Share
Embed
Seabird Group Conference, 2018
Presentation on work from my PhD about the effect of environmental heterogeneity on seabird behaviour and fitness. Thank you to the scientific committe for awarding me with joint first student presentation for this talk.
Alice Trevail
September 04, 2018
Transcript
48 slides
-
The Consequences of Environmental Heterogeneity Alice Trevail, J Green, J
Sharples, J Polton, P Miller & S Patrick FAME data from Ellie Owen, Mark Bolton et al. @AliceTrevail [email protected] -
• Not all heterogeneous resource distributions are equal • Distribution
of patches travel distance Resource heterogeneity -
• Not all heterogeneous resource distributions are equal • Distribution
of patches travel distance • Heterogeneity Number of foragers at each patch Resource heterogeneity Matt Doggett -
Q: How does resource heterogeneity influence Foraging behaviour ? &
Fitness ? Resource heterogeneity -
• The environment can define resource distributions Environmental heterogeneity =
proxy for resource heterogeneity Environmental heterogeneity -
Data from 15 colonies around UK range • Foraging behaviour:
GPS data 415 birds 1567 trips • Reproductive success Muckle Skerry Copinsay Winnyfold Fowlsheugh Isle of May Coquet Filey Bempton Cliffs Puffin Bardsey Skomer St Martins Rathlin Colonsay Lambay Black-legged kittiwakes -
Data from 15 colonies around UK range • Foraging behaviour:
GPS data • Reproductive success Muckle Skerry Copinsay Winnyfold Fowlsheugh Isle of May Coquet Filey Bempton Cliffs Puffin Bardsey Skomer St Martins Rathlin Colonsay Lambay Does environmental heterogeneity influence 1. Kittiwake foraging behaviour ? 2. Kittiwake reproductive success ? Black-legged kittiwakes -
Quantifying environmental heterogeneity 1. Environmental variables for spatial points •
Bathymetry • Stratification • Front density, persistence & distance -
Quantifying environmental heterogeneity 1. Environmental variables for spatial points 2.
Principal coordinate analysis • Account for variation in all environmental variables Axis 1 Axis 2 Colony A Colony B -
Quantifying environmental heterogeneity 1. Environmental variables for spatial points 2.
Principal coordinate analysis • Account for variation in all environmental variables Axis 1 Axis 2 Colony A Colony B Heterogeneous Homogeneous -
Quantifying environmental heterogeneity 1. Environmental variables for spatial points 2.
Principal coordinate analysis 3. Heterogeneity = dispersion of points along principal coordinate axes • Continuous variable - average distance from colony mean Axis 1 Axis 2 Colony A Colony B Heterogeneous Homogeneous -
Quantifying environmental heterogeneity • Can identify gradient between colonies (p
< 0.01) 0.8 1.2 1.6 2.0 Coquet Winnyfold Isle of May Muckle Skerry Fowlsheugh St Martins Lambay Filey Bempton Skomer Puffin Island Bardsey Colonsay Rathlin Colony Average distance from colony mean Heterogeneous Homogeneous -
Quantifying environmental heterogeneity • Can identify gradient between colonies (p
< 0.01) 0.8 1.2 1.6 2.0 Coquet Winnyfold Isle of May Muckle Skerry Fowlsheugh St Martins Lambay Filey Bempton Skomer Puffin Island Bardsey Colonsay Rathlin Copinsay Colony Average distance from colony mean Heterogeneous Homogeneous Increasing heterogeneity Muckle Skerry Copinsay Winnyfold Fowlsheugh Isle of May Coquet Filey Bempton Cliffs Puffin Bardsey Skomer St Martins Rathlin Colonsay Lambay -
Quantifying foraging behaviour 1. Trip characteristics • Duration • Max
distance • Total distance -
Quantifying foraging behaviour 2. At-sea area use • Size of
50% core area 1. Trip characteristics • Duration • Max distance • Total distance -
Quantifying foraging behaviour 2. At-sea area use • Size of
50% core area • Overlap between individuals 1. Trip characteristics • Duration • Max distance • Total distance -
Quantifying foraging behaviour 3. Behavioural state • HMM model 2.
At-sea area use • Size of 50% core area • Overlap between individuals 1. Trip characteristics • Duration • Max distance • Total distance transit forage rest transit -
Quantifying foraging behaviour 3. Behavioural state • HMM model •
Proportion of time in different states 2. At-sea area use • Size of 50% core area • Overlap between individuals 1. Trip characteristics • Duration • Max distance • Total distance transit forage rest transit -
Results: foraging behaviour 1. Trip characteristics 1 2 3 -1
0 1 2 Environmental heterogeneity -
Results: foraging behaviour 1. Trip characteristics 1 2 3 -1
0 1 2 Environmental heterogeneity Trip Duration ( log (h) ) -
Results: foraging behaviour 1. Trip characteristics 1 2 3 -1
0 1 2 Environmental heterogeneity Trip Duration ( log (h) ) • Significantly longer trips • No effect on max or total distance -
Results: foraging behaviour 2. At-sea area use 1. Trip characteristics
1 2 3 -1 0 1 2 0.05 0.10 0.15 0.20 -1 0 1 2 Environmental heterogeneity Trip Duration ( log (h) ) Foraging Overlap (BA index) • Significantly longer trips • No effect on max or total distance -
Results: foraging behaviour 2. At-sea area use 1. Trip characteristics
1 2 3 -1 0 1 2 0.05 0.10 0.15 0.20 -1 0 1 2 Environmental heterogeneity Trip Duration ( log (h) ) Foraging Overlap (BA index) • Significantly longer trips • No effect on max or total distance • Significantly more overlap • No effect on foraging area -
Results: foraging behaviour 3. Behavioural state 2. At-sea area use
1. Trip characteristics 1 2 3 -1 0 1 2 0.05 0.10 0.15 0.20 -1 0 1 2 Environmental heterogeneity Trip Duration ( log (h) ) Foraging Overlap (BA index) Proportion of time • Significantly longer trips • No effect on max or total distance • Significantly more overlap • No effect on foraging area 0.2 0.4 0.6 -1 0 1 2 behaviour Forage Transit Rest -
Results: foraging behaviour 3. Behavioural state 2. At-sea area use
1. Trip characteristics 1 2 3 -1 0 1 2 0.05 0.10 0.15 0.20 -1 0 1 2 Environmental heterogeneity Trip Duration ( log (h) ) Foraging Overlap (BA index) Proportion of time behaviour Forage Transit Rest • Significantly longer trips • No effect on max or total distance • Significantly more overlap • No effect on foraging area • Significantly more foraging • Significantly less transiting 0.2 0.4 0.6 -1 0 1 2 -
Results: reproductive success 0.5 1.0 -1 0 1 2 Environmental
heterogeneity Mean fledglings per nest -
• Environmental heterogeneity = lower reproductive success (p < 0.001)
Results: reproductive success 0.5 1.0 -1 0 1 2 p < 0.001, R2=0.27 Environmental heterogeneity Mean fledglings per nest -
• Environmental heterogeneity = lower reproductive success (p < 0.001)
Results: reproductive success 0.5 1.0 -1 0 1 2 p < 0.001, R2=0.27 63% decrease in success across range of environmental heterogeneity Environmental heterogeneity Mean fledglings per nest -
Why does fitness decline with heterogeneity? 1. Are homogeneous sites
higher quality? Heterogeneity Environment metric -
Why does fitness decline with heterogeneity? 1. Are homogeneous sites
higher quality? Homogeneous Heterogeneous Increase in foraging range Heterogeneity Environment metric -
Why does fitness decline with heterogeneity? 1. Are homogeneous sites
higher quality? Homogeneous Heterogeneous Increase in foraging range Heterogeneity Environment metric No links No change in max foraging distance -
Why does fitness decline with heterogeneity? 2. Does heterogeneity make
it harder to find food? -
Why does fitness decline with heterogeneity? 2. Does heterogeneity make
it harder to find food? No change in total distance travelled -
Why does fitness decline with heterogeneity? 2. Does heterogeneity make
it harder to find food? No change in total distance travelled No change in size of core foraging area -
Why does fitness decline with heterogeneity? 3. Does heterogeneity increase
competition at resource patches? Homogeneous Heterogeneous Increase in overlap -
Why does fitness decline with heterogeneity? 3. Does heterogeneity increase
competition at resource patches? Trip duration increased Homogeneous Heterogeneous Increase in overlap -
Why does fitness decline with heterogeneity? 3. Does heterogeneity increase
competition at resource patches? Trip duration increased Time spent foraging increased Homogeneous Heterogeneous Increase in overlap -
Why does fitness decline with heterogeneity? 3. Does heterogeneity increase
competition at resource patches? Trip duration increased Overlap between individuals increased Time spent foraging increased Homogeneous Heterogeneous Increase in overlap -
Summary Heterogeneity may cluster resources into patches This increases competition
at patches Foraging takes longer Poorer chick provisioning Reduced breeding success -
Summary • Heterogeneity could effect species distributions • Important consideration
in studies of population resilience to environmental stressors? -
Thanks to… FAME project Many others for their help in
the field Steve Dodd Matt Wood Ed Stubbings Birgitta Buche Kendrew Colhoun Liam McFaul SEGUL Lots more… Ellie Owen Mark Bolton Ewan Wakefield Kendrew Colhoun Louise Soanes Julia Baer Matthew Carroll Francis Daunt Tim Guilford Roddy Mavor Mark Newall Stephen Newton Gail Robertson Akiko Shoji Steve Votier Sarah Wanless