Share
Embed
2014-09-NanoGe-Oxford
Perovskite work presented at the NanoGe conference in Oxford in September 2014.
Jarvist Moore Frost
September 12, 2014
Transcript
51 slides
-
Jarvist Moore Frost (University of Bath, UK) Hybrid halide perovskites:
Modelling crystal dynamics 12th September 2014 Jarvist Moore Frost, Federico Brivio, Christopher Hendon, Keith Butler, Aron Walsh Walsh Materials Design Group, University of Bath, UK [email protected] Hybrid halide perovskites: Modelling crystal dynamics and devices -
Jarvist Moore Frost (University of Bath, UK) Hybrid halide perovskites:
Modelling crystal dynamics 12th September 2014 Molecular Dynamics on MAPI (PBESol, Γ-point, VASP) Soft crystal; large distortions of octahedra Repercussions for grain boundaries? (fortuitous?) Accuracy of electronic structure calculations on 'perfect' 'equilibrated' crystals? Would fluctuations lead to polaron localisation? [2x2x2 Pseudo cubic relaxed supercell, lattice parameters held constant during MD (NVT simulation). PBESol Functional at the Gamma point (forces + energies should converge well). dt=0.5fs, T=300K] -
Jarvist Moore Frost (University of Bath, UK) Hybrid halide perovskites:
Modelling crystal dynamics 12th September 2014 Molecular Dynamics Video (hopefully...) • MA ion yaws • ...and rolls… • ...CH3 clicks • so does NH3 ( 25 fs / frame 0.625 ps / s ) -
Jarvist Moore Frost (University of Bath, UK) Hybrid halide perovskites:
Modelling crystal dynamics 12th September 2014 Molecular Dynamics Challenge is getting useful science out of R{x, y,z}(t) • {Static} ensemble information • Dynamics ◦ Correlation (MA ion vs. Octahedra) -
Jarvist Moore Frost (University of Bath, UK) Hybrid halide perovskites:
Modelling crystal dynamics 12th September 2014 Purple - Iodine Green - Lead Orange - Carbon (methylammonium) Disordered & soft! Tilting octahedra -
Jarvist Moore Frost (University of Bath, UK) Hybrid halide perovskites:
Modelling crystal dynamics 12th September 2014 Lead Iodine Carbon (Methylammonium) -
Jarvist Moore Frost (University of Bath, UK) Hybrid halide perovskites:
Modelling crystal dynamics 12th September 2014 Iodine Location -
Jarvist Moore Frost (University of Bath, UK) Hybrid halide perovskites:
Modelling crystal dynamics 12th September 2014 Glazer Tilting - Glazer 1972 -
Jarvist Moore Frost (University of Bath, UK) Hybrid halide perovskites:
Modelling crystal dynamics 12th September 2014 -
Jarvist Moore Frost (University of Bath, UK) Hybrid halide perovskites:
Modelling crystal dynamics 12th September 2014 -
Jarvist Moore Frost (University of Bath, UK) Hybrid halide perovskites:
Modelling crystal dynamics 12th September 2014 Perovskite Distortions • DISTORTIONS of the octahedra • DISPLACEMENTS of cations (i.e. BaTiO3) • TILTING of the Octahedra Distortion & displacement driven by electronic instabilities of A-cation (Here, Pb) Tilting retains same 1st coordination sphere (octahedra), while cation-anion distance changes (After Woodward, 1997) -
Jarvist Moore Frost (University of Bath, UK) Hybrid halide perovskites:
Modelling crystal dynamics 12th September 2014 MAPI: Tilts, Distorts & Displaces • This is a problem; how to deconvolve? "Gauge kinematics of deformable bodies" Shapere, Wilczek Am. J. Phys. 57, 514 (1989); DOI: 10.1119/1.15986 -
Jarvist Moore Frost (University of Bath, UK) Hybrid halide perovskites:
Modelling crystal dynamics 12th September 2014 Previously: POTATO Given Glazer notation & tilt angles, generates corner-sharing Octahedra 2x2x2 supercell. Acta Cryst. (1997). B53, 32-43 [ doi:10.1107/S0108768196010713 ] Octahedral Tilting in Perovskites. I. Geometrical Considerations P. M. Woodward -
Jarvist Moore Frost (University of Bath, UK) Hybrid halide perovskites:
Modelling crystal dynamics 12th September 2014 Here: SMASH • Framework of ab-initio perovskite analysis codes • Written in julia ◦ Easier to extend analysis to further parameters • Work in progress! © National Cancer Institute, Renee Comet (photographer) -
Jarvist Moore Frost (University of Bath, UK) Hybrid halide perovskites:
Modelling crystal dynamics 12th September 2014 Deformation potential Large scale movement of ions considerably varies Hamiltonian used to calculate the electronic structure Disorder of movement means there is no longer a perfect lattice - Bloch states feel a disordered potential Consequence for band transport? (i.e. polaron localisation) For absorption? (losing dimensionality of bands increases absorption coefficient, i.e. as amorphous silicon vs. X'taline) -
Jarvist Moore Frost (University of Bath, UK) Hybrid halide perovskites:
Modelling crystal dynamics 12th September 2014 Band Gap variation (Gamma, PBESol) during MD Qualitative only. Gamma point PBESol occ->unocc energy only! No fermi golden rule / overlap consideration Need a quasi-particle theory for proper absorption -
Jarvist Moore Frost (University of Bath, UK) Hybrid halide perovskites:
Modelling crystal dynamics 12th September 2014 MD: Extract methyl-ammonium alignment vectors... C-N C-N C-N -
Jarvist Moore Frost (University of Bath, UK) Hybrid halide perovskites:
Modelling crystal dynamics 12th September 2014 A total of 58 ps (2319 frames) of data was used for analysis, after an equilibration run of 5 ps. This generated 18547 unique MA alignment vectors. -
Jarvist Moore Frost (University of Bath, UK) Hybrid halide perovskites:
Modelling crystal dynamics 12th September 2014 Octahedral symmetry... Pseudo cubic, therefore Oh symmetry… But how to apply the reductions? (Brews ohare, Wikimedia Commons) (Tom Ruen, Wikimedia Commons) -
Jarvist Moore Frost (University of Bath, UK) Hybrid halide perovskites:
Modelling crystal dynamics 12th September 2014 -
Jarvist Moore Frost (University of Bath, UK) Hybrid halide perovskites:
Modelling crystal dynamics 12th September 2014 Reduce to first octant… abs(r), r=[x,y,z] -
Jarvist Moore Frost (University of Bath, UK) Hybrid halide perovskites:
Modelling crystal dynamics 12th September 2014 Apply reflection symmetry… sorted(abs(r)) , r={x,y,z} = 48 fold increase in SNR (Tom Ruen, Wikimedia Commons) -
Jarvist Moore Frost (University of Bath, UK) Hybrid halide perovskites:
Modelling crystal dynamics 12th September 2014 FACE (X) DIAGONAL (R) EDGE (M) -
Jarvist Moore Frost (University of Bath, UK) Hybrid halide perovskites:
Modelling crystal dynamics 12th September 2014 FACE (X) DIAGONAL (R) EDGE (M) FACE: 42% EDGE: 31% DIAG.: 26% (weighted by MC integration of random sphere points) -
Jarvist Moore Frost (University of Bath, UK) Hybrid halide perovskites:
Modelling crystal dynamics 12th September 2014 (1 frame = 25 fs) Sampling both residence time (long tail) & time taken to move (short time peak) ~2.5 ps for average (mean) dynamics ~1.25 ps for first peak (fast) dynamics -
2D photon echo anisotropy measurements • monoexponential decay ~2 ps
reorientation time • This is the fastest estimate as energy transfer may be involved Pump 1470 cm-1 Probe 1445 cm-1 Experiment & Data Analysis by Artem Bakulin et al. -
Jarvist Moore Frost (University of Bath, UK) Hybrid halide perovskites:
Modelling crystal dynamics 12th September 2014 What effect do these rotating cations have? There are a lot of dynamic processes here... Monopoles moving (i.e. ions) will dominate dielectric response, dipole rotation will add an additional smaller contribution Now we build a model for electrostatic interacting dipole domains -
Jarvist Moore Frost (University of Bath, UK) Hybrid halide perovskites:
Modelling crystal dynamics 12th September 2014 Ferroelectric domain Hamiltonian -
Jarvist Moore Frost (University of Bath, UK) Hybrid halide perovskites:
Modelling crystal dynamics 12th September 2014 STARRYNIGHT code; live user interface Dipole alignment Resultant potential -
Jarvist Moore Frost (University of Bath, UK) Hybrid halide perovskites:
Modelling crystal dynamics 12th September 2014 Electrostatic potential projected onto electron density isosurface (iso value = 0.02) 0.6 0.375 0.3 Electrostatic Potential Vacuum calculation CCSD/cc-pVTZ on b3lyp/6-31g* geom. Gaussian09 2.2 Debye Φ E 18 electrons,closed shell = happy quantum chemical days Hartrees (x 27.211 V) -
Jarvist Moore Frost (University of Bath, UK) Hybrid halide perovskites:
Modelling crystal dynamics 12th September 2014 Same data, volume slice projection 0.6 0.0 Hartrees (x 27.211 V) -
Jarvist Moore Frost (University of Bath, UK) Hybrid halide perovskites:
Modelling crystal dynamics 12th September 2014 Interaction Energy Vacuum dielectric (effect through empty cage gap) On-lattice dipoles, spacing of 6.29Å. Point dipole approximation * = 25 meV * MA Dipole moment massively dominates in polarisation tensor, point approximation possibly not valid r=6.29Å 2.2 Debye -
Jarvist Moore Frost (University of Bath, UK) Hybrid halide perovskites:
Modelling crystal dynamics 12th September 2014 Display direction of Dipole by point on HSV sphere p -
Jarvist Moore Frost (University of Bath, UK) Hybrid halide perovskites:
Modelling crystal dynamics 12th September 2014 0K 100K 300K 1000K -
Jarvist Moore Frost (University of Bath, UK) Hybrid halide perovskites:
Modelling crystal dynamics 12th September 2014 Zero field Dipole alignment .04% aligned (noise) -
Jarvist Moore Frost (University of Bath, UK) Hybrid halide perovskites:
Modelling crystal dynamics 12th September 2014 Zero field Dipole potential -
Jarvist Moore Frost (University of Bath, UK) Hybrid halide perovskites:
Modelling crystal dynamics 12th September 2014 Zero field Dipole potential Zero field Dipole potential (2D FFT) Zero frequency origins -
Jarvist Moore Frost (University of Bath, UK) Hybrid halide perovskites:
Modelling crystal dynamics 12th September 2014 Short-circuit field Dipole alignment .5% aligned -
Jarvist Moore Frost (University of Bath, UK) Hybrid halide perovskites:
Modelling crystal dynamics 12th September 2014 Short-circuit field Dipole potential -
Jarvist Moore Frost (University of Bath, UK) Hybrid halide perovskites:
Modelling crystal dynamics 12th September 2014 Short-circuit field (10MV/m) Dipole potential Dipole potential (2D FFT) -
Jarvist Moore Frost (University of Bath, UK) Hybrid halide perovskites:
Modelling crystal dynamics 12th September 2014 Zero field (open circuit) Dipole potential Short Circuit Field Dipole potential Same figures, presented side by side... -
Jarvist Moore Frost (University of Bath, UK) Hybrid halide perovskites:
Modelling crystal dynamics 12th September 2014 Zero field (open circuit) Dipole potential (2D FFT) Short Circuit Field Dipole potential (2D FFT) Same figures, presented side by side... -
Jarvist Moore Frost (University of Bath, UK) Hybrid halide perovskites:
Modelling crystal dynamics 12th September 2014 Conclusions • MAPI is soft. Distorting / Tilting @ 300K • MA is highly rotationally mobile… ◦ … with a large static dipole along it ◦ Cage:Cage dipole interaction ~25meV • Very rich phase behaviour of 'Potts' style classical model • Dipole domains form regions of electro static potential which may be relevant for charge carrier mobility & recombination -
Jarvist Moore Frost (University of Bath, UK) Hybrid halide perovskites:
Modelling crystal dynamics 12th September 2014 WMD Group (Bath) Piers Barnes, Aurelien Leguy (Imperial - quasi-inelastic neutron scattering data & device operation & hysteresis / effect of built in fields) Hugo Bronstein, Robert Palgrave (UCL - discussing hybrid perovskites & the potential for alternative cations) Artem Bakulin (direct time constant measurements; following discussion at EMRS) Piers Aurelien Hugo Artem Acknowledgments -
Jarvist Moore Frost (University of Bath, UK) Hybrid halide perovskites:
Modelling crystal dynamics 12th September 2014 Papers & codes Atomistic Origins of High-Performance in Hybrid Halide Perovskite Solar Cells Jarvist M. Frost, Keith T. Butler, Federico Brivio, Christopher H. Hendon, Mark van Schilfgaarde, and Aron Walsh Nano Letters 2014 14 (5), 2584-2590 DOI: 10.1021/nl500390f Molecular ferroelectric contributions to anomalous hysteresis in hybrid perovskite solar cells Jarvist M. Frost, Keith T. Butler, and Aron Walsh APL Mat. 2, 081506 (2014); DOI: 10.1063/1.4890246 Barnes, Leguy et al. - quasi-inelastic neutron scattering - in production MD Videos - on YouTube: https://t.co/5z81WfUZhw https://github.com/WMD-Bath/StarryNight - Starrynight code (classical dipoles 2D MC code) https://github.com/jarvist/MAPI-MD-analysis - Analysis codes for MD (Python) https://github.com/WMD-Bath/Hybrid-perovskites - Hybrid perovskite DFT structures -
Jarvist Moore Frost (University of Bath, UK) Hybrid halide perovskites:
Modelling crystal dynamics 12th September 2014 Dipole angle distributions Increasing (applied) electric field E=1 kBT (NB: Enormous applied electric fields!) E=2 kBT E=10 kBT -
Jarvist Moore Frost (University of Bath, UK) Hybrid halide perovskites:
Modelling crystal dynamics 12th September 2014 Red: Zero Field Green: Applied Field -
Jarvist Moore Frost (University of Bath, UK) Hybrid halide perovskites:
Modelling crystal dynamics 12th September 2014 Classic dipole model MAPI perovskite has competing interactions giving rise to geometric frustration i.e. similar to a spin glass, but with various electrostatic and cage distortion interactions rather than ferromagnetic and anti-ferromagnetic. Potts model (Potts, 1952), n-dimensional, generalisation of Ising (Ising, 1925) model. Simple 'dipole like' dot-product interaction energy:- See: F. Y. Wu, The Potts model Rev. Mod. Phys. 54, 235 – Published 1 January 1982 -
Jarvist Moore Frost (University of Bath, UK) Hybrid halide perovskites:
Modelling crystal dynamics 12th September 2014 -
Jarvist Moore Frost (University of Bath, UK) Hybrid halide perovskites:
Modelling crystal dynamics 12th September 2014 Directly animated live in the terminal... -
Jarvist Moore Frost (University of Bath, UK) Hybrid halide perovskites:
Modelling crystal dynamics 12th September 2014 Piet Mondrian, 'Broadway Boogie-Woogie', 1942