Brilliant Discussion

Transcript

1. !"#$%&'"()($*)+(,-&& ./,&!,$0&$%1&)/,&21,$0&& !*3/$(1&4(*00*$%)5&6./,&7+)/"(*)8&"9& :*;,%,<<=&9("#&!"#$#%&$'#(5&>>?&@ABCC?&&

2. D(,,&E(*),& 733"(1*%F&)"&8"+5&G/$)&$(,&)/,&,<<,%H$0& I+$0*H,<&"9&$&6>"()($*)=J&&E/$)&$(,&)/,& ,<<,%H$0&I+$0*H,<&"9&$&)""*&>"()($*)J&

3. K"G&1*<3+<<&8"+(&1,L%*H"%<&G*)/& 8"+(&%,*F/M"(?&

4. N3,%,<&9("#&)/,&OPQR&!,S"0)&*%&4+1$>,<)5&T+%F$(8?& U%&>F?&@A&$%1&@C&4(*00*$%)&)$0;<&$M"+)&6)($%<9,(,%3,?=&& E/$)&*<&)/,&>"G,(&"9&<$8*%F5&6./*<&*<&V<"&$%1&<"W=&*%&(,F$(1& )"&$&*#$F,J&&T"G&1",<&)/*<&$>>08&)"&<"#,&"9&)/,&G"(;&G,& /$S,&<,,%&<"&9$(J&

5. X$%& X$%&<3"01<&)/,&6/,$1=&"9&N)$0*%5&4+1$>,<)5&T+%F$(85&OPQR?&

6. X$%&<3"01<&)/,&6/,$1=&"9&:,%*%5&!+<<*$5&OPYPZOPP[?&

7. X"<3"G&<3/""0&3/*01(,%&(,<)&"%&$&)">>0,1& <)$)+,&"9&N)$0*%5&OPPO?&&

8. N)$)+,&"9&N$11$#&T+<<,*%&M,*%F&)">>0,1&M8&\?N?& X$(*%,5&4$F1$15&E,1%,<1$8&7>(*0&P5&@[[A?&

9. T"G&1",<&,I+$H%F&$&>"()($*)&G*)/& 60*;,%,<<=&0*#*)&)/,&>"),%H$0&"9&*#$F,<& F*S,%&)/$)&0$M,0J&T"G&*<&1,L%*%F&$&>"()($*)& $<&61,>*3H"%&"9&)/,&*%1*S*1+$0&*%&/*<&"G%& 3/$($3),(=&>("M0,#$H3J&

10. 7%%,B:"+*<&]*("1,)&.(*"<"%5&!"#$#%&$+ ",+-(%./0%123$(+0(44(55&O^P^?&

11. '($_*),0,<5&6`$>*)"0*%,& N$)8(5=&3?&@%1&3,%)+(8&4`a?& 7%%,B:"+*<&]*("1,)&.(*"<"%5&!"#$#%&$+ ",+-(%./0%123$(+0(44(55&O^P^?&

12. Portrait Head of an Elder. Roman Republican, c.80 BCE. Augustus

    Primaporta, Roman Imperial 1st century CE.

13. Augustus Primaporta, Roman Imperial 1st century CE. 4+<)&"9&U3)$S*$%5&!"#$%&!,>+M0*3$%5&3?& AP&4`a& 7F,-&@C&

    7F,-&^^&

14. '(,<*1,%)<&E$</*%F)"%5&b,c,(<"%5&!""<,S,0)5&$%1& :*%3"0%&"%&X)?&!+</#"(,5&N"+)/&d$;")$5&OP@Q&e,<)?f& E/$)&,c,3)&1",<&;%"G*%F&"(&%")&;%"G*%F& )/,&<+Mg,3)&e)/,&6%$#,=f&"9&$&6>"()($*)=&/$S,& "%&8"+(&*%),(>(,)$H"%&"9&*)J&

15. 29&$&<+Mg,3)&3$%%")&M,&*1,%HL,1&M8&%$#,5&*<&*)& <H00&$&>"()($*)J&

16. T"G&*<&$&6>,(9,3)&0*;,%,<<=& 1,),(#*%,1&$%1&3"%<)(+3),1J&&E/"& 3"%<)(+3)<&)/,#J&&&

17. 7(H<)&$<&7F,%)& 62)&*<&%")&4$+1,0$*(,hM+)&*)&*<&$&/,$1&)/$)& (,<,#M0,<&4$+1,0$*(,?&&./,(,&$(,&$&<,(*,<& "9&3/$($3),(*<H3<&)/$)h>(,<,(S,&)/,& 3,(,M($0&3"%9"(#$H"%&$%1&)/$)&3"(,& 3$00<&)/,&)8>,i&)/*<&M+<)&*<&"9&$&1($j<#$%& %$#,1&X$0),<),&G/"&</"G<&$00&)/,& 3/$($3),(*<H3<&"9&)/,&4$+1,0$*(,$%&#$<;?&& N,,&)/,&,%"(#"+<&9"(,/,$15&<G"00,%&$)& )/,&),#>0,<5&1,%),15&)"(#,%),15&

    /$%1<"#,5&%,S,()/,0,<<h)/,&,8,<&/$S,& )/,&0"";&"9&1*<1$*%i&)/,&#"+)/&*<& <$(3$<H35&M*k,(&*%&*)<&<*%+"+<&0*%,5&M+)& )/,&<G,00*%F&"9&)/,&#+<30,<5&$&0*k0,&9$)5& $%%"+%3,<&)/,&S"0+>)+"+<&$>>,H),<?&&2%& </"()5&*)&*<&4$+1,0$*(,?=& 7+F+<),&!"1*%5&T,$1&"9&4$+1,0$*(,5&OYP@?& !"1*%5&U%&)/,&'"()($*)5&3?&OYP@?&

18. E/$)&*<&)/,&"%,&9,$)+(,&#"<)&+<,1&)"& 1,),(#*%,&0*;,%,<<J&&E/$)&*<&"+(& $k$3/#,%)&)"&)/$)&9,$)+(,J&

19. \N&2##*F($H"%&$%1& K$)+($0*l$H"%&N,(S*3,& D"(#&

20. b"/%&D(,1,(*3;&',)"5& 6(7&.&38(.8(3+",+9:;<5& $j,(&OP[[?&

21. d"BT"&N+/5&=.&/>"#73?3@+A(4,/!"#$#%&$?3@+B5+CD+E(%#35&@[[R?&

22. d"BT"&N+/5&F&)G+A8G""4+=.&/>%8(@+0"5H+OPP^?&&