Chain rule arXiv:2107.05355v1 musing

אם ירצה ה׳

Every time you adjust your morning coffee grind, unlock your phone with a glance, or wonder why a USD $200 payment bumps your credit score?

The Chain Rule is pulsing underneath. It’s calculus’s engine for asking: how does a tiny change at the start ripple through layers to the end?

Uwe Naumann’s 2021 paper On the Computational Complexity of the Chain Rule of Differential Calculus (arXiv:2107.05355v1) shows that finding the perfect order to compute that ripple is NP-complete. Not “hard” but provably un-optimizable. No supercomputer, no future algorithm will ever guarantee the absolute fastest path.

So how does backpropagation in AI “just work”? Heuristics. The paper shows that forward and reverse modes inherit the same hardness; they simply hide it in human-engineered shortcuts. Your phone, GPS, and lender all gamble on “good enough” multiplication order. We compress the infinite search into a blink.

Below a visual travelogue from Naumann’s prime-encoded lock to the espresso in your hand. No equations, just the hidden calculus of everyday rebellion against exponential darkness.

We live inside chain rule approximations. What's amazing is that 'pretty good' is usually perfect for living.

שבת שלום

Transcript