Share
Embed
A System Psychodynamic Perspective on Evaluation
The second in the series of lunchtime dialogues on the Dynamics of Evaluation.
Tavistock Institute
November 02, 2015
Transcript
19 slides
-
A System Psychodynamic perspective on Evaluation A Dynamics of Evaluation
Dialogue Giorgia Iacopini Leslie Brissett 1 -
The dynamics of evaluation series • Bringing together evaluation and
consultancy practice • Exploring this interface with others working in the field • Considering the potential for a future professional development offer 2 -
Today’s event How can we increase understanding of, and work
effectively with, underlying dynamics in operation in evaluation activities? An evaluator’s experience An organisational consultant’s perspective Experiential exercise Feedback 3 -
An introduction to the case: evaluation of a Preventing Violent
Extremism project In general, it’s a: • Highly sensitive and controversial agenda; • Methodologically and practically challenging. Specifics of the project: • Aim: to deliver a safe platform for discussion for young people (seeking to engage those who stated their religion as Islam); Our task: • Understand the journey of participants through the project, and highlight any changes in knowledge and awareness of specific topics -
The nature of the challenge 6 …with particular reference to
initial phases of the work (contracting and early implementation) • Access to parts of the ‘system’ • The boundaries of ‘testing’ • Role negotiation -
How can it affect an evaluator? 7 • Feeling disempowered,
de-skilled • Conflict between what the client is asking for, and the needs of the evaluator • Sense of a ‘disconnect’ between what the client was saying and what appears to be the case ‘on the ground’ • Feeling diverted from task -
A framework for understanding and managing evaluation challenges: an analysis
Systems perspective OD theories of ‘phases’/roles System psychodynamics 8 -
A systems perspective Systems: • Are a configuration of parts
connected and joined together by a web of relationships. • Have boundaries • Are influenced by and reflect the environment in which they operate 9 -
What can happen when… • We ‘cross the boundary’ into
a system? We find ourselves: - Too far ‘inside’ the boundary? - Too far ‘outside’ the boundary? - Straddling the boundary? -
A system psychodynamic perspective Systems/organisations are made up of people,
and as such have processes going on that may be hidden or ‘unconsciously’ repressed. 12 -
Some system psycho-dynamics we may encounter Systems (groups, organisations, programmes)
may: • Have defence mechanisms by which they protect themselves (organisation as a defence against anxiety) • May reflect the feelings, thoughts, or identity, of the environment in which (or client groups with which) they are working • May deny feelings, thoughts and identities that they are uncomfortable with – and project these elsewhere – onto another organisation, or person (the evaluator?) As evaluators we may • Either take on, or challenge defence mechanisms • Take on the same feelings thoughts or identity as the organisation or • Take on feelings, thoughts and identities that are being denied/projected elsewhere -
The evaluation may ‘mirror’ the system being evaluated i.e. take
on the same characteristics 14 -
What can happen to evaluation teams This can be understood
to be a fractal of the system as the same patterns repeat through the system Parallel process – the dynamics within an organisation are reproduced between the organisation and a consultant [or evaluator], or within the consultant [evaluation] team 15 -
Systems may have ‘split off’ parts the organisation team working
with difficult clients 16 -
Projection and transference Projection: Seeing unaccepted parts of ourselves as
belonging to others (negative and positive) Transference: Repeating in current relationships patterns from early relationships (parents, siblings etc.) 17 -
What can help manage dynamics? Using consultancy thinking and ways
of working helped to: • Take the time understand the source of the challenge • See ‘resistance’ to evaluation and personal reactions as useful information about ‘what is going on’ • Working with the team as a whole • Feel ‘authorised’, and confident, to take on a different role