Share
Embed
Visualizing Ten Years of Quantitative Color Schemes
Travis White
University of Kansas
#nacis2015
Nathaniel V. KELSO
October 15, 2015
Transcript
47 slides
-
Existing research & resources indicate how Qc should be used…
How are mapmakers using Qc? -
Qc Map Review & Evaluation Key parameters ∙2004-2013 ∙geographic journals
from multiple fields ∙no cartographic articles -
Qc Map Review & Evaluation Key parameters ∙2004-2013 ∙geographic journals
from multiple fields ∙no cartographic articles ∙at least one map selected per article ∙univariate maps only ∙no elevation maps -
Qc Map Review & Evaluation Key parameters ∙2004-2013 ∙geographic journals
from multiple fields ∙no cartographic articles ∙at least one map selected per article ∙univariate maps only ∙no elevation maps 440 Qc maps from 315 articles -
100% 80% 60% 40% 20% 0% 2004 2005 2006 2007
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 Qualitative color scheme rates 11% 29% 42% 71% -
Question 1 Which Qc schemes were used? How appropriately? By
whom? Question 2 Which colors were used? How appropriately? By whom? -
Question 1 Which Qc schemes were used? How appropriately? By
whom? Question 2 Which colors were used? How appropriately? By whom? -
Persona 1 ∙maps human data ∙works w/ unipolar data ∙prefers
choropleth (enum. units) ∙uses fewer data classes 2 Qc mapper personas: -
Persona 1 ∙maps human data ∙works w/ unipolar data ∙prefers
choropleth (enum. units) ∙uses fewer data classes 2 Qc mapper personas: Persona 2 ∙maps physical data ∙works equally between polarities ∙prefers surface data ∙uses more data classes -
Useful color assessment requires accurate color identification, but… consistent accurate
sampling not possible with unclassed schemes: Cloetingh 2007 , Koch 2009, Fischer 2001, Salvati 2013 -
Gimpel 2004, Combes 2005, Wahl 2012, Holand 2013 However… consistent,
accurate sampling is possible with classed Qc -
Classed Qc sampling process Photoshop CC 2015 sRGB IEC61966-2.1 color
profile RGB color image mode example: Escutia 2005 Confirm the color profile, copy legend to a new layer Edit out pixel noise -
Classed Qc sampling process Photoshop CC 2015 sRGB IEC61966-2.1 color
profile RGB color image mode example: Escutia 2005 Average the edited color pixel values Point sample the averaged color values [eyedropper] -
DISCLAIMER Sampling & evaluations based on digital versions of maps,
not original map files. Qc scheme appearances are inconsistent across display devices. -
Sequential Red/Orange/Yellow ∙n = 99 (31% of all Qc maps)
∙primary scheme for choropleths ∙preferred scheme for human data -
Sequential Green/Blue/Purple ∙n = 99 (31% of all Qc maps)
∙primary scheme for choropleths ∙preferred scheme for human data -
Sequential Yellow/Orange/Brown ∙n = 99 (31% of all Qc maps)
∙primary scheme for choropleths ∙preferred scheme for human data -
Diverging non-spectral (critical class) ∙n = 86 (27% of all
Qc maps) ∙common on both choro & surface maps ∙more frequently used for physical data -
Diverging non-spectral (critical break) ∙n = 86 (27% of all
Qc maps) ∙common on both choro & surface maps ∙more frequently used for physical data -
Spectral (non-diverging) ∙n = 76 (24% of all Qc maps)
∙overwhelmingly used on surface maps ∙overwhelmingly used for physical data -
Spectral (diverging) ∙n = 76 (24% of all Qc maps)
∙overwhelmingly used on surface maps ∙overwhelmingly used for physical data -
Traffic (diverging & non-diverging) ∙n = 26 (8% of all
Qc maps) ∙more common on surface maps ∙used for half of all human + physical data -
Other (hypso, thermal, undefined…) ∙n = 35 (11% of all
Qc maps) ∙no noteworthy patterns -
Accentuating the positive ∙Sequential & Diverging schemes used appropriately ∙Qc
schemes rarely lost in visual hierarchy ∙Color deficiency not too problematic (ignoring Spectral & Traffic schemes) -
Accentuating the negative ∙Too many classes! ∙Poor color grading (cannot
distinguish colors within a scheme) ∙Poor matching btwn data type & Qc (e.g., unipolar data + diverging scheme) ∙Illogical sequencing of colors ∙Image quality matters! -
Recommendations ∙Educate & Inform! mappers need instruction and guidance ∙Improve
graphics publication guidelines ∙Improve or limit software/package offerings ∙A Brewer for non-choro mapping (?) -
Thank You! Expanded slides & RGB profiles available at: References
Bordi, I. and A. Sutera. 2004. Drought variability and its climatic implications, Global and Planetary Change 40, 115–127 . Brewer, Cynthia A., 2013. http://www.colorbrewer2.org, accessed October 4, 2015 Gillespie, T, Foody, G., Saatchi, S. 2008. Measuring and modelling biodiversity from space, Progress in Physical Geography 32, 203. Groisman, P . Y. 2007 . Potential forest fire danger over Northern Eurasia: Changes during the 20th century, Global and Planetary Change, 56, 371–386. Kaplan, D. and G. Sommers. 2009. An Analysis of the Relationship Between Housing Foreclosures, Lending Practices, and Neighborhood Ecology: Evidence from a Distressed County, The Professional Geographer, 61:1, 101-120. Lewis, L. 2010. Biogeography and Genetic Diversity of Pearl Millet (Pennisetum glaucum) from Sahelian Africa , The Professional Geographer, 62:3, 377-394. Lombard, A. 2005. Contribution of thermal expansion to present-day sea-level change revisited, Global and Planetary Change 47 , 1–16. Maliszewski, P . and M. Horner. 2010. A Spatial Modeling Framework for Siting Critical Supply Infrastructures , The Professional Geographer, 62:3, 426-441. Morehouse, B and S. O’Brien. 2008. Facilitating Public Involvement in Strategic Planning for Wildland Fire Management , The Professional Geographer, 60:4, 495-507 . Setton, E. 2010. Gender Differences in Chronic Exposure to Traffic-Related Air Pollution—A Simulation Study of Working Females and Males, The Professional Geographer, 62:1, 66- 83. Taus, A. 2013. Conversion to Organic Farming in the Continental United States: A Geographically Weighted Regression Analysis, The Professional Geographer, 65:1, 87-102. Wen, T., Lin, M., Fang, C. 2012. Population Movement and Vector-Borne Disease Transmission: Differentiating Spatial–Temporal Diffusion Patterns of Commuting and Noncommuting Dengue Cases, Annals of the Association of American Geographers, 102:5, 1026-1037 .