Upgrade to Pro
— share decks privately, control downloads, hide ads and more …
Speaker Deck
Features
Speaker Deck
PRO
Sign in
Sign up for free
Search
Search
Duck Typing, Compatibility, and the Adaptor Pat...
Search
Reg Braithwaite
September 12, 2014
Programming
7
10k
Duck Typing, Compatibility, and the Adaptor Pattern
Nordic JS, 2014
Reg Braithwaite
September 12, 2014
Tweet
Share
More Decks by Reg Braithwaite
See All by Reg Braithwaite
Courage
raganwald
0
120
Waste in Software Development
raganwald
0
180
First-Class Commands, the 2017 Edition
raganwald
1
180
Optimism and the Growth Mindset
raganwald
0
300
ember-concurrency: an experience report
raganwald
1
140
Optimism II
raganwald
0
400
Optimism
raganwald
0
2k
First-Class Commands: an unexpectedly fertile design pattern
raganwald
4
2.9k
JavaScript Combinators, the “six” edition
raganwald
8
1.4k
Other Decks in Programming
See All in Programming
AI時代のドメイン駆動設計-DDD実践におけるAI活用のあり方 / ddd-in-ai-era
minodriven
25
9.7k
AWS発のAIエディタKiroを使ってみた
iriikeita
1
150
詳解!defer panic recover のしくみ / Understanding defer, panic, and recover
convto
0
210
Laravel Boost 超入門
fire_arlo
2
180
オープンセミナー2025@広島「君はどこで動かすか?」アンケート結果
satoshi256kbyte
0
240
Jakarta EE Core Profile and Helidon - Speed, Simplicity, and AI Integration
ivargrimstad
0
310
CJK and Unicode From a PHP Committer
youkidearitai
PRO
0
100
複雑なドメインに挑む.pdf
yukisakai1225
5
940
オープンセミナー2025@広島LT技術ブログを続けるには
satoshi256kbyte
0
150
KessokuでDIでもgoroutineを活用する / Go Connect #6
mazrean
0
140
【第4回】関東Kaggler会「Kaggleは執筆に役立つ」
mipypf
0
1k
Rancher と Terraform
fufuhu
2
200
Featured
See All Featured
JavaScript: Past, Present, and Future - NDC Porto 2020
reverentgeek
51
5.6k
Product Roadmaps are Hard
iamctodd
PRO
54
11k
Refactoring Trust on Your Teams (GOTO; Chicago 2020)
rmw
34
3.1k
Fight the Zombie Pattern Library - RWD Summit 2016
marcelosomers
234
17k
Why You Should Never Use an ORM
jnunemaker
PRO
59
9.5k
Why Our Code Smells
bkeepers
PRO
339
57k
RailsConf 2023
tenderlove
30
1.2k
KATA
mclloyd
32
14k
Let's Do A Bunch of Simple Stuff to Make Websites Faster
chriscoyier
507
140k
The Cult of Friendly URLs
andyhume
79
6.6k
CoffeeScript is Beautiful & I Never Want to Write Plain JavaScript Again
sstephenson
161
15k
Building Applications with DynamoDB
mza
96
6.6k
Transcript
None
the$art$of$the$javascript$metaobject$protocol Duck%Typing,%Compa1bility,%and The$Adaptor$Pa-ern
None
Duck%typing%is%a%style%of%typing%in% which%an%object's%methods%and% proper:es%determine%the%valid% seman:cs,
...rather'than'its'inheritance'from'a' par0cular'class'or'implementa0on'of' an'explicit'interface.
None
Tastes&Like&Fruit
None
Also%Tastes%Like%Fruit
"Write'code'that'depends'upon' tastes1like(fruit)'rather'than' depending'upon'is1a(fruit)."
None
duck%typing%is%a Compa&bility,Technique
None
A"Problem:
None
Conway's)Game)of)Life
"Conway's*Game*of*Life*is*a*two2 state*cellular*automata."
An#Implementa+on 1. Cells,
An#Implementa+on 1. Cells, 2. Universe,
An#Implementa+on 1. Cells, 2. Universe,.and 3. View.
Cell 1. Neighbours,
Cell 1. Neighbours,.and 2. State.
function StandardCell () { this._neighbours = []; this._alive = false;
}
StandardCell.prototype.neighbours = function neighbours (neighbours) { return this._neighbours; }; StandardCell.prototype.setNeighbours
= function setNeighbours (neighbours) { this._neighbours = neighbours.slice(0); return this; };
StandardCell.prototype.alive = function alive () { return this._alive; }; StandardCell.prototype.setAlive
= function setAlive (alive) { this._alive = alive; return this; };
None
moving'through Time
Cell 1. Neighbours, 2. State,2and 3. Transforma9on2of2State.
Universe 1. Neighbourhoods.(not.shown),
Universe 1. Neighbourhoods.(not.shown),.and 2. Transforma:on.of.States.
StandardCell.prototype.nextAlive = function nextAlive () { var alives = this._neighbours.filter(function
(n) { return n.alive(); }).length; if (this.alive()) { return alives === 2 || alives == 3; } else { return alives == 3; } };
Universe.prototype.iterate = function iterate () { var aliveInNextGeneration = this.cells().map(
function (c) { return [c, c.nextAlive()]; } ); aliveInNextGeneration.forEach(function (a) { var cell = a[0], next = a[1]; cell.setAlive(next); }); };
None
drawing Life
View 1. Drawing*a*Cell:
View.prototype.drawCell = function drawCell (cell, x, y) { var xPlus
= x + this.cellSize(), yPlus = y + this.cellSize() this._canvasContext.clearRect(x, y, xPlus, yPlus); this._canvasContext.fillStyle = this.cellColour(cell); this._canvasContext.fillRect(x, y, xPlus, yPlus); return self; };
View.prototype.cellColour = function cellColour (cell) { return cell.alive() ? WHITE
: BLACK; };
None
None
Ch#ch#ch#changes!
None
redesigning(for Colour
function ColourCell () { this._neighbours = []; this._age = 0;
} ColourCell.prototype.neighbours = StandardCell.prototype.neighbours; ColourCell.prototype.setNeighbours = StandardCell.prototype.setNeighbours;
ColourCell.prototype.age = function age () { return this._age; }; ColourCell.prototype.setAge
= function setAge (age) { this._age = age; return this; };
None
moving'through',me in#Colour
ColourCell.prototype.nextAge = function next () { var alives = this._neighbours.filter(function
(n) { return n.age() > 0; }).length; if (this.age() > 0) { return (alives === 2 || alives == 3) ? (this.age() + 1) : 0; } else { return (alives == 3) ? (this.age() + 1) : 0; } };
Universe.prototype.iterate = function iterate () { var ageInNextGeneration = this.cells().map(
function (c) { return [c, c.nextAge()]; } ); ageInNextGeneration.forEach(function (a) { var cell = a[0], next = a[1]; cell.setAge(next); }); };
None
drawing(life in#Colour
var COLOURS = [ BLACK, GREEN, BLUE, YELLOW, WHITE, RED
]; View.prototype.cellColour = function cellColour (cell) { return COLORS[ (cell.age() >= COLOURS.length) ? (COLOURS.length - 1) : cell.age() ]; }; // ...
None
something Doesn't(Fit
Object.keys(StandardCell.prototype) // => [ 'neighbours', 'setNeighbours', 'alive', 'setAlive', 'nextAlive' ]
Object.keys(ColourCell.prototype) // => [ 'neighbours', 'setNeighbours', 'age', 'setAge', 'nextAge' ]
The$state$of$a$cell$is$now$"age"$ instead$of$"aliveness."
None
These%changes%will Ripple&Through&Universe&and&View
our$problem$is$that Universe(is(coupled(to(Cell's( Interface
None
None
how$smart$people Solve&the&Problem
"Make&a&coloured&cell&behave&like&a& standard&cell."
ColourCell.prototype.alive = function alive () { return this._age > 0;
};
ColourCell.prototype.setAlive = function setAlive (alive) { if (alive) { this.setAge(this.age()
+ 1); } else this.setAge(0); return this; };
ColourCell.prototype.nextAlive = StandardCell.prototype.nextAlive;
Object.keys(ColourCell.prototype) // => [ 'neighbours', 'setNeighbours', 'age', 'setAge', 'nextAge', 'alive',
'setAlive', 'nextAlive' ]
Presto!(Backwards(Compa2bility. (it$"tastes$like$a$standard$cell")
None
universe(and(cell(are No#Longer#Coupled
None
At#What#Cost?
None
Increasing*Flexibility Increases(Complexity
None
None
there%is Another(Way
"Make&a&cell&that&behaves&like&a& Standard&Cell,&but&is&implemented&in& terms&of&a&Coloured&Cell."
function AsStandard (colouredCell) { this._colouredCell = colouredCell; } var tastesLikeAStandardCell
= new AsStandard(aColourCell);
AsStandard.prototype.neighbours = function neighbours () { return this._colouredCell.neighbours(); }; AsStandard.prototype.setNeighbours
= function setNeighbours (neighbours) { this._colouredCell.setNeighbours(neighbours); return this; };
AsStandard.prototype.alive = function alive () { return this._colouredCell.age() > 0;
};
AsStandard.prototype.setAlive = function setAlive (alive) { if (alive) { this._colouredCell.setAge(this._colouredCell.age()
+ 1); } else this._colouredCell.setAge(0); return this; };
AsStandard.prototype.nextAlive = function nextAlive () { return this._colouredCell.nextAge() > 0;
}
Object.keys(AsStandard.prototype) // => [ 'neighbours', 'setNeighbours', 'alive', 'setAlive', 'nextAlive' ]
When%we%Upgrade%to%ColourCell 1. View'can'depend'upon'ColourCell,
When%we%Upgrade%to%ColourCell 1. View'can'depend'upon'ColourCell,'and 2. Universe'can'depend'upon'AsStandard.
Sweet! 1. Universe*is*decoupled*from*changes*to*Cell,
Sweet! 1. Universe*is*decoupled*from*changes*to*Cell,*and 2. ColourCell*isn't*burdened*with*backwards*compa>bility.
None
AsStandard)is)an)Adaptor
The$adapter$(sic)$pa/ern$is$a$ so2ware$design$pa/ern$that$allows$ the$interface$of$an$exis8ng$class$to$ be$used$from$another$interface...
It#is#o'en#used#to#make#exis0ng# classes#work#with#others#without# modifying#their#source#code.
TIMTOWTDI
None
good$programmers$borrow$from$smalltalk, Great&Programmers&Steal&from&C++
function colourFromStandard (standard) { return new ColourCell() .setNeighbours(standard.neighbours()) .setAge(standard.alive() ?
1 : 0); }
function standardFromColour (colour) { return new StandardCell() .setNeighbours(colour.neighbours()) .setAlive(colour.age() >
0); }
None
None
Coproxies
None
None
Approaching+the+End
None
adaptors Separate'Concerns
None
and$thus,$adaptors Isolate(Change
None
and$they Decouple(Modules
None
adaptors Solve&Compa+bility&Problems
None
but$they$also$gives$us$the$freedom$to Make%Changes,%Safely
None
when%we're%using%teams%to%build%so3ware%at%scale Adaptors)are)an)Important)Tool
None
None
one$more$thing:
None
None
when%you're%holding%a Version(Shaped.Hammer
None
all#changes#look#like Migra&on)Shaped/Nails
None
Packages(Have(Interlocking( Dependencies
None
Migra&ons*Can*Cascade you$never$know$how$much$work$a$single$upgrade$can$cause
None
migra&on)is)expensive,)so)semver)values Backwards)Compa.bility
None
"duck&typed"&backwards&compa2bility Holds&Progress&Back
None
breaking)compa.bilty Exposes'Clients'to'Bugs
None
adaptors(decouple Compa&bility,from,Progress
None
adaptors(provide Safe%Compa*bility
None
What%would%an%adaptor.aware% package%manager%look%like?
An#Adaptor*Aware#Package#Manager 1. Interfaces,and,Implementa1ons,would,be,independantly, versioned,
An#Adaptor*Aware#Package#Manager 1. Interfaces,and,Implementa1ons,would,be,independantly, versioned, 2. Interfaces,would,have,a,many<to<many,rela1onship,with, Implementa1ons,,mediated,by,Adaptors,
An#Adaptor*Aware#Package#Manager 1. Interfaces,and,Implementa1ons,would,be,independantly, versioned, 2. Interfaces,would,have,a,many<to<many,rela1onship,with, implementa1ons,,mediated,by,adaptors, 3. Clients,would,specifiy,the,required,interface,and, implementa1on,
An#Adaptor*Aware#Package#Manager 1. Interfaces,and,Implementa1ons,would,be,independantly, versioned, 2. Interfaces,would,have,a,many<to<many,rela1onship,with, implementa1ons,,mediated,by,adaptors, 3. Clients,would,specifiy,the,required,interface,and, implementa1on,,and
4. Old,clients,can,benefit,from,bug,fixes,without,rewrites.
None
an#adaptor)aware#package#manager#could Change'the'Way'We'Grow'So0ware
None
and$that$provides Food$for$Thought for$a$very$long$,me$indeed
None
Tack%Så%Mycket!
Reg$Braithwaite,$ GitHub,$Inc. raganwald.com,•,@raganwald Ar#pelag,*Stockholm,* September*19,*2014