Share
Embed
Why the @#!% isn't WordPress a CMS?
The traditional CMS world still looks down at WordPress as “just a blogging platform.” After the merge of multiuser with core, custom post types, BuddyPress, and all the fabulous plugins that build on core, why are some folks still not able to see WordPress as a content management system? I’ll explore some of the reasons both technical and cultural.
John Eckman
July 15, 2012
Transcript
30 slides
-
Why the @#!% isn’t WordPress a CMS? John Eckman
ISITE Design -‐ h4p://www.isitedesign.com/ CMS Myth -‐ h4p://www.cmsmyth.com/ Blog -‐ h4p://www.openparenthesis.org/ Github: h4p://github.com/jeckman Twi4er -‐ @jeckman -
What’s a CMS? “A system that lets you apply management
principles to web content.” (real story group) A content management system (CMS) is a system providing a collecFon of procedures used to manage work flow in a collaboraFve environment. These procedures can be manual or computer-‐based. The procedures are designed to do the following: • Allow for a large number of people to contribute to and share stored data • Control access to data, based on user roles (defining which informaFon users or user groups can view, edit, publish, etc.) • Aid in easy storage and retrieval of data • Reduce repeFFve duplicate input • Improve the ease of report wriFng • Improve communicaFon between users (wikipedia on CMS) h"p://www.flickr.com/photos/quinnanya/5403098626/ @jeckman #WordPressCMS #wcbos -
What would lead one to say WordPress is NOT a
CMS? h"p://www.flickr.com/photos/narisa/97218748/ @jeckman #WordPressCMS #wcbos -
WordPress is like the leading candidate in a primary race:
everyone’s a critic h"p://knowyourmeme.com/memes/haters-‐gonna-‐hate/photos @jeckman #WordPressCMS #wcbos -
Why would people say WordPress is just a blog platform?
Because we keep telling them it is. h"p://www.flickr.com/photos/thomashawk/4595386436/ @jeckman #WordPressCMS #wcbos -
Sometimes people use tools in unexpected ways: edge cases Edge
cases can reveal limits in a platform. Is CMS an edge case for WordPress? h"p://bikeportland.org/2012/06/28/with-‐six-‐kids-‐and-‐no-‐car-‐ this-‐mom-‐does-‐it-‐all-‐by-‐bike-‐73731 @jeckman #WordPressCMS #wcbos -
What doesn’t WordPress do well? • MulFlingual •
Publish to Remote Servers • Extended, Fine-‐Grained User Permissions • Content TargeFng / Dynamic PersonalizaFon • In-‐Context EdiFng • Custom ApplicaFons with High User InteracFon • Complex Workflow • Versioning across complex asset types • EdiFons / Content Bundles • Digital Asset Management at Scale @jeckman #WordPressCMS #wcbos -
Do open source projects reflect the attitudes of their founders
and leaders? h"p://schipulcon.com/photos/514/in/9/ @jeckman #WordPressCMS #wcbos -
Dries vs. Matt • PhD in Computer Science and
Engineering • Founded Drupal project 2000 • Founded Acquia 2008, as CTO • Coding, Technology, Photography • Studied PoliFcal Science at University of Houston (leg to join CNET) • Started WordPress in 2003, founded Automaic and WordPress.com 2005 • Jazz, Photography, Simplicity @jeckman #WordPressCMS #wcbos -
Acquia vs Automattic • VC Funded (aggressive growth plan)
• Corporate Headquarters in Burlington MA with some distributed employees • Focus: “Your enterprise guide to Drupal” • VC funded, though slower growth plan (?) • All virtual / Distributed • Small office in SF (now closed?) • Focus: “we are passionate about making the web a be"er place” h"p://www.flickr.com/photos/pgoye"e/1276986086/in/photostream/ @jeckman #WordPressCMS #wcbos -
What does this suggest about Drupal and WordPress as platforms?
• Engineering culture • Steep learning curve, but very powerful once learned • Design / Content culture • Simple learning curve but arguably less powerful / flexible h"p://www.flickr.com/photos/andrewl04/3163980834/ h"p://www.commonplaces.com/inspiring-‐conversaFon/team-‐posts/drupal-‐7-‐vs-‐ wordpress-‐3-‐ba"le-‐new-‐features-‐0 -
What, if anything, should we do about the state of
WordPress as a CMS? @jeckman #WordPressCMS #wcbosc -
Do we want more power, and therefore accept more complexity?
h"p://www.cmsmyth.com/2012/02/build-‐one-‐to-‐throw-‐away/ @jeckman #WordPressCMS #wcbos -
“What the detractors and critics of electric vehicles have been
saying for years, is true. The electric vehicle is not for everybody; given the limited range it can only meet the needs of 90% of the population.“ h"p://www.filmaluaFon.com/who-‐killed-‐the-‐electric-‐car.html @jeckman #WordPressCMS #wcbos -
Should there be a fork of WordPress focused on CMS
use cases? A Distribution? Package? Application? Downstream? h"p://www.flickr.com/photos/jonathancohen/5396179251/ @jeckman #WordPressCMS #wcbosc -
How can we preserve WordPress’ existing advantages? • Focus on
usability and user experience design for the content author / site admin • Ease of installaFon and Fme to “live site” experience • Broad availability of themes and plugins • Community (including WordCamps!) • WordPress.com as a massive scale ongoing tesFng plaoorm for new concepts h"p://www.flickr.com/photos/r_a_z_e/498818720/ @jeckman #WordPressCMS #wcbosc -
This is a great time for exactly what WordPress is
best at • Shig in buying power from IT to business owner • Renewed interest in and focus on content strategy • Focused small iniFaFves rather than large enterprise roll outs • Focus on design, usability, and content impact -
Closing Thoughts • WordPress certainly can be used as a
CMS: the quesFon is ulFmately whether this is an edge case or the core direcFon of the project. • In trying to grow WordPress as a CMS: – We won’t win by trash talking other plaoorms – Power is shiging from IT buyer to markeFng/ business buyer – Don’t fall for the technology selecFon myth – Don’t compete on feature checklists – The “S” in CMS should be strategy h"p://blog.schipul.com/drupal-‐and-‐wordpress-‐at-‐schipulcon-‐one-‐stage-‐one-‐open-‐source-‐love/ @jeckman #WordPressCMS #wcbosc