Upgrade to Pro — share decks privately, control downloads, hide ads and more …

Surrender (But Don't Give Yourself Away) - Swif...

Surrender (But Don't Give Yourself Away) - SwiftSonic, Nashville, TN, November 2026

A walk through some of the research about Cognitive Surrender and how we interact with AI, and some of my experiences with it.

Ellen Shapiro PRO

November 21, 2026

Transcript

94 slides
  1. SURRENDER (BUT DON'T GIVE YOURSELF AWAY) ! SWIFTSONIC | NASHVILLE,

    TN | NOVEMBER 2026 DESIGNATEDNERD.COM | MASTODON.SOCIAL/@DESIGNATEDNERD
  2. !

  3. ☢

  4. !

  5. "COGNITIVE SURRENDER REPRESENTS A DEEPER ABDICATION OF CRITICAL EVALUATION, WHERE

    THE USER RELINQUISHES COGNITIVE CONTROL AND ADOPTS THE AI'S JUDGMENT AS THEIR OWN." https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=6097646 (Emphasis mine)
  6. !

  7. !

  8. !

  9. !

  10. “SYSTEMS THAT GIVE DIRECT ANSWERS MAY HAVE VERY DIFFERENT LONG-TERM

    EFFECTS FROM SYSTEMS THAT SCAFFOLD, COACH, OR CHALLENGE THE USER” https://www.wired.com/story/using-ai-negative-impact-thinking-problem-solving-study/
  11. "PARTICIPANTS WHO USED AI FOR HINTS SHOWED NO SIGNIFICANT IMPAIRMENTS

    RELATIVE TO CONTROL." https://ai-project-website.github.io/AI-assistance-reduces-persistence/
  12. ✅

  13. "PARTICIPANTS REWARDED FOR ACCURACY AND GIVEN IMMEDIATE ITEM-LEVEL FEEDBACK WERE

    SIGNIFICANTLY MORE ACCURATE" https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=6097646
  14. !

  15. !

  16. !

  17. !

  18. !

  19. "THE PROBLEM WITH WRITING WITH A.I. IS THAT IT’S MENTALLY

    ENFEEBLING — AN ESCALATOR TOWARD A RESULT WHEN YOU REALLY NEED TO MAKE A DAILY HABIT OF TAKING THE STAIRS." https://www.nytimes.com/2026/08/04/opinion/artificial-intelligence-ai-writing.html
  20. "WE BECOME MORE CREATIVE WHEN WE LEARN HOW TO PUT

    A PERSONAL STAMP EVEN ON ROUTINE THINGS, MAKING THEM UNMISTAKABLY OUR OWN." https://www.nytimes.com/2026/08/04/opinion/artificial-intelligence-ai-writing.html
  21. OBLIGATORY SUMMARY SLIDE > Cognitive surrender is letting AI make

    decisions for you, without applying any intuitive or critical thought.
  22. OBLIGATORY SUMMARY SLIDE > Cognitive surrender is letting AI make

    decisions for you, without applying any intuitive or critical thought. > reducing CS means actively participating or getting hints from AI rather than letting it do the thing for you
  23. OBLIGATORY SUMMARY SLIDE > Cognitive surrender is letting AI make

    decisions for you, without applying any intuitive or critical thought. > reducing CS means actively participating or getting hints from AI rather than letting it do the thing for you > Your brain is a muscle: It'll atrophy if not used
  24. OBLIGATORY SUMMARY SLIDE > Cognitive surrender is letting AI make

    decisions for you, without applying any intuitive or critical thought. > reducing CS means actively participating or getting hints from AI rather than letting it do the thing for you > Your brain is a muscle: It'll atrophy if not used > This is all kind of exhausting. Don't get tempted to work all the time to "keep up".
  25. LINKS! > AI and the Psychology of Cognitive Surrender https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/

    the-digital-self/202606/ai-and-thepsychology-of-cognitive-surrender > Learning Curve: The AI Optimist Researching Cognitive Surrender https://learningcurve.fm/ episodes/the-ai-optimist-researchingcognitive-surrender
  26. EVEN MORE LINKS! > I Sold Out for $20 a

    Month and All I Got Was This Perfectly Generated Terraform https:// matduggan.com/i-sold-out-for-200-a-monthand-all-i-got-was-this-perfectlygenerated-terraform/ > Just One More Prompt: Why Agentic Coding Hooks Us https://www.youtube.com/watch? v=ILCT1Ql2Psg
  27. MORE LINKS! > Using AI for Just 10 Minutes Might

    Make You Lazy and Dumb, Study Shows https://www.wired.com/ story/using-ai-negative-impact-thinkingproblem-solving-study/ > Will A.I. Make Your Brain Lazy? Here’s What the New Research Actually Shows. https:// www.nytimes.com/interactive/2026/09/29/ magazine/ai-chatbots-brain-development-
  28. ACADEMIC PAPER LINKS! > Thinking — Fast, Slow, and Artificial:

    How AI is Reshaping Human Reasoning and the Rise of Cognitive Surrender https://osf.io/preprints/psyarxiv/yk25n_v1 > Gradual Disempowerment: Systemic existential Risks From Incremental AI Development https:// arxiv.org/abs/2501.16946
  29. MORE ACADEMIC PAPER LINKS! > AI Assistance Reduced Persistence https://aiproject-website.github.io/AI-assistancereduces-persistence/

    > Experimental Evidence on the Learning Impact of Generative AI https://arxiv.org/abs/2607.08849

More Decks by Ellen Shapiro

Other Decks in Technology