Comparison Due 04/26 Image/Text Due 05/2 Full Instruc]ons, Supplementary Materials, and Rubrics are available on Blackboard !Mythological Comparison Instructions Due: Thursday April 11, 2013 Prompt: One of the most interesting aspects of classical mythology is the variety with which myths can be told, retold and, represented. In this assignment, you will write an essay that compares and contrasts two interpretations of one of the many adventures of the hero Odysseus (also called Ulysses) had on his journey home after Trojan War—his perilous encounter with the sirens (also called seirens). Format: Your essay should be organized around a thesis statement, which is supported by a thorough comparison of the two objects, how they represent the myth, and their formal qualities. When comparing the two depictions, be sure to identify each of the figures in the scene by name and determine the different versions of the myth being presented. To help you understand the “Judgment of Paris,” it is recommended that you refer to the attached selections from Timothy Gantz’s Early Greek Myth and Jennifer Neils’ “Les Femmes Fatales: Skylla and the Sirens in Greek Art.” This short reading outlines the different versions of the myth that occur in Greek literature and pottery. Issues you may consider: While formulating your thesis, you may ask yourself the following questions: What part of the story is each image portraying? What version of the myth does each image represent? What are some significant differences between the two representations? How do those differences create a distinct interpretation of the chosen story? How do their respective contexts (date/location) change the story being told and the methods by which it is told? Remember the more specific your thesis is, the better it will be. Requirements: Your paper should be around three to four pages double spaced with one-inch margins using Times New Roman. The best papers will be well-organized analyses organized around a central observation, or THESIS STATEMENT with supporting paragraphs that utilize appropriate examples from the images or the provided texts. A reader should be able to follow your reasoning, observations and descriptions. Be thorough, be organized and be specific in your references. Figure 2, William Etty, Ulysses and the Sirens, 1836. Figure 1, “Odysseus and the Sirens” (Detail), Attic Red-Figure Stamnos, Attributed to the Siren Painter, c. 480-470 BCE.