Share
Embed
Tensor decomposition based unsupervised feature extraction with optimized standard deviation applied to identification of differential gene expression, DNA methylation and histone modification
Presentation at ISAIC2022
https://www.isaic-conf.com/#/
10th Dec 2022
Y-h. Taguchi PRO
December 07, 2022
Transcript
29 slides
-
Tensor decomposition based unsupervised feature extraction with optimized standard deviation
applied to identification of differential gene expression, DNA methylation and histone modification Y-h. Taguci, Departement of Physics, Chuo University, Tokyo, Japan The contents were published in the following paper and two preprints in bioRxiv. https://rdcu.be/c0WE8 (Sci. Rep.) https://doi.org/10.1101/2022.04.02.486807 https://doi.org/10.1101/2022.04.29.490081 google slide ISAIC2022 1 -
Basic claims 1. Principal component analysis (PCA) based- and tensor
decomposition (TD) based- unsupervised feature extraction (FE) applied to identification of differentially expressed genes (DEGs) can outperform various state of art methods including DESeq2, when standard deviations (SDs) used to generate the null hypothesis (Gaussian distribution of principal components) are optimized. 2. They are applicable to identification of differentially methylated cytosine (DMCs) as well as differential histone modification without specific modification as well. ISAIC2022 2 -
The original (w/o SD optimization) PCA/TD based unsupervised FE 1.
Apply PCA to matrices (e.g., genes ⨉ samples) or TD to tensors (e.g. genes ⨉ samples ⨉ tissues) and get vectors attributed separately to genes, samples, or tissues. 2. Select the vectors of interest, attributed to samples and tissues. 3. Select genes whose contribution to corresponding vectors attributed to genes are larger (based upon the null hypothesis of Gaussian distribution of components of vectors). ISAIC2022 3 -
Matrix Tensor PCA TD Gene vectors Sample vectors Gene vectors
Sample vectors Tissue vectors Gene Sample Gene Sample Tissue Gaussian Dist. Frequency 0 1 1-P DEG Gene Selection ISAIC2022 4 -
Although PCA/TD based FE (w/o SD optimization) worked pretty well
for various problems, they have some problems. 1. Histogram of 1-P does not fully obey the null hypothesis 2. Too small genes are selected to think that there are no false negatives. Frequency 0 1 1-P DEG ISAIC2022 5 -
MAQC(benchmark data set for DEG *) RNA-seq: x ij repsents
expression of ith gene at jth sample Samples: seven Universal Human Reference RNA (UHRR) vs seven Human Brain Reference RNA (HBRR) Measured for 40933 genes (done by the presenter) (*) https://www.fda.gov/science-research/bioinformatics-to ols/microarraysequencing-quality-control-maqcseqc ISAIC2022 7 -
Gene wise mean log x ij Gene wise Log FC
ratio between two classes Density distribution MA plot ISAIC2022 8 -
u 1i u 2i Density distribution Gene wise embedding by
PCA ISAIC2022 9 -
v 1j v 2j Sample wise principal components Corresponds to
mean log x ij Corresponds to log FC ratio Corresponds to MA plot PCA ISAIC2022 10 -
Null hypothesis: u 2i obeys Gaussian Right: optimal σ minimizes
σ h n 0 h n h n n n Select genes with adjusted P i <0.1 Cumulative χ2 distribution Histogram 1-P i , h n of nth bin Adjusted P(n 0 )=0.1 Left: ISAIC2022 12 -
DESeq2: empirical dispersion relation PCA : naturally satisfied. “Highly expressed
genes should be more likely selected” μ σ2 σ2 ISAIC2022 13 -
(A) KEGG (B) GO BP (C) Human gene atlas PCA
vs DESeq2 vs edgeR vs NOISeq vs voom ISAIC2022 15 -
PCA based unsupervised FE with optimized SD outperformes various state
of art methods, DESeq2, edgeR, NOISeq, voom, with assuming neither empirical dispersion relation nor negative binomial distribution. ISAIC2022 16 -
Next, we tried to apply them to DNA methylation …...
ISAIC2022 17 -
Application to DMC identification (GSE42308, microarray) DMR: known differentially methylated
regions DHS: known DNase I high sensitivity site ISAIC2022 18 -
Application to DMC identification ( EH1072, sequencing) t test of
P-values attributed by PCA between DHS and non-DHS Chromosome ISAIC2022 19 -
Various state of art methods were compared, Microarray: ChAMP and
COHCAP Sequencing: DMRcate, DSS, and metilene None of them can be better than PCA ISAIC2022 20 -
COHCAP to GSE42308 ChAMP to GSE42308 DHS: known DNase I
high sensitivity site DMR: known differentially methylated regions ISAIC2022 21 -
DMRcate to EH1072 DSS takes more than a week. metilene
failed identify DMC ISAIC2022 22 -
PCA and TD based unsupervised FE with optimized SD can
be applied to identification of DMC without the specific modification ISAIC2022 23 -
Application to differential histone modification Histograms of 1-P i do
not obey Gaussian (double peak) but…. ISAIC2022 25 -
Comparisons with other methods (H3K9me3, GSE24850) The number of histone
modification experiments overlapped with selected genes ISAC2022 26 -
Other histone modification The number of histone modification experiments overlapped
with selected genes ISAIC2022 27 -
PCA and TD based unsupervised FE with optimized SD can
be applied to identification of differential histone modification without the specific modification ISAIC2022 28 -
Conclusions 1. Principal component analysis (PCA) based- and tensor decomposition
(TD) based- unsupervised feature extraction (FE) applied to identification of differentially expressed genes (DEGs) can outperform various state of art methods including DESeq2, when standard deviations (SDs) used to generate the null hypothesis (Gaussian distribution of principal components) are optimized. 2. They are applicable to identification of differentially methylated cytosine (DMCs) as well as differential histone modification without specific modification as well. ISAIC2022 29