Monday, 13 September 2010 History Analysis Systems KTH SUPD Manoochehri 100913 H N p c METABOLISM SYMBIOSIS R E S I L I E N C E SOCIETY LIFESTYLES INFRASTRUCTURE BUILT ENVIRONMENT CITIES BIOCYCLING SERVICE-USE RECYCLING URBAN SUSTAINABILITY PT I
Romantics Muir, Ruskin, Thoreau: late 19th C Early Scientists Pinchot, Leopold, Geddes: 19th-20th 20th C Disasters Minamata Bay, Torrey Canyon, Chernobyl: 60s-80s Scientists Carson, Meadows, Commoner, Ehrlich: 60s, 70s Green Ideologues Kelly, Bahro, Porritt: 80s IDEA HISTORY
Romantics Muir, Ruskin, Thoreau: late 19th C Early Scientists Pinchot, Leopold, Geddes: 19th-20th 20th C Disasters Minamata Bay, Torrey Canyon, Chernobyl: 60s-80s Scientists Carson, Meadows, Commoner, Ehrlich: 60s, 70s Green Ideologues Kelly, Bahro, Porritt: 80s IDEA HISTORY
Romantics Muir, Ruskin, Thoreau: late 19th C Early Scientists Pinchot, Leopold, Geddes: 19th-20th 20th C Disasters Minamata Bay, Torrey Canyon, Chernobyl: 60s-80s Scientists Carson, Meadows, Commoner, Ehrlich: 60s, 70s Green Ideologues Kelly, Bahro, Porritt: 80s IDEA HISTORY
Romantics Muir, Ruskin, Thoreau: late 19th C Early Scientists Pinchot, Leopold, Geddes: 19th-20th 20th C Disasters Minamata Bay, Torrey Canyon, Chernobyl: 60s-80s Scientists Carson, Meadows, Commoner, Ehrlich: 60s, 70s Green Ideologues Kelly, Bahro, Porritt: 80s IDEA HISTORY
Romantics Muir, Ruskin, Thoreau: late 19th C Early Scientists Pinchot, Leopold, Geddes: 19th-20th 20th C Disasters Minamata Bay, Torrey Canyon, Chernobyl: 60s-80s Scientists Carson, Meadows, Commoner, Ehrlich: 60s, 70s Green Ideologues Kelly, Bahro, Porritt: 80s IDEA HISTORY
Romantics Muir, Ruskin, Thoreau: late 19th C Early Scientists Pinchot, Leopold, Geddes: 19th-20th 20th C Disasters Minamata Bay, Torrey Canyon, Chernobyl: 60s-80s Scientists Carson, Meadows, Commoner, Ehrlich: 60s, 70s Green Ideologues Kelly, Bahro, Porritt: 80s IDEA HISTORY
own living environment Wise-use Lack of strategy in exploiting resources Industrial Ugliness Machinery harming Nature, humankind brutalising/being brutalised Enlightenment Inverted Separation from natural systems, lack of immediate feedbacks, lack of contextual limits Hypertechnology, Systems Complexity Super-pollution, Mega-catastrophe Politico-economic ‘anthropocentrism’ (c.f. ‘geocentrism’) Defective theories of economic development
own living environment Wise-use Lack of strategy in exploiting resources Industrial Ugliness Machinery harming Nature, humankind brutalising/being brutalised Enlightenment Inverted Separation from natural systems, lack of immediate feedbacks, lack of contextual limits Hypertechnology, Systems Complexity Super-pollution, Mega-catastrophe Politico-economic ‘anthropocentrism’ (c.f. ‘geocentrism’) Defective theories of economic development EARLY IDEAS
positive effects than - ve Dream in the future Mechanism > through ages Rel independent with E + R ‘Place that works’ Respect for nature and equity Small footprint, or offset Needs of present > future Development vs Resources Reduce impact + human needs Needs in balance with Res Self-sufficient Balancing growth vs Res Planned to conserve Res Place that works out Self-sustaining Needs vs Resources/Nature Nature not disrupted, QL up I-O balance, via indiv + grp Knowledge? Manages different R Solving problems in v parad’s
can sustain More positive effects than - ve Dream in the future Mechanism > through ages Rel independent with E + R ‘Place that works’ Respect for nature and equity Small footprint, or offset Needs of present > future Development vs Resources Reduce impact + human needs Needs in balance with Res Self-sufficient Balancing growth vs Res Planned to conserve Res Place that works out Self-sustaining Needs vs Resources/Nature Nature not disrupted, QL up I-O balance, via indiv + grp Knowledge? Manages different R Solving problems in v parad’s
Policy? Industry Policies Standards > Business Models ? Campaigning Organisations, Campaigns, Information > Policy, Lobbying Social Debate, Media, Personal Concern ACTION TYPES
Policy? Industry Policies Standards > Business Models ? Campaigning Organisations, Campaigns, Information > Policy, Lobbying Social Debate, Media, Personal Concern > Information Campaigns ACTION TYPES
Policy? Industry Policies Standards > Business Models ? Campaigning Organisations, Campaigns, Information > Policy, Lobbying Social Debate, Media, Personal Concern > Information Campaigns Discourse ACTION TYPES
Policy? Industry Policies Standards > Business Models ? Campaigning Organisations, Campaigns, Information > Policy, Lobbying Social Debate, Media, Personal Concern > Information Campaigns Discourse Sustainable development ACTION TYPES
Policy? Industry Policies Standards > Business Models ? Campaigning Organisations, Campaigns, Information > Policy, Lobbying Social Debate, Media, Personal Concern > Information Campaigns Discourse Sustainable development > Sustainable development? ACTION TYPES
Government Agencies and Ministries Policies Regulatory: Preservation, Anti-pollution Fiscal: Resource-use taxes, Behaviour taxes, Funding for research Informational: consumer education/information Discourse Sustainable development
Government Agencies and Ministries Policies Regulatory: Preservation, Anti-pollution Fiscal: Resource-use taxes, Behaviour taxes, Funding for research Informational: consumer education/information Discourse Sustainable development POLICY ACTION
positive effects than - ve Dream in the future Mechanism > through ages Rel independent with E + R ‘Place that works’ Respect for nature and equity Small footprint, or offset Needs of present > future Development vs Resources Reduce impact + human needs Needs in balance with Res Self-sufficient Balancing growth vs Res Planned to conserve Res Place that works out Self-sustaining Needs vs Resources/Nature Nature not disrupted, QL up I-O balance, via indiv + grp Knowledge? Manages different R Solving problems in diff
can sustain More positive effects than - ve Dream in the future Mechanism > through ages Rel independent with E + R ‘Place that works’ Respect for nature and equity Small footprint, or offset Needs of present > future Development vs Resources Reduce impact + human needs Needs in balance with Res Self-sufficient Balancing growth vs Res Planned to conserve Res Place that works out Self-sustaining Needs vs Resources/Nature Nature not disrupted, QL up I-O balance, via indiv + grp Knowledge? Manages different R Solving problems in diff
can sustain More positive effects than - ve Dream in the future Mechanism > through ages Rel independent with E + R ‘Place that works’ Respect for nature and equity Small footprint, or offset Needs of present > future Development vs Resources Reduce impact + human needs Needs in balance with Res Self-sufficient Balancing growth vs Res Planned to conserve Res Place that works out Self-sustaining Needs vs Resources/Nature Nature not disrupted, QL up I-O balance, via indiv + grp Knowledge? Manages different R Solving problems in diff City? Future? Needs? Power? Future Needs? Lifestyle? I-O? Harmony?
VS SUSTAINABLE TOTAL MATERIALISATION? CONDITIONED MATERIALISATION? DESIGN VS ENGINEERING DESIGN? CREATIVITY? HUMAN DEVELOPMENT CREATIVITY FREEDOM OBSCURITY? COHERENT STRUCTURE? MASKING OF POLITICS? SOCIAL ISSUES? APPROPRIATE RELATIONSHIP? SERIOUS TREATMENT? COST? FEASIBLE? COST EFFECTIVE? 0 CRITIQUE
the Crisis of Civilization | Lewis Mumford The Steady-State Economy | Herman Daly The Metabolism of Cities | Herbert Girardet Urban Planning in Curitiba | Rabinovitch and Leitman CLASSIC OF SUSTAINABILITY SCIENCE CLASSIC OF URBANISM TEXT ON SUSTAINABLE URBANISM
present ideas, e.g. animal liberation ANALYSIS is there an idea crisis? explain and critique 1234 SYSTEMS describe/draw concepts of urban resource system management
present ideas, e.g. animal liberation ANALYSIS is there an idea crisis? explain and critique 1234 SYSTEMS describe/draw concepts of urban resource system management describe/draw practice example
present ideas, e.g. animal liberation ANALYSIS is there an idea crisis? explain and critique 1234 SYSTEMS describe/draw concepts of urban resource system management describe/draw practice example TO CLARIFY - NO MORE THAN TWO PAGES PER TASK, UNLESS U UP 4 IT - BRING DRAWINGS OF SYSTEMS TASKS FOR PRESENTATION IN CLASS - DISCUSS READINGS, WRITING, AND DRAWINGS IN YOUR GROUPS
Monday, 13 September 2010 History Analysis Systems KTH SUPD [email protected] 100913 H N p c METABOLISM SYMBIOSIS R E S I L I E N C E SOCIETY LIFESTYLES INFRASTRUCTURE BUILT ENVIRONMENT CITIES BIOCYCLING SERVICE-USE RECYCLING URBAN SUSTAINABILITY PT I