Upgrade to Pro — share decks privately, control downloads, hide ads and more …

Gaze-Based Self-Confidence Estimation on Multip...

Avatar for Shoya Ishimaru Shoya Ishimaru
April 25, 2020
Research
0
470

Gaze-Based Self-Confidence Estimation on Multiple-Choice Questions and Its Feedback - Asian CHI Symposium 2020

Slides used at the Asian CHI Symposium 2020 and modified a bit after the talk.
Avatar for Shoya Ishimaru

Shoya Ishimaru

April 25, 2020
Tweet

More Decks by Shoya Ishimaru

See All by Shoya Ishimaru
AI研究者になる－学生時代の経験から最先端の研究まで－ / 2023-09-27
Avatar for Shoya Ishimaru shoya140
0
52
技術的視点から見る生成AIとその活用方法 / 2023-06-09
Avatar for Shoya Ishimaru shoya140
0
29
Meta-Augmented Human: Augmenting the Capability of Augmenting the Capability / 2022-12-07
Avatar for Shoya Ishimaru shoya140
0
29
エクストリーム・モチベーション / Extreme Motivation
Avatar for Shoya Ishimaru shoya140
0
240
Zenから箇条書きまで幅広く使えるKeynoteテンプレート「Zebra 2」の紹介 / Introducing Zebra 2
Avatar for Shoya Ishimaru shoya140
3
4.1k
人を賢くする人工知能 / 2019.08.31
Avatar for Shoya Ishimaru shoya140
0
220
未踏ナイト2018LT「エンジニアリング・リサーチの振り子」
Avatar for Shoya Ishimaru shoya140
0
140
楽しいドイツの観光地ベスト５
Avatar for Shoya Ishimaru shoya140
0
520
人工知能研究の最前線と中学・高校で得た経験
Avatar for Shoya Ishimaru shoya140
0
580

Other Decks in Research

See All in Research
さくらインターネット研究所 アップデート2025年
Avatar for MATSUMOTO Ryosuke matsumoto_r
PRO
0
550
Vision Language Modelと完全自動運転AIの最新動向
Avatar for Tsubasa Takahashi tsubasashi
2
500
言語モデルによるAI創薬の進展 / Advancements in AI-Driven Drug Discovery Using Language Models
Avatar for tsurubee tsurubee
2
330
クラウドのテレメトリーシステム研究動向2025年
Avatar for Yuuki Tsubouchi (yuuk1) yuukit
3
880
熊本都市圏「公共交通利用者2倍」に向けた公的投資獲得の成功・失敗・目論見@公共交通マーケティング研究会「公的投資獲得」
Avatar for Traffic Brain trafficbrain
0
100
学生向けアンケート＜データサイエンティストについて＞
Avatar for The Japan DataScientist Society datascientistsociety
PRO
0
1.5k
言語モデルの内部機序：解析と解釈
Avatar for Sho Yokoi eumesy
PRO
39
17k
研究テーマのデザインと研究遂行の方法論
Avatar for Hisashi Ishihara hisashiishihara
5
1.2k
Mathematics in the Age of AI and the 4 Generation University
Avatar for Mohammed Hachama hachama
0
150
インドネシアのQA事情を紹介するの
Avatar for tamaru yujijs
0
190
EarthMarker: A Visual Prompting Multimodal Large Language Model for Remote Sensing
Avatar for SatAI.challenge satai
3
210
PhD Defence: Considering Temporal and Contextual Information for Lexical Semantic Change Detection
Avatar for Taichi Aida a1da4
1
170

Featured

See All Featured
Designing for humans not robots
Avatar for Tammie Lister tammielis
253
25k
CoffeeScript is Beautiful & I Never Want to Write Plain JavaScript Again
Avatar for Sam Stephenson sstephenson
160
15k
Making the Leap to Tech Lead
Avatar for Ryan Cromwell cromwellryan
133
9.3k
Helping Users Find Their Own Way: Creating Modern Search Experiences
Avatar for Dan Newman danielanewman
29
2.6k
Learning to Love Humans: Emotional Interface Design
Avatar for Aarron Walter aarron
273
40k
Optimising Largest Contentful Paint
Avatar for Harry Roberts csswizardry
37
3.2k
Cheating the UX When There Is Nothing More to Optimize - PixelPioneers
Avatar for Stéphanie Walter stephaniewalter
280
13k
A Modern Web Designer's Workflow
Avatar for Chris Coyier chriscoyier
693
190k
Done Done
Avatar for chrislema chrislema
184
16k
The Cost Of JavaScript in 2023
Avatar for Addy Osmani addyosmani
49
7.9k
Distributed Sagas: A Protocol for Coordinating Microservices
Avatar for Caitie McCaffrey caitiem20
331
21k
Building Applications with DynamoDB
Avatar for Matt Wood mza
94
6.4k

Transcript

  1. (B[F#BTFE4FMG$POpEFODF&TUJNBUJPOPO
 .VMUJQMF$IPJDF2VFTUJPOTBOE*UT'FFECBDL 4IPZB*TIJNBSV 5BLBOPSJ.BSVJDIJ ,PJDIJ,JTFBOE"OESFBT%FOHFM  (FSNBO3FTFBSDI$FOUFSGPS"SUJpDJBM*OUFMMJHFODF %',* 
 

    (SBEVBUF4DIPPMPG&OHJOFFSJOH 0TBLB1SFGFDUVSF6OJWFSTJUZ

  2. .PUJWBUJPO*NQSPWJOHUIF1FSGPSNBODFPGB-FBSOFS 

  3. .PUJWBUJPO*NQSPWJOHUIF1FSGPSNBODFPGB-FBSOFS  -FDUVSFUFYUCPPL

  4. .PUJWBUJPO*NQSPWJOHUIF1FSGPSNBODFPGB-FBSOFS  -FDUVSFUFYUCPPL 2VFTUJPOT UFTU

  5. .PUJWBUJPO*NQSPWJOHUIF1FSGPSNBODFPGB-FBSOFS  -FDUVSFUFYUCPPL 2VFTUJPOT UFTU 3FWJFX

  6. .PUJWBUJPO*NQSPWJOHUIF1FSGPSNBODFPGB-FBSOFS  -FDUVSFUFYUCPPL 2VFTUJPOT UFTU 3FWJFX

  7. .PUJWBUJPO*NQSPWJOHUIF1FSGPSNBODFPGB-FBSOFS  -FDUVSFUFYUCPPL 2VFTUJPOT UFTU 3FWJFX

  8. .PUJWBUJPO*NQSPWJOHUIF1FSGPSNBODFPGB-FBSOFS  -FDUVSFUFYUCPPL 2VFTUJPOT UFTU 3FWJFX

  9. .PUJWBUJPO*NQSPWJOHUIF1FSGPSNBODFPGB-FBSOFS  -FDUVSFUFYUCPPL 2VFTUJPOT UFTU 3FWJFX 8IJDIRVFTUJPOTIPVMECFSFWJFXFEDBSFGVMMZ  QSJPSJUZ MFBLBHF

  10.  ,FZ*EFB$POpEFODF"XBSF-FBSOJOH"TTJTUBOU

  11.  ,FZ*EFB$POpEFODF"XBSF-FBSOJOH"TTJTUBOU $PSSFDU *ODPSSFDU

  12.  ,FZ*EFB$POpEFODF"XBSF-FBSOJOH"TTJTUBOU $PSSFDU *ODPSSFDU $POpEFOU 6ODPOpEFOU

  13.  ,FZ*EFB$POpEFODF"XBSF-FBSOJOH"TTJTUBOU $PSSFDU *ODPSSFDU $POpEFOU 6ODPOpEFOU

  14.  ,FZ*EFB$POpEFODF"XBSF-FBSOJOH"TTJTUBOU $PSSFDU *ODPSSFDU $POpEFOU 6ODPOpEFOU 

  15.  ,FZ*EFB$POpEFODF"XBSF-FBSOJOH"TTJTUBOU $PSSFDU *ODPSSFDU $POpEFOU 6ODPOpEFOU  

  16.  ,FZ*EFB$POpEFODF"XBSF-FBSOJOH"TTJTUBOU $PSSFDU *ODPSSFDU $POpEFOU 6ODPOpEFOU   

  17.  ,FZ*EFB$POpEFODF"XBSF-FBSOJOH"TTJTUBOU $PSSFDU *ODPSSFDU $POpEFOU 6ODPOpEFOU    .VMUJQMF$IPJDF2VFTUJPO

  18. (B[F#BTFE4FMG$POpEFODF&TUJNBUJPO 

  19. (B[F#BTFE4FMG$POpEFODF&TUJNBUJPO 

  20. (B[F#BTFE4FMG$POpEFODF&TUJNBUJPO  %FDJTJPOXJUIDPOpEFODF

  21. (B[F#BTFE4FMG$POpEFODF&TUJNBUJPO  %FDJTJPOXJUIDPOpEFODF %FDJTJPOXJUIPVUDPOpEFODF

  22. (B[F#BTFE4FMG$POpEFODF&TUJNBUJPO  • IBTCFFOPSJHJOBMMZQSPQPTFECZ:BNBEBFUBM %FDJTJPOXJUIDPOpEFODF %FDJTJPOXJUIPVUDPOpEFODF <>,:BNBEB ,,JTF BOE0"VHFSFBV&TUJNBUJPOPGDPOpEFODFCBTFEPOFZFHB[FBOBQQMJDBUJPOUPNVMUJQMFDIPJDFRVFTUJPOT*O1SPD6CJ$PNQ"EKVODUQQr

  23. (B[F#BTFE4FMG$POpEFODF&TUJNBUJPO  • IBTCFFOPSJHJOBMMZQSPQPTFECZ:BNBEBFUBM • 8FJNQMFNFOUUIJTJEFBBTBXPSLJOHTZTUFNBOE
 FWBMVBUFIPXNVDIEPFTJUJNQSPWFMFBSOJOHQFSGPSNBODFT %FDJTJPOXJUIDPOpEFODF %FDJTJPOXJUIPVUDPOpEFODF <>,:BNBEB

    ,,JTF BOE0"VHFSFBV&TUJNBUJPOPGDPOpEFODFCBTFEPOFZFHB[FBOBQQMJDBUJPOUPNVMUJQMFDIPJDFRVFTUJPOT*O1SPD6CJ$PNQ"EKVODUQQr

  24. 3FTFBSDI)ZQPUIFTFT 

  25. • 3)2VFTUJPOTBOTXFSFEDPSSFDUMZXJUIPVUDPOpEFODFUFOEUPCF GPSHPUUFODPNQBSFEUPLOPXMFEHFXJUIDPOpEFODF 3FTFBSDI)ZQPUIFTFT 

  26. • 3)2VFTUJPOTBOTXFSFEDPSSFDUMZXJUIPVUDPOpEFODFUFOEUPCF GPSHPUUFODPNQBSFEUPLOPXMFEHFXJUIDPOpEFODF • 3)2VFTUJPOTBOTXFSFEJODPSSFDUMZXJUIDPOpEFODFUFOEUPCF NJTUBLFOBHBJODPNQBSFEUPXSPOHLOPXMFEHFXJUIPVUDPOpEFODF 3FTFBSDI)ZQPUIFTFT 

  27. • 3)2VFTUJPOTBOTXFSFEDPSSFDUMZXJUIPVUDPOpEFODFUFOEUPCF GPSHPUUFODPNQBSFEUPLOPXMFEHFXJUIDPOpEFODF • 3)2VFTUJPOTBOTXFSFEJODPSSFDUMZXJUIDPOpEFODFUFOEUPCF NJTUBLFOBHBJODPNQBSFEUPXSPOHLOPXMFEHFXJUIPVUDPOpEFODF • 3)&TUJNBUJOHTFMGDPOpEFODFGSPNMFBSOJOHCFIBWJPSTBOEHJWJOH GFFECBDL FH

    BEEJOHRVFTUJPOTUPBSFWJFXMJTU IJHIMJHIUJOHUIFN XIJMFSFWJFXJOH BWPJETTVDITDFOBSJPT 3FTFBSDI)ZQPUIFTFT 

  28. %FNP

  29. %FNP

  30. 4ZTUFN0WFSWJFX 

  31. 4ZTUFN0WFSWJFX  1SFQSPDFTTJOH
 pYBUJPOTBDDBEFEFUFDUJPO

  32. 4ZTUFN0WFSWJFX  1SFQSPDFTTJOH
 pYBUJPOTBDDBEFEFUFDUJPO 'FBUVSFDBMDVMBUJPO

  33. 4ZTUFN0WFSWJFX  1SFQSPDFTTJOH
 pYBUJPOTBDDBEFEFUFDUJPO 'FBUVSFDBMDVMBUJPO 8FVUJMJ[FUIFGPMMPXJOHpWFFGGFDUJWFGFBUVSFTTFMFDUFECZ'PSXBSETUFQXJTFGFBUVSFTFMFDUJPO
 GTVNPGpYBUJPOEVSBUJPOTPO$IPJDFT GWBSJBODFPGYDPPSEJOBUFPGpYBUJPOT
 GUIFOVNCFSPGTBDDBEFTCFUXFFODIPJDFBSFBT GTVNPGTBDDBEFEVSBUJPOT

    GSFBEJOHUJNF

  34. 4ZTUFN0WFSWJFX  • #JOBSZDMBTTJpDBUJPO • 4VQQPSU7FDUPS .BDIJOF 47.  •

    3#'LFSOFM 
 $ Ѝ 1SFQSPDFTTJOH
 pYBUJPOTBDDBEFEFUFDUJPO 'FBUVSFDBMDVMBUJPO $MBTTJpDBUJPO 8FVUJMJ[FUIFGPMMPXJOHpWFFGGFDUJWFGFBUVSFTTFMFDUFECZ'PSXBSETUFQXJTFGFBUVSFTFMFDUJPO
 GTVNPGpYBUJPOEVSBUJPOTPO$IPJDFT GWBSJBODFPGYDPPSEJOBUFPGpYBUJPOT
 GUIFOVNCFSPGTBDDBEFTCFUXFFODIPJDFBSFBT GTVNPGTBDDBEFEVSBUJPOT GSFBEJOHUJNF

  35. &YQFSJNFOUBM%FTJHO 

  36. &YQFSJNFOUBM%FTJHO  • 1BSUJDJQBOUT BHF

  37. &YQFSJNFOUBM%FTJHO  • 1BSUJDJQBOUT BHF • &ZFUSBDLFS5PCJJ$)[

  38. &YQFSJNFOUBM%FTJHO  • 1BSUJDJQBOUT BHF • &ZFUSBDLFS5PCJJ$)[ • 2VFTUJPOT&OHMJTIHSBNNBS

  39. &YQFSJNFOUBM%FTJHO  • 1BSUJDJQBOUT BHF • &ZFUSBDLFS5PCJJ$)[ • 2VFTUJPOT&OHMJTIHSBNNBS •

    1SPDFEVSFT

  40. &YQFSJNFOUBM%FTJHO  • 1BSUJDJQBOUT BHF • &ZFUSBDLFS5PCJJ$)[ • 2VFTUJPOT&OHMJTIHSBNNBS •

    1SPDFEVSFT • 5IFTUEBZ5SJBMBOEQSFUFTU

  41. &YQFSJNFOUBM%FTJHO  • 1BSUJDJQBOUT BHF • &ZFUSBDLFS5PCJJ$)[ • 2VFTUJPOT&OHMJTIHSBNNBS •

    1SPDFEVSFT • 5IFTUEBZ5SJBMBOEQSFUFTU • 5IFSEEBZ3FWJFX *ODPSSFDU DPSSFDUXJUIPVUDPOpEFODF

  42. &YQFSJNFOUBM%FTJHO  • 1BSUJDJQBOUT BHF • &ZFUSBDLFS5PCJJ$)[ • 2VFTUJPOT&OHMJTIHSBNNBS •

    1SPDFEVSFT • 5IFTUEBZ5SJBMBOEQSFUFTU • 5IFSEEBZ3FWJFX *ODPSSFDU DPSSFDUXJUIPVUDPOpEFODF • 5IFUIEBZ1PTUUFTU

  43. &YQFSJNFOUBM%FTJHO  • 1BSUJDJQBOUT BHF • &ZFUSBDLFS5PCJJ$)[ • 2VFTUJPOT&OHMJTIHSBNNBS •

    1SPDFEVSFT • 5IFTUEBZ5SJBMBOEQSFUFTU • 5IFSEEBZ3FWJFX *ODPSSFDU DPSSFDUXJUIPVUDPOpEFODF • 5IFUIEBZ1PTUUFTU • 5IFDMBTTJpFSXBTQSFMJNJOBSZCVJMUXJUIBOPUIFSQBSUJDJQBOUT

  44.  %JWJOH"OTXFSTJOUP&YQFSJNFOUBMBOE$POUSPM(SPVQT (1) corr. w/ conf. 53.5% (2a) corr. w/o

    conf. 5.6% (2b) corr. w/o conf. > feedback 5.1% (3) incorr. w/o conf. 5.1% (4a) incor. w/ conf. 16.5% (4b) incorr. w/ conf. > feedback 14.1% %BUBDPSSFDUFEBUUIFQSFUFTU

  45.  %JWJOH"OTXFSTJOUP&YQFSJNFOUBMBOE$POUSPM(SPVQT (1) corr. w/ conf. 53.5% (2a) corr. w/o

    conf. 5.6% (2b) corr. w/o conf. > feedback 5.1% (3) incorr. w/o conf. 5.1% (4a) incor. w/ conf. 16.5% (4b) incorr. w/ conf. > feedback 14.1% PGDPSSFDUBOTXFST
 XJUIPVUDPOpEFODFXFSF
 JODMVEFEJOUIFSFWJFX %BUBDPSSFDUFEBUUIFQSFUFTU

  46.  %JWJOH"OTXFSTJOUP&YQFSJNFOUBMBOE$POUSPM(SPVQT (1) corr. w/ conf. 53.5% (2a) corr. w/o

    conf. 5.6% (2b) corr. w/o conf. > feedback 5.1% (3) incorr. w/o conf. 5.1% (4a) incor. w/ conf. 16.5% (4b) incorr. w/ conf. > feedback 14.1% PGDPSSFDUBOTXFST
 XJUIPVUDPOpEFODFXFSF
 JODMVEFEJOUIFSFWJFX PGJODPSSFDUBOTXFST
 XJUIDPOpEFODFXFSF
 IJHIMJHIUFEBUUIFSFWJFX %BUBDPSSFDUFEBUUIFQSFUFTU

  47. &YQFSJNFOUBM3FTVMUT    B C    

          DPSSXDPOG B DPSSXPDPOG C DPSSXPDPOGGFFECBDL   B C           JODPSSXPDPOG B JODPSXDPOG C JODPSSXDPOGGFFECBDL 5IFNFBOPGDPSSFDUBOTXFSSBUFT
 BNPOHQBSUJDJQBOUTBUUIFQPTUUFTU

  48. &YQFSJNFOUBM3FTVMUT    B C    

          DPSSXDPOG B DPSSXPDPOG C DPSSXPDPOGGFFECBDL   B C           JODPSSXPDPOG B JODPSXDPOG C JODPSSXDPOGGFFECBDL • 5IFSBUJPPG B DPSSFDUBOTXFSTXJUIPVU DPOpEFODFXBTESPQQFEDPNQBSFEUP  BOTXFSTXJUIDPOpEFODF Q  5IFNFBOPGDPSSFDUBOTXFSSBUFT
 BNPOHQBSUJDJQBOUTBUUIFQPTUUFTU

  49. &YQFSJNFOUBM3FTVMUT    B C    

          DPSSXDPOG B DPSSXPDPOG C DPSSXPDPOGGFFECBDL   B C           JODPSSXPDPOG B JODPSXDPOG C JODPSSXDPOGGFFECBDL • 5IFSBUJPPG B DPSSFDUBOTXFSTXJUIPVU DPOpEFODFXBTESPQQFEDPNQBSFEUP  BOTXFSTXJUIDPOpEFODF Q  • "OTXFSTXJUIPVUDPOpEFODFUFOEUPCF GPSHPUUFOJOUIFOFBSGVUVSF 5IFNFBOPGDPSSFDUBOTXFSSBUFT
 BNPOHQBSUJDJQBOUTBUUIFQPTUUFTU

  50. &YQFSJNFOUBM3FTVMUT    B C    

          DPSSXDPOG B DPSSXPDPOG C DPSSXPDPOGGFFECBDL   B C           JODPSSXPDPOG B JODPSXDPOG C JODPSSXDPOGGFFECBDL • 5IFSBUJPPG B DPSSFDUBOTXFSTXJUIPVU DPOpEFODFXBTESPQQFEDPNQBSFEUP  BOTXFSTXJUIDPOpEFODF Q  • "OTXFSTXJUIPVUDPOpEFODFUFOEUPCF GPSHPUUFOJOUIFOFBSGVUVSF • 5IFQFSGPSNBODFPG C IJHIMJHIUFEBT JODPSSFDUXJUIDPOpEFODFXBTIJHIFS UIBO B XPIJHIMJHIU Q 5IFNFBOPGDPSSFDUBOTXFSSBUFT
 BNPOHQBSUJDJQBOUTBUUIFQPTUUFTU

  51. &YQFSJNFOUBM3FTVMUT    B C    

          DPSSXDPOG B DPSSXPDPOG C DPSSXPDPOGGFFECBDL   B C           JODPSSXPDPOG B JODPSXDPOG C JODPSSXDPOGGFFECBDL • 5IFSBUJPPG B DPSSFDUBOTXFSTXJUIPVU DPOpEFODFXBTESPQQFEDPNQBSFEUP  BOTXFSTXJUIDPOpEFODF Q  • "OTXFSTXJUIPVUDPOpEFODFUFOEUPCF GPSHPUUFOJOUIFOFBSGVUVSF • 5IFQFSGPSNBODFPG C IJHIMJHIUFEBT JODPSSFDUXJUIDPOpEFODFXBTIJHIFS UIBO B XPIJHIMJHIU Q • 'FFECBDLTVDDFFEFEUPJNQSPWFUIF NFBODPSSFDUBOTXFSSBUF 5IFNFBOPGDPSSFDUBOTXFSSBUFT
 BNPOHQBSUJDJQBOUTBUUIFQPTUUFTU

  52. • 3)2VFTUJPOTBOTXFSFEDPSSFDUMZXJUIPVUDPOpEFODFUFOEUPCF GPSHPUUFODPNQBSFEUPLOPXMFEHFXJUIDPOpEFODF • 5SVF FWBMVBUFECZUIFDPNQBSJTPOCFUXFFOBOEB  • 3)2VFTUJPOTBOTXFSFEJODPSSFDUMZXJUIDPOpEFODFUFOEUPCF NJTUBLFOBHBJODPNQBSFEUPXSPOHLOPXMFEHFXJUIPVUDPOpEFODF

    • /PUBMXBZTUSVF FWBMVBUFECZUIFDPNQBSJTPOCFUXFFOBOEB  • 3)&TUJNBUJOHTFMGDPOpEFODFGSPNMFBSOJOHCFIBWJPSTBOEHJWJOH GFFECBDL FH BEEJOHRVFTUJPOTUPBSFWJFXMJTU IJHIMJHIUJOHUIFN XIJMFSFWJFXJOH BWPJETTVDITDFOBSJPT • 5SVF FWBMVBUFECZUIFDPNQBSJTPOCFUXFFOBBOEC "OTXFSTUPUIF3FTFBSDI)ZQPUIFTFT    B C           DPSSXDPOG B DPSSXPDPOG C DPSSXPDPOGGFFECBDL   B C           JODPSSXPDPOG B JODPSXDPOG C JODPSSXDPOGGFFECBDL

  53. $PODMVTJPOBOE'VUVSF8PSL 

  54. • 8FIBWFEFNPOTUSBUFE$POpEFODF"XBSF-FBSOJOH"TTJTUBOU 
 XIJDINFBTVSFTUIFTFMGDPOpEFODFPGMFBSOFSTGSPNUIFJSFZF NPWFNFOUTBOEOBWJHBUFTUIFNUPSFWJFXDSJUJDBMRVFTUJPOT $PODMVTJPOBOE'VUVSF8PSL 

  55. • 8FIBWFEFNPOTUSBUFE$POpEFODF"XBSF-FBSOJOH"TTJTUBOU 
 XIJDINFBTVSFTUIFTFMGDPOpEFODFPGMFBSOFSTGSPNUIFJSFZF NPWFNFOUTBOEOBWJHBUFTUIFNUPSFWJFXDSJUJDBMRVFTUJPOT • $PSSFDUBOTXFSSBUFTPGRVFTUJPOTXFSFJODSFBTFECZBOE
 CZHJWJOHGFFECBDLBCPVUDPSSFDUBOTXFSTXJUIPVUDPOpEFODF
 BOEJODPSSFDUBOTXFSTXJUIDPOpEFODF SFTQFDUJWFMZ

    $PODMVTJPOBOE'VUVSF8PSL 

  56. • 8FIBWFEFNPOTUSBUFE$POpEFODF"XBSF-FBSOJOH"TTJTUBOU 
 XIJDINFBTVSFTUIFTFMGDPOpEFODFPGMFBSOFSTGSPNUIFJSFZF NPWFNFOUTBOEOBWJHBUFTUIFNUPSFWJFXDSJUJDBMRVFTUJPOT • $PSSFDUBOTXFSSBUFTPGRVFTUJPOTXFSFJODSFBTFECZBOE
 CZHJWJOHGFFECBDLBCPVUDPSSFDUBOTXFSTXJUIPVUDPOpEFODF
 BOEJODPSSFDUBOTXFSTXJUIDPOpEFODF SFTQFDUJWFMZ

    • 'VUVSFXPSL $PODMVTJPOBOE'VUVSF8PSL 

  57. • 8FIBWFEFNPOTUSBUFE$POpEFODF"XBSF-FBSOJOH"TTJTUBOU 
 XIJDINFBTVSFTUIFTFMGDPOpEFODFPGMFBSOFSTGSPNUIFJSFZF NPWFNFOUTBOEOBWJHBUFTUIFNUPSFWJFXDSJUJDBMRVFTUJPOT • $PSSFDUBOTXFSSBUFTPGRVFTUJPOTXFSFJODSFBTFECZBOE
 CZHJWJOHGFFECBDLBCPVUDPSSFDUBOTXFSTXJUIPVUDPOpEFODF
 BOEJODPSSFDUBOTXFSTXJUIDPOpEFODF SFTQFDUJWFMZ

    • 'VUVSFXPSL • %FTJHOJOHCFUUFSGFFECBDL $PODMVTJPOBOE'VUVSF8PSL 

  58. • 8FIBWFEFNPOTUSBUFE$POpEFODF"XBSF-FBSOJOH"TTJTUBOU 
 XIJDINFBTVSFTUIFTFMGDPOpEFODFPGMFBSOFSTGSPNUIFJSFZF NPWFNFOUTBOEOBWJHBUFTUIFNUPSFWJFXDSJUJDBMRVFTUJPOT • $PSSFDUBOTXFSSBUFTPGRVFTUJPOTXFSFJODSFBTFECZBOE
 CZHJWJOHGFFECBDLBCPVUDPSSFDUBOTXFSTXJUIPVUDPOpEFODF
 BOEJODPSSFDUBOTXFSTXJUIDPOpEFODF SFTQFDUJWFMZ

    • 'VUVSFXPSL • %FTJHOJOHCFUUFSGFFECBDL • "QQMZJOHUPEJGGFSFOURVFTUJPOGPSNBUT $PODMVTJPOBOE'VUVSF8PSL 

  59. • 8FIBWFEFNPOTUSBUFE$POpEFODF"XBSF-FBSOJOH"TTJTUBOU 
 XIJDINFBTVSFTUIFTFMGDPOpEFODFPGMFBSOFSTGSPNUIFJSFZF NPWFNFOUTBOEOBWJHBUFTUIFNUPSFWJFXDSJUJDBMRVFTUJPOT • $PSSFDUBOTXFSSBUFTPGRVFTUJPOTXFSFJODSFBTFECZBOE
 CZHJWJOHGFFECBDLBCPVUDPSSFDUBOTXFSTXJUIPVUDPOpEFODF
 BOEJODPSSFDUBOTXFSTXJUIDPOpEFODF SFTQFDUJWFMZ

    • 'VUVSFXPSL • %FTJHOJOHCFUUFSGFFECBDL • "QQMZJOHUPEJGGFSFOURVFTUJPOGPSNBUT $PODMVTJPOBOE'VUVSF8PSL