Upgrade to Pro — share decks privately, control downloads, hide ads and more …

Rebel Rebel: a case study on taking the opposite approach

Rebel Rebel: a case study on taking the opposite approach

Products we’re passionate about start by scratching an itch; we have a problem we want to solve. But with a marketplace crowded with options and the likelihood it’s been tried before, how do we approach it in a way that’s fresh enough to attract users?

In this case study, Hannah and Matt will share the thinking and process behind their product This Is My Jam, an unconventional approach to song sharing.

Learn about the benefits of (and techniques for) questioning established product and technical orthodoxy; the role style and trends play in product appeal; and victories as well as mistakes from the early days of prototyping Jam.

Hannah Donovan

April 12, 2013
Tweet

More Decks by Hannah Donovan

Other Decks in Design

Transcript

  1. Rebel Rebel
    Hannah Donovan & Matthew Ogle
    UX London 2013

    View Slide

  2. HI!
    @han
    we are…
    & @flaneur

    View Slide

  3. Product patterns
    Trend, anti-trend
    The story of Jam
    In this
    talk…

    View Slide

  4. Product patterns
    Trend, anti-trend
    The story of Jam
    1
    2
    3
    In this
    talk…
    GO

    View Slide

  5. There are two big problems
    in online music:

    View Slide

  6. There are two big problems
    in online music:
    I want to listen to ‘my’
    music – when, where
    and how I want
    Access
    * For varying definitions of ‘my’

    View Slide

  7. There are two big problems
    in online music:
    I want to listen to ‘my’
    music – when, where
    and how I want
    Access
    * For varying definitions of ‘my’
    I need ‘new’ music
    Discovery
    and ‘new’

    View Slide

  8. View Slide

  9. View Slide

  10. View Slide

  11. View Slide

  12. View Slide

  13. View Slide

  14. View Slide

  15. View Slide

  16. Access Discovery
    Music Startups by Primary Focus

    View Slide

  17. Access Discovery
    Music Startups by Primary Focus
    1998
    Napster
    2006
    Last.fm
    Pandora
    YouTube
    2004
    MySpace
    2010 +
    Turntable.fm
    Jam
    iTunes Match
    2002
    iTunes Store
    2000
    iPod
    2008
    Spotify
    GrooveShark

    View Slide

  18. Access Discovery
    Music Startups by Primary Focus
    1998
    Napster
    2006
    Last.fm
    Pandora
    YouTube
    2004
    MySpace
    2010 +
    Turntable.fm
    Jam
    iTunes Match
    2002
    iTunes Store
    2000
    iPod
    2008
    Spotify
    GrooveShark

    View Slide

  19. Access & discovery are examples
    of 1st and 2nd order problems

    View Slide

  20. Access & discovery are examples
    of 1st and 2nd order problems
    1st order
    Infrastructure
    Tools
    Needs

    View Slide

  21. Access & discovery are examples
    of 1st and 2nd order problems
    1st order
    Infrastructure
    Tools
    Needs
    2nd order
    Community
    Play
    Wants

    View Slide

  22. Access & discovery are examples
    of 1st and 2nd order problems
    1st order
    Infrastructure
    Tools
    Needs
    2nd order
    Community
    Play
    Wants
    Government consensus Public gov.uk website

    View Slide

  23. Access & discovery are examples
    of 1st and 2nd order problems
    1st order
    Infrastructure
    Tools
    Needs
    2nd order
    Community
    Play
    Wants
    Government consensus Public gov.uk website

    View Slide

  24. Access & discovery are examples
    of 1st and 2nd order problems
    1st order
    Infrastructure
    Tools
    Needs
    2nd order
    Community
    Play
    Wants
    Government consensus Public gov.uk website
    Sodastream™

    View Slide

  25. Access & discovery are examples
    of 1st and 2nd order problems
    1st order
    Infrastructure
    Tools
    Needs
    2nd order
    Community
    Play
    Wants
    Government consensus Public gov.uk website
    Clean tap water Sodastream™

    View Slide

  26. 1
    st
    or
    2nd
    ?
    Both are important but require different strategies.

    View Slide

  27. Find out as early as possible
    which type of problem you
    like working on.
    It will make
    you happier.

    View Slide

  28. 1
    st
    order
    products
    2nd
    order
    Second order products
    usually require a stable first
    order product or system in
    their space first.

    View Slide

  29. Access Discovery
    Music Startups by Primary Focus
    1998
    Napster
    iPod
    2006
    Spotify
    GrooveShark
    2004
    Last.fm
    Pandora
    YouTube
    2010
    Turntable.fm
    Jam
    iTunes Match
    2002
    MySpace
    2000 2008

    View Slide

  30. First order Second order
    Product Opportunities by Problem Type
    Infrastructure
    Tools
    Needs
    Community
    Play
    Wants

    View Slide

  31. First order Second order
    Product Opportunities by Problem Type
    Infrastructure
    Tools
    Needs
    Community
    Play
    Wants
    Trends
    & taste
    matter more

    View Slide

  32. New trends often emerge in
    opposition to previous ones.

    View Slide

  33. New trends often emerge in
    opposition to previous ones.
    70s

    View Slide

  34. New trends often emerge in
    opposition to previous ones.
    70s
    80s

    View Slide

  35. New trends often emerge in
    opposition to previous ones.
    70s
    80s
    90s

    View Slide

  36. New trends often emerge in
    opposition to previous ones.
    70s
    80s
    90s
    00s

    View Slide

  37. New trends often emerge in
    opposition to previous ones.
    70s
    80s
    90s
    00s
    …and we wanted to make a
    new music discovery service
    201
    1
    it
    was

    View Slide

  38. We noticed:
    In 2011, music discovery apps
    were borrowing many trends
    from online culture in general.

    big data / algorithms

    social = real-time feeds, updated frequently

    more content = better; playlists as base unit

    “spreadsheet music”

    View Slide

  39. Imagined
    Opposite
    ✤ 100% hand-picked
    ✤ Slow
    ✤ Less content; a song as
    base unit
    ✤ Visual culture of music;
    personal expression
    If you want to create something playful, a good
    exercise is to imagine the opposite.
    ✤ Big data / algorithms
    ✤ Fast (real time)
    ✤ More content; a playlist
    as base unit
    ✤ “spreadsheet music”
    201
    1
    Status Quo

    View Slide

  40. This Is My Jam
    1 2

    View Slide

  41. This Is My Jam
    1 2

    View Slide

  42. And we recently reached 1million jams shared
    (slowly and thoughtfully).
    Chris Thorpe @jaggeree
    @ThisIsMyJam is closest thing I've felt for a while to the John Peel
    show I remember from youth. You may not like all but discovery is key.
    27 Jan 12
    “Here’s the deal: you get one song at a
    time and that’s all you get. That’s your
    jam. Simple. I like it”
    “This is My Jam is part of a growing, and
    overdue, movement… fucking delightful”

    View Slide

  43. It’s worked surprisingly well, but we’ve also
    grappled with mistakes along the way:
    Mobile native vs. web first?
    When is a constraint too much?
    How do you know the ‘first order’ infrastructure
    is reliable?
    ?

    View Slide

  44. 1
    2
    3
    Are you trying to solve a first or second
    order problem?
    Both are valuable but have different
    properties. How does that affect you?
    If you’re solving a second order problem,
    how does it interact with larger trends?

    View Slide

  45. And imagine the
    OPPOSITE
    You might just create something new
    that meets emerging desires.

    View Slide