Share
Embed
How Many Bought Backlinks Survive a Year? A 15,389-Link Audit
How many bought backlinks still work a year later? We audited 15,389 Fiverr and Kwork links: only 3.7% are in Google's index, a third are dead, and 14.8% are blocked by noindex, robots.txt or canonical. Full data and charts: https://en.speedyindex.com/cases/marketplace-backlinks-one-year-later/
Linda Bjorkvin PRO
November 02, 2026
Transcript
12 slides
-
CASE STUDY · BOUGHT-LINK AUDIT · SPEEDYINDEX Bought Backlinks One
Year Later: 15,389 Links Audited Links bought on Fiverr and Kwork, crawled as Googlebot Smartphone on August 21, 2026 and checked in Google’s index on October 29, 2026. 3.7% of the links are in Google’s index 562 URLs Bought backlinks one year later 01 -
THE DATASET 15,389 bought URLs. Every one checked, no sampling.
12,350 from Fiverr 2,886 from Kwork Profiles, Web 2.0, forum and comment links, articles, PBN links Tier 1, Tier 2 and Tier 3 packages from different sellers Each link came with the seller’s placement report Source: SpeedyIndex case study, October 29, 2026 153 from other marketplaces Link age: 13,742 older than 12 months, 1,572 aged 6–12 months, 75 under 6 months Googlebot Smartphone UA, Chrome TLS fingerprint, redirects not followed 02 -
WHAT GOOGLE ACTUALLY SEES 562 of 15,388 checked URLs are
indexed 3.7% Live, open and indexed: only 277 links, 1.8%. Out of every 100 links bought, fewer than two actually work. Screenshot from the case study: bought links vs. links open and in Google’s index. 15,388 URLs were checked: two links that differed only in letter case were merged 03 -
SIX OUTCOMES A YEAR LATER Only 21% of the bought
links are live, open pages Live and open 21.0% Dead 33.7% Error response 13.4% Redirected elsewhere Cloudflare challenge Blocked from indexing One primary outcome per URL. Cloudflare-challenged URLs count as unverified, not dead. 3,231 URLs 5,179 URLs 2,063 URLs 11.9% 1,837 URLs 11.9% 1,832 URLs 8.1% 1,247 URLs 04 -
WHY LINKS STOP WORKING DNS failures and deleted pages lead
the list Screenshot from the case study: the 12 most common causes. Bought backlinks one year later 2,626 URLs (17.1%): domain does not resolve 1,885 (12.2%): 404, page deleted 1,837 (11.9%): 3xx redirect to another URL 566 (3.7%): redirect to the homepage 547 meta robots noindex, 337 robots.txt Disallow, 194 X-RobotsTag 05 -
LINK AGE Early on pages get deleted. Later, whole domains
vanish. SIGNAL 6–12 MONTHS · 1,572 URLS OLDER THAN 12 MONTHS · 13,742 URLS Domain not resolving (DNS) 2.3% 24.9% 23.4% 3.8% 18.5% 10.8% 20.8% 3.6% Deleted pages (404) Working links Indexed In both cohorts about a third of links are dead. DNS failures are 8× more common in the older cohort: typically nobody renewed the domain. Indexed: 60 / 1,572 and 494 / 13,742 06 -
FIVERR VS KWORK More working links on Kwork, the same
third dead Working Dead Indexed Screenshot from the case study: outcomes by marketplace. Bought backlinks one year later FIVERR KWORK 19.4% 33.9% 3.6% 27.5% 33.4% 3.4% Indexed: 442 / 12,350 and 97 / 2,886. Neither marketplace guarantees a link will survive a year. 07 -
A 200 STATUS IS NOT ENOUGH A page that loads
fine can still block Google 4,750 URLs returned HTTP 200 15.7% of them carry noindex 32.4% have an indexing block of any kind Counting every blocking signal (noindex, robots.txt Disallow, a canonical pointing elsewhere), 14.8% of all bought links are blocked from indexing. Even among technically clean pages, only 8.6% are indexed (277 / 3,231). Check the directives, not just the status code 08 -
CLOSED PAGE T YPES The homepage is open. The profile
you bought is not. Screenshot from the case study: one bought link from each of 4,512 sites. 1,829 open page types · 308 could not be checked 457 blocked page types on 443 sites On 266 of them the homepage is open: only that page type is blocked Example: trello.com is open, but user profiles (trello.com/u/{id}) are blocked by robots.txt and meta noindex 09 -
CHECKLIST 8 steps before and after you pay 1 Check
the linking site first Is the domain or section in Google’s index at all? 2 Look for noindex and X-Robots-Tag Also robots.txt Disallow and a foreign canonical. 3 Check the report for 404s 4 Catch redirects 5 Check for server errors 6 Re-check at 3, 6 and 12 months 7 Get live links indexed 8 Index gradually Deletions cause most losses in the first months. 5xx and timeouts are early signs of a dying site. A live link that is not indexed is wasted money too. Bought backlinks one year later A 301/302 to the homepage is not the link you paid for. Links die gradually; audits show what still works. Spread a large package out instead of one day. 10 -
METHOD AND LIMITATIONS What this audit does and does not
show One set of our own orders, two dates: crawl on August 21, 2026, index check on October 29, 2026 Redirects were recorded as returned (301, 302, 307, 308), not followed The Cloudflare JS challenge was not bypassed: 1,832 URLs count as unverified, not dead Each URL has one primary outcome; the 14.8% “blocked” figure counts every signal, so it is higher than the 8.1% group The crawl measured technical indexability; index presence was checked separately Bought backlinks one year later 11 -
FULL DATA, CHARTS AND TABLES Read the complete case study
en.speedyindex.com/cases/marketplace-backlinks-one-year-later/ A note on the rules: Google’s spam policies list buying or selling links for ranking purposes as link spam; paid links are fine only when qualified with rel="nofollow" or rel="sponsored". This audit adds a second problem: a year later, most such links simply do not work. SpeedyIndex · case study published October 29, 2026 12