Share
Embed
North Atlantic polar mesoscale cyclones in ERA5 and ERA-Interim reanalyses
Denis Sergeev
June 18, 2019
Transcript
98 slides
-
North Atlantic polar mesoscale cyclones in ERA5 and ERA-Interim reanalyses
Denis Sergeev, Ian Renfrew, Thomas Spengler, Annick Terpstra, Shun-ichi Watanabe IGP workshop | University of East Anglia, UK | 18 June 2019 @meteodenny -
Take-home message 1. First polar mesoscale cyclone climatology using ERA5
shows improvements in reproducing key statistics and geographical patterns. 2. Cyclone occurrence in ERA5 is closer to that in satellite studies due to higher spatial resolution, which better captures wind gradients. 3. Cyclone tracking shows limited sensitivity to the time resolution, with a 6-hourly time interval being sufficient. -
In this talk... • What are PMCs and why we
use reanalyses for PMC climatology -
In this talk... • What are PMCs and why we
use reanalyses for PMC climatology • Case study of ACCACIA PMC -
In this talk... • What are PMCs and why we
use reanalyses for PMC climatology • Case study of ACCACIA PMC • Automatic tracking algorithm -
In this talk... • What are PMCs and why we
use reanalyses for PMC climatology • Case study of ACCACIA PMC • Automatic tracking algorithm • Verification of tracking -
In this talk... • What are PMCs and why we
use reanalyses for PMC climatology • Case study of ACCACIA PMC • Automatic tracking algorithm • Verification of tracking • Geographical patterns of cyclone occurrence -
In this talk... • What are PMCs and why we
use reanalyses for PMC climatology • Case study of ACCACIA PMC • Automatic tracking algorithm • Verification of tracking • Geographical patterns of cyclone occurrence • PMC characteristics -
In this talk... • What are PMCs and why we
use reanalyses for PMC climatology • Case study of ACCACIA PMC • Automatic tracking algorithm • Verification of tracking • Geographical patterns of cyclone occurrence • PMC characteristics • How to reproduce this study -
Polar mesoscale cyclones (PMCs) - maritime - tropospheric - short-lived
& sub-synoptic-scale - poleward of the main polar front -
Polar mesoscale cyclones (PMCs) - maritime - tropospheric - short-lived
& sub-synoptic-scale - poleward of the main polar front a PMC event during IGP 8 Feb 2018 Greenland Sea Image courtesy G.W.K. Moore -
Polar mesoscale cyclones (PMCs) - maritime - tropospheric - short-lived
& sub-synoptic-scale - poleward of the main polar front a PMC event during IGP 8 Feb 2018 Greenland Sea Image courtesy Dundee Satellite Receiving Station Image courtesy G.W.K. Moore -
Polar mesoscale cyclones (PMCs) - maritime - tropospheric - short-lived
& sub-synoptic-scale - poleward of the main polar front Image courtesy Dundee Satellite Receiving Station a PMC event during IGP 8 Feb 2018 Greenland Sea Image courtesy G.W.K. Moore Image courtesy Dundee Satellite Receiving Station -
Climatologies of polar mesoscale cyclones • Interaction with global climate
system, e.g. the ocean circulation and sea ice • Socio-economic impact -
Climatologies of polar mesoscale cyclones • Interaction with global climate
system, e.g. the ocean circulation and sea ice • Socio-economic impact Bracegirdle & Gray (2008) Verezemskaya+ (2017) Stoll+ (2018) -
Climatologies of polar mesoscale cyclones • Interaction with global climate
system, e.g. the ocean circulation and sea ice • Socio-economic impact - Satellite-based: irregular retrievals, limited extent, subjectivity - Earlier reanalysis studies: low resolution, limited extent Bracegirdle & Gray (2008) Verezemskaya+ (2017) Stoll+ (2018) -
1979 - 31 Aug 2019 1950 - present ~79 km
(T L 255) ~31 km (T L 639) ERA-Interim ERA5 ERA-Interim -
1979 - 31 Aug 2019 1950 - present ~79 km
(T L 255) ~31 km (T L 639) 60 levels up to 0.1 hPa 137 levels up to 0.01 hPa ERA-Interim ERA5 ERA-Interim -
1979 - 31 Aug 2019 1950 - present ~79 km
(T L 255) ~31 km (T L 639) 60 levels up to 0.1 hPa 137 levels up to 0.01 hPa 6 h (plus 3 h forecast fields) 1 h ERA-Interim ERA5 ERA-Interim -
1979 - 31 Aug 2019 1950 - present ~79 km
(T L 255) ~31 km (T L 639) 60 levels up to 0.1 hPa 137 levels up to 0.01 hPa 6 h (plus 3 h forecast fields) 1 h Input obs. like in ERA-40 and from GTS + various newly reprocessed datasets and recent instruments that could not be ingested in ERA-Interim ERA-Interim ERA5 ERA-Interim -
1979 - 31 Aug 2019 1950 - present ~79 km
(T L 255) ~31 km (T L 639) 60 levels up to 0.1 hPa 137 levels up to 0.01 hPa 6 h (plus 3 h forecast fields) 1 h Input obs. like in ERA-40 and from GTS + various newly reprocessed datasets and recent instruments that could not be ingested in ERA-Interim No uncertainty estimate 10-member Ensemble of Data Assimilations ERA-Interim ERA5 ERA-Interim -
1979 - 31 Aug 2019 1950 - present ~79 km
(T L 255) ~31 km (T L 639) 60 levels up to 0.1 hPa 137 levels up to 0.01 hPa 6 h (plus 3 h forecast fields) 1 h Input obs. like in ERA-40 and from GTS + various newly reprocessed datasets and recent instruments that could not be ingested in ERA-Interim No uncertainty estimate 10-member Ensemble of Data Assimilations ~100 parameters ~240 parameters ERA-Interim ERA5 ERA-Interim -
1979 - 31 Aug 2019 1950 - present ~79 km
(T L 255) ~31 km (T L 639) 60 levels up to 0.1 hPa 137 levels up to 0.01 hPa 6 h (plus 3 h forecast fields) 1 h Input obs. like in ERA-40 and from GTS + various newly reprocessed datasets and recent instruments that could not be ingested in ERA-Interim No uncertainty estimate 10-member Ensemble of Data Assimilations ~100 parameters ~240 parameters Consistent SST and sea ice ERA-Interim ERA5 ERA5 wins! -
1979 - 31 Aug 2019 1950 - present ~79 km
(T L 255) ~31 km (T L 639) 60 levels up to 0.1 hPa 137 levels up to 0.01 hPa 6 h (plus 3 h forecast fields) 1 h Input obs. like in ERA-40 and from GTS + various newly reprocessed datasets and recent instruments that could not be ingested in ERA-Interim No uncertainty estimate 10-member Ensemble of Data Assimilations ~100 parameters ~240 parameters Consistent SST and sea ice ERA-Interim ERA5 ERA5 wins! -
ACCACIA polar low 26 Mar 2013 Image courtesy Dundee Satellite
Receiving Station -
ACCACIA polar low 26 Mar 2013 Vorticity Image courtesy Dundee
Satellite Receiving Station -
ACCACIA polar low 26 Mar 2013 Vorticity Wind speed Image
courtesy Dundee Satellite Receiving Station -
ACCACIA polar low 26 Mar 2013 Scatterometer Vorticity Wind speed
Image courtesy Dundee Satellite Receiving Station -
ACCACIA polar low 26 Mar 2013 Scatterometer ERA5 Vorticity Wind
speed Image courtesy Dundee Satellite Receiving Station -
ACCACIA polar low 26 Mar 2013 ERA-Interim Scatterometer ERA5 Vorticity
Wind speed Image courtesy Dundee Satellite Receiving Station -
ACCACIA polar low 26 Mar 2013 More detailed analysis: Sergeev+,
QJRMS (2017) ERA-Interim Scatterometer ERA5 Vorticity Wind speed Image courtesy Dundee Satellite Receiving Station -
ACCACIA polar low 26 Mar 2013 More detailed analysis: Sergeev+,
QJRMS (2017) ERA5 better reproduces • Asymmetric structure of vorticity patterns and mesoscale troughs • “Double-winged” wind field with sharp horizontal gradients ERA-Interim Scatterometer ERA5 Vorticity Wind speed Image courtesy Dundee Satellite Receiving Station -
Automatic PMC tracking • Uses relative vorticity maxima • Suitable
for detecting and tracking small cyclones embedded in large-scale cyclones View from above Code: github.com/dennissergeev/pmctrack -
Automatic PMC tracking • Uses relative vorticity maxima • Suitable
for detecting and tracking small cyclones embedded in large-scale cyclones Vorticity vs distance View from above Code: github.com/dennissergeev/pmctrack -
Automatic PMC tracking • Uses relative vorticity maxima • Suitable
for detecting and tracking small cyclones embedded in large-scale cyclones Vorticity vs distance View from above Code: github.com/dennissergeev/pmctrack -
Automatic PMC tracking • Uses relative vorticity maxima • Suitable
for detecting and tracking small cyclones embedded in large-scale cyclones Vorticity vs distance View from above Code: github.com/dennissergeev/pmctrack -
Automatic PMC tracking • Uses relative vorticity maxima • Suitable
for detecting and tracking small cyclones embedded in large-scale cyclones Vorticity vs distance View from above Code: github.com/dennissergeev/pmctrack -
Automatic PMC tracking • Uses relative vorticity maxima • Suitable
for detecting and tracking small cyclones embedded in large-scale cyclones • Developed by Watanabe+ (2016, 2017, 2018) for mesoscale cyclones in the Sea of Japan Vorticity vs distance View from above Code: github.com/dennissergeev/pmctrack -
Automatic PMC tracking • Uses relative vorticity maxima • Suitable
for detecting and tracking small cyclones embedded in large-scale cyclones • Developed by Watanabe+ (2016, 2017, 2018) for mesoscale cyclones in the Sea of Japan Vorticity vs distance View from above Code: github.com/dennissergeev/pmctrack -
Parameters in this study • Data: ◦ ERA-Interim (0.5°⨉0.5° grid)
◦ ERA5 (0.25°⨉0.25° grid) • Period: 18 extended winter seasons (1 Oct 2000 - 30 Apr 2018) • Extent: 65°N-85°N, 20°W-50°E • Time interval ◦ ERA-Interim: 3 h ◦ ERA5: 1 h • Other parameters - same as in Watanabe+ (2017) -
Reference dataset: STARS • Intense PMCs (polar lows) in the
Nordic Seas • Coverage: 2002-2011 • Compiled by forecasters on duty at the Norwegian Met Institute • Publicly available at http://polarlow.met.no/stars-dat • Has been used by for PMC tracking verification (Zappa+ 2014; Michel+ 2018; Stoll+ 2018) Exactly 100 STARS tracks are used -
(Optional) How to match automatic tracks to the observed ones?
Observed Tracked -
(Optional) How to match automatic tracks to the observed ones?
Observed Tracked ? -
(Optional) How to match automatic tracks to the observed ones?
• Usually some arbitrary distance threshold • Requires interpolation in time etc. Observed Tracked ? -
(Optional) How to match automatic tracks to the observed ones?
• Usually some arbitrary distance threshold • Requires interpolation in time etc. • A better choice: a non-dimensional distance metric (Blender & Schubert, 2000) Observed Tracked ? -
(Optional) How to match automatic tracks to the observed ones?
• Usually some arbitrary distance threshold • Requires interpolation in time etc. • A better choice: a non-dimensional distance metric (Blender & Schubert, 2000) Observed Tracked ? (x 1 , y 1 , t 1 ) (x 2 , y 2 , t 2 ) -
(Optional) How to match automatic tracks to the observed ones?
• Usually some arbitrary distance threshold • Requires interpolation in time etc. • A better choice: a non-dimensional distance metric (Blender & Schubert, 2000) Observed Tracked ? (x 1 , y 1 , t 1 ) (x 2 , y 2 , t 2 ) -
(Optional) How to match automatic tracks to the observed ones?
• Usually some arbitrary distance threshold • Requires interpolation in time etc. • A better choice: a non-dimensional distance metric (Blender & Schubert, 2000) Observed Tracked ? (x 1 , y 1 , t 1 ) (x 2 , y 2 , t 2 ) -
• 88 are detected in ERA5, compared to 64 in
ERA-Interim • Rate similar to those using Arctic System Reanalysis (Smirnova & Golubkin, 2017; Stoll+ 2018) • Detection rate sensitive to the vorticity threshold • Longer time intervals are sufficient Sensitivity to: Vorticity threshold Time interval -
Cyclone density spatial distribution ERA5 ERA-Interim • ERA5 maximum: 20
PMCs per 104 km2 per winter • Western part of the Barents Sea • ERA-Interim maximum is close to Svalbard - likely due to orographic vorticity filaments • ERA-Interim: track density is too low Genesis density derived from satellite passive microwave data over 14 winters (Smirnova+ 2015) -
PMC characteristics MIN(SLP 0 , …, SLP N ) SLP
0 SLP N SLP 1 -
A typical wintertime PMC ERA5 ERA-Interim Frequency [PMC per week]
6 1 Lifetime [h] 21 21 Total distance [km] 900 700 Propagation speed [km h-1] 42 34 Approx. size [km] 150 250 Max vorticity [10-4 s-1] 4.5 2.5 Min SLP [hPa] 993 988 Take-home message: our results show North Atlantic PMCs as smaller but more intense and faster-moving vortices compared to most previous climatologies. -
Conclusions • First PMC climatology based on ERA5 & using
new tracking algorithm Submitted to GRL! -
Conclusions • First PMC climatology based on ERA5 & using
new tracking algorithm • Overall, ERA5 provides a refined picture of PMC activity over the NE Atlantic compared to ERA-Interim Submitted to GRL! -
Conclusions • First PMC climatology based on ERA5 & using
new tracking algorithm • Overall, ERA5 provides a refined picture of PMC activity over the NE Atlantic compared to ERA-Interim • Time resolution - less crucial for PMC tracking once it is above a certain threshold, so can save computational resources Submitted to GRL! -
Conclusions • First PMC climatology based on ERA5 & using
new tracking algorithm • Overall, ERA5 provides a refined picture of PMC activity over the NE Atlantic compared to ERA-Interim • Time resolution - less crucial for PMC tracking once it is above a certain threshold, so can save computational resources • PMCs tend to form and develop over the Barents Sea, close to areas of high occurrence of CAOs (more info - in Annick’s talk!) Submitted to GRL! -
Conclusions • First PMC climatology based on ERA5 & using
new tracking algorithm • Overall, ERA5 provides a refined picture of PMC activity over the NE Atlantic compared to ERA-Interim • Time resolution - less crucial for PMC tracking once it is above a certain threshold, so can save computational resources • PMCs tend to form and develop over the Barents Sea, close to areas of high occurrence of CAOs (more info - in Annick’s talk!) Submitted to GRL! Thank you! -
Conclusions • First PMC climatology based on ERA5 & using
new tracking algorithm • Overall, ERA5 provides a refined picture of PMC activity over the NE Atlantic compared to ERA-Interim • Time resolution - less crucial for PMC tracking once it is above a certain threshold, so can save computational resources • PMCs tend to form and develop over the Barents Sea, close to areas of high occurrence of CAOs (more info - in Annick’s talk!) Submitted to GRL! P.S. Key aspects of PMC climatology are very sensitive to what tracking method is used and how cyclones are selected - but it’s almost impossible to know what code was used for the analysis Thank you! -
How this study can be reproduced 0. Data • Freely
available on Copernicus • Downloading can be automated with Python libraries (cdsapi and ecmwfapi) -
How this study can be reproduced 0. Data • Freely
available on Copernicus • Downloading can be automated with Python libraries (cdsapi and ecmwfapi) 1. Cyclone tracking • PMCTRACK algorithm (Fortran library with netCDF interface) • http://github.com/dennissergeev/pmctrack -
How this study can be reproduced 0. Data • Freely
available on Copernicus • Downloading can be automated with Python libraries (cdsapi and ecmwfapi) 1. Cyclone tracking • PMCTRACK algorithm (Fortran library with netCDF interface) • http://github.com/dennissergeev/pmctrack 2. Postprocessing and analysis • Octant (Python package) • http://github.com/dennissergeev/octant -
How this study can be reproduced 0. Data • Freely
available on Copernicus • Downloading can be automated with Python libraries (cdsapi and ecmwfapi) 1. Cyclone tracking • PMCTRACK algorithm (Fortran library with netCDF interface) • http://github.com/dennissergeev/pmctrack 2. Postprocessing and analysis • Octant (Python package) • http://github.com/dennissergeev/octant 3. Plotting • Jupyter Notebooks and Python scripts • http://github.com/dennissergeev/mc_era5