Upgrade to Pro — share decks privately, control downloads, hide ads and more …

Comparative Education - Teacher Professionalism

Nirankoon
August 22, 2016

Comparative Education - Teacher Professionalism

CHAPTER 4
TEACHER PROFESSIONALISM
(Focusing on Japan and USA)
Assoc. Prof. Dr. Athithouthay CHATOUPHONEXAY
2013-2014

Nirankoon

August 22, 2016
Tweet

More Decks by Nirankoon

Other Decks in Education

Transcript

  1. Comparative Education CHAPTER 4 TEACHER PROFESSIONALISM (Focusing on Japan and

    USA) Assoc. Prof. Dr. Athithouthay CHATOUPHONEXAY 2013-2014
  2. International Trends in Education • Teacher as a professional •

    Learner-Centered methodology • EFA • Gender Education • Inclusive Education • ASEAN Community in 2015 • English as a globalized language • World Class University • University without walls • Knowledge-based society • Borderless Teacher Education • The Best and the Brightest • Nano Technology……………………….
  3. Professionals Who are professionals? • Scientist • Engineer • Pilot

    • Doctor • Teacher • Soldier • Police • Lawyer • Manager/Administrator
  4. Teacher as….. (Western) • Trainer • Coach • Facilitator •

    Scaffolder • Researcher • Curriculum Developer • Guide • Helper • Community Developer • Agent of Change Q: What is an ‘armchair researcher’?
  5. Teacher as…… (Lao)  Temple Education ( Buddhism, Lao and

    ….)  French Education (French educational system)  Western Education (American educational system)  Socialist Education (State and Religion)  Democratic Education (State + Religion) • Second Parent • Blue Print/Printing House • Person of the Party • Soul Engineer
  6. Teacher as……….. (Malaysian) • Knowledge Practitioner • Skill Practitioner •

    Value Inculcator • Educator • Agent of Socialization • Agent of Change • Community Innovator • Nation-Builder • Knowledge Disseminator • Caring Intellectual • Consultant • Mentor • Manager • Researcher • Patriot
  7. What will happen? • Poor design • Poor landing •

    Poor treatment • Poor teaching • Poor military training • Poor security • Poor judgment • Poor management/administration
  8. Contents of TP • Introduction • What is Teacher Professionalism?

    • The professional roles of teachers • Professional Development • Reflections • References
  9. Is teaching a profession or not? Some educators say: •

    What is taught, how it is taught and when it is taught depends on Ts themselves • Students are taught by several people (Formal, Informal and Non-formal) • Teachers are monitored and supervised • Teachers are usually not well-paid
  10. Types of Professionalism • Classical professionalism • Flexible professionalism •

    Practical professionalism • Extended professionalism • Complex professionalism All depends on the social, cultural and political environment of the society
  11. Education of Origin • Laos (Temple education) • Vietnam (Confucius

    education) • Thailand (Temple education) • Malaysia (Islamic education) • Singapore (Western Education) • Korea (Confucius education) • Japan (Confucius education) • China (Confucius education) • Iran (Islamic education) • USA (Western education) Q: What do you think ‘Kouam Ru Ku Kunnatham’?
  12. Prestigious Educational Institutions • NUOL Laos • ……… Vietnam •

    Chulalongkorn Uni. Thailand • SNU Singapore • SKY Korea • …… Japan • Howard USA • Cambridge UK • Oxford UK
  13. Problems • Shortage of teachers in many Asian countries •

    In Laos, besides….Maths and Nat Sci • The number of teachers retiring has grown in recent years • A large number of new teachers are needed due to EFA • Large number of qualified teachers in Africa are victims of AIDS • In Thailand, low achievement of Math and Natural sciences among M.Pay
  14. Effective Measures • Peer support and collaboration • Supportive environment

    • Openness to observation and critique • Commitment to professional growth • The use of micro-teaching • Socialization
  15. Interesting facts and arguments • Professionalization and professionalism • In

    USA, teaching as a profession is problematic. -Children have many teachers -Teacher’s decision making is controlled -Teachers often teach curriculum that they do not choose or that was developed by individuals who are not teachers -Teachers are often relatively low paid
  16. Interesting facts and arguments • Due to Sputnik satellite in

    1957, American teachers have been accused of failing to adequately prepared students in the areas of Math and science. • American teachers stated concepts to students 78% of the time, while Japanese teachers developed concepts with students 83% of the time.
  17. Interesting facts and arguments • The Ministry of Education, Culture,

    Sports, Science and Technology has recently initiated reforms to encourage Japanese students to ‘think, judge, and act independently’. • Japan seeks to continue to construct its Japaneseness, ‘ a modern-yet not Western-culture’, while simultaneously integrating what have often been considered Western values namely, individualism and democracy.
  18. What is the difference? Phylosophical Concept: Japan : Collectivism USA

    : Individualism Example: Mod Deng Alawad and Rambo, Arnold, Van Dam,…
  19. Interesting facts and arguments • In Japan, Families place a

    great deal of importance on education, and children grow up with the message that education is valuable. • The high social value attached to education has been a prominent historical feature of Japanese society.
  20. Interesting facts and arguments • Since the beginning of modernization

    in the 19th century, Japanese teachers ‘have been viewed as agents of character development and nation- building. • The high status of Japanese teachers is not dependent on their having received an advanced degree but their salaries are based on professional longevity, and their salaries increase in relation to that of other public workers.
  21. Interesting facts and arguments • American teachers complain of exceptionally

    low prestige in a land that claimed consensus among Japanese educators universal education. • There is the Japanese public opinion that teaching is a combination of science and artistry. Professional development in Japan reinforces this notion.
  22. Interesting facts and arguments • American scholar Linda Darling-Hammond (2000)

    has argued that a professional is ‘ one who learns from teaching rather than one who has finished learning how to teach(p.170). • It is also considered that teachers who possess more knowledge of the process of teaching and learning as opposed to more subject expertise are more effective in the classroom.
  23. Most people learn…. 10% of what they READ 20% of

    what they HEAR 30% of what they SEE 50% of what they SEE and HEAR 70% of what they Talk over with others 80% of what they USE and DO in real life 95% of what they ……….someone else (William Glasser, 1988)
  24. Interesting facts and arguments • Most Americans view teachers as

    public servants who are accountable to school officials, parents, and the public at large. Thus, in many situations, teachers can be told what to do by parents and other citizens, principals, superintendents and school board members, even when these directives go against the teachers’ professional judgments.
  25. Interesting facts and arguments • In ancient times, teaching in

    Japan was considered a sacred profession, as teachers were commissioned to serve the Emperor. • Now, although Japanese teachers spend more hours at school, they do not teach all day, as do American teachers. • The researchers found that only 60% of Japanese teachers’ time is devoted to classroom teaching; the rest is spent to extracurricular duties and school activities.
  26. Interesting facts and arguments • Teacher authority in the Japanese

    context emerges from teachers’ interaction with students rather than teachers demanding respect from their students. • Novice teachers in the USA are often warned to not be friends with their students. The Concept: ‘ Invisible Pedagogy’
  27. Interesting facts and arguments • While Japanese students have 40

    days of summer vacation, 14 days of winter vacation, and another 14 days of spring vacation, their teachers of ten work during these periods. • Since teaching is considered a full- time occupation, teachers’ salaries reflect 12 months of work, and teachers are forbidden to do any other paid work, even on their own time.
  28. Interesting facts and arguments • When misbehavior does occur outside

    school, the witnesses report it to the school as opposed to the family. • In case of stealing, teachers, principals, and parents must all apologize in person to the store owners.
  29. Interesting facts and arguments • Leadership roles are rotated so

    that all Japanese students are provided opportunities to assume authority in the classroom. • Particular features of Japanese schools support the development of NINGEN and peer relationships. Although classes average about 30 students each, the HAN (a group of 4 children) creates a family- like unit in which students participate together in activities throughout the school day.
  30. Interesting facts and arguments • Besides HAN, the 240-day school

    year in Japan, compared with 180-day school year in the USA • What about Laos? • What about Thailand? • What about Vietnam?
  31. Interesting facts and arguments • Active participation is a common

    feature of Japanese elementary instruction. Okano and Tsuchiya (1999), citing the work of Sato (1998), stated that more than 60% of Japanese classroom teachers direct their instruction to their less academically able students. • American teachers direct theirs to those that are considered above average.
  32. Interesting facts and arguments Avoidance of Textbook-Dominated Instruction • Findings

    from the TIMSS have revealed that the Japanese curriculum is more focused and in-depth compared with the breath of topics that US students are exposed to during a given school year. • The Concept: BREATH and DEPTH
  33. Interesting facts and arguments Avoidance of Textbook-Dominated Instruction • Regarding

    depth rather than breadth, Japanese educators teach fewer topics and devote more time to a selected number of them when compared with curricular in other nations. • This became a philosophy of LESS is MORE.
  34. Interesting facts and arguments • Japanese teachers did not use

    rewards, punishments, or threats. • There is a common teachers’ room for regular collegial contact with a professional code of conduct. • Isolation seemed to characterize teaching for a host of American teachers. Slang : Pigeon Hole
  35. Interesting facts and arguments • Japan, Hong Kong, Malaysia, Singapore,

    South Korea have been looking to find ways to pursue creative innovation in addition to academic rigor. • Infant mortality, malnutrition, child abuse, family stability, parental drug abuse, poverty-Japanese children are extraordinarily fortunate (almost 100% of class attendance for children 6-15 years of age).
  36. The 4 Pillars of Education Source: UNESCO, 1996 Learn to

    KNOW Learn to DO Learn to BE Learn to LIVE TOGETHER
  37. What about Laos? The 5 Pillars of Education: • Panya

    Suksa Knowledge • Khounsombath Suksa Morale • Silapa Suksa Arts • Phala Suksa Phys. Ed (Sports) • Hengngan Suksa Manual work Source: Ministry of Education and Sports (2012)
  38. Say good bye to………… • Chalk and talk and No

    walk • Sage on the stage • One-Man-Show teaching style • Spoon-fed / Bucket filling • Parrot learning • Teach as Taught • No Smile until Christmas • Shoes of one- size-to-fit-all-feet • More is more Why? Because it limits INNOVATION and CREATIVITY
  39. STUDIES IN COMPARATIVE EDUCATION LEARNING TO LIVE TOGETHER: BUILDING SKILLS,

    VALUES AND ATTITUDES FOR THE TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY Margaret Sinclair INTERNATIONAL BUREAU OF EDUCATION © UNESCO: International Bureau of Education, Geneva, 2004
  40. References • Patricia, K.K., & Paul, R. F. (2007). Comparative

    Education: Exploring Issues in International Context. Pearson: Merrill Prentice Hall. • Mok, S. S. (2005). Education Studies for KPLI: Teacher Professionalism. Multimedia-ES Resources Sdn. Bhd. • UNESCO PRINCIPAL REGIONAL OFFICE FOR ASIA AND THE PACIFIC, BANGKOK, 1998. LEARNING TO LIVE TOGETHER IN PEACE AND HARMONY. UNESCO APNIEVE.