Share
Embed
NU18
October 18, 2018 presentation of pilot research results at Northeastern University on redlining, segregation, and health
Christopher Prener
October 18, 2018
Transcript
60 slides
-
Detrimental Influences Redlining, Race, and Health Christopher Prener, Ph.D.
Assistant Professor of Sociology Saint Louis University 10.18.2018 -
Detrimental Influences Redlining, Race, and Health Christopher Prener, Ph.D.
Assistant Professor of Sociology Saint Louis University 10.18.2018 -
Acknowledgments Northeastern University Department of Sociology & Anthropology Especially Isabel
Geisler, Kathrin Zippel, Ph.D., and Linda Blum, Ph.D. Student Contributors Nivi Biju Branson Fox Jack Norys Institute for Health Equity and Social Justice Research Especially Alisa K. Lincoln, MPH, Ph.D. -
AGENDA 1. Preface 2. Background: Redlining & St. Louis 3.
Data & Pilot Methods 4. Redlining & Asthma in St. Louis 5. Next Steps NORTHEASTERN UNIVERSITY | BOSTON, MA | 10.18.2018 -
FOR THE PROBLEM OF THE TWENTIETH CENTURY IS THE PROBLEM
OF COLOR LINE W.E.B. Du Bois The Souls of Black Folk (1903) Wikimedia Commons -
2. BACKGROUND: REDLINING & ST. LOUIS RESTRICTIVE DEED COVENANTS EARLY
EXAMPLE FROM ST. LOUIS St. Louis American -
2. BACKGROUND: REDLINING & ST. LOUIS RESTRICTIVE DEED COVENANTS 4600
LABADIE AVE Google Street View -
2. BACKGROUND: REDLINING & ST. LOUIS RESTRICTIVE DEED COVENANTS ETHEL
SHELLEY St. Louis Post-Dispatch -
REDLINING A - “Best” B - “Still Desirable” C -
“Definitely Declining” D - “Hazardous” -
REDLINING A - “Best” B - “Still Desirable” C -
“Definitely Declining” D - “Hazardous” “‘homogeneous,’ and were in demand in ‘good times or bad’” (Hillier 2005:216) Hillier, Amy. 2005. “Residential Security Maps and Neighborhood Appraisals.” Social Science History 29(2):207-233. -
REDLINING A - “Best” B - “Still Desirable” C -
“Definitely Declining” D - “Hazardous” “In St. Louis, the white middle class suburb of Ladue was colored green because…it had ’not a single foreigner or negro.’” (Rothstein 2017) Rothstein, Richard. 2017. The Color of Law. New York, NY: W.W. Norton & Co. -
REDLINING A - “Best” C - “Definitely Declining” D -
“Hazardous” B - “Still Desirable” “‘They are like a 1935 automobile—still good, but not what the people are buying today who can afford a new one.’” (Hillier 2005:217) Hillier, Amy. 2005. “Residential Security Maps and Neighborhood Appraisals.” Social Science History 29(2):207-233. -
REDLINING A - “Best” B - “Still Desirable” D -
“Hazardous” C - “Definitely Declining” “‘infiltration of a lower grade population’” (Hillier 2005:217) Hillier, Amy. 2005. “Residential Security Maps and Neighborhood Appraisals.” Social Science History 29(2):207-233. -
REDLINING A - “Best” B - “Still Desirable” C -
“Definitely Declining” D - “Hazardous” Hillier, Amy. 2005. “Residential Security Maps and Neighborhood Appraisals.” Social Science History 29(2):207-233. “‘detrimental influences in a pronounced degree,’ and ‘undesirable population or an infiltration of it’” (Hillier 2005:217) -
REDLINING A - “Best” B - “Still Desirable” C -
“Definitely Declining” D - “Hazardous” Rothstein, Richard. 2017. The Color of Law. New York, NY: W.W. Norton & Co. “Lincoln Terrace was colored red because ‘it had little or no value today…due to the colored element now controlling the district’” (Rothstein 2017) -
2. BACKGROUND: REDLINING & ST. LOUIS A SOCIOLOGY OF REDLINING
▸ Growth in recent interest in dynamics related to redlining ▸ Hillier (2003; 2005a; 2005b; 2005c), Rothstein (2017), and Woods (2012) have all recently focused heavily on the history of the Home Owners’ Loan Corporation ▸ Most sociological focus (~30 recent studies) has been on redlining as a piece of history related to the development of segregated metros and cities in the mid-20th century ▸ National Community Reinvestment Coalition report (2018) ▸ Little direct use of redlining data, particularly across cities ▸ No direct study of how health has been affected by redlining -
2. BACKGROUND: REDLINING & ST. LOUIS SEGREGATION & HEALTH ▸
Have long recognized the segregation may impact communities’ health • Yankauer (1950) is one of the first examples of research in this vein ▸ Hypothesis has been that segregation impacts individuals through concentrated poverty and disadvantage (Collins and Williams 1999) ▸ Studies treat segregation primarily as a compositional factor in neighborhoods ▸ Literature has focused primarily on African American communities (Anderson 2016) -
3. DATA & PILOT METHODS DATA SOURCES Mapping Inequality (University
of Richmond) GIS data for HOLC redlining boundaries in ~150 cities; Redlining data -
3. DATA & PILOT METHODS DATA SOURCES Mapping Inequality (University
of Richmond) GIS data for HOLC redlining boundaries in ~150 cities; Redlining data 500 Cities Project (Centers for Disease Control) Census tract estimates for 28 health behaviors, outcomes, and prevention; CDC data -
3. DATA & PILOT METHODS CDC DATA Preventative Health
Care Health Outcomes 1. Arthritis 2. Current Asthma 3. High Blood Pressure 4. Cancer 5. High Cholesterol 6. Chronic Kidney Disease 7. COPD 8. Diabetes 9. Heart Disease 10.Mental Illness 11.Physical Health 12.Teeth Loss 13.Stroke Health Behaviors 1. Binge Drinking 2. Current Smoking 3. Physical Activity 4. Obesity 5. Sleep 1. Annual Checkup 2. Blood Pressure Medication 3. Colorectal Cancer Screen 4. Core Preventative Services for Men 5. Core Preventative Services for Women 6. Cholesterol Screening 7. Dental Visit 8. Health Insurance 9. Mammography 10.Pap Smear Test -
3. DATA & PILOT METHODS DATA SOURCES Mapping Inequality (University
of Richmond) GIS data for HOLC redlining boundaries in ~150 cities; Redlining data 500 Cities Project (Centers for Disease Control) Census tract estimates for 28 health behaviors, outcomes, and prevention; CDC data 2012-2016 American Community Survey (U.S. Census Bureau) Census tract estimates for demographic measures (race, poverty, etc.); ACS data Tiger/Line Shapefiles (U.S. Census Bureau) GIS data for census tract boundaries and other features -
3. DATA & PILOT METHODS DATA SET CONSTRUCTION Redlining GIS
Data Census Tract Boundary GIS Data Area (m2) of “C” and “D” Grade per tract CDC Data ACS Data Tract-level data set with redlining, health, and demographic measures -
3. DATA & PILOT METHODS DATA SET CONSTRUCTION Redlining GIS
Data Census Tract Boundary GIS Data Area (m2) of “C” and “D” Grade per tract CDC Data ACS Data Tract-level data set with redlining, health, and demographic measures Code for project specific calculations generalized in an R package redHealth Open science approach -
3. DATA & PILOT METHODS DATA SET CONSTRUCTION Redlining GIS
Data Census Tract Boundary GIS Data Area (m2) of “C” and “D” Grade per tract CDC Data ACS Data Tract-level data set with redlining, health, and demographic measures Reproducible API calls for downloading data instead of “point-and-click” Open science approach -
3. DATA & PILOT METHODS DATA SET CONSTRUCTION Redlining GIS
Data Census Tract Boundary GIS Data Area (m2) of “C” and “D” Grade per tract CDC Data ACS Data Tract-level data set with redlining, health, and demographic measures Repackaged CDC data in “tidy” format available in an R package cityHealth Open science approach -
3. DATA & PILOT METHODS DATA SET CONSTRUCTION Redlining GIS
Data Census Tract Boundary GIS Data Area (m2) of “C” and “D” Grade per tract CDC Data ACS Data Tract-level data set with redlining, health, and demographic measures Full process implemented with open source tools (principally R) Open science approach -
3. DATA & PILOT METHODS DATA SET CONSTRUCTION Redlining GIS
Data Census Tract Boundary GIS Data Area (m2) of “C” and “D” Grade per tract CDC Data ACS Data Tract-level data set with redlining, health, and demographic measures Full process documented publicly on GitHub and the Open Science Framework Open science approach -
3. DATA & PILOT METHODS DATA SET CONSTRUCTION Redlining GIS
Data Census Tract Boundary GIS Data Area (m2) of “C” and “D” Grade per tract CDC Data ACS Data Tract-level data set with redlining, health, and demographic measures Analytic data set available for download via GitHub and citable via Figshare Open science approach -
Segregation calculations and mapping: 1. What is the geography of
segregation in St. Louis? OLS and spatial regression: 2. What is the relationship between redlining and contemporary health outcomes? 3. DATA & PILOT METHODS DATA ANALYSIS Tract-level data set with redlining, health, and demographic measures -
New R package tidyseg with modern toolkit for segregation calculations
Open science approach Segregation calculations and mapping: 1. What is the geography of segregation in St. Louis? OLS and spatial regression: 2. What is the relationship between redlining and contemporary health outcomes? 3. DATA & PILOT METHODS DATA ANALYSES Tract-level data set with redlining, health, and demographic measures -
Segregation calculations and mapping: 1. What is the geography of
segregation in St. Louis? OLS and spatial regression: 2. What is the relationship between redlining and contemporary health outcomes? 3. DATA & PILOT METHODS DATA ANALYSES Tract-level data set with redlining, health, and demographic measures Models fit using the PySAL spatial analysis library for Python Open science approach -
4. REDLINING & ASTHMA IN ST. LOUIS DESCRIPTIVE STATISTICS Variables
Mean SD Range Asthma 0.11 0.02 0.08-0.15 C/D Grade* 0.41 0.39 0.00-1.00 Dissimilarity* 0.00 0.014 -0.03-0.04 Poverty 0.28 0.14 0.04-0.64 Medicaid 0.25 0.15 0.02-0.60 TANF** 0.04 0.03 0.01-0.19 SNAP** 0.29 0.17 0.02-0.67 Renters** 0.57 0.18 0.16-0.99 Uninsured 0.20 0.07 0.08-0.33 * - neighborhood, ** - households; otherwise proportion of individuals -
4. REDLINING & ASTHMA IN ST. LOUIS FULL MODELS Variables
OLS Spatial Error (GMM) C/D Grade -0.0005 (0.001)*** -0.0005 (0.001)*** Dissimilarity -0.325 (0.053)*** -0.292 (0.057)*** Poverty 0.017 (0.008)*** 0.016 (0.008)*** Medicaid -0.009 (0.008)*** -0.004 (0.009)*** TANF -0.014 (0.020)*** -0.013 (0.017)*** SNAP 0.030 (0.007)*** 0.026 (0.007)*** Renters -0.005 (0.003)*** -0.007 (0.003)*** Uninsured 0.133 (0.017)*** 0.139 (0.023)*** Lambda 0.447 (0.109)*** Constant 0.078 (0.002)*** 0.077 (0.003)*** Pseudo R2 0.947*** 0.950*** -
4. REDLINING & ASTHMA IN ST. LOUIS STEPWISE MODELS Variables
OLS 1 OLS 2 OLS 3 C/D Grade 0.016 (0.004)*** 0.005 (0.003)†** -0.0004 (0.001)*** Dissimilarity -1.153 (0.073)*** -0.376 (0.056)*** Poverty 0.014 (0.007)*** Uninsured 0.172 (0.014)*** Constant 0.105 (0.003)*** 0.110 (0.001)*** 0.074 (0.002)*** Adjusted R2 0.098*** 0.737*** 0.937*** Log Likelihood 276.484*** 342.199*** 418.647*** AIC -548.968*** -678.399*** -827.294*** -
4. REDLINING & ASTHMA IN ST. LOUIS FULL MODELS Variables
OLS Spatial Error (GMM) C/D Grade -0.0005 (0.001)*** -0.0005 (0.001)*** Dissimilarity -0.325 (0.053)*** -0.292 (0.057)*** Poverty 0.017 (0.008)*** 0.016 (0.008)*** Medicaid -0.009 (0.008)*** -0.004 (0.009)*** TANF -0.014 (0.020)*** -0.013 (0.017)*** SNAP 0.030 (0.007)*** 0.026 (0.007)*** Renters -0.005 (0.003)*** -0.007 (0.003)*** Uninsured 0.133 (0.017)*** 0.139 (0.023)*** Lambda 0.447 (0.109)*** Constant 0.078 (0.002)*** 0.077 (0.003)*** Pseudo R2 0.947*** 0.950*** -
4. REDLINING & HEALTH IN ST. LOUIS DISCUSSION ▸ Impact
of redlining explained away by segregation and poverty ▸ Robust spatial findings that neighborhood-level asthma rates impacted significantly by segregation, poverty, and un-insurance rates ▸ Limitations • These models are not ideal for proportional outcomes • Models would benefit from regular geographical features (such as square kilometer grids) • Measurement error in both ACS and CDC data -
NEXT STEPS Analyses Methods 1. Census tract level measures of
segregation 2. Development of tidyseg 3. Effect sizes for spatial regression models • Not a part of the PySAL library 4. Measuring effects across sparse data • Meta analysis is one possibility Funding 1. Initial grants applications a. National Institutions of Health LRP b. Internal funding mechanism 2. Longterm funding a. National Science Foundation? b. National Institutes of Health? 1. What are the geographies of segregation across the 150 cities in the Mapping Inequality data set? 2. What are the contemporary relationships between redlining and segregation? 3. What health outcomes are most salient for measuring the effect of redlining on contemporary population health? 4. What is the contemporary relationship between these health outcomes and historical redlining boundaries? -
Raw data, code, and docs archived on OSF . 10.17605/OSF.IO/KXWP5
github.com/prenerlab/redHealth github.com/slu-openGIS/tidyseg Slides available via SpeakerDeck speakerdeck.com/chrisprener/nu18 Raw data, code available via GitHub github.com/prenerlab/redliningPilot [email protected] chris-prener.github.io LEARN MORE THANKS FOR COMING! Analysis data is archived on Figshare 10.6084/m9.figshare.7223621 , : @chrisprener Project software github.com/slu-openGIS/cityHealth