Upgrade to Pro
— share decks privately, control downloads, hide ads and more …
Speaker Deck
Sign up for free
Menu
Search
Features
All features
Private URLs
Password Protection
Custom URLS
Scheduled publishing
Remove Branding
Restrict embedding
Deck Collections
Notes
Features
All features
Private URLs
Password Protection
Custom URLS
Scheduled publishing
Remove Branding
Restrict embedding
Deck Collections
Notes
Explore
Featured decks
Featured speakers
Programming
Technology
Storyboards
Explore
Featured decks
Featured speakers
Programming
Technology
Storyboards
Pricing
Search
Sign in
Sign up for free
Towards Meta-Level Engineering and Tooling for ...
Search
Sponsored
·
Your Podcast. Everywhere. Effortlessly.
Share. Educate. Inspire. Entertain. You do you. We'll handle the rest.
→
Stefan Marr
March 24, 2016
Research
1k
1
Share
Embed
Copy iframe code
Copy JS code
Copy link
Start on current slide
Towards Meta-Level Engineering and Tooling for Complex Concurrent Systems
Stefan Marr
March 24, 2016
Transcript
34 slides
Stefan Marr, Elisa Gonzalez Boix, Hanspeter Mössenböck Towards Meta-Level Engineering
and Tooling for Complex Concurrent Systems
ApplicaFons in the MulFcore Age 2 Concurrency Model: event-loops or
actors User Interface asynchronous event-driven
ApplicaFons in the MulFcore Age 3 ~/Library/Mail$ sqlite3 EnvelopeIndex SQLite
version 3.7.7.1sqlite> .schema CREATE TABLE addresses (ROWID int, address, comment); CREATE TABLE messages (ROWID int, message_id, document_id, in_reply_to, remote_id int, sender int…); Data Storage consistency required transacFonal backends Concurrency Model: transacFonal operaFons
ApplicaFons in the MulFcore Age 4 Data Analysis and Processing
performance sensiFve Concurrency Model: data-parallel queries, map/reduce, fork/join, …
And, This is Real! hUp://stefan-marr.de/ 2014/07/why-is-concurrent- programming-hard/ 5 Tasharofi, S.;
Dinges, P. & Johnson, R. E. Why Do Scala Developers Mix the Actor Model with other Concurrency Models? ECOOP 2013. Apple Mail
How to provide tooling for all of them? 6
Research Challenges • Debugger for MulFple Concurrency Models • Minimizing
Interference 7 How to Abstract from Concurrency Models?
A DEBUGGER FOR SUCH APPLICATIONS SupporFng a Wide Range of
Concurrency Models. 8
Subsystems as CommunicaFng Event Loops 9 Actor A Actor B
Actor Principle
Subsystems as CommunicaFng Event Loops 10 Actor A Actor B
In Theory: One Message at a Time
Subsystems as CommunicaFng Event Loops 11 Actor A Actor B
Actors Contain Objects
Subsystems as CommunicaFng Event Loops 12 Actor A Actor B
Which message cause which changes?
Subsystems as CommunicaFng Event Loops 13 Actor A Actor B
caused? caused?
Subsystem uses TransacFons 14 Actor A Subsystem B
Subsystem uses TransacFons 15 Subsystem B
Subsystem uses TransacFons 16 Subsystem B
Subsystem uses TransacFons Subsystem B Thread A Thread B
Subsystem uses TransacFons Subsystem B Thread A Thread B Thread
A
Subsystem uses TransacFons Subsystem B Thread A Thread B Thread
A Thread B How did transacFons interact?
Requirements • High-level representaFon of concepts • Move between abstracFon
levels • Enable – Observe AcFons (History) – Understand Dependencies – Interact and Explore 20
MINIMIZING INTERFERENCE Research Challenge 21
Shared Resource in Message-based System 22 Synchro nizer Shared “Mutable”
Resource Added later, forgot about synchronizer
Shared Resource in Message-based System 23 Synchro nizer Shared “Mutable”
Resource 75% probability 25% probability
AUaching Debugger 24 Synchro nizer Shared “Mutable” Resource Debugger
With Debugger 25 Synchro nizer Shared “Mutable” Resource Debugger 99%
probability 1% probability
Tradeoff: Precision vs. Interference • How to minimize recorded data?
– Maximize re-synthesized informaFon – ParFal re-execuFon? • Independent of the concurrency model? 26
HOW TO ABSTRACT FROM CONCURRENCY MODELS? Research Challenge 27
What are common properFes for debugging? 28
Causality: Control & Data Dependencies 29 Details different for each
Concurrency Model
Scheduling Dependencies 30 Async message sends, rendevous semanFcs, blocking semanFcs,
...
Challenge: Support Wide Range of Concepts ConflicFng Goals – ImplementaFon Level:
Use common abstracFons – Tool Level: Show expected semanFcs 31 EnFty Event causes influences * *
SOMns: A Smalltalk with Actors 32 • • JavaScript, Node.js
5.4.0 JavaScript, GraalJS Ruby, JRuby+Truffle SOMns, Newspeak Java, 1.8.0_66 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 Runtime Factor, normalized to Java 1.8.0_66 (lower is better) Dynamic Language Research Planorm Faster than V8
Actor Performance On Par with JVM Frameworks 33 Chameneos ConcurrentSorted
LinkedList Counting ForkJoinThroughput PingPong RadixSort ThreadRing Geo Mean 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Runtime factor over Scalaz lower is better Akka Jetlang SOMns Scalaz
Research Goals • Debugger for MulFple Concurrency Models • Minimizing
Interference 34 How to Abstract from Concurrency Models?
More Decks by Stefan Marr
See All by Stefan Marr
Actors! And now? An Implementer's Perspective onHigh-level Concurrency Models,Debugging Tools,and the Future of Automatic Bug Mitigation
smarr
0
600
How do we do Benchmark?Impressions from Conversations with the Community
smarr
0
11k
Metaprogramming, Metaobject Protocols, Gradual Type Checks: Optimizing the "Unoptimizable" Using Old Ideas
smarr
1
3.7k
Few Versatile vs. Many Specialized Collections: How to design a collection library for exploratory programming?
smarr
0
3.3k
Multi-Paradigm Concurrent Debugger
smarr
0
200
Other Decks in Research
See All in Research
横浜市長(山中氏)の言動にかかる第三者による調査報告書
sishi2026
0
680
Pesée et pointage par imagerie 3D : PHENO3D entre en phase de test terrains
institutdelelevage
PRO
0
160
共感型採用に関する採用サイト意識調査 2026
gpol
1
120
完全自律LLMエージェントでDIVER OSINT CTF 2026に挑戦してみた
analokmaus
0
840
A Preliminary Performance Evaluation of Cassandra Accord
sira
0
110
[Research Paper Analysis] Deep Learning - SigLIP2
auranightsky
0
180
最先端NLP 2026 論文紹介: Wait, Wait, Wait... Why Do Reasoning Models Loop? / SNLP Paper Review: Wait, Wait, Wait... Why Do Reasoning Models Loop?
tkng
0
280
【令和7年度版】内航船 VS 外航船 早見表
anikisencyo
0
250
オンライン凸最適化の基礎とゲーム理論への応用 (IBIS 2026 チュートリアル)
taira_tsuchiya
2
1.4k
SPACE 2026 - Femmes en Elevage – Regards croisés desdifférentes filières
institutdelelevage
PRO
0
130
Paris et Berlin face à un monde sans repères. Entre convergences et divergences en matière de politique étrangère
ifri
0
250
Kunai: Toward a Verifier-Safe Layered DSL for Nested Encapsulation Packet Filtering on eBPF
takehaya
1
210
Featured
See All Featured
Designing for Timeless Needs
cassininazir
1
570
Lightning talk: Run Django tests with GitHub Actions
sabderemane
0
330
Put a Button on it: Removing Barriers to Going Fast.
kastner
60
4.6k
Exploring anti-patterns in Rails
aemeredith
4
570
Context Engineering - Making Every Token Count
addyosmani
9
1.3k
The Director’s Chair: Orchestrating AI for Truly Effective Learning
tmiket
1
360
Claude Code どこまでも/ Claude Code Everywhere
nwiizo
68
61k
The #1 spot is gone: here's how to win anyway
tamaranovitovic
4
1.2k
Design in an AI World
tapps
1
390
A Soul's Torment
seathinner
9
3.9k
Digital Projects Gone Horribly Wrong (And the UX Pros Who Still Save the Day) - Dean Schuster
uxyall
2
4k
Max Prin - Stacking Signals: How International SEO Comes Together (And Falls Apart)
techseoconnect
PRO
0
540