Share
Embed
Transcript
17 slides
-
Agora 2.0: Increasing Engagement with Onsite Public Display Team Schiavo
G., Saldivar J., Milano M., Nasir T.! ! Advisors Convertino G., Zancanaro M., Casati F., Hoehn R.! Publication Schiavo, G., Milano, M., Saldivar, J., Nasir., T., Zancanaro, M., & Convertino, G. (2013). ! Agora 2.0: Enhancing Civic Participation through a Public Display. Communities and Technologies (C&T ’13) comtech13.xrce.xerox.com! Contacts [email protected] ! [email protected]! -
Web-based tools are at the forefront ! to support public
deliberation ! (Lighninger, 2011)! Most powerful applications merge online ! and face-to-face interaction! (Bittle, Haller & Kadlec - Center for advances in Public Engagement)! but web tools might not be enough…! -
Digital Divide Connectivity and Internet Access in Italy (as of
2012)! 45.5 55.5 Whole population Has Has not 11.8 88.2 Access for >65 Source: Italian National Institute of statistics (ISTAT) - 2012 ! -
Agora 2.0 a public display for civic participation It is
an e-participation system that combines a website with a public display! It allows the public administration staff and citizens to post polls and gather opinions about local issues! -
an online site! (IdeaScale)! an onsite tool in the form
of an interactive public display ! Agora 2.0 a public display for civic participation Ideas and Votes -
Based on the IdeaScale platform! Allows the public administration staff
and the citizenry ! to post pools and gather opinions about local issues.! Ideas are phrased as yes or no-question! Each ideas is presented with a description of the topic! Users can answer, comment or add new questions! The Online Website -
Extension of IdeaScale platform! We designed and implemented a public
display that extend the functionalities of the web-based ideascale platform.! The Public Display -
The question and background information are displayed on the left!
The sidebar contains information about the project! At the bottom there are instructions on ! how to vote! Public Display: Interface Layout -
Synchronization between the online site (IdeaScale) and the public display!
• The ideas posted in IdeaScale had to be displayed in the public display • The votes collected in IdeaScale had to be aggregated with the votes collected in the public display and vice versa Technical Requirements -
Public Display Interface Public screen Front End Core DB IdeaScale
Get Idea Information (Idea list, Votes) Back End Users actions Display Information Save/Get Idea Information Save Vote / Change Idea Online platform Public display AGORA 2.0 System Architecture System Architecture API -
Press green to agree with the question! Press the red
button to disagree! Middle button to change question! Low-entry barrier ! method of interaction! Mouse with ! coloured buttons! Public Display: Interaction Technique Public Display: Interaction Technique -
4 weeks Loca l community • Usage data and system
logs ! • Observations and notes from the field! • Interviews to both users an passive-users! Field Deployment at the city of Trento’s office for the relation with the public -
Passers-by were ! middle-age citizens ! ! 290 votes !
from approximately ! 250 users ! 15 people were interviewed! ! Results for the field study -
Topic Technology Notice Boards Main Reasons to interact Voting behavior
• Interacting and voting in groups! • People tended to agree with the question displayed! • Voting with the “feet”! -
Impact on future work Benefits with Onsite Public Displays Key
Factors • Expand the audience – Close the digital divide! • Involve frequent and sporadic users! • Trigger group discussions in front of the device! • Easy and low-barrier interaction! • The topic should be relevant and attract the audience! • Choosing the right location is fundamental! -
Agora 2.0: Increasing Engagement with Onsite Public Display Team Schiavo
G., Saldivar J., Milano M., Nasir T.! ! Advisors Convertino G., Zancanaro M., Casati F., Hoehn R.! Publication Schiavo, G., Milano, M., Saldivar, J., Nasir., T., Zancanaro, M., & Convertino, G. (2013). ! Agora 2.0: Enhancing Civic Participation through a Public Display. Communities and Technologies (C&T ’13) comtech13.xrce.xerox.com! Contacts [email protected] ! [email protected]!