusoids Monday, April 8, 13
69. SMS Algorithm Peak Tracking • Frequency Guides - Peak Trajectories • Gradually Varying Sinusoids • Doppler Shift Monday, April 8, 13
70. SMS Algorithm Peak Tracking • Frequency Guides - Peak Trajectories • Gradually Varying Sinusoids • Doppler Shift Monday, April 8, 13
71. SMS Algorithm Peak Trajectories Monday, April 8, 13
72. SMS Algorithm Noise Analysis • Original Audio & Tonal Synthesis - Residual Parameters Original Audio Peak Trajectories Tonal ReSynth Residual Audio Residual Parameterization Residual Parameters Monday, April 8, 13
73. SMS Algorithm Residual Calculation Monday, April 8, 13
74. SMS Algorithm Residual Calculation • Original - Tonal = Residual Monday, April 8, 13
75. SMS Algorithm Residual Calculation • Original - Tonal = Residual • Spectrum Subtraction Monday, April 8, 13
76. SMS Algorithm Residual Calculation • Original - Tonal = Residual • Spectrum Subtraction Monday, April 8, 13
77. SMS Algorithm Residual Parameterization Monday, April 8, 13
78. SMS Algorithm Residual Parameterization • Perceptual Model Monday, April 8, 13
79. SMS Algorithm Residual Parameterization • Perceptual Model • Noise Energy per Critical Band Monday, April 8, 13
80. SMS Algorithm Residual Parameterization • Perceptual Model • Noise Energy per Critical Band Monday, April 8, 13
81. SMS Algorithm - Residual Parameters Monday, April 8, 13
82. SMS Algorithm Complete Model Monday, April 8, 13
83. SMS Algorithm Complete Model • Peak Trajectories Monday, April 8, 13
84. SMS Algorithm Complete Model • Peak Trajectories Monday, April 8, 13
85. SMS Algorithm Complete Model • Peak Trajectories • Residual Parameters Monday, April 8, 13
86. SMS Algorithm Complete Model • Peak Trajectories • Residual Parameters Monday, April 8, 13
87. SMS Algorithm Complete Model • Peak Trajectories • Residual Parameters 6 seconds - 80KB Monday, April 8, 13
88. SMS Algorithm Synthesis • Peak Trajectories - Tonal Sound • Residual Parameters - Noise Peak Trajectories Tonal ReSynth Residual Parameters Noise ReSynth ReSynth Audio Monday, April 8, 13
89. SMS Algorithm Tonal Synthesis Monday, April 8, 13
90. SMS Algorithm Tonal Synthesis • Peak Trajectories - Sinusoid Waveform Monday, April 8, 13
91. SMS Algorithm Tonal Synthesis • Peak Trajectories - Sinusoid Waveform • x[n] = A[n]*cos(w[n]) Monday, April 8, 13
92. SMS Algorithm Tonal Synthesis • Peak Trajectories - Sinusoid Waveform • x[n] = A[n]*cos(w[n]) + + = = Monday, April 8, 13
93. SMS Algorithm Residual Synthesis Monday, April 8, 13
94. SMS Algorithm Residual Synthesis • Residual Parameters - Noise Monday, April 8, 13
95. SMS Algorithm Residual Synthesis • Residual Parameters - Noise • Interpolation Monday, April 8, 13
96. SMS Algorithm Residual Synthesis • Residual Parameters - Noise • Interpolation • Random Phase Assignment Monday, April 8, 13
97. SMS Algorithm Residual Synthesis • Residual Parameters - Noise • Interpolation • Random Phase Assignment • Inverse Fourier Transform Monday, April 8, 13
98. SMS Algorithm Residual Synthesis • Residual Parameters - Noise • Interpolation • Random Phase Assignment • Inverse Fourier Transform • Overlap and Add Synthesis Monday, April 8, 13
99. SMS Algorithm Residual Synthesis • Overlap and Add Synthesis Monday, April 8, 13
100. SMS Algorithm STFT Analysis Original Audio Peak Detection Peak Tracking Peak Trajectories Tonal ReSynth Residual Audio Residual Parameterization Residual Parameters Noise ReSynth ReSynth Audio Tonal Analysis Noise Analysis Synthesis Monday, April 8, 13
101. • LISTEN Project • Auralization • Sound Synthesis • Spectral Modeling Synthesis (SMS) • SMS Implementation for Vehicle Sounds • Listening Test • Results and Analysis • Q & A Organization Monday, April 8, 13
102. SMS for Vehicle Sounds • Multi Pass Analysis • Trajectory Energy Filtering • Residual parameter smoothing Monday, April 8, 13
103. SMS for Vehicle Sounds • Multi Pass Analysis • Analysis Window - Frequency Dependence Monday, April 8, 13
104. SMS for Vehicle Sounds • Multi Pass Analysis - Pyramid Analysis • Vary window length for each ‘Pass’ Monday, April 8, 13
105. SMS for Vehicle Sounds Monday, April 8, 13
106. SMS for Vehicle Sounds • Multi Pass Analysis Monday, April 8, 13
107. SMS for Vehicle Sounds • Multi Pass Analysis • Frequency band - Pass Monday, April 8, 13
108. SMS for Vehicle Sounds • Multi Pass Analysis • Frequency band - Pass Pass 1 Pass 2 Pass 3 Monday, April 8, 13
109. SMS for Vehicle Sounds • Trajectory Energy Filtering • Too many trajectories - Filter by ‘Importance’ Monday, April 8, 13
110. SMS for Vehicle Sounds Monday, April 8, 13
111. SMS for Vehicle Sounds • Fluctuating Residual Parameter Monday, April 8, 13
112. SMS for Vehicle Sounds • Fluctuating Residual Parameter • Smoothen Monday, April 8, 13
113. SMS for Vehicle Sounds • Fluctuating Residual Parameter • Smoothen Monday, April 8, 13
114. SMS on Vehicle Sounds • Bus (39km/h) • Original • Tonal • Noise • ReSynth Monday, April 8, 13
115. SMS on Vehicle Sounds • Bus (39km/h) • Original • Tonal • Noise • ReSynth Monday, April 8, 13
116. SMS on Vehicle Sounds • Bus (39km/h) • Original • Tonal • Noise • ReSynth Monday, April 8, 13
117. SMS on Vehicle Sounds • Bus (39km/h) • Original • Tonal • Noise • ReSynth Monday, April 8, 13
118. SMS on Vehicle Sounds • Bus (39km/h) • Original • Tonal • Noise • ReSynth Monday, April 8, 13
119. SMS on Vehicle Sounds • Open Astra (45 km/h) • Volvo V70 (50 km/h) • IV Medium-Heavy (40km/h) • Bus (86km/h) Monday, April 8, 13
120. SMS on Vehicle Sounds • Open Astra (45 km/h) • Volvo V70 (50 km/h) • IV Medium-Heavy (40km/h) • Bus (86km/h) Monday, April 8, 13
121. SMS on Vehicle Sounds • Open Astra (45 km/h) • Volvo V70 (50 km/h) • IV Medium-Heavy (40km/h) • Bus (86km/h) Monday, April 8, 13
122. SMS on Vehicle Sounds • Open Astra (45 km/h) • Volvo V70 (50 km/h) • IV Medium-Heavy (40km/h) • Bus (86km/h) Monday, April 8, 13
123. SMS on Vehicle Sounds • Open Astra (45 km/h) • Volvo V70 (50 km/h) • IV Medium-Heavy (40km/h) • Bus (86km/h) Monday, April 8, 13
124. • LISTEN Project • Auralization • Sound Synthesis • Spectral Modeling Synthesis (SMS) • SMS Implementation for Vehicle Sounds • Listening Test • Results and Analysis • Q & A Organization Monday, April 8, 13
125. Listening Test Monday, April 8, 13
126. Listening Test • Perceptual Similarity of Sounds Monday, April 8, 13
127. Listening Test • Perceptual Similarity of Sounds • 18 Sounds - 72 Combination Monday, April 8, 13
128. Listening Test • Perceptual Similarity of Sounds • 18 Sounds - 72 Combination • Paired Sound Test Monday, April 8, 13
129. Listening Test • Perceptual Similarity of Sounds • 18 Sounds - 72 Combination • Paired Sound Test • 3 Questions • Realism • Annoyance • Speed Monday, April 8, 13
130. Listening Test • Perceptual Similarity of Sounds • 18 Sounds - 72 Combination • Paired Sound Test • 3 Questions • Realism • Annoyance • Speed • 27 Participants Monday, April 8, 13
131. Listening Test Results Monday, April 8, 13
132. Listening Test Results • Significant Difference Match Pair t-test - 90% Monday, April 8, 13
133. Spectral Analysis Monday, April 8, 13
134. • LISTEN Project • Auralization • Sound Synthesis • Spectral Modeling Synthesis (SMS) • SMS Implementation for Vehicle Sounds • Listening Test • Results and Analysis • Q & A Organization Monday, April 8, 13
135. Analysis - Applications Monday, April 8, 13
136. Analysis - Applications • Applying propagation to Sound Model Monday, April 8, 13
137. Analysis - Applications • Applying propagation to Sound Model • Direct Frequency-Domain Changes Monday, April 8, 13
138. Analysis - Applications • Applying propagation to Sound Model • Direct Frequency-Domain Changes • Less Memory Requirement Monday, April 8, 13
139. Analysis - Applications • Applying propagation to Sound Model • Direct Frequency-Domain Changes • Less Memory Requirement • Interaction Real-Time Synthesis Monday, April 8, 13
140. Analysis - Applications Monday, April 8, 13
141. Analysis - Applications • Binaural calculation of propagation Monday, April 8, 13
142. Analysis - Applications • Binaural calculation of propagation • Multiple source height - issue Monday, April 8, 13
143. Analysis - Applications • Binaural calculation of propagation • Multiple source height - issue • SMS can ‘separate’ engine and tyre Monday, April 8, 13
144. Conclusion Monday, April 8, 13
145. Conclusion • SMS works great for vehicle sounds. Monday, April 8, 13
146. Conclusion • SMS works great for vehicle sounds. • Less memory and more flexible Monday, April 8, 13
147. Conclusion • SMS works great for vehicle sounds. • Less memory and more flexible • Fine tuning for effectively and efficiency. Monday, April 8, 13
148. Conclusion • SMS works great for vehicle sounds. • Less memory and more flexible • Fine tuning for effectively and efficiency. • Can produce perceptually similar sounds. Monday, April 8, 13
149. Future Work Monday, April 8, 13
150. Future Work • Automated Parameter Estimation Monday, April 8, 13
151. Future Work • Automated Parameter Estimation • Improved Noise Model Monday, April 8, 13
152. Future Work • Automated Parameter Estimation • Improved Noise Model • Transients Modeling Monday, April 8, 13
153. Future Work • Automated Parameter Estimation • Improved Noise Model • Transients Modeling • Support for Binaural Propagation calculation Monday, April 8, 13
154. Thanks! Monday, April 8, 13