Share
Embed
LEED v4, Renewable Energy, and Carbon Offsets
The U.S. Green Building Council's (USGBC's) Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design (LEED) is the market-leading standard for green building design. The recent LEED v4 update includes the ability to earn points toward certification by purchasing Green-e certified renewable energy and carbon offsets. Join Alex Pennock, manager of Green-e Energy and Todd Jones, manager of Green-e Climate, as they review the new changes and answer common questions about the updated green power and carbon offset credit, along with the rationale for these changes and how they will affect the market. With Alex Pennock, manager of Green-e Energy, and Todd Jones, manager of Green-e Climate. Originally aired Wednesday, April 10, 2014.
Center for Resource Solutions PRO
April 10, 2014
Transcript
34 slides
-
LEED, RENEWABLE ENERGY, AND CARBON OFFSETS HOW THE LEED v4
STANDARD IMPACTS YOUR RENEWABLE ENERGY AND OFFSET STRATEGY April 10, 2014 -
Brief Intros to LEED and Green-e Green-e in the 2009
versions of LEED Rating Systems LEED v.4 Green Power and Carbon Offsets Point Green-e “equivalence” Other points for renewables Effect of LEED v4 on Renewable Energy and Carbon Offset Markets Summary/Conclusions Q&A OUTLINE -
2 Standards Working Together Green-‐e is a family of independent
cer1fica1on programs, for renewable energy, carbon offsets, and the companies and products that use them to reduce their environmental impact. LEED is an independent cer1fica1on for green building design, construc1on, opera1ons and maintenance. -
2 Standards Working Together The leading cer2fica2on for renewable energy
in North America. Works with renewable energy sellers to offer consumers na1onwide clean, renewable electricity that has been independently verified, as a viable alterna1ve to conven1onal electricity and the impacts of its genera1on. Cer1fies the following renewable energy products: • Renewable Energy Cer1ficates, • U1lity Green Pricing Programs, and • Compe11ve Electricity Products. -
2 Standards Working Together The global retail standard for carbon
offsets. Strengthens the market for voluntary emissions reduc1ons by cer1fying that carbon offsets sold contain real, verified reduc1ons from high-‐quality and addi1onal projects, verifying sales, correct delivery of the offsets and exclusive retail ownership, and by reviewing the informa1on provided to offset consumers for adequacy and accuracy. -
LEED 2009 Green Power and Green-e in NC, C&S, Schools,
Retail, Healthcare (1 pt) – EA CREDIT: GREEN POWER (maximum 2 points) • “as defined by the … Green-‐e Energy product cer2fica2on requirements or an equivalent.” • “Engage in at least a 2-‐year renewable energy contract” • “at least 35% of the building’s electricity from renewable sources” -
LEED 2009 Green Power and Green-e in CI – EA
CREDIT: GREEN POWER (maximum 5 points) • Op1on 1: 2-‐year renewable energy contract to provide at least 50% of the tenant’s electricity from renewable sources” • Op1on 2: “2-‐year renewable energy contract to purchase at least 8 kilowaU hours per square foot per year” -
LEED 2009 Green Power and Green-e in EBOM – EA
CREDIT: ON-‐SITE AND OFF-‐SITE RENEWABLE ENERGY (maximum 6 points) • “Off-‐site renewable energy sources are defined by the … Green-‐e Energy program … or the equivalent.” • “… purchase RECs for a minimum of 2 years and must also make a commitment to purchase RECs on an ongoing basis beyond that.” • Up to 6 points are awarded for purchases of 25% to 100% RE per year -
LEED v4 Stronger Green Power Obligations & Introducing Carbon Offsets
• Building Design and Construc1on (BD&C) • Exis1ng Building Opera1ons and Maintenance (EBOM) • Interior Design and Construc1on (ID&C) • Homes • Neighborhood Development (ND) LEED 2009 Ra2ng Systems LEED v.4 Ra2ng Systems -
LEED v4 Stronger Green Power Obligations & Introducing Carbon Offsets
BD&C and ID&C – EA CREDIT: GREEN POWER AND CARBON OFFSETS (maximum 2 points) • “resources that have come online since January 1, 2005” • “contract […] for a minimum of five years, […] delivered at least annually” • “provision of at least 50% or 100% of the project’s energy from green power, carbon offsets, or renewable energy cer1ficates (RECs)” • “Green power and RECs must be Green-‐e Energy cer2fied or the equivalent. RECs can only be used to mi1gate the effects of Scope 2, electricity use.” -
LEED v4 Stronger Green Power Obligations & Introducing Carbon Offsets
• “Carbon offsets may be used to mi1gate Scope 1 or Scope 2 emissions on a metric ton of carbon dioxide–equivalent basis and must be Green-‐ e Climate cer2fied, or the equivalent.” • “For U.S. projects, the offsets must be from […] projects within the United States.” BD&C and ID&C – EA CREDIT: GREEN POWER AND CARBON OFFSETS (maximum 2 points) -
LEED v4 Stronger Green Power Obligations & Introducing Carbon Offsets
Percentage of total energy addressed by green power, RECs and/or offsets Points 50% 1 100% 2 “Determine the percentage of green power or offsets based on the quan1ty of energy consumed, not the cost. Points are awarded according to Table 1.” Table 1. Points for energy from green power or carbon offsets BD&C and ID&C – EA CREDIT: GREEN POWER AND CARBON OFFSETS (maximum 2 points) -
LEED v4 Stronger Green Power Obligations & Introducing Carbon Offsets
EBOM – EA CREDIT: RENEWABLE ENERGY AND CARBON OFFSETS (maximum 5 points) “Demonstrate one or both of the following for at least a por2on of the building’s total energy use. • Total energy use is met directly with renewable energy systems. • A minimum two-‐year contract is in place, with the commitment to renew on an ongoing basis, to purchase qualified resources that will be delivered at least annually. Resources must have come online a_er January 1, 2005.” -
LEED v4 Stronger Green Power Obligations & Introducing Carbon Offsets
• If the second op1on, then “engage in a contract to purchase green power, carbon offsets, or Renewable Energy Cer1ficates (RECs).” • RECs for Scope 2 only; offsets for Scopes 1 or 2 • “Green power and RECs must be Green-‐e Energy cer2fied or the equivalent” and “Carbon offsets […] must be Green-‐e Climate cer2fied, or the equivalent.” • “For U.S. projects, the offsets must be from […] projects within the United States.” EBOM – EA CREDIT: RENEWABLE ENERGY AND CARBON OFFSETS (maximum 5 points) -
LEED v4 Stronger Green Power Obligations & Introducing Carbon Offsets
EBOM – EA CREDIT: RENEWABLE ENERGY AND CARBON OFFSETS “Use the following equa1on to calculate credit, up to the 5-‐point limit:” Points = Renewable energy generated % 1.5% Energy purchased/offset % (Not to exceed 100%) 25% + -
LEED v4 Stronger Green Power Obligations & Introducing Carbon Offsets
• Annual electricity and non-‐electricity energy use calcula1ons • Calcula1ons showing required REC, green power, or carbon offsets for targeted point threshold • Purchase contract for RECs, green power, or carbon offsets • Green-‐e equivalency documenta1on, if not Green-‐e cer1fied • EBOM on-‐site: RE produc1on, and 10-‐year contract for replacement RECs / offset if on-‐site RECs sold REQUIRED DOCUMENTATION -
LEED v4 Other Points for Renewables • Credit is based
on COST of electricity, not produc1on and use • Off-‐site “solar gardens” allowed ND+C and ID+C – EA CREDIT: RENEWABLE ENERGY PRODUCTION hUp://www.leeduser.com/credit/NC-‐2009/EAc2 • REC reten1on not specified, but indicated in: • USGBC Forums • Reference Guide (for EBOM RE point e.g.) • LEEDuser.com (for 2009 NC EAc2): -
( =) What is “equivalent” to Green-e? or LEED
v4 says: “Green power and RECs must be Green-‐e Energy cer2fied or the equivalent. RECs can only be used to mi1gate the effects of Scope 2, electricity use. ” -
( =) What is “equivalent” to Green-e? or •
Resource eligibility • All aUributes included • Double coun1ng preven1on • Annual verifica1on • Customer disclosure • Claims enforcement Includes: -
( =) What is “equivalent” to Green-e? or •
Standalone tracking system REC re1rement • ‘Green-‐e Energy Eligible’ facility • ‘Cer1fiABLE’ RECs • RE w/out carbon value • Null power claimed as RE ≠ -
( =) What is “equivalent” to Green-e? or •
Green-‐e Energy US RECs s1ll allowed, though USGBC interested in suppor1ng local genera1on • EBOM 2009 EU alterna1ve compliance paths • Offsets allowed for electricity emissions in any country • Calcula1on informa1on in Reference Guide INTERNATIONAL TIPS -
( =) What is “equivalent” to Green-e? or ≠
American Carbon Registry (ACR) VERs Clean Development Mechanism (CDM) CERs Climate Ac1on Reserve CRTs Gold Standard VERs Verified Carbon Standard (VCS) VCUs …alone -
( =) What is “equivalent” to Green-e? or Carbon
offset project Greenhouse gas emissions reduc2on Retail carbon offset product End-‐use consumer Carbon Offset Market -‐ Oversight -
( =) What is “equivalent” to Green-e? or The
American Carbon Registry The Climate Ac2on Reserve The Gold Standard The Verified Carbon Standard Carbon offset project Greenhouse gas emissions reduc2on Retail carbon offset product End-‐use consumer Carbon Offset Market -‐ Oversight Registry account-‐ holders/retailers • Permanence • Addi1onality • Verified • Enforceable • Real -
( =) What is “equivalent” to Green-e? or The
American Carbon Registry The Climate Ac2on Reserve The Gold Standard The Verified Carbon Standard Carbon offset project Greenhouse gas emissions reduc2on Retail carbon offset product End-‐use consumer Carbon Offset Market -‐ Oversight Registry account-‐ holders/retailers • Permanence • Addi1onality • Verified • Enforceable • Real Looks for the Green-‐e Logo -
• Permanence • Addi1onality • Verified
• Enforceable • Real The American Carbon Registry The Climate Ac2on Reserve The Gold Standard The Verified Carbon Standard Carbon offset project Greenhouse gas emissions reduc2on Retail carbon offset product End-‐use consumer Registry account-‐ holders/retailers Looks for the Green-‐e Logo • Cer1fies the retail carbon offset product • Looks back at the chain of custody to: § Set a standard for project standard eligibility § Verify chain of custody from project to end user in registries • Verifies the retail transac1on for correct delivery and unique ownership ( =) What is “equivalent” to Green-e? or -
LEED v4 Effect on the Markets for Renewable Energy and
Carbon Offsets • Importance of long-‐term purchasing is addressed, transi1on may not be smooth • Per-‐MWh prices for long-‐term REC contracts higher, and prices already likely to rise as market demand meets supply • U1lity green electricity programs may benefit, as long-‐term par1cipa1on is easier and poses less risk • Number of buildings choosing the point likely to decrease vs using LEED 2009, slowing growth of RE MWh for LEED -
LEED v4 Effect on the Markets for Renewable Energy and
Carbon Offsets • Compe11on between RE and offsets for electricity emissions • Offset markets will benefit overall • Renewable MWh s1ll chosen for electricity due to price • Total emissions addressed by LEED buildings, and purchases of offsets and renewable MWh, will rise overall • Interna1onal projects benefit, as point can be met with offsets rather than only US RECs -
Summary and Conclusions • Green power/Renewable Energy and Carbon Offset
points in 3 of 5 new LEED ra1ng systems • 2 possible points in BD&C and ID&C, and 4 possible points for RE or offset in EBOM (up to 5 total with on-‐site RE) • 50 or 100% of energy use in BD&C and ID&C, 0-‐100% in EBOM • 2005 online date • 5-‐year commitments in BD&C and ID&C, 2-‐year commitment with renewal in EBOM • Green-‐e Energy cer1fica1on required for green power and RECs -
Summary and Conclusions • Green-‐e Climate cer1fica1on required for carbon
offsets • Offsets for US buildings met with US offsets • REC ownership/re1rement required for all renewable energy usage claims in the US • There is no “equivalent” of Green-‐e; purchasers of uncer1fied products will need to demonstrate assurances; project cer1fica1ons alone are not equivalent • RE and offset markets likely to grow; RE perhaps more slowly • Cost of RE in point will increase, likely to remain below offset prices -
? ? Todd Jones Green-e Climate Manager Center for Resource
Solutions [email protected] CONTACT @greenemarktplc facebook.com/CenterForResourceSolutions Alex Pennock Green-e Energy Manager Center for Resource Solutions [email protected]