CERAMENT™ PMMA CaS-based materials CaP-based materials Injectability Very high, also in high viscosity mode Very high. However, for high viscosity mode special injection systems may be needed Basically high, but commercially available products have very short working time Low flowability, high risk for separation between water and powder Stiffness Mimics cancellous bone 100-300x cancellous bone with increased risk of adjacent fractures Initial stiffness similar to cancellous bone, however becomes a non-supportive slurry before sufficient bone ingrowth has occurred. Stiffer than cancellous bone with increased risk of adjacent fractures Remodelling Becomes bone within months No Yes, in small defects. In defects > 5mm, resorbs too quickly and bone growth will cease resulting in non-union Non-remodelling / very slow (years). Brittle ceramic materials that crack with time Setting temp. /
time 37°C / 1 hour 70-95°C / 30 min -1 hour 45-50°C / 1 hour 37°C / 24-72 hours Radiopacity Protected technology for non-ionic radiocontrast media Non-radiopaque. Requires addition of barium sulfate or zirconium oxide1) Non-radiopaque. Additives cannot be used given that they are toxic when exposed to circulation Non-radiopaque. Additives cannot be used given that they are toxic when exposed to circulation Crystallization Process Restarts if disturbed
e.g. by patient movements Polymerization process to make it harden Restarts if disturbed in a limited period of time (< 10min) Halted by movements in the implant. Results in micro-cracks and non-complete hardening CONCLUSION Ideal bone substitute for osteoporotic VCF Sub-optimal material for osteoporotic VCF (risk for adjacent fractures, no remodelling, high setting temp) Unsuitable for KP or VP (short working time, quick resorption, inferior visibility) Unsuitable for KP or VP (long setting time with risk for micro-cracks with movement, low flowability) 1) These compounds are cytotoxic and cause thrombophlebitis when exposed to the circulation. They are able to be used in PMMA given that PMMA is not expected to be exposed to the circulation ✓ ✗ ✓ ✓ ✓/✓ ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓ ✗ ✗/✓ ✓ ✓ ✗ ✓ ✓ ✗ ✗ ✗/✓ ✗ ✗ ✗ ✗ ✗ ✗ ✗ ✗ ✓/✗