Share
Embed
Тестирование на основе сетей Петри
A talk about automated exploratory testing based on Petri net models for HeisenBug Piter 2018 (https://2018.heisenbug-piter.ru/talks/2018/spb/6feubdtqqwqocya2w4cwq2/). The recording of the talk is available on YouTube (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TeKHZw61pb8).
Alex Rodionov
May 17, 2018
Transcript
181 slides
-
ДЛЯ КОГО? 1.Для тех, у кого много тестов и багов.
2.Для тех, кто только планирует автоматизированное тестирование. 11 -
1. Недостаточность обычных тестов 2. Тестирование на основе моделей 3.
Сети Петри 4. Тестирование на основе сетей Петри -
1. Недостаточность обычных тестов 2. Тестирование на основе моделей 3.
Сети Петри 4. Тестирование на основе сетей Петри -
ОБЫЧНЫЙ ТЕСТ Arrange: выполняет предусловия Act: выполняет какое-то действие Assert:
верифицирует состояние/поведение 20 -
ОБЫЧНЫЙ ТЕСТ Arrange: выполняет предусловия Act: выполняет какое-то действие Assert:
верифицирует состояние/поведение 21 -
23 class User < ApplicationRecord end it 'destroys user’ do
user = User.create! user.destroy expect(User.count).to eq(0) end -
24 arrange act assert class User < ApplicationRecord end it
'destroys user’ do user = User.create! user.destroy expect(User.count).to eq(0) end -
25 class User < ApplicationRecord end it 'destroys user’ do
user = User.create! user.destroy expect(User.count).to eq(0) end -
26 class User < ApplicationRecord has_many :notes end class Note
< ApplicationRecord belongs_to :user end it 'destroys user’ do user = User.create! user.destroy expect(User.count).to eq(0) end -
27 class User < ApplicationRecord has_many :notes end class Note
< ApplicationRecord belongs_to :user end it 'destroys user with a note’ do user = User.create!(note: Note.create!) user.destroy expect(User.count).to eq(0) end -
28 class User < ApplicationRecord has_many :notes end class Note
< ApplicationRecord belongs_to :user end it 'destroys user with a note’ do user = User.create!(note: Note.create!) user.destroy expect(User.count).to eq(0) end -
29 class User < ApplicationRecord has_many :notes end class Note
< ApplicationRecord belongs_to :user end ActiveRecord ::InvalidForeignKey: PG ::ForeignKeyViolation: ERROR: update or delete on table "users" violates foreign key constraint “fk_rails_83d9817008" on table "notes" DETAIL: Key (id)=(1) is still referenced from table “notes". -
30 class User < ApplicationRecord has_many :notes, dependent: :destroy end
class Note < ApplicationRecord belongs_to :user end it 'destroys user with a note’ do user = User.create!(note: Note.create!) user.destroy expect(User.count).to eq(0) end -
31 class User < ApplicationRecord has_many :notes, dependent: :destroy end
class Note < ApplicationRecord belongs_to :user end it 'destroys user with a note’ do user = User.create!(note: Note.create!) user.destroy expect(User.count).to eq(0) end -
1. Недостаточность обычных тестов 2. Тестирование на основе моделей 3.
Сети Петри 4. Тестирование на основе сетей Петри -
50 @GraphWalker(value = "random(edge_coverage(100))", start = "v_NotesListView") public class NotesListTest
{ @Override public void e_GoToNewNoteView() { } } -
51 @GraphWalker(value = "random(edge_coverage(100))", start = "v_NotesListView") public class NotesListTest
{ @Override public void e_GoToNewNoteView() { driver.pressKeyCode(AndroidKeyCode.KEYCODE_MENU); driver.findElementByClassName("android.widget.TextView").click(); } } -
52 @GraphWalker(value = "random(edge_coverage(100))", start = "v_NotesListView") public class NotesListTest
{ @Override public void e_Discard() { driver.pressKeyCode(AndroidKeyCode.KEYCODE_MENU); driver.findElementByClassName("android.widget.TextView").click(); } } -
53 @GraphWalker(value = "random(edge_coverage(100))", start = "v_NotesListView") public class NotesListTest
{ @Override public void e_Create() { } } -
54 @GraphWalker(value = "random(edge_coverage(100))", start = "v_NotesListView") public class NotesListTest
{ @Override public void e_Create() { String noteName = "test+" + new Random().nextInt(); } } -
55 @GraphWalker(value = "random(edge_coverage(100))", start = "v_NotesListView") public class NotesListTest
{ @Override public void e_Create() { String noteName = "test+" + new Random().nextInt(); driver.findElement(By.xpath(" //android.widget.EditText[1]")) .sendKeys(noteName); } } -
56 @GraphWalker(value = "random(edge_coverage(100))", start = "v_NotesListView") public class NotesListTest
{ @Override public void e_Create() { String noteName = "test+" + new Random().nextInt(); driver.findElement(By.xpath(" //android.widget.EditText[1]")) .sendKeys(noteName); driver.hideKeyboard(); driver.pressKeyCode(AndroidKeyCode.KEYCODE_BACK); } } -
57 @GraphWalker(value = "random(edge_coverage(100))", start = "v_NotesListView") public class NotesListTest
{ @Override public void e_Create() { String noteName = "test+" + new Random().nextInt(); driver.findElement(By.xpath(" //android.widget.EditText[1]")) .sendKeys(noteName); driver.hideKeyboard(); driver.pressKeyCode(AndroidKeyCode.KEYCODE_BACK); expectedNumberOfNotes ++; } } -
58 @GraphWalker(value = "random(edge_coverage(100))", start = "v_NotesListView") public class NotesListTest
{ @Override public void v_NotesListView() { } } -
59 @GraphWalker(value = "random(edge_coverage(100))", start = "v_NotesListView") public class NotesListTest
{ @Override public void v_NotesListView() { WebElement notesList = driver.findElementByClassName("android.widget.TextView"); assertTrue(notesList.getText().equals("Note pad”)); } } -
60 @GraphWalker(value = "random(edge_coverage(100))", start = "v_NotesListView") public class NotesListTest
{ @Override public void v_NotesListView() { WebElement notesList = driver.findElementByClassName("android.widget.TextView"); assertTrue(notesList.getText().equals("Note pad”)); List<WebElement> notesInList = driver.findElement(By.className("android.widget.ListView")) .findElements(By.className("android.widget.TextView")); int actualNumberOfNotes = notesInList.size(); assertEquals(expectedNumberOfNotes, actualNumberOfNotes); } } -
61 @GraphWalker(value = "random(edge_coverage(100))", start = "v_NotesListView") public class NotesListTest
{ @Override public void v_NewNoteView() { } } -
62 @GraphWalker(value = "random(edge_coverage(100))", start = "v_NotesListView") public class NotesListTest
{ @Override public void v_NewNoteView() { WebElement notesEditor = driver.findElementByClassName("android.widget.EditText"); Assert.assertTrue(notesEditor.isDisplayed()); } } -
64 $ mvn graphwalker:test [INFO] Tests: [INFO] NotesListTest(RandomPath, VertexCoverage, 100)
Before element v_NotesListView After element v_NotesListView -
65 $ mvn graphwalker:test [INFO] Tests: [INFO] NotesListTest(RandomPath, VertexCoverage, 100)
Before element v_NotesListView After element v_NotesListView Before element e_GoToNewNoteView After element e_GoToNewNoteView -
66 $ mvn graphwalker:test [INFO] Tests: [INFO] NotesListTest(RandomPath, VertexCoverage, 100)
Before element v_NotesListView After element v_NotesListView Before element e_GoToNewNoteView After element e_GoToNewNoteView Before element v_NewNoteView After element v_NewNoteView -
67 $ mvn graphwalker:test [INFO] Tests: [INFO] NotesListTest(RandomPath, VertexCoverage, 100)
Before element v_NotesListView After element v_NotesListView Before element e_GoToNewNoteView After element e_GoToNewNoteView Before element v_NewNoteView After element v_NewNoteView Before element e_Create After element e_Create -
68 $ mvn graphwalker:test [INFO] Tests: [INFO] NotesListTest(RandomPath, VertexCoverage, 100)
Before element v_NotesListView After element v_NotesListView Before element e_GoToNewNoteView After element e_GoToNewNoteView Before element v_NewNoteView After element v_NewNoteView Before element e_Create After element e_Create Before element v_NotesListView After element v_NotesListView -
69 $ mvn graphwalker:test [INFO] Tests: [INFO] NotesListTest(RandomPath, VertexCoverage, 100)
Before element v_NotesListView After element v_NotesListView Before element e_GoToNewNoteView After element e_GoToNewNoteView Before element v_NewNoteView After element v_NewNoteView Before element e_Create After element e_Create Before element v_NotesListView After element v_NotesListView Before element e_GoToNewNoteView After element e_GoToNewNoteView -
70 $ mvn graphwalker:test [INFO] Tests: [INFO] NotesListTest(RandomPath, VertexCoverage, 100)
Before element v_NotesListView After element v_NotesListView Before element e_GoToNewNoteView After element e_GoToNewNoteView Before element v_NewNoteView After element v_NewNoteView Before element e_Create After element e_Create Before element v_NotesListView After element v_NotesListView Before element e_GoToNewNoteView After element e_GoToNewNoteView Before element v_NewNoteView After element v_NewNoteView -
71 $ mvn graphwalker:test [INFO] Tests: [INFO] NotesListTest(RandomPath, VertexCoverage, 100)
Before element v_NotesListView After element v_NotesListView Before element e_GoToNewNoteView After element e_GoToNewNoteView Before element v_NewNoteView After element v_NewNoteView Before element e_Create After element e_Create Before element v_NotesListView After element v_NotesListView Before element e_GoToNewNoteView After element e_GoToNewNoteView Before element v_NewNoteView After element v_NewNoteView Before element e_Discard After element e_Discard -
72 $ mvn graphwalker:test [INFO] Tests: [INFO] NotesListTest(RandomPath, VertexCoverage, 100)
Before element v_NotesListView After element v_NotesListView Before element e_GoToNewNoteView After element e_GoToNewNoteView Before element v_NewNoteView After element v_NewNoteView Before element e_Create After element e_Create Before element v_NotesListView After element v_NotesListView Before element e_GoToNewNoteView After element e_GoToNewNoteView Before element v_NewNoteView After element v_NewNoteView Before element e_Discard After element e_Discard Before element v_NotesListView After element v_NotesListView -
1. Недостаточность обычных тестов 2. Тестирование на основе моделей 3.
Сети Петри 4. Тестирование на основе сетей Петри -
СЕТЬ ПЕТРИ 84 позиции (places) хранят метки переходы (transitions) перемещают
метки not created Create User created -
СЕТЬ ПЕТРИ 85 позиции (places) хранят метки дуги связывают позиции
и переходы переходы (transitions) перемещают метки not created Create User created -
СЕТЬ ПЕТРИ 86 позиция not created содержит метку not created
Create User created -
СЕТЬ ПЕТРИ 87 переход Create User может сработать not created
Create User created -
СЕТЬ ПЕТРИ 88 срабатывание удаляет метку из not created и
добавляет в created not created Create User created -
89 1. Переходы могут быть связаны только с позициями (и
наоборот) СЕТЬ ПЕТРИ -
90 1. Переходы могут быть связаны только с позициями (и
наоборот) 2. Переход может сработать когда в каждой входной позиции есть по меньшей мере одна метка СЕТЬ ПЕТРИ -
91 1. Переходы могут быть связаны только с позициями (и
наоборот) 2. Переход может сработать когда в каждой входной позиции есть по меньшей мере одна метка 3. Срабатывание перехода забирает по одной метке из каждой входной позиции и добавляет по одной метке в каждую выходную позицию СЕТЬ ПЕТРИ -
СЕТЬ ПЕТРИ 93 not created Create User created ip allowed
not created Create User created ip allowed -
СЕТЬ ПЕТРИ 95 pending review not created Create User created
pending review not created Create User created -
СЕТЬ ПЕТРИ 97 not created Create User created not created
Create User created -
СЕТЬ ПЕТРИ 101 user not created user created note created
Create User Destroy User -
СЕТЬ ПЕТРИ 102 user not created user created note created
Create User Destroy User Create Note -
СЕТЬ ПЕТРИ 103 user not created user created note created
Create User Destroy User Create Note Destroy Note -
СЕТЬ ПЕТРИ 104 user not created user created note created
Create User Destroy User Create Note Destroy Note -
СЕТЬ ПЕТРИ 105 user not created user created note created
Create User Destroy User Create Note Destroy Note -
СЕТЬ ПЕТРИ 106 user not created user created note created
Create User Destroy User Create Note Destroy Note -
СЕТЬ ПЕТРИ 108 user not created user created note created
Create User Destroy User Create Note Destroy Note post created -
СЕТЬ ПЕТРИ 109 user not created user created note created
Create User Destroy User Create Note Destroy Note post created Create Post -
СЕТЬ ПЕТРИ 110 user not created user created note created
Create User Destroy User Create Note Destroy Note post created Create Post Destroy Post -
СЕТЬ ПЕТРИ 112 user not created user created note created
Create User Destroy User Create Note Destroy Note post created Create Post Destroy Post video created -
СЕТЬ ПЕТРИ 113 user not created user created note created
Create User Destroy User Create Note Destroy Note post created Create Post Destroy Post Create Video video created -
СЕТЬ ПЕТРИ 114 user not created user created note created
Create User Destroy User Create Note Destroy Note post created Create Post Destroy Post Create Video Destroy Video video created -
1. Недостаточность обычных тестов 2. Тестирование на основе моделей 3.
Сети Петри 4. Тестирование на основе сетей Петри -
ТЕСТИРОВАНИЕ НА ОСНОВЕ СЕТЕЙ ПЕТРИ 1.Создаем модель системы используя cеть
Петри 2.Генерируем на основе модели тесты 118 -
СОЗДАНИЕ МОДЕЛИ 120 { "places": [ { "guid": "e57c0830-148f-11e8-bb7f-adf9986e1043", "identifier":
"user created" } ], "transitions": [ { "guid": “df65a6e0-148f-11e8-bb7f-adf9986e1043" "identifier": "Create User", } ], "arcs": [ { "from_guid": "e57c0830-148f-11e8-bb7f-adf9986e1043", "to_guid": “df65a6e0-148f-11e8-bb7f-adf9986e1043" } ] } -
ЗАГРУЗКА СЕТИ 122 class Node def input_arcs # ... end
def output_arcs # ... end end -
ЗАГРУЗКА СЕТИ 123 class Node def input_arcs # ... end
def output_arcs # ... end end class Place < Node end -
ЗАГРУЗКА СЕТИ 124 class Node def input_arcs # ... end
def output_arcs # ... end end class Place < Node end class Transition < Node end -
ЗАГРУЗКА СЕТИ 125 class Node def input_arcs # ... end
def output_arcs # ... end end class Place < Node end class Transition < Node end class Arc def from # ... end def to # ... end end -
ЗАГРУЗКА СЕТИ 126 class Runner def enabled?(transition) # ... end
def fire(transition) # ... end def marking # ... end end -
СВЯЗЬ СЕТИ С ТЕСТОВЫМ КОДОМ 128 user not created user
created note created Create User Destroy User Create Note Destroy Note -
129 user not created user created note created Create User
Destroy User Create Note Destroy Note class UserNoteNet < Rhizome ::Net end -
130 user not created user created note created Create User
Destroy User Create Note Destroy Note class UserNoteNet < Rhizome ::Net runner { Runner.new('user-note.bpf', marking: ['user not created']) } end -
131 class UserNoteNet < Rhizome ::Net runner { Runner.new('user-note.bpf', marking:
['user not created']) } transition('Create User') { @user = User.create! } transition('Destroy User') { @user.destroy } end user not created user created note created Create User Destroy User Create Note Destroy Note -
132 class UserNoteNet < Rhizome ::Net runner { Runner.new('user-note.bpf', marking:
['user not created']) } transition('Create User') { @user = User.create! } transition('Destroy User') { @user.destroy } transition('Create Note') { @note = Note.create!(user: @user) } transition('Destroy Note') { @note.destroy } end user not created user created note created Create User Destroy User Create Note Destroy Note -
133 class UserNoteNet < Rhizome ::Net runner { Runner.new('user-note.bpf', marking:
['user not created']) } transition('Create User') { @user = User.create! } transition('Destroy User') { @user.destroy } transition('Create Note') { @note = Note.create!(user: @user) } transition('Destroy Note') { @note.destroy } place('user not created') do empty { expect(User.count).to be > 0 } filled { expect(User.count).to eq(0) } end end user not created user created note created Create User Destroy User Create Note Destroy Note -
134 class UserNoteNet < Rhizome ::Net runner { Runner.new('user-note.bpf', marking:
['user not created']) } transition('Create User') { @user = User.create! } transition('Destroy User') { @user.destroy } transition('Create Note') { @note = Note.create!(user: @user) } transition('Destroy Note') { @note.destroy } place('user not created') do empty { expect(User.count).to be > 0 } filled { expect(User.count).to eq(0) } end place('user created') do empty { expect(User.count).to eq(0) } filled { expect(User.count).to be > 0 } end end user not created user created note created Create User Destroy User Create Note Destroy Note -
class UserNoteNet < Rhizome ::Net runner { Runner.new('user-note.bpf', marking: ['user
not created']) } transition('Create User') { @user = User.create! } transition('Destroy User') { @user.destroy } transition('Create Note') { @note = Note.create!(user: @user) } transition('Destroy Note') { @note.destroy } place('user not created') do empty { expect(User.count).to be > 0 } filled { expect(User.count).to eq(0) } end place('user created') do empty { expect(User.count).to eq(0) } filled { expect(User.count).to be > 0 } end place('note created') do empty { expect(Note.count).to eq(0) } filled { expect(Note.count).to be > 0 } end end user not created user created note created Create User Destroy User Create Note Destroy Note 135 -
ОБХОД СЕТИ 1. Даем каждому переходу одинаковую вероятность (4 перехода
= 0,25 каждому) 136 -
ОБХОД СЕТИ 1. Даем каждому переходу одинаковую вероятность (4 перехода
= 0,25 каждому) 2. Генерируем случайное число - порог вероятности выбора перехода 137 -
ОБХОД СЕТИ 1. Даем каждому переходу одинаковую вероятность (4 перехода
= 0,25 каждому) 2. Генерируем случайное число - порог вероятности выбора перехода 3. Выбираем первый переход с подходящей под порог вероятностью, который может сработать 138 -
ОБХОД СЕТИ 1. Даем каждому переходу одинаковую вероятность (4 перехода
= 0,25 каждому) 2. Генерируем случайное число - порог вероятности выбора перехода 3. Выбираем первый переход с подходящей под порог вероятностью, который может сработать 4. Срабатываем переход 139 -
ОБХОД СЕТИ 1. Даем каждому переходу одинаковую вероятность (4 перехода
= 0,25 каждому) 2. Генерируем случайное число - порог вероятности выбора перехода 3. Выбираем первый переход с подходящей под порог вероятностью, который может сработать 4. Срабатываем переход 5. Проверяем пустые и заполненные позиции 140 -
ОБХОД СЕТИ 1. Даем каждому переходу одинаковую вероятность (4 перехода
= 0,25 каждому) 2. Генерируем случайное число - порог вероятности выбора перехода 3. Выбираем первый переход с подходящей под порог вероятностью, который может сработать 4. Срабатываем переход 5. Проверяем пустые и заполненные позиции 6. Уменьшаем вероятность сработанного перехода в 2 раза 141 -
ОБХОД СЕТИ 1. Даем каждому переходу одинаковую вероятность (4 перехода
= 0,25 каждому) 2. Генерируем случайное число - порог вероятности выбора перехода 3. Выбираем первый переход с подходящей под порог вероятностью, который может сработать 4. Срабатываем переход 5. Проверяем пустые и заполненные позиции 6. Уменьшаем вероятность сработанного перехода в 2 раза 7. Если все переходы сработали хотя бы раз, останавливаемся. Если нет, повторяем с пункта 2 142 -
144 $ bin/rhizome Traversing user_note net: Initial marking: user not
created Executing Create User New marking: user created Transitions left: Destroy User, Create Note, Destroy Note -
145 $ bin/rhizome Traversing user_note net: Initial marking: user not
created Executing Create User New marking: user created Transitions left: Destroy User, Create Note, Destroy Note Executing Create Note New marking: user created, note created Transitions left: Destroy User, Destroy Note -
146 $ bin/rhizome Traversing user_note net: Initial marking: user not
created Executing Create User New marking: user created Transitions left: Destroy User, Create Note, Destroy Note Executing Create Note New marking: user created, note created Transitions left: Destroy User, Destroy Note Executing Destroy Note New marking: user created Transitions left: Destroy User -
147 $ bin/rhizome Traversing user_note net: Initial marking: user not
created Executing Create User New marking: user created Transitions left: Destroy User, Create Note, Destroy Note Executing Create Note New marking: user created, note created Transitions left: Destroy User, Destroy Note Executing Destroy Note New marking: user created Transitions left: Destroy User Executing Destroy User New marking: user not created Finished traversing user_note net. -
149 $ bin/rhizome Traversing user_note net: Initial marking: user not
created Executing Create User New marking: user created Transitions left: Destroy User, Create Note, Destroy Note -
150 $ bin/rhizome Traversing user_note net: Initial marking: user not
created Executing Create User New marking: user created Transitions left: Destroy User, Create Note, Destroy Note Executing Destroy User New marking: user not created Transitions left: Create Note, Destroy Note -
151 $ bin/rhizome Traversing user_note net: Initial marking: user not
created Executing Create User New marking: user created Transitions left: Destroy User, Create Note, Destroy Note Executing Destroy User New marking: user not created Transitions left: Create Note, Destroy Note Executing Create User New marking: user created Transitions left: Create Note, Destroy Note -
152 $ bin/rhizome Traversing user_note net: Initial marking: user not
created Executing Create User New marking: user created Transitions left: Destroy User, Create Note, Destroy Note Executing Destroy User New marking: user not created Transitions left: Create Note, Destroy Note Executing Create User New marking: user created Transitions left: Create Note, Destroy Note Executing Create Note New marking: user created, note created Transitions left: Destroy Note -
153 $ bin/rhizome Traversing user_note net: Initial marking: user not
created Executing Create User New marking: user created Transitions left: Destroy User, Create Note, Destroy Note Executing Destroy User New marking: user not created Transitions left: Create Note, Destroy Note Executing Create User New marking: user created Transitions left: Create Note, Destroy Note Executing Create Note New marking: user created, note created Transitions left: Destroy Note Executing Destroy Note New marking: user created Finished traversing user_note net. -
155 $ bin/rhizome Traversing user_note net: Initial marking: user not
created Executing Create User New marking: user created Transitions left: Destroy User, Create Note, Destroy Note -
156 $ bin/rhizome Traversing user_note net: Initial marking: user not
created Executing Create User New marking: user created Transitions left: Destroy User, Create Note, Destroy Note Executing Create Note New marking: user created, note created Transitions left: Destroy User, Destroy Note -
157 $ bin/rhizome Traversing user_note net: Initial marking: user not
created Executing Create User New marking: user created Transitions left: Destroy User, Create Note, Destroy Note Executing Create Note New marking: user created, note created Transitions left: Destroy User, Destroy Note Executing Destroy User ActiveRecord ::InvalidForeignKey: PG ::ForeignKeyViolation: ERROR: update or delete on table "users" violates foreign key constraint "fk_rails_83d9817008" on table "notes" DETAIL: Key (id)=(1) is still referenced from table “notes". -
RHIZOME 1. Воспроизводимость тестов с помощью seed 2. Параллелизация как
у любого другого фреймворка 159 -
RHIZOME 1. Воспроизводимость тестов с помощью seed 2. Параллелизация как
у любого другого фреймворка 3. Фреймворк общего назначения (хоть с Selenium) 160 -
ТЕСТИРОВАНИЕ НА ОСНОВЕ СЕТЕЙ ПЕТРИ 1. Тестовое покрытие увеличилось 2.
Время выполнения тестов осталось прежним 165 -
ТЕСТИРОВАНИЕ НА ОСНОВЕ СЕТЕЙ ПЕТРИ 1. Тестовое покрытие увеличилось 2.
Время выполнения тестов осталось прежним 3. Время на написание/поддержку тестов сократилось 166 -
168 user not created user created note created Create User
Destroy User Create Note Destroy Note -
169 user not created user created note created Create User
Destroy User Create Note Destroy Note -
170 user not created user created note created Create User
Destroy User Create Note Destroy Note -
171 user not created user created note created Create User
Destroy User Create Note Destroy Note -
172 user not created user created note created Create User
Destroy User Create Note Destroy Note -
RESET ARC 173 user not created user created note created
Create User Destroy User Create Note Destroy Note очищает позицию после срабатывания -
INHIBITOR ARC 174 user created note created Create User Destroy
User Create Note Destroy Note разрешает срабатывание перехода только если в позиции нет меток -
БЕЗОПАСНЫЕ СЕТИ ПЕТРИ 175 user not created user created note
created Create User Destroy User Create Note Destroy Note не больше одной метки в позиции -
ОБЫЧНЫЕ СЕТИ ПЕТРИ 176 user not created user created note
created Create User Destroy User Create Note Destroy Note -
ЦВЕТНЫЕ СЕТИ ПЕТРИ 177 user not created user created note
created Create User Destroy User Create Note Destroy Note метка хранит данные -
ARC GUARD 178 user not created user created note created
Create User Destroy User Create Note Destroy Note разрешает срабатывание перехода только если guard = true user is admin -
user not created user created Create User Destroy User ИЕРАРХИЧЕСКИЕ
СЕТИ ПЕТРИ 179 Note note created Create Note Destroy Note