Share
Embed
Gender-diversity analysis of technical contributions in OpenStack (Barcelona edition)
OpenStack Summit, Barcelona 2016.
Daniel Izquierdo.
Bitergia
October 26, 2016
Transcript
45 slides
-
Gender-diversity analysis of technical contributions Daniel Izquierdo Cortázar @dizquierdo dizquierdo
at bitergia dot com https://speakerdeck.com/bitergia OpenStack Summit, Barcelona 2016 -
/me CDO in Bitergia, the software development analytics company Lately
involved in understanding the gender diversity in some OSS communities Involved in OPNFV dashboard (opnfv.biterg.io) Disclaimer: not involved in any working group, own analysis and interest, I may have missed some stuff... -
Why this study Diversity matters I attended some (Women of
OpenStack) talks in the OpenStack Summit (Tokyo and Austin) Produced some numbers that gained some attention: OpenStack and Linux Kernel In the end this is all about transparency and improvement Update the numbers -
What we have so far FOSS Survey in 2013: -
http://floss2013.libresoft.es/results.en.html - 11% of women answered the survey The Industry Gender Gap by the World Economic Forum. - 5% for CEOs, 21% for Mid-level roles, 32% of Junior roles -
OpenStack (Austin) numbers Women activity (all of the history): ~
10,5% of the population ( ~ 570 developers ) ~ 6,8% of the activity ( >=16k commits ) -
OpenStack (Austin) numbers Women activity (last year): ~ 11% of
the population ( ~ 340 active developers ) ~ 9% of the activity ( >=6k commits ) -
Linux Kernel Numbers Women activity (since 2005): ~ 5.2% (
> 31K commits) ~ 8% of the population ( ~ 1,15K developers) -
Linux Kernel Numbers Women activity (last year): ~ 6.8% of
the activity ( ~ 4k commits ) ~ 9.9% of the population ( ~ 330 active developers ) -
Summary Conclusions not representative, but: - Women represents around 30%/40%
of the workforce in tech companies. - And between 10% and 20% if focused on tech teams. - OpenStack shows a 11% of the population - Linux Kernel shows a 10% of the population -
Some Definitions Contributions: commit, patchset, code review, email Other potential
metrics: diversity by company, fairness in the code review among organizations and genders, transparency in the process Available but sensitive info: affiliation, countries, time to review -
Architecture Original Data Sources Mining Tools Perceval Info Enrich. Genderize.io
Pandas Manual work Viz ElasticSearch + Kibana @ -
Architecture Original Data Sources • Git and mailing lists •
~ 600K commits (359K w/o merges and deb) • ~ 150K emails • ~ 300K changesets (w/o deb) • ~ 1M patchsets (w/o deb) • ~ 1.5M code reviews (w/o deb) @ -
Architecture Mining Tools Perceval • Produces JSON documents from the
usual data sources in OSS • Part of the GrimoireLab toolchain • grimoirelab.github.io -
Architecture Info Enrich. Genderize.io Pandas Manual work • Genderize.io: name
database • Pandas: data analysis lib. • Ceres library (dicortazar/ceres @ github) • Manual work: -
Architecture Viz ElasticSearch + Kibana • ElasticSearch: Schemaless db •
Kibana: works great with ES • This tandem helps a lot to verify info • Drill down capabilities • Extra info available (but not displayed) -
Validation: manual work Check main contributors by hand Asian names
hard to check ( u_u ) (help needed!) Mailing lists providing not expected format -
Git Activity and Population Women activity (all history): 27,162 commits
(7.35% of activity) 839 (10.63% of population) -
Git Activity and Population Women activity (last year): 7748 commits
(8,58% of the activity) 422 developers (11,53% of the population) -
Git Activity Women Evolution • There are jumps at the
beginning of the year • Stable during the last year -
Git Authors Women Evolution • Interesting pattern: each year is
kind of a block of developers -
Mailing List WOO Activity • 14K emails, 9% of the
activity • 672 WOO participants, 9,07% of the population • Similar numbers to the last year -
Code Reviews Overview • Projects not found in the yaml
file were ignored • Package-deb project also ignored -
Gerrit WOO Activity • 28,503 changesets sent, 9,4% activity •
812 women sending changesets, 11,87% of the population • 9,56% of the activity and 13% of the population during the last year Women sending changesets -
October-April-October October 2015 - April 2016 April 2016 - October
2016 Women reviewers -
Some Answers • Similar activity in Git: increase in the
number of repositories • WOO lower activity as core reviewers (~ -9%) ◦ Activity has increased on the other hand (~ 6%) -
Conclusions Room for improvement of the dataset This provides some
initial numbers about the current status Hopefully useful for the Foundation -
Open Questions from Last Talk Question: Is there a specific
action for helping you with the data correctness or the name identification? Suggestion: integrate openstack id with gerrit and in the members foundation directory, there's specific information related to gender Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TQIQCT-Aqpo -
Open Questions from Last Talk Comment: the reason why the
documentation project is doing so great is because they have great inclusive leaders Comment: Another interesting point is 'retention': how to bring them on board and keep them contributing Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TQIQCT-Aqpo -
Open Questions from Last Talk Suggestion: work on relative numbers
and not that much in the net numbers. As projects come and go, it would be interesting to work at this level. Comment: working at the level of high school, works done in the USA/Europe? People are willing to help with this line. Suggestion: address people outside of the gender binary Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TQIQCT-Aqpo -
Further Work Sensitive info: dashboard still private Extra analysis: time
to merge fairness, companies women %, Outreachy follow ups, quarterly reports, updated data, specific policies ROI and others. This [hopefully] helps to have a better picture Other minorities analysis could be done -
Gender-diversity analysis of technical contributions Daniel Izquierdo Cortázar @dizquierdo dizquierdo
at bitergia dot com https://speakerdeck.com/bitergia OpenStack Summit, Barcelona 2016