Upgrade to Pro — share decks privately, control downloads, hide ads and more …

Insect pests of trees in Scotland: the auld and the new

Forest Research
November 25, 2013

Insect pests of trees in Scotland: the auld and the new

Pests- an overview of threats from native, naturalised & exotic pests (past, present & future) by Dr. Roger Moore, Forest Research

Forest Research

November 25, 2013
Tweet

More Decks by Forest Research

Other Decks in Research

Transcript

  1. Pests- an overview of threats from native, naturalised & exotic

    pests (past, present & future) Dr Roger Moore Forest Health Day Event Autumn 2013
  2. 25/11/2013 2 Allies in the fight vs Pests & Diseases

    Grace MacAskill Sarah Green Joan Webber Sandra Denman Anna Brown Clive Brasier Kath Tubby Richard Baden David Rose Nigel Straw Daegan Inward Christine Tilbury Hugh Evans Nick Fielding Steve Hendry Roger Moore Alice Holt Alice Holt NRS NRS Pathologists Pathologists Entomologists Entomologists Advisory Advisory Services Services Wales Wales Tree Health Specialists Matt Elliot April Armstrong
  3. 25/11/2013 3 Insect species Order/Family Status Origin Douglas fir seed

    wasp, Megastigmus spermatrophus Hymenoptera/ Torymidae Can be serious in a poor seed year Exotic North America Douglas fir woolly aphid, Adelges cooleyi Homoptera/ Adelgidae First noted in 1913. Shoot distortion of Douglas fir Exotic North America Larch budmoth, Zeiraphera diniana Lepidoptera/ Tortricidae Periodically causes severe defoliation of Scots and, particularly, lodgepole pines. Exotic Europe Pine looper moth, Bupalus piniaria Lepidoptera/ Geometridae First major outbreak in 1953, then periodically since then, especially on lodgepole pine sites Native Exotic host Pine beauty moth, Panolis flammea Lepidoptera/ Noctuidae Major infestations on lodgepole pine in Scotland (from mid 1970s) Native Exotic host Large pine weevil, Hylobius abietis Coleoptera/ Curculionidae Increasing problem, linked to felling and restocking of conifer crops Native Native and exotic hosts Great spruce bark beetle, Dendroctonus micans Coleoptera/ Scolytidae Established in early 1970s - outbreaks in Wales, bordering counties of England, Lancashire and Kent Exotic Eurasia Large larch bark beetle, Ips cembrae Coleoptera/ Scolytidae From 1950s. Minor outbreaks in Scotland and northern England. Occasionally on spruce. Exotic Europe Six-toothed bark beetle, Ips sexdentatus Coleoptera/ Scolytidae Secondary pest on all pine species Exotic Europe Principal insect outbreaks in Great Britain over the last 100 years Pink = Exotic Pests White = Native Pests
  4. 25/11/2013 4 Insect species Order/Family Status Origin Winter moth, Operophtera

    brumata Lepidoptera/ Geometridae Major defoliator on oak but more recently causing localised outbreaks on Sitka spruce Native Exotic host Horse chestnut scale, Pulvinaria regalis Homoptera/ Coccidae New scale insect pest on horse chestnut, lime and sycamore, first recorded in 1964. Exotic Europe European spruce sawfly, Gilpinia hercyniae Hymenoptera/ Diprionidae Minor records from 1906 but major outbreak period from 1968 to 1975 in mid Wales Exotic Europe Web-spinning larch sawfly, Cephalcia lariciphila Hymenoptera/ Pamphiliidae First record in 1953, then major outbreak from 1972 to 1979 in Wales and many forests in England. Exotic Europe Knopper gall wasp, Andricus quercuscalicis Hymenoptera/ Cynipidae First record in 1961. Knopper galls on acorns reduce oak seed production in poor mast years Exotic Eurasia Gypsy moth, Lymantria dispar Lepidoptera/ Lymantriidae Extinct in Britain in 1907. Asian strain poses higher risk than European; 1994 – present. Small infestations current in north London. Native extinct Current population is exotic (Europe or Asia) Horse chestnut leafminer, Cameraria ohridella Lepidoptera/ Gracillariidae First recorded in Macedonia in 1985. Moved west across Europe. Found in London in 2002, still spreading Exotic Uncertain, could be Macedonia Oak processionary moth, Thaumetopoea processionea Lepidoptera/ Thaumetopoeidae Moving northwards in Europe. Found in London in 2006. Arrived on live plants for planting Exotic Europe Pine lappet moth, Dendrolimus pini Lepidoptera/ 2007. Small breeding population found in north of Scotland. Under investigation Exotic Europe, Asia Principal insect outbreaks in Great Britain over the last 100 years ………CONTINUED Pink = Exotic Pests White = Native Pests
  5. 25/11/2013 5 Insect species Order/Family Status Origin Western conifer seed

    bug, Leptoglossus occidentalis Hemiptera/ Heteroptera First record in 2007 and now widespread. Arrived in Italy in 1999 and spread across Europe Exotic Western North America Asian longhorn beetle, Anoplophora glabripennis Coleoptera/ Cerambycidae Intercepted on imported packaging wood for several years. Breeding population in Kent found in 2012. Under eradication Exotic Asia Pest arrivals are not new, but they appear to be accelerating also pathogens causing diseases of trees ….why? 4 native pest species outbreak on exotic trees 16 exotic pest species outbreak on either native or exotic trees ……Host-switch more damaging- not co-evolved Principal insect outbreaks in Great Britain over the last 100 years ………CONTINUED
  6. 25/11/2013 6 Reasons for trade P&D ‘jump spread’ Factors increasing

    global transport of pests & diseases • Travel (faster) • Transport (further) • Trade (increased) http://bioval.jrc.ec.europa.eu/products/gam/index.htm
  7. 25/11/2013 8 FC approach to P&D threats Our approach is:

    • Keep it out …..if that fails • Eradicate it or contain it …..if that fails • Learn to live with it Good science lies at the heart of all these approaches Examples of attempted eradication (ALB) & containing populations to prevent spread (PtLM)
  8. Established Pests (Native & Introduced) Dendroctonus Dendroctonus Large Pine Weevil

    Large Pine Weevil Winter Moth Winter Moth Pine Pine Looper Looper Moth Moth Pine Beauty Pine Beauty Moth Moth Green Spruce Aphid Green Spruce Aphid Large Larch Beetle Large Larch Beetle
  9. 25/11/2013 11 Large larch bark beetle, Ips cembrae Ips cembrae

    • discovered in western Scotland during 1955 (Moray, Nairn, Banff, Inverness)…now in South Scotland • assumed to have entered the country in post-war shipments of German timber following gales in 1953 • one year life-cycle with two broods per year (Adults Apr/May & July/Aug • can kill standing larch if populations are allowed to build significantly
  10. 25/11/2013 13 Estimates suggest that in the region of 10,000

    ha of Larch will be lost in the SW of Scotland to P.ramorum Bark beetles differ in their degree of aggressiveness (mainly secondary to some other debilitating factor)…. larch bark beetle, Ips cembrae one of the more aggressive
  11. 25/11/2013 14 Large larch bark beetle, Ips cembrae • Ips

    cembrae is intrinsically aggressive • Attacks debilitated but still green trees • This is especially true where it is allowed to build up to high density in windblown, felled, weakened or dead timber • Adults on emergence enter the crown of healthy trees and undertake maturation feeding on 2 to 6 year old branches • Shoots often break off at the point of injury Damage (Adult) Altyre Estate, Moray Monaughty Forest, Moray
  12. 25/11/2013 16 Large larch bark beetle, Ips cembrae Damage Egg

    gallery- extensive, typically 3 armed & star shaped
  13. 25/11/2013 17 Large larch bark beetle, Ips cembrae Outbreak Prevention

    (Monitoring) Monitoring of Ips cembrae populations with pheromone traps in SW Scotland due to P.ramorum outbreak
  14. 25/11/2013 18 Large larch bark beetle, Ips cembrae Bark beetles-

    ‘ability to take advantage of the forester when he is in the greatest of difficulties- after fire, windblow, drought or defoliating insect’. (D. Bevan FC Handbook 1, 1987) or or after fungal attack after fungal attack
  15. 25/11/2013 20 World distribution of Elatobium abietinum (from Carter &

    Halldórsson, 1998) Where is it from? Native to north, central & eastern Europe on Norway spruce Has spread by silviculture and encountered other species of spruce en route • Host Switch • Milder winters in UK- greater populations & damage Distribution
  16. 25/11/2013 21 Aphids feed on mature needles …………not on current

    needles Green spruce aphid- feeding on Sitka Spruce Pest Identification & Feeding Damage
  17. 25/11/2013 22 Elatobium damage to 1yr old & older needles.

    New shoots undamaged. Elatobium abietinum- Sitka spruce damage Damage
  18. 25/11/2013 25 Winter Moth (Operophtera brumata) damage to oak Egg-hatch

    timed to occur during budburst when leaves are more nutritious and less well defended! Pest Identification and Damage on Oak
  19. 25/11/2013 26 Larvae feed only on new current years foliage-

    hatch during budburst! Eggs laid on along twigs and move towards buds on hatching Winter Moth (Operophtera brumata) damage to spruce Eggs and early instar feeding in Sitka spruce buds Host Switch to introduced tree: Since early 1980’s outbreaks have occurred on Sitka spruce in the Scottish Borders Pest Identification and Damage on Sitka
  20. 25/11/2013 27 Winter moth (Operophtera brumata) feeding damage on Sitka

    spruce Substantial defoliation and shoot damage Poor distorted growth with multiple leaders Leading shoots are often eaten out and die back …also feeds on heather !! Damage on Sitka spruce
  21. 25/11/2013 29 • Indigenous to Great Britain and natural host

    is Scots pine • Very common in most GB pinewoods • Rarely outbreaks on native host • A serious pest of Lodgepole pine (‘non-native’) in GB • ‘Host switch’ to LP in 1976 • Within tree genera switch Distribution Pine beauty moth
  22. 25/11/2013 30 Pine beauty moth Identification: Pest Stages Eggs: Pale

    green (laid) to violet-brown (hatching). Dome-shaped, c.1mm diam, with strong vertical ribbing. Laid in rows (in groups of 6-8 eggs)- normally on upper needle surface mainly in upper canopy. Larva: On hatching 3mm, brown head, grey-green & black spots. Instars 2-4 paler green with longitudinal pale stripes. Instar 5 with bright orange stripe on side. Black then white wavy line above legs. Eats ‘new’ & then ‘old needles’. Grows to 40mm (1 1/ 2 inches). Pupa: Dark reddish brown. Length up to 20mm. Adult: Wing span c 30mm (11/ 4 inches).
  23. 25/11/2013 31 Late March to May April and early May

    Early June to late July July to following spring in litter Life cycle of pine beauty moth Life Cycle Pine beauty moth Nb. Strong vertical ribs
  24. 25/11/2013 32 Late instars move onto old foliage Pine Beauty

    Moth - caterpillar feeding & damage on Lodgepole Pine Pine beauty moth Damage Early instars: Feed on developing current shoots (bite small holes at base of needle-pairs- feeding partly inside them. Damage above occurs by late June. Leading shoots collapse due to early feeding & later feeding removes the old foliage
  25. 25/11/2013 33 Locations of PBM outbreaks on Lodgepole Pine •

    ‘Switched’ to introduced introduced Lodgepole pine in 1976 • Attacks in Sutherland, Caithness & Isle of Lewis • Then to South Scotland (Kirkcudbrightshire) • Outbreaks on poorly drained, low nutrient peat soils • Kills trees (as feeds on new and old needles) • Periodic outbreaks since 1976 Outbreaks Pine beauty moth
  26. 25/11/2013 35 Outbreaks PMB damage- early (June) and late stage

    Pine beauty moth ….. 2 to 3 months later !! …..very rapid- no time to mount control programme
  27. 25/11/2013 36 PANOLIS FLAMMEA . Large scale defoliation of forest

    in Scotland by Pine Beauty moth . Location: Naver , Highlands , Scotland . Outbreaks Pine beauty moth
  28. 25/11/2013 38 Pine beauty moth Naver Forest Outbreak …..not just

    Pine beauty other damaging agents involved
  29. Exotic Pests/ Recent Arrivals Dendroctonus Dendroctonus Horse Chestnut Horse Chestnut

    leafminer leafminer Gypsy Moth Gypsy Moth Oak Oak Processionary Processionary Moth Moth Plant products & timber imports Vehicles Pine Pine- -tree Lappet Moth tree Lappet Moth Asian Longhorn Asian Longhorn Beetle Beetle
  30. 25/11/2013 42 25/11/2013 42 Asian longhorn beetle, Anoplophora glabripennis Citrus

    longhorn beetle, Anoplophora chinensis • Native to the Far East (China, Taiwan and Korea). • Both species attack and kill healthy broadleaved trees- very wide host range • Are considered by the FAO to be amongst the top 5 most serious tree pests worldwide. • In China $1.5 billion p.a. estimated costs (12% total spend on P&D’s) • Established USA- $400m spent on eradication. • Established in parts of Europe • Frequently intercepted in UK (packaging & live plants) ALB/CLB Origin and spread
  31. 25/11/2013 43 A.chinensis in bonsai Acer palmatum (Photographs courtesy of

    CSL) Frequent interceptions- imported live plants A.chinensis in bonsai Malus sylvestris Emergence hole Citrus Longhorn Beetles
  32. 25/11/2013 44 25/11/2013 44 Asian longhorn beetle, Anoplophora glabripennis Citrus

    longhorn beetle, Anoplophora chinensis ALB/CLB Hosts & Damage Asian longhorn beetle causes most damage to: Acer (maples, sycamore) Aesculus (horse-chestnut) Betula (birch) Populus (poplars) Salix (willows, sallow) Ulmus (elm) Also many other tree species- both stressed & healthy trees attacked.
  33. 25/11/2013 45 A.chinensis, exit holes Acers, Milan suburb, April 2007

    ALB exit holes higher on tree Asian & Citrus Longhorn Beetles
  34. 25/11/2013 46 Egg niche holes with resin bleeding 25/11/2013 46

    Egg (7mm) laid under the bark. ALB larvae- internal damage to tree 1 cm. Larvae tunnel through wood for 1-3 yrs. Up to 1000 cm3 of timber destroyed Vascular system disrupted, tree structurally weakened & susceptible. Most die within 3-4 yrs. Pupa
  35. 25/11/2013 47 25/11/2013 47 Asian longhorn beetle • March 2012:

    outbreak discovered at Paddock Wood in Kent, the first known outbreak of ALB in the UK • Premises importing stone from China, live adult found locally 2009. • Larvae recovered from roadside sallow tree following routine inspection, identified morphologically and confirmed using DNA
  36. 25/11/2013 48 25/11/2013 48 ALB visual damage at Paddock Wood

    Sycamore – large tree with dead top, contained 155 live A. glabripennis larvae & pupae (40 % of total) & 487 adult exit holes (88 % of total)- June 2012 Adult exit hole
  37. 25/11/2013 50 25/11/2013 50 Felling Felling of all potential host

    trees within 100m of any infested tree. Survey all potential hosts up to 500m
  38. 25/11/2013 53 Discovery of ALB in Field Maple adjacent to

    roundabout has extended outbreak zone northwards Within outbreak zone 2166 trees felled 66 infested trees (10 different tree species but 62% Sycamore) 556 exit holes >350 larvae found in infested material
  39. 25/11/2013 55 • 1748 Surrey • 1809 Norfolk • 2003

    Cornwall • 2004 Kent England (South Coast) England (South Coast) • 1989-2004 Guernsey (5) • 2005, 2006, 2008 Jersey • 1996, 2009, 2010 Isle of Wight • 2004 Inverness 1 male • 2007 Kiltarlity 2 males • 2008 Kiltarlity/Boblainy 10 males Brought to FC’s attention • 2009-10 FR extensive surveys confirm PtLM is established • 2009-12 FR surveys show low densities in c. 8km radius (max) around Kiltarlity (20km WSW of Inverness) Channel Islands Channel Islands Scotland Scotland Distribution British Records (Male moths) Pine-tree Lappet moth
  40. 25/11/2013 56 Pine-tree Lappet moth Identification: Pest Stages Eggs: Light

    brown to green then purple/black, c.1-2mm long. Female produces 150-250 eggs. Laid in groups. Larva: 6 to 8mm on hatching. Grows up to 80mm (31/ 4 inch) long. Pupa: Inside spun silken cocoon suspended in canopy. Length 45-55mm. Adult: Wing span 60-80mm (21/ 2 to 31/ 4 inches). Males smaller than females Eggs © Jeroen Voogd
  41. 25/11/2013 57 Life cycle of Pine-tree Lappet Moth June to

    July Male © Roger Kiddie Female © Keith Tailby Feb to May Older larva © Jeroen Voogd June to Aug Eggs © Jeroen Voogd Young larvae © Jeroen Voogd Aug to Oct Overwinter to litter layer Climb back up in spring Wingspan 45-70mm May to June © Stanislaw Kinelski , Polish Forest Research Institute, Bugwood.org eggs in batches of 20-100 feeds on 700-1000 needles Pine-tree Lappet moth Life Cycle
  42. 25/11/2013 59 Pine-tree Lappet moth Photos by Iwona Skrzecz Damage

    Central Poland 1996 Scots pine defoliated and heavily damaged by Pine-tree lappet caterpillars Poland, 2006
  43. 25/11/2013 60 • Can cause severe/ total defoliation & tree

    death • Outbreaks up to 233,000ha of pine forests esp. in Poland & Germany & freq. required direct control Pine-tree Lappet Moth (Dendrolimus pini)- is one of the most serious defoliators in Europe Larva © Keith Tailby Outbreaks Pine-tree Lappet moth
  44. 25/11/2013 62 Surveys of Adult Male & Female Moths (summer)

    Light traps Pheromone & light traps surveys Pheromone traps Outbreak Monitoring
  45. 25/11/2013 63 Pine-tree Lappet Moth- Current Distribution 47 Survey sites-

    up to 50km from initial moth capture site Pheromone Trap Locations 2009 Light Trap Locations 2009 & 2010 & 2010 Current Distribution INVERNESS 7km Distribution
  46. 25/11/2013 64 UK Distribution & Containment Cordon Sanitaire/ Timber Movement

    Restrictions Containment Pine-tree Lappet moth risk zones ….but range expanding by natural spread c. 3-5km/yr