Share
Embed
Transcript
56 slides
-
How do transcription factors recognize their binding sites? C T
A A T T A C T A A T T A T T A A G T A C T A A T G G T T A A T T G T T A A G G A C T A A T G A G T A A T T G Binding sites Sequence that best matches motif. 206,801 exact matches in mouse genome. 2,807 of these are bound by Isl1 in motor neurons. In general (vertebrate genomes): • Millions of motif instances. • Tens of thousands of binding sites. Isl1 -
Most TF binding motif instances are unbound • Essentially all
TF binding motif occurrences will have no function in a given cell type*. • How can we focus on motif instances that are more likely to be bound & functional? • Conservation • Cis-regulatory modules (i.e., clusters of sites) • Measuring TF binding (ChIP-seq) • Accessibility (DNaseI hypersensitivity) • Chromatin marks (H3K4me1, H3K27ac) * Wasserman & Sandelin, Nature Reviews Genetics (2004) Cell type dependent: we would need experimental data -
Limitations of phylogenetic footprinting • Only ~60% of TF binding
sites are directly conserved between human & mouse. • Perhaps even fewer TF binding sites are functionally conserved. • Phylogenetic shadowing approaches allows conservation analysis of binding sites across more closely related species. -
Cis-regulatory modules • Idea: motif instances should be clustered at
real enhancers. • Different combinations of TFs may have different regulatory effects. Regulatory synergy -
Cis-regulatory modules • Multiple TF binding sites will form a
stronger binding region. • Motif instances for cooperating TFs should be located together. -
How do transcription factors recognize their regulatory targets in a
given cell type? CHROMATIN STATE DEPENDENT ACCESSIBILITY TF XYZ COOPERATIVE INTERACTIONS TF XYZ PIONEER BINDING TF BEFORE AFTER BEFORE AFTER BEFORE AFTER NO DEPENDENCE ON PRIOR STATE… -
Chromatin structure may determine TF binding locations • Regulatory sites
are typically located in regions of accessible chromatin. • Enhancers and promoters have characteristic histone modifications. • H3K4me1 at enhancers • H3K4me3 at promoters • TFs may interact differently with methylated DNA. • Higher-order genome topology may also play a role in TF binding. Rosa & Shaw, Biology (2013) -
Chromatin immunoprecipitation (ChIP) 1. Crosslink: Use formaldehyde or UV light
to covalently crosslink proteins to DNA (i.e. stick everything together) 2. Lyse: Use a lysis buffer to break down cell walls and release chromatin. 3. Shear: Use sonication or nuclease digestion to break the crosslinked chromatin into small fragments. -
Chromatin immunoprecipitation (ChIP) 4. Immunoprecipitate: Use antibodies attached to beads
to select for DNA fragments that have a protein of interest attached. Separate out beads using magnet for magnetic beads or centrifugation for agarose beads. Y Y Y Y Y magnetic bead with attached antibodies Y -
Chromatin immunoprecipitation (ChIP) 5. Reverse crosslinks Incubate at 70°C to
reverse cross-linking (i.e., unstick DNA from protein), and separate DNA. -
Chromatin immunoprecipitation (ChIP) 6. Library preparation: Select DNA fragments that
are ~200bp in length. Amplify the fragments using PCR. Size select PCR amplify -
ChIP-seq • Directly sequence ChIPed DNA fragments using a high-throughput
sequencer. • Sequence one or both fragment ends? • à FASTQ file • Map the sequenced reads back to the genome. • Bowtie / BWA • à BAM file -
Data smoothing helps ChIP-seq signals to stand out + -
500bp Foxa2 Liver ChIP-seq Aldh1a1 ~35Kbp upstream -
Data smoothing helps ChIP-seq signals to stand out + -
500bp Foxa2 Liver ChIP-seq extend in 3’ direction Aldh1a1 ~35Kbp upstream -
Data smoothing helps ChIP-seq signals to stand out + -
500bp Foxa2 Liver ChIP-seq extend in 3’ direction remove strandedness Aldh1a1 ~35Kbp upstream -
Making genome browser tracks • Why view data in a
browser? • Visually assess quality of ChIP-enrichment • Confirm previously known binding targets • Explore the data! • Genome browsers • UCSC genome browser (tracks from Galaxy) [http://genome.ucsc.edu] • IGV [https://www.broadinstitute.org/igv] -
ChIP-seq “heat-maps” summarize enrichment over a set of binding sites
Site 1 Site 2 Site 3 Site N 1Kbp -
ChIP-seq “heat-maps” summarize enrichment over a set of binding sites
11,474 binding events 8,687 binding events -
ChIP-seq ChIP-seq signal can be punctate or broadly distributed (or
both) Park, Nature Reviews Genetics (2009) -
Identifying ChIP-enriched regions • Scan the genome using a sliding
window, looking for regions that have more ChIP-seq reads than we would have expected. • Expected by chance? • Expected according to a control experiment? • What would be a good control experiment? • Sequence input material? • Pseudo IP experiment? • Reads from control experiments are not evenly distributed. • More likely to occur in regions of open chromatin • Possibly more likely to occur near highly expressed genes -
Identifying ChIP-enriched regions • MACS: • Artificially extend reads to
expected fragment length, and generate coverage map along genome. • Assume background reads are Poisson distributed. • Mean of the Poisson is locally variable… estimate from control experiment in 5Kbp or 10Kbp around examined location. • For a given location, do we see more reads than we would have expected from the Poisson (p<10-5) MACS: Zhang, et al. Genome Biology, 2008 -
Identifying ChIP-enriched regions PeakSeq: Rozowsky, et al., Nature Biotech, 2009
• Appropriate normalization between signal & control experiments is key • Approaches: • Total tag normalization • Regression on binned paired read counts (ignoring peaks) -
Identifying ChIP-enriched regions • PeakSeq: • Step 1: Identify candidate
enriched locations • Examine only the signal experiment. • Determine an enrichment threshold by simulating the same number of reads and setting a false discovery rate. • Step 2: • Find a control vs. signal scaling ratio by performing regression using non-candidate regions. • Use Binomial test of population proportion differences to assess differences between signal read counts and corresponding scaled control read counts. • Benjamini-Hochberg correction for multiple hypothesis testing. PeakSeq: Rozowsky, et al., Nature Biotech, 2009 -
How many locations does a protein bind? • Statistical answers:
• p-value thresholds (significance of enrichment) • Fold-enrichment cutoffs • Greater sequencing depth typically yields higher numbers of peaks. • Statistical significance vs. biological significance? -
Identifying precise TF binding locations • ChIP-seq reads are distributed
bimodally around binding sites. • Regions of ChIP-enrichment are known as “peaks”. Valouev, et al. Nature Methods (2008) -
Computational challenge: resolve the structure of TF binding events from
ChIP-seq data How many binding events are here? How close to the actual bound bases are event predictions? + - -
Mixture models of ChIP-seq binding events Lhx3 ChIP-seq Predicted binding
events: Motif instances: 140bp 160bp -
GPS/GEM/ChExMix allow more accurate spatial resolution of binding events GEM:
http://groups.csail.mit.edu/cgs/gem/ -
Signal to noise scores • FRiP: fraction of reads in
peaks • Correlates with number of peaks • “Successful” experiments have FRiP >1% • FRiP is sensitive to peak-calling parameters, etc. Landt, et al., Genome Res, 2012 -
Signal to noise scores • Cross-correlation analysis • Pearson linear
correlation between Watson & Crick strand read densities after shifting Watson reads by k bases. • Takes advantage of fact that reads are bimodally distributed around true binding sites. • Independent of peak-calling. Landt, et al., Genome Res, 2012 -
Signal to noise scores • SES: Signal extraction scaling •
Rank order statistic • Rank genomic bins by read count • Plot against cumulative % of reads • Look for inflection point in the graph • CHANCE: https://github.com/songlab/chance Diaz, et al., Genome Biol, 2012 -
Signal to noise scores NCIS: Liang & Keles (2012) NCIS:
• Rank bins by total tags (signal+control) • Estimate ratio using summed tag counts in n lowest ranked bins. • Find point at which estimated ratio begins to increase (using at least 75% of bins) -
Reproducibility scores • Correlation between biological replicates • Compute correlation
between binned read counts across entire genome, or read counts within peak regions. • IDR: Irreproducible Discovery Rate • Assumes ranks of genuine binding site peaks should be consistent across replicates, and ranks of false positive peaks should not. • Uses model to cluster reproducible peaks from irreproducible peaks. • IDR score = probability peak comes from irreproducible group. -
Peak-finders have a wide range of reproducibility Li, et al.,
Annals of Applied Statistics (2011) -
Summary • We cannot (yet) predict where a given transcription
factor will bind in a given cell type. • Motif scanning yields too many potential sites. • ChIP-seq or other experimental approaches are required. • Analysis of ChIP-seq and other protein-DNA binding assay data is not fully standardized • Choice of peak-finding methodology & interpretation of QC metrics is dataset-dependent. • Many tools available for ChIP-seq analysis, only some of which are accessible beyond the command-line. • Few principled performance comparisons have been performed. -
Further reading • Park PJ “ChIP-seq: advantages and disadvantages of
a maturing technology”, Nature Reviews Genetics (2009) 10(10):669-680 • Landt S, et al. “ChIP-seq guidelines and practices of the ENCODE and modENCODE consortia”, Genome Research (2012) 22:1813 – 1831 • Carroll TS, et al. “Impact of artifact removal on ChIP quality metrics in ChIP-seq and ChIP-exo data”, Frontiers in Genetics (2014) 5:75 • Mahony S & Pugh BF “Protein-DNA binding in high resolution”, Critical Reviews in Biochemistry and Molecular Biology (2015) 4:269-283