Share
Embed
Transcript
15 slides
-
Discussion: Art and the Ideal in Ancient Greece
Plato, “The Quarrel Between Philosophy and Poetry: From The Republic, Book X” from Aesthe&cs: A Cri&cal Anthology, pp. 20-‐31. -
Terms for Plato: • Techne (Tek-‐nay): Any applicaMon of
skill or knowledge (includes: carpentry, painMng, poetry, rhetoric, governing, etc.) • Mimesis (Mi-‐may-‐sis): ImitaMon of Truth, especially in reference to the work of the “craQsman.” • Essence/Truth: The highest (or “Truest”) form of existence, all-‐encompassing and unchanging. This is what Forms refer to. -
What is the fate of arMsts in Plato’s Republic?
What does this have to do with the bed analogy? Free Write -
God CraQsman Painter Form Product
Semblance Real Real Not Real Hierarchy of Form -
Forms of Cogni,on Degree of Reality
Examples Knowledge/ Understanding A Intelligible Forms (ex. Form of the Good) Thought B MathemaMcal/ TheoreMcal Belief C Visible Physical Objects Conjecture/ ImaginaMon D Shadows and Images Towards a higher form cogniMon Towards more “real” objects Hierarchy of Thought -
According to Plato, how are “painters” like “poets”?
How are they different? -
What does Plato say about emoMon? How is the
human mind weak? -
In this reading, Plato makes a lot of damning
claims about the acMons of the arMst. How does this apply to the “Canons” we have discussed? -
The Canon of Polykleitos 5-‐40, Polykleitos, Doryphoros (Spear Bearer),
Roman Copy from Greek Original, High Classical c. 5th Century CE -
Thesis Statements… • …orient the reader to your topic
and how you will be wriMng about it. • …tells the reader what they are reading, why they are reading, and what they will find out. • …set up your argument, judgment, or insight you will be providing the reader. • …should be specific, clear, and usually argue a single point. -
Thesis Statements There are many differences and similariMes between
the Last Suppers of Tintorego and da Vinci. Weak In Tintorego’s Last Supper, food takes a much more prominent social and narraMve role than in da Vinci’s Last Supper. Strongest I would like to talk about the representaMon of food in the da Vinci’s Last Supper and Tintorego’s Last Supper. Stronger